London Mayoral Candidate Espouses "Law of Ten" Wages Regulation

Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
606
I don't have a suitable link to an article but Jenny Jones, Green Party mayoral candidate for London (and occupy London Stock exchange camper) was on the BBC 6 news espousing (a mild version of) the law of 10, namely that nobody should be paid more than ten times that of anybody else in The City.

Radical communist dictatorship!!!!


ETA: A more totalitarian version of the law of 10 is that nobody's income should exceed that of the next person by more than 10 and would be...perhaps extremely difficult to regulate given all sales of assets and income from investments would need to be accounted for also.
 
She needs to have a reply to the "but the best CEOs/footballers will go elsewhere if there's a maximum wage" argument or she just looks stupid IMO.
 
In the US, this would cap someone at $145,000/year. People in my line of work typically make around this much at the end of their career.

More obviously: is a cardiologist worth 10 times more than the guy who flips burgers at McDonalds? Yes, duh.
 
In the US, this would cap someone at $145,000/year. People in my line of work typically make around this much at the end of their career.

More obviously: is a cardiologist worth 10 times more than the guy who flips burgers at McDonalds? Yes, duh.

There would not be a pay ceiling, there would be a pay floor.

And the obvious question is, is a cardiologist worth MORE than ten times the salary that a burger flipper makes? I don't know that it's so obviously so.
 
Last edited:
It always seems to boil down to the problem of international competition. Given that a one world government seems impossible, "closing the borders" seems the only real way to stop economic/national entity #1 from being priced out of the market by the fierce/bloody competition from foreign economies.
 
It always seems to boil down to the problem of international competition. Given that a one world government seems impossible, "closing the borders" seems the only real way to stop economic/national entity #1 from being priced out of the market by the fierce/bloody competition from foreign economies.

No, it simply shows how nationalism is used to divide workers and benefit the international corporations.
 
IIRC, UK pay ratios are a lot more balanced than US, so I don't see why this is necessary.

Not familiar with the tax system over there, or even the one over here, but I'm sure people will just find ways of dodging it. Steve Jobs only had a salary of $1, after all :rolleyes: .
 
No, it simply shows how nationalism is used to divide workers and benefit the international corporations.

I disagree. It shows how the wall that keeps us first worlders above everyone else is slowly crumbling. Very slowly :p .
 
There would not be a pay ceiling, there would be a pay floor.

And the obvious question is, is a cardiologist worth MORE than ten times the salary that a burger flipper makes? I don't know that it's so obviously so.

You don't think the work output of a cardiologist is 10 times more valuable than a person flipping burgers? Try looking at the revenue that a cardiologist brings in for a for-profit healthcare company.
 
There would not be a pay ceiling, there would be a pay floor.

And the obvious question is, is a cardiologist worth MORE than ten times the salary that a burger flipper makes? I don't know that it's so obviously so.


the more relevant question seems to be: given the difficulty, education, effort, and expense to become a cardiologist, if you cap the pay at 10 times a fast food server, how many people will work as cardiologists? Related question: do you mind a 9 month waiting time for your heart problem?
 
Law of 10 Definition check needed

I may be wrong but I think the OP has the wrong definition the ‘law of 10’, which has triggered the burger flipper/cardiologist debate.

I read that the ‘law of 10’ is that the person at the top of a company/organisation should not earn more than 10 times the salary of the person at the bottom of that company/organisation. Much more logical (but 10 is probably still too high).

This means that the director of the burger flipper’s firm can only earn 10 times more than the burger flipper and the head of a hospital can only be earning 10 times more than the hospital junior.

It doesn’t mean that the flipper and junior are on identical salaries, or that their bosses are. It allows for differences across industries and businesses.

Whilst it would be impossible to force private companies to do this, I think it should be encouraged. It means that company directors would need to be more conscious of salary levels at the bottom of their firms. The gap in salary from the top and lowest levels has been increasing for years. The rich get richer and the poor get poorer even though they all work hard.:(


ETA: It would be possible to force companies to make the actual % number available to the public in their annual report, that would enable us to judge whether to do business with those organisations!
 
Last edited:
I may be wrong but I think the OP has the wrong definition the ‘law of 10’, which has triggered the burger flipper/cardiologist debate.

I read that the ‘law of 10’ is that the person at the top of a company/organisation should not earn more than 10 times the salary of the person at the bottom of that company/organisation. Much more logical (but 10 is probably still too high).

This means that the director of the burger flipper’s firm can only earn 10 times more than the burger flipper and the head of a hospital can only be earning 10 times more than the hospital junior.

It doesn’t mean that the flipper and junior are on identical salaries, or that their bosses are. It allows for differences across industries and businesses.

Whilst it would be impossible to force private companies to do this, I think it should be encouraged. It means that company directors would need to be more conscious of salary levels at the bottom of their firms. The gap in salary from the top and lowest levels has been increasing for years. The rich get richer and the poor get poorer even though they all work hard.:(


ETA: It would be possible to force companies to make the actual % number available to the public in their annual report, that would enable us to judge whether to do business with those organisations!

Surely all it would lead to is a bunch of outsourced temporary agency burger flippers so they don't count as junior employees?
 
I don't have a suitable link to an article but Jenny Jones, Green Party mayoral candidate for London (and occupy London Stock exchange camper) was on the BBC 6 news espousing (a mild version of) the law of 10, namely that nobody should be paid more than ten times that of anybody else in The City.

Radical communist dictatorship!!!!

ETA: A more totalitarian version of the law of 10 is that nobody's income should exceed that of the next person by more than 10 and would be...perhaps extremely difficult to regulate given all sales of assets and income from investments would need to be accounted for also.

This is the link:
http://www.greenparty.org.uk/news/jenny_jones_vows_to_make_london_fair_pay_city.html

'..... declared her aim to make London the ‘Fair Pay City’, starting with a 10:1 maximum pay ratio for employees of organisations within the GLA group.'

As mentioned in my prev post, the 10:1 ration is within an organisation, she refers to starting it in the GLA.
 
Last edited:
Surely all it would lead to is a bunch of outsourced temporary agency burger flippers so they don't count as junior employees?

So I'm not the only cynic? :D

I agree that capitalists will find ways round it, the most obvious is having bonuses that aren't 'salary' or free whatever else.

I suppose they can't offshore the burger flipping ;)

I still think the principle is a good idea tho.
 
Related question: do you mind a 9 month waiting time for your heart problem?
Or do you want to pay $10 for the burger? But seriously, do you think that there'll be so few cardiologists if their salary is capped?

I have to laugh at this analogy because the cardiologist is most likely solving the problems that the burger cook helped create.
 
You don't think the work output of a cardiologist is 10 times more valuable than a person flipping burgers? Try looking at the revenue that a cardiologist brings in for a for-profit healthcare company.

I don't doubt that the hospital makes a great amount of money off the Dr., this isn't about what someone is worth to a corporation, this is an effort to solve the problem of income disparity. I don't think that we rate the "worth" of human beings based on their earning power. Or we shouldn't, at least. I don't know that it would work, but I do think that the problem of income disparity is a big one that needs to be addressed in some way.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom