Locating the roots of official Twin Towers philosophy

Major_Tom

Graduate Poster
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
1,995
Gravy first started the thread "Gravysites: Where 9/11 Conspiracies are Laid to Rest" on May 20, 2007. The thread has been pinned to the top of this forum for the last 19 years.

The Bazant "crush down, then crush up" Twin Towers collapse progression model (promoted by Gravysites) first appeared in the Journal of Engineering Mechanics in March, 2007.

Therefore, for the last 19 years the James Randi Educational Foundation and then the International Skeptics Forum has promoted the Bazant "crush down, then crush up" collapse progression mechanism of the Twin Towers.

I created the following video clip to help people locate the 'official story' or 'debunker' position on the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanisms in the written history since so few people seem to know how to do it themselves. The video is at this link

I'll be making a second video clip which focuses only on the history of how the James Randi Educational Foundation Forum and the International Skeptics Forum have presented the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanics to the general public for the last quarter century.

I want the videos to be as accurate as possible and I want them to capture the true heart of skepticism internationally with respect to the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanisms the the Twin Towers collapses generally.

I have a few questions for the true skeptics among you:

1) Does the International Skeptics Forum still promote the Bazant "crush down, then crush up" model of the Twin Towers collapse progressions in 2026? If not, why is it still pinned on page 1 of this forum?

2) Is there any intention for the International Skeptics Forum to update the pinned links titled "Gravysites" to reflect a non-cartoon version of the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanisms for the general viewing pubic?

3) If the James Randi Education Foundation forum and the International Skeptics Forum has been promoting a child's cartoon as the most accurate representation of the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanism to the general public for the last 19 years, what does that say about the current state of knowledge and skepticism, internationally, for the last quarter century with respect to the Twin Towers collapses?

I'd like your feedback on these issues. And remember, your comments represent how self-identified skeptics in the International Skeptics Forum currently perceive the contents of this forum and the true role of this forum in representing the Twin Towers collapses to the public for the last 25 years.
 
The cartoon depiction is close enough start with. Sure it's a bit childish, but sometimes you have to meet your audience where they are.

Though to be fair I'm not sure the ISF has enough of an audience anymore to be worth your time and effort getting into it.

Anyway, I think there's far more pressing social issues where the overall "skeptic consensus" matters a lot more and deserves this kind of inquiry.
 
What does it matter? The collapse initiation dynamics have been modelled in detail by multiple organisations, and every competent authority agrees that collapse initiation was overwhelmingly likely given the damage suffered by both towers. Once collapse was initiated, the most trivial understanding of the dynamics makes it clear that, whatever the fine details, collapse must progress to essentially complete destruction of both towers. From a point of view of skeptical enquiry into the causes of collapse, that's ample answer to the question "Why did the Twin Towers collapse?"

Dave
 
...I have a few questions for the true skeptics among you:

1) Does the International Skeptics Forum still promote the Bazant "crush down, then crush up" model of the Twin Towers collapse progressions in 2026?
No.
If not, why is it still pinned on page 1 of this forum?
Because it was a discussion that readers found interesting. This is a discussion forum, not a propaganda site. There was a very popular and fascinating thread a few years back started by some yahoo that thought he could prove that people were immortal mathematically.

If you adjust your thinking to what is in front of you instead of what you already believe, you might find that many questions are answered with that same kind of reasoning.
 
No.

Because it was a discussion that readers found interesting. This is a discussion forum, not a propaganda site. There was a very popular and fascinating thread a few years back started by some yahoo that thought he could prove that people were immortal mathematically.

If you adjust your thinking to what is in front of you instead of what you already believe, you might find that many questions are answered with that same kind of reasoning.
To make it “official”

As Forum Liaison to both the JREF and the owner of the ISF I can categorically state (does that sound official enough?) that the forum has never taken any official position on anything to do with 9/11. The Forum doesn’t have official positions (outside of the moderation of the forum). What threads are pinned and so on have nothing to do with any official position of any of the owners of the forum, they will have been done either at the request of the members or because an admin or mod at the time thought it would be useful or handy or some other such reason.
 
1) Does the International Skeptics Forum still promote the Bazant "crush down, then crush up" model of the Twin Towers collapse progressions in 2026? If not, why is it still pinned on page 1 of this forum?
They should, definitely over Major Tom's unexplained theories. I watched the stupid video at your site, and no surprise, you present no evidence to disprove Bazant. Instead you are reduced to complaining that it was represented with a "cartoon" in New York Magazine 15 years ago.

2) Is there any intention for the International Skeptics Forum to update the pinned links titled "Gravysites" to reflect a non-cartoon version of the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanisms for the general viewing pubic?
What you call a cartoon is actually a graphic, a graphic that actually does a pretty good job of explaining reality. What's your non-cartoon version of the Twin Towers collapse progression? I notice your video is about the "history" of the official theory, and you avoid carefully revealing your own thoughts (probably a good idea).
 
Thanks for the feedback. I'll explain what i mean in more detail.

The collapse progression mechanism of the Twin Towers is by far the single largest, most visible feature of the collapses of both towers I will call this "#1 Elephant in the Room".

The complete contents of this forum allows us to track in detail (month by month, year by year) how this "#1 Elephant in the Room" was represented by forum participants, individually and collectively, especially through the pivotal years of 2010 to 2015.

To this end the following threads are especially illuminating:

On May 11, 2010 a thread titled "OOS Collapse Propagation Model" was created.

On October 26, 2010 a thread titled "WTC 1 features list, initiation model / WTC 2 features list, collapse model" was created.

On June 7, 2012 a thread titled "Bazant in a nutshell" was created.

On April 17, 2012 a thread titled "Major_Tom Disproves NIST Claims in a Number of Key Areas" was created.

On June 23, 2013 a thread titled "Questions about ROOSD, and its founder" was created.

On May 30, 2014 a thread titled "It appears that Bazant was right. No crush-up." was created.

On September 21, 2015 a thread titled "Since the prevalent mechanism for collapse is composite ROOSD, I have a question? " was created by a "debunker" (Crazy Chainsaw) with fellow debunkers participating.

On October 15, 2015 "OOS Collapse Propagation Model Part II" was created.

On April 17, 2016 a thread titled "Another Crush down / Crush up thread" was created.


These specific threads allow us to track in detail (month by month, year by year) how this "#1 Elephant in the Room" was represented by forum participants.

This forum is an invaluable source of documentation in that any reader has access to direct evidence that the model called "ROOSD" was thoroughly rejected by prominent forum members with degrees and advanced degrees in the physical sciences and engineering from the moment it first appeared in this forum in 2010 and their reasons for doing so are clearly stated (and dated) in this forum (in the threads listed above and elsewhere). It took about 5 years of internal discussions between forum participants (all documented) to finally come to the conclusion that "the prevalent mechanism for collapse is composite ROOSD" and the earliest comments by prominent forum members with degrees and advanced degrees in the physical sciences and engineering were simply wrong.

The Bazant "crush down, then crush up" Twin Towers collapse progression model (promoted by Gravysites) first appeared in the Journal of Engineering Mechanics in March, 2007. It is a matter of record in your own forum that prominent forum members with degrees and advanced degrees in the physical sciences and engineering were vigorously defending the Bazant "crush down, then crush up" model from (at least) 2010 onward. It is also a matter of record that this same literal interpretation of "crush down, then crush up" appeared in New York Magazine from August 2011 onward in an article that claimed to “explain, precisely, how the towers fell” to New Yorkers and others, including to the families of those who died in the Twin towers collapses.

This is careless negligence at best. People do make mistakes. So why doesn't the forum simply correct the mistakes for the record and clearly inform the public of the mistakes made in the James Randi Education Foundation forum and the International Skeptics Forum over 2 decades concerning the "#1 Elephant in the Room"?

Isn't that something that those who value accuracy, skepticism and the encouragement of critical thinking would want to do?
 
No, it isn't. Going back over many years of posts and picking over where the general tide of opinion has changed is a ridiculously time-consuming endeavour, and this forum is such an unimportant backwater of the internet that the effect on wider public opinion would be zero. Nobody cares enough to be bothered, nor should they. There are more important issues to address in the world than the obsessive resentment of one forum member at not being recognised as the unsung genius he thinks he is.

Dave
 
This is careless negligence at best. People do make mistakes. So why doesn't the forum simply correct the mistakes for the record and clearly inform the public of the mistakes made in the James Randi Education Foundation forum and the International Skeptics Forum over 2 decades concerning the "#1 Elephant in the Room"?
This is a discussion forum, not an official engineering, or investigative entity. As you point out, the subject was debated in GREAT DETAIL from both sides, as is how things are done around here.

On September 11, 2001, Al Qaeda hijackers took control of four commercial jetliners which they flew into the twin towers, the Pentagon, and a field in Shanksville, PA. That's it. That's always been the bottom line.

The collapse of WTC-1, WTC-2, and WTC-7 has been the subject of multiple treads, as has the Pentagon, and Shanksville. In 16 years these discussions have covered a lot of interesting details, and theories based on facts, and others on speculation. In recent years the forum has fallen silent as the trolls have moved on with only the low-hanging fruit remaining with their nutjob theories and claims.

It's not the forum's job to "correct" anything since facts and evidence rule the day here. If you have facts and evidence feel free to present it here.
 
No, it isn't. Going back over many years of posts and picking over where the general tide of opinion has changed is a ridiculously time-consuming endeavour, and this forum is such an unimportant backwater of the internet that the effect on wider public opinion would be zero. Nobody cares enough to be bothered, nor should they. There are more important issues to address in the world than the obsessive resentment of one forum member at not being recognised as the
unsung genius he thinks he is.

You never heard the Ballad of Major Tom?
 
Hello Major_Tom! :)

I did a VERY stupid thing today. You know what?
I clicked the link to your video.
Now, luckily, some of us here judge internet videos by a metric we call "Time to First Lie"
Your video's score on that metric: 11 seconds - that's where the word "exactly" is spoken in, and makes a LIE of, the sentence:

"This ... set of graphics ... claimed to describe exactly how the twin towers collapsed..."​

Any junior high school student can figure out for themselves that these graphics are mere doodles, partially hand drawn, lacking tons of relevant detail. The towers aren't even drawn to scale (they were more slender in reality. There is nowhere a "claim to describe exactly" anything.

So right out of the gate, your video uses extreme hyperbole to deceive the viewer into greatly overestimating the relevance of something that once appeared in a newspaper.

Being the generous opponent I have always been towards you, I did not stop right there and then, as I should have given that you are a liar, but continued to listen. Now picture my surprise when I heard this:

0:00:26 hours: "and here is the link, and if you go there, now, or since the 20th anniversary [i.e. September 2021; Oystein], and if you click on it, nothing happens, so ... I couldn't access the image anymore."

My surprise is linked (pun intended) to your introducing that video with the words:

"I created the following video clip to help people locate the 'official story' or 'debunker' position on the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanisms in the written history"​

Wait - the "official story" is to be found in a set of graphics that YOU CAN'T FIND, that once was in a newspaper (and its online presence)?
Really? The "official story" is a set of doodles???
How STUPID do you think anyone around here is?

That is when I closed the video, and I will never again look at it. I am not that stupid. I have no taste for being lied to. Eliminate the lies, apologize for the lies, and repost your video without the lies. Then we me get to talk.
 
Last edited:
I have a few questions for the true skeptics among you:

1) Does the International Skeptics Forum still promote the Bazant "crush down, then crush up" model of the Twin Towers collapse progressions in 2026? If not, why is it still pinned on page 1 of this forum?
No. Darat already answered this authoritatively.
I'd like to add that you unfairly and untruthfully characterize the "gravisites", i.e. Gravy's old google site, large discontinued after 2009 and no longer available in the original, as (primarily) "promoting" crush-down-before-crush-up. That is merely a detail, and Gravy never meant to spell out every last detail of the twin tower collapsed. The Gravysites are about the LIES of the so-called "9/11 Truth Movement" and contain a great many debunkings of contemporary (as of 2009) "9/11 Truth" lies and errors.

2) Is there any intention for the International Skeptics Forum to update the pinned links titled "Gravysites" to reflect a non-cartoon version of the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanisms for the general viewing pubic?
The pinned links link to, as you correctly figured out, "Gravysites".
These are sites created by a member, Gravy, who has ceased to be active in debuking the many lies of "9/11 Truth" 17 years ago. His sites aren't even available anymore, as Google no loger supports Google Sites. That's why the links in the opening post of the pinned thread no refer to the archived version on the Wayback machine.
Since Gravy no longer updates any of the content, there is of course no intention on the part of ISF to link to any updated version of the graphic that you have a personal problem with and lie about.
Besides, the links in the opening post of the pinned thread no refer to the archived version on the Wayback machine do NOT link to to the cd/cu graphic, so there is no link to be updated on the part of ISF.
Basically, you just asked a particularly stupid question.

3) If the James Randi Education Foundation forum and the International Skeptics Forum has been promoting a child's cartoon as the most accurate representation of the Twin Towers collapse progression mechanism to the general public for the last 19 years, what does that say about the current state of knowledge and skepticism, internationally, for the last quarter century with respect to the Twin Towers collapses?
Since the condition "JREF and ISF have been promoting a child's cartoon" is FALSE, the question you ask as the consequent is rendered moot and thus will be ignored.

If this absurd misrepresentation of everything involved - the "position" of ISF on anything, the importance of the doodles, the content of Gravysites, possible shortcomings in Bazant's papers - is and has been bugging you so badly that you come here again, 15 and more years after you first got on everyone's nerves with you bombast, what does that say about the current state of your mental health?
 
Thank you for recording your opinions. I do appreciate it. James Randi had a few different social roles. From wikipedia on "James Randi":

"James Randi (born Randall James Hamilton Zwinge; August 7, 1928 – October 20, 2020) was a Canadian-American stage magician, author, and scientific skeptic who extensively challenged paranormal and pseudoscientific claims.[1] He was the co-founder of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (CSI), and founder of the James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF). Randi began his career as a magician under the stage name The Amazing Randi and later chose to devote most of his time to investigating paranormal, occult, and supernatural claims."

James Randi also admitted conducting a series of hoaxes on a university laboratory. From the wikipedia "Project Alpha":

"In the 1970s, James Smith McDonnell, board chairman of McDonnell Douglas and believer in the paranormal, approached Washington University in St. Louis with plans to set up a permanent PSI research facility.[1] Eventually, physicist Peter Phillips, who was also interested in the field, agreed to lead a parapsychology lab at the school. Phillips had degrees in physics from both Cambridge University and Stanford University. In 1979, McDonnell arranged a US$500,000 grant for the establishment and five years operation of the McDonnell Laboratory for Psychical Research, or MacLab for short."

"Randi offered his services to watch the experiments, noting that a conjurer would be an excellent person to look for fakery. According to Michael Thalbourne, Phillips did not take Randi up on the offer because of the magician's reputation of being "a showman rather than an unprejudiced critic" and his perceived hostility towards psychic claimants."

So James Randi secretly infiltrated the experiments and intentionally played tricks on the laboratory and the university.


From the wikipedia descriptions we can see James Randi has played at least 3 different social roles:

1) James Randi the stage magician (illusionist) and escape artist

2) James Randi the skeptical inquirer and consummate rational thinker

3) James Randi the hoaxer or practical joker


In the same way, what social role does this forum play? This forum "9/11 Conspiracy Theories" was first formed in March, 2006 and consists of 524 pages of thread lists at about 20 threads per page, so there are about 1,048 threads which contain about 1 million messages. We have a very straightforward way to see how accurately forum participants, individually and as part of JREF and later ISF subculture, perceived and described the Twin Towers collapses over a 20 year period. Simply watch how what I called "#1 Elephant in the Room" was perceived and interpreted in this forum month after month, year after year, by any individual poster and especially by prominent participants with professional technical backgrounds through the close to 1 million messages.


Since James Randi was known to be a 'conjurer', a 'showman', a practical joker and skeptical inquirer all in one, a cautions skeptical thinker has a duty to consider:

1) Does this forum show evidence of information manipulation and trickery? (Randi as 'conjurer')

2) Does the forum show evidence of being a vehicle through which a practical joke is played on the general public? (Randi as 'practical joker' and 'showman')

3) Does this forum show evidence of open and honest skeptical inquiry toward the subject matter? (Randi as 'consummate rational thinker')


It is a matter of record that the notion of 'crush down, then crush up' through a practically indestructible 'upper block' was literally conjured up in March, 2007. It is a complete fictional cartoon, kind of like a practical joke played on the general public and on readers of the Journal of Engineering Mechanics to test the gullibility of the social environment.

It is also a matter of record that the JREF forum and later the ISF were the central public vehicles through which this cartoon was promoted and defended. They still are. So the answer to questions 1 and 2 above appear to be "yes" and "yes".

How can forum participants explain their close affiliation with a child's cartoon interpretation of the #1 Elephant in the Room for close to 2 decades? If your previous statements serve as your answer to this question, fine. If not, please explain further.
 
James Randi had a few different social roles. From wikipedia on "James Randi":
If your lone source is Wikipedia you've already lost.

Since James Randi was known to be a 'conjurer', a 'showman', a practical joker and skeptical inquirer all in one, a cautions skeptical thinker has a duty to consider:

1) Does this forum show evidence of information manipulation and trickery? (Randi as 'conjurer')

2) Does the forum show evidence of being a vehicle through which a practical joke is played on the general public? (Randi as 'practical joker' and 'showman')

3) Does this forum show evidence of open and honest skeptical inquiry toward the subject matter? (Randi as 'consummate rational thinker')
Wow, you are really bad at this. This is high school debate team crap. If your mission is to undermine the forum's credibility you need to stick to the subject. James Randi did not initiate nor participate in any of the 9-11 discussions on this board. So you're already fighting ghosts, which I suspect is your M.O.
How can forum participants explain their close affiliation with a child's cartoon interpretation of the #1 Elephant in the Room for close to 2 decades? If your previous statements serve as your answer to this question, fine. If not, please explain further.
So what you've just told us is you haven't read any of the 9-11 forum threads at all. You just base your delusions on an AI prompt. Typical truther,
 
[snipped loads of irrelevant ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊]
It is a matter of record that the notion of 'crush down, then crush up' through a practically indestructible 'upper block' was literally conjured up in March, 2007.
It is now a matter of record that you misunderstand and misrepresent the cd/cu model. It's driven not by an "indestructible 'upper block'" but by an already destructed and growing debris layer travelling with and ahead of the upper block.

It is also a matter of record that the JREF forum and later the ISF were the central public vehicles through which this cartoon was promoted and defended.
You vastly overestimate the size, reach and relevance of this forum, or any other. You present a childish cartoon of how public information works.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom