Lilly Ledbetter Act H.R. 2831

mindcore

Scholar
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
78
Lilly Ledbetter Act H.R. 2831

Contact your senator and ask them to support H.R. 2831. It needs to be done in the next 3 days.

H.R. 2831 would allow a woman (or man) to sue the company they work for anytime if the company
is paying them less due to their gender. The current limit is 180 days, so if you discover you were getting ****ed by your bosses 180 days after they start, you have no rights. That is the current law.

H.R. 2831 changes that.

Call the senate NOW!

866-338-1015
 
I'm not sure this is correct-- any type of EEOC discrimination has a 180 day filing limit but it's since the last act of discrimination. I thought there was a recent court case that said a paycheck is an act of discrimination (if gender's the reason you're getting less money) and so you'd have 180 days from the last pay check under the equal pay act.

Plus, why extend the time limit for sex and pay but not for any other type of discrimination?
 
I stand corrected-- coincidentally, just got this email from the Society for HR management. Here's more info if anyone's interested:



YOUR ASSISTANCE IS NEEDED! HR professionals should be aware that the U.S. Senate is scheduled to vote on Wednesday, April 23 on legislation that would eliminate the uniform statute of limitations for filing employment discrimination claims.



Under H.R. 2831, the Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, the time clock for bringing a Title VII claim would re-start indefinitely as long as an employee continued to receive a paycheck – or even a pension payment – from a given employer. Consequently, the bill would force HR professionals and employers to be prepared to defend pay decisions made years or even decades earlier. Employees seeking avenues to challenge pay decisions currently have at least 180 days under Title VII and two years under the Equal Pay Act to pursue discrimination claims.



The House of Representatives already passed the Ledbetter Fair Pay Act on July 31, 2007. The good news is that, thanks in part to letters sent by SHRM members last July, the House vote on H.R. 2831 was much closer than expected.



Now we ask that you please write your Senators and urge them to VOTE NO on the Ledbetter Fair Pay Act!



Background



Ledbetter v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., on which the Supreme Court decided in May 2007, was a landmark case in employment law. The case revolved around the statutory time limit for filing an employment discrimination claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which requires employees to bring such claims within 180 days (if the employee's home state has no equal employment agency) or 300 days (if the employee's home state has an equal employment agency) of the alleged unlawful employment action.



Shortly after retiring in 1998, Lilly Ledbetter, a supervisor at Goodyear’s Gadsden, Alabama facility, filed a pay discrimination claim with the U.S. Equal Opportunity Commission, as directed under Title VII. Ledbetter asserted that her gender had been the central factor in several unsatisfactory performance evaluations she received that led to her earning lower wages, and specifically challenged a 1998 management decision to deny her a raise on the grounds that it was gender biased.

Ledbetter's case advanced all the way to the Supreme Court, which decided on May 29, 2007 that Ledbetter had not brought her discrimination claim within the time period provided by the Civil Rights Act. The Court held that the act of issuing paychecks cannot be challenged as a discriminatory act; rather, the basis of an actionable claim must be the decision to set compensation rates. Therefore, the time limit for filing a charge with the EEOC is not extended upon the receipt of each successive paycheck.



Legislation



The Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, sponsored by Representative George Miller (D-CA), is intended to overrule the Supreme Court’s decision in Ledbetter. The proposed measure would effectively eliminate the statue of limitations on pay discrimination claims by re-starting the time clock for filing such a charge with the EEOC upon the receipt of each successive paycheck. The bill would also re-start the time clock when a retiree receives an annuity check from an employer, and would thus keep employers liable to a discrimination claim potentially decades after an alleged act of misconduct.



The legislation would amend the Civil Rights Act, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and the Rehabilitation Act.



SHRM’s Position



SHRM adamantly opposes all unlawful discrimination practices in the workplace, and believes any intentional misconduct against employees in any sector should be promptly addressed and resolved. Consistent with that view, SHRM opposes the Ledbetter Fair Pay Act because it would effectively eliminate the uniform statue of limitations on pay discrimination claims.



Specifically, SHRM opposes the following aspects of the Ledbetter Fair Pay Act:



* Fundamentally Changes Statute of Limitations—By making the time clock start over upon the issuance of each successive paycheck, the bill would allow individuals to bring discrimination claims many years after the occurrence of an alleged act of discrimination. Yet the more time passes, the more likely it is that employment records and witnesses will be unavailable, making it nearly impossible for an employer to defend itself against such a claim. Congress enacted the current statute of limitations on employment suits based on the interest that all parties have in promptly and accurately resolving claims.
 
I am slightly sympathetic to the bill for the following argument:

Point 1) Person X is hired at a company at a reduced wage or receives a low pay increase due to unlawful discrimination.

Point 2) Person X is not privy to the wages of other employees and so has no way to be aware of point 1.

Point 3) It could easily be more than 180 days before Person X builds a solid enough rapport with co-workers to discuss the personal issue of income and finances or finds some other way to access that information.

Point 4) In the status quo, Person X would have no recourse.


My objection is that it limits this protection to gender issues.

I'm open to counterarguments.
 
Last edited:
This sounds like the "let's make it as painful as possible to hire women" bill. Hire a woman and take on a risk almost forever that at some point in the future the woman can decide to bring a suit against your company. Long after anybody that would remember the details has left the company.

It is questionable whether women are better off at all with the government playing the part of a nanny watching out to make sure they got a good deal when they were hired, but this bill would just codify the idea of women as some sort of strange underclass that can't look out for themselves.

I'm going to vote for Democrats on the national level for the foreseeable future because the Republican Party has become crony driven, anti-science and pro-war. But crap like this makes me wonder how long the country could withstand Democratic leadership before the weight of their pro-union, pro-lawyer, nanny state ideas did the country in.
 
This sounds like the "let's make it as painful as possible to hire women" bill. Hire a woman and take on a risk almost forever that at some point in the future the woman can decide to bring a suit against your company. Long after anybody that would remember the details has left the company.

It is questionable whether women are better off at all with the government playing the part of a nanny watching out to make sure they got a good deal when they were hired, but this bill would just codify the idea of women as some sort of strange underclass that can't look out for themselves.

I'm going to vote for Democrats on the national level for the foreseeable future because the Republican Party has become crony driven, anti-science and pro-war. But crap like this makes me wonder how long the country could withstand Democratic leadership before the weight of their pro-union, pro-lawyer, nanny state ideas did the country in.

In the status quo, you already "Hire a woman and take on a risk almost forever that at some point in the future the woman can decide to bring a suit against your company."

The difference here is that if you've actually discriminated against her, she can win. I don't recall them throwing out rules of evidence regarding the case, so she still needs a preponderance of evidence.

Woman: I was passed over for promotion because I'm a woman!
Judge: Ok take some of their money.

Not gonna happen.

Under the new law, if she finds the evidence of discrimination 3 months after the decision was made (an entirely likely prospect, IMO) she isn't screwed by the legal system.

Under current law, if you can hide evidence of discrimination for 180 days, you can do it all you like.
 
It turns out this bill was killed with a filibuster.

So hooray for everyone who thought supporting this bill was foolish!
 
This sounds like the "let's make it as painful as possible to hire women" bill. Hire a woman and take on a risk almost forever that at some point in the future the woman can decide to bring a suit against your company. Long after anybody that would remember the details has left the company.

It is questionable whether women are better off at all with the government playing the part of a nanny watching out to make sure they got a good deal when they were hired, but this bill would just codify the idea of women as some sort of strange underclass that can't look out for themselves.

I'm going to vote for Democrats on the national level for the foreseeable future because the Republican Party has become crony driven, anti-science and pro-war. But crap like this makes me wonder how long the country could withstand Democratic leadership before the weight of their pro-union, pro-lawyer, nanny state ideas did the country in.

Well I guess that's one perspective. This article by Dahlia Lithwick presents to other side.

I guess I can see both sides of the argument. It certainly seems like this particular woman got screwed over by Goodyear.
 
In the status quo, you already "Hire a woman and take on a risk almost forever that at some point in the future the woman can decide to bring a suit against your company."

The difference here is that if you've actually discriminated against her, she can win. I don't recall them throwing out rules of evidence regarding the case, so she still needs a preponderance of evidence.

Woman: I was passed over for promotion because I'm a woman!
Judge: Ok take some of their money.

Well if the Lithwick article provides a realistic appraisal of the evidence (and I suspect that she does not), then I can see a lot of problems with no effective time limit.

To summarise, the points she mentioned were:

She was the lowest paid area manager and the only female;

She was paid below the minimum threshold for her position during a one year period at some point in her career;

Two former employees claimed that they were discriminated against; and

One of her supervisors was claimed to be openly biased against women.

Taking them in turn:

Lowest paid - so what, somebody always is.

Minimum threshold - hardly unusual in my experience. Companies regularly change pay scales (often in response to market pressures which mean they need to offer higher wages to recruit) but do not give all existing employees a raise immediately.

Two former employees - hard to evaluate, if two current employees said they hadn't been discriminated against would that carry equal weight?

And a claim against one person's attitude ten years ago. Need I say more.


Is it reasonable to expect businesses to retain information forever to guard against the chance that a claim may be made? How are they meant to defend a claim that one individual, ten years ago discriminated? Particularly if that individual no longer works for them?

180 days seems too short, but I do not agree with the effective removal of all time limits.
 
Lilly Ledbetter Act

I'm sorry to say that this act was killed by filibuster.

So for everyone who was against it, congratulations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom