Lie detector tests for paedophiles in the UK

Big Les

Philosopher
Joined
Mar 9, 2006
Messages
5,058
Location
UK
I can't help but baulk at news that an authority called the "Ministry of Justice" (!) is to insist upon lie detector tests for criminals. In the UK. Good lord.

I heard it on Radio 4 this morning, and there was not one mention of the paucity of evidence (in fact, the counter evidence) regarding polygraphs and the false positive possibilities. In my view, this is exactly the sort of thing the press should be questioning.

Of course, since the crims in question are "nonces", no-one will care about the adoption of fundamentally flawed and discredited methods and equipment.
 
Interestingly enough, there was a thread recently started in the Science/Math/Medicine section discussion whether or not the lie detector was BS or not. I am inclined to believe it is and the results can be tainted by the examiner. To my knowledge there isn't much to support the results are much better than chance.
 
The last thread took five posts before someone posted the most relevant link on this topic there is. It should be up sooner in this one:

http://antipolygraph.org/

Terrible, terrible decision and I hope logic prevails very soon. I'm a supporter of perverted justice so questionable tactics to nail pedophiles isn't exactly at the top of my great injustices list, but lie detectors are pure woo and nobody should be forced into such a railroading. :mad:
 
Terrible, terrible decision and I hope logic prevails very soon. I'm a supporter of perverted justice so questionable tactics to nail pedophiles isn't exactly at the top of my great injustices list, but lie detectors are pure woo and nobody should be forced into such a railroading. :mad:

And of course, this tactic presumes guilt, which is a tad problematic.

Anyone want to join me in a media, politician and police letter-writing campaign?
 
And of course, this tactic presumes guilt, which is a tad problematic.
Yeah well the whole "after care" of sex offenders assumes guilt (I mean, future repeat offence), and it depresses me that the public appear to firmly want it that way. If any government wants to introduce repression the easiest entry point by far is to start with sex offenders (particularly against children)

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7625186.stm

Results could affect how they are monitored, but the results will not be admissible as evidence in court.
 
Last edited:
For me, the assumption of guilt isn't really the issue - it's the fact that the method itself is highly questionable. It also smacks of giving the perpetually terrified Daily Mail readers what they want, so that they can FEEL safer. After all, they've all seen movies and TV - lie detectors work, right? The slippery slope argument may also apply somewhat - if polygraphs are given any credence at all, the chance of them being used in other areas might increase.

Yes, a stiff letter-writing campaign is required! Focussing on the polys, not the paedos.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom