Liam Neeson under fire from Taken 3 gun makers

Just some random thoughts:
1) If Neeson thinks it's a "disgrace", why is he making a movie that glorifies guns? Look at the picture in the link. It screams, "a gun is the way to solve problems", and "a gun makes you a real man". Why didn't he find another way to overcome the challenges he faced in the movie?
Hypocrite.
He's an actor. A paid actor. He plays the part that the script - which is fictional - requires.

2) He said this in response to a question about the Charlie Hebdo shootings? WTF?
Perfect time. Good for him. I completely agree with him on this, and if the gun manufacturer doesn't like it, tough titties for them.
 
Just some random thoughts:
1) If Neeson thinks it's a "disgrace", why is he making a movie that glorifies guns? Look at the picture in the link. It screams, "a gun is the way to solve problems", and "a gun makes you a real man". Why didn't he find another way to overcome the challenges he faced in the movie?
Hypocrite.

It's possible to differentiate between fiction and reality. Taken is a fun movie. I enjoyed it. I'm glad he made it because it entertained me while I watched it. It certainly didn't make me want to go out and buy a gun, nor did it make me want to shoot the next person who cut in line in front of me at that cafe.

On the other hand I also think that more gun control in the US would be a good idea.

There's no conflict between A) Thinking Taken was a good movie. and B) supporting gun control.
 
1) If Neeson thinks it's a "disgrace", why is he making a movie that glorifies guns? Look at the picture in the link. It screams, "a gun is the way to solve problems", and "a gun makes you a real man". Why didn't he find another way to overcome the challenges he faced in the movie?
Hypocrite.


Err... Probably for the same reason I play video games that involve guns? He understands that it's fantasy.

Edit: Bah. Beaten to it by arthwollipot and Roboramma.
 
Last edited:
To purchase or own a gun. Did it really need to be spelled out for you?

Well, yes, you did. Because purchasing and owning a gun (and what kind of gun? A long gun or a handgun?) isn't the same thing as carrying it around. And in many places in the US, no, you cannot legally carry around a gun with only the qualifications you listed.

Why do you ask questions that you couldn't care less what the answer is?

I didn't.

Yes, I think it is.

I don't. A gun sitting in a basement isn't a problem. A gun being used by a criminal, invariably NOT in that criminal's basement, is a problem. I think the gap between these two things is very large.

They're generally committed by people who have irrational beliefs, they're performed in a way to inflict maximum damage, and the people are cowards that attack those that are either unarmed or can't fight back.

With respect to terrorism, cowardice is irrelevant. It's emotionally satisfying to label them as such because we always like to denigrate our enemies (I do too), but it's simply beside the point.

Your opinion on what is more important is noted. There are enough similarities to draw a connection. Keep picking nits, whatever you need to rationalize whatever it is you're trying to get across here.

It is strange to try dismiss my point when you admit that you do not even know what it is.
 
Didn't know that about Barrett... what a pillock.

As to prop houses... just a coincidence as I don't watch regularly, but I just saw a Shooting USA episode and hour or so ago with a couple segments on ISS. I get the gist they are one of the larger movie armorers.

The technical aspects of getting safe functional prop guns are pretty specialized, not something I expect PARA to be involved in. If that's the case, there's not much they can do about it. They either supply units for mod or they don't. They can't stop anyone from buying their own for use in a film.

Barrett took his position when California banned (subject to registration of existing firearms) any rifle chambered in .50 BMG for civilian possession. Many departments (including mine) had Barrett's in inventory.

The big prop houses will not be effected at all by Para's policy, the big houses are barely constrained by the NFA, Para isn't even a speed bump for them.
 
Sweet a gun thread! I've been saying for months we need more of these :thumbs up:
 
*words* It is strange to try dismiss my point when you admit that you do not even know what it is.

Your point is the same in every gun thread. "It's not the guns fault, leave the gun alone."

Let's not pretend like this, or any thread related to shooting or guns, are any different. This is standard practice, this thread has progressed exactly like every other one. I started one the other day, knowing it would go exactly the way it did. These are more to keep it fresh in peoples mind that at some point change is going to be needed. No matter how much people hate it, the laws now aren't working.
 
The prop houses use (or in some cases manufacture) whatever firearm the story calls for, and no prop house is going to turn down business.

It's a feel good stand by Para, as opposed to Ronnie Barrett cutting California LEA's off from sales and service on their Barrett .50's

But they are government gun grabbers so who can blame him?
 
I think they mean this line. "I think it's a disgrace. Every week now we're picking up a newspaper and seeing, 'Yet another few kids have been killed in schools.'"

He said after talking about how many guns are in private hands in America, but also after saying there are too many guns out there, but especially in America. If he is referring to another school shooting in the US every week, that is certainly factually inaccurate but I'd say most understand it as hyperbole. If he is talking about another school shooting somewhere in the world, that is much less hyperbole and perhaps even true.

I do disagree with him on one level while agreeing on another. There are far too many guns out there available for nefarious use. The actual number wouldn't matter at all if people who should not have them and/or don't know how to employ them couldn't easily get them. They're too common and too easy to make for most places to have them be scares enough to achieve that on it's own, so other measures need to be employed too. Talking about the absolute numbers doesn't help much besides to discuss certain specific proposals.

True most school shootings don't get the kind of reporting that would lead to them being in newspapers, which are dead anyway. That is the factual error. Unless you need some definition of school shooting that is not shootings in schools.
 
Being an action movie star makes you not entitled to an opinion

Charlton Heston played Moses. Does that mean he should'nt have promoted guns?

As such he clearly had no problem with killing kids to make a point, so they go really well together.
 
Just some random thoughts:
1) If Neeson thinks it's a "disgrace", why is he making a movie that glorifies guns? Look at the picture in the link. It screams, "a gun is the way to solve problems", and "a gun makes you a real man". Why didn't he find another way to overcome the challenges he faced in the movie?
Hypocrite.

At the risk of piling on: I'm about as pro-guns as it gets, but that's a terrible argument. There's all kinds of movies about murdering people, with or without guns, and I wouldn't call the filmmakers hypocrites for thinking that murder should be illegal...
 
And what do you think that accomplishes, other than erecting barriers to the poor and minorities from exercising a constitutional right? Or is that the point?

Well, if it's one thing I can say that I know about you, it's that you're a champion for the poor and minorities.

Considering that poor can't just run out and buy guns. Guns aren't cheap, they cost money to purchase, and shoot. I don't know a lot of poor people that spend a lot of time at the gun range.

As far as minorities, I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about since I am pushing for equal gun regulation no matter what color of skin they have. Only you separate it by color or race.
 
Weird, I've never actually stated that before this gun thread.

Weird, I've never actually stated what you attribute to me either.

Are you enjoying the fruits of your refusal to engage on merits?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom