Lawrence O'Donnell: Source says Russian oligarchs co-signed Trump's Loans

To be fair, it was a Fox News guest who said the caravans would bring in leprosy and smallpox, not a reporter. When a guest says something plumb false on Meet the Press, say, NBC doesn't issue a retraction.

(If they did, they'd have to issue retractions every time they featured Spicer or Huckabee Sanders.)

In media, if your guest says something that is completely and demonstrably false, and you don't question or correct it, it is the same as if you said it and didn't retract it. In some ways its even more serious because at least with sources, you have a chance to vet their information beforehand; with guests, you don't really know what they are going to say until they say it.

Its also worth noting the the "guest" in the case of the Faux News report was a regular Faux News contributor - he should have known the system and should have known better.

In the case of Lawrence O'Donnell, he is a veteran broadcaster who should have known better. However, everyone makes mistakes, and in O'Donnell's case, as soon as he realised he made one, the mea culpa was immediately forthcoming, and the same goes for Brian Williams, Rachel Maddow, Ali Velchi and the rest of the broadcasters at MSNBC when they make mistakes like this. Faux News do not... they just hope people won't notice!
 
The fact that the story got any traction at all with skeptics is because, well, its so believable.

You have:
1) multiple bankruptcies (which shows Trump's incompetence as a businessman), and a reluctance for North American banks to lend Trump money
2) Statements by Trump Jr. about how they 'get all the money they need from Russia'
3) Some rather shady financial dealings between Trump and Russian interests (such as Trump selling property to a Russian Oligarch who had no intention of living there, for millions more than any other property in the area)
4) An unwillingness to publicly release his taxes, and fights to keep other financial information from being examined by congress
5) Meetings between Trump associates and Russians in the financial industry that were later lied about
6) Deutschebank are the only bank who will lend Trump money, and they were fined $630m in Jan 2017 for laundering $10b of Russian money, and were raided again in Nov 2018 as part of another money laundering probe.

Put all that together, and the idea that Trump had Russians co-sign a loan doesn't necessarily seem that far fetched.

Ok, maybe the reporter in question was premature with his claim of 'Russians cosigned a loan'. Take that away, and what do you have? Multiple pieces of evidence (which ARE rock solid) which still tie Trump financially to Russian interests.

Added 6) for you
 
Last edited:
While I'm in agreement that Trump is a douche, he's also not considered a news source.
Oh, I think you'd find that about 40% of the American population considers Trump to be a source of truth about "what's really going on."

There's also the thing whereby statements from the POTUS are literally news in that journalists report them.

I don't know that it's a contest, i.e., the truthfulness of the POTUS is more important to me than the truthfulness of journalists; I only know that I want truthful information to be coming from both the POTUS and the Press. (I can forgive partisan spin from the POTUS, but not just abject lying.)

This wasn't a case of that happening, and Lawrence did the right thing by apologizing and retracting the story.
Agree. O'Donnell should have apologized and retracted. Trump has a few thousand apologies and retractions waiting to be uttered.

I have a certain level of trust in news organizations. ... One is more than enough.
Right, but you've already ceded that the #1 news outlet for the American people can't be trusted to tell the truth. A POTUS parroting demonstrably false stuff he sees on Fox is dangerous. Rational folks can't get complacent about calling it out.
 
Oh, I think you'd find that about 40% of the American population considers Trump to be a source of truth about "what's really going on."

There's also the thing whereby statements from the POTUS are literally news in that journalists report them.

I don't know that it's a contest, i.e., the truthfulness of the POTUS is more important to me than the truthfulness of journalists; I only know that I want truthful information to be coming from both the POTUS and the Press. (I can forgive partisan spin from the POTUS, but not just abject lying.)


Agree. O'Donnell should have apologized and retracted. Trump has a few thousand apologies and retractions waiting to be uttered.


Right, but you've already ceded that the #1 news outlet for the American people can't be trusted to tell the truth. A POTUS parroting demonstrably false stuff he sees on Fox is dangerous. Rational folks can't get complacent about calling it out.

FOX is the #1 ranked CABLE news service. NETWORK channels ABC, NBC and CBS make up the network news; all draw more viewers than FOX:

•In broadcast, NBC averaged 5.1M viewers, ahead of CBS (NYSE:CBS) at 4.2M and ABC (NYSE:DIS) at 3.7M. Fox lagged at 1.7M
https://seekingalpha.com/news/3291124-ratings-nbc-leads-broadcast-nets-fox-news-tops-cable

So most Americans do not get their news from FOX.

eta: the green grinning emoji is the result of the NYSE stock exchange name for ABC being the same as the code for the emoji.
 
Last edited:
Is there any evidence he paid too much for that property at that time? It was a pretty unique property. Trump had already dropped his asking price by I believe 25%. Billionaires buy properties they don’t intend to live in. The man supposedly bought it as an investment. It looks as if he bought it at a bad time. A few months before the crash.
He eventually razed the existing home subdivided it into 3 lots and sold one vacant lot for 30 something million. My guess is with hindsight he lost money once holding costs and lost income is considered.

How would the purchase be used to launder money? I don’t know much about money laundering.
Money laundering is very simple in concept but often extremely complex in execution. The basics go something like this:

1. Have money that was procured from an illegitimate source putting it at risk of forfeiture if government(s) find out about it.
2. Invest illegitimate money into anything legitimate. This investment can to some degree be a loser, and it can be beneficial for that to happen because bad investments are common and can confer tax advantages.
3. Take money out of investment (through revenue, selling the business/property, etc.).
3.5. Lather, rinse, repeat depending on just how dirty the money was. Filter it through different corporate entities and such.
4. Declare money that now appears to have a legitimate source.
 
FOX is the #1 ranked CABLE news service. NETWORK channels ABC, NBC and CBS make up the network news; all draw more viewers than FOX:


https://seekingalpha.com/news/3291124-ratings-nbc-leads-broadcast-nets-fox-news-tops-cable

So most Americans do not get their news from FOX.

eta: the green grinning emoji is the result of the NYSE stock exchange name for ABC being the same as the code for the emoji.


And if you believe the right wing mantra that all the other news networks are liberal commies and only Fox gives you the fair and balanced news, then you shouldn't even compare Fox to any individual network, but to the sum of all the others.. so how does Fox compare to ABC+NBC+CBS+CNN+HLN+MSNBC? Because all the conservatives watch Fox. Nom-conservatives watch any of the others and not one in particular.
 
Some examples of appropriate skepticism:

My post was highlighting that the story would be consistent with what we already know of Trump's finances, as said by members of his own family, not saying that it was true. My default position is scepticism and, as such, I don't feel the need to loudly proclaim it in every post. If you're reading more in to my posts than what I actually put in them, then that's on you, not me.
 
How would the purchase be used to launder money? I don’t know much about money laundering.

You seem to be expressing incredulity that real estate can be used to launder money. If that is what you're saying, then I can help: https://newrepublic.com/article/143...ses-dirty-money-international-crime-syndicate

At the time, Russian mobsters were beginning to invest in high-end real estate, which offered an ideal vehicle to launder money from their criminal enterprises. “During the ’80s and ’90s, we in the U.S. government repeatedly saw a pattern by which criminals would use condos and high-rises to launder money,” says Jonathan Winer, a deputy assistant secretary of state for international law enforcement in the Clinton administration. “It didn’t matter that you paid too much, because the real estate values would rise, and it was a way of turning dirty money into clean money. It was done very systematically, and it explained why there are so many high-rises where the units were sold but no one is living in them.”

[...]

After he fled the country, the government seized his five condos at Trump Tower, saying that he had purchased them to “launder money, to shelter and hide assets.”

The whole article is worth reading.

If you're just genuinely asking how money laundering works and what real estate has got to do with it, then here you go: https://www.wired.com/story/if-trump-is-laundering-russian-money-heres-how-it-works/
 
Is there any evidence he paid too much for that property at that time? It was a pretty unique property. Trump had already dropped his asking price by I believe 25%. Billionaires buy properties they don’t intend to live in. The man supposedly bought it as an investment. It looks as if he bought it at a bad time. A few months before the crash.
He eventually razed the existing home subdivided it into 3 lots and sold one vacant lot for 30 something million. My guess is with hindsight he lost money once holding costs and lost income is considered.

How would the purchase be used to launder money? I don’t know much about money laundering.

Money laundering using real estate is simplicity itself - in basic terms

The Players:
Russian Oligarch: Viktor Fukofski
US Property owner: Tronald Dump
Intermediary: Dutchiebank GMBH

1. Fukovski has ₽1.3 billion (~ US$20m) "dirty" Rubles illicitly gained from Russian mob activities that he wants to wash. He deposits that ₽1.3billion in the Moscow branch of Dutchiebank GMBH.

2. Fukovski then buys a US$15m property from Tronald Dump for $20m. Dutchiebank transfers the purchase price from Fukovski's Moscow branch account to Dump's New York branch account.

3. Fukovksi now has a "clean" US$15m property - and Dump pockets $US5m over and above the value of the property.

4. At some future time, Fukovski sells the property for, say $US18m. The purchaser deposits the purchase price into an account at the New York branch of Dutchiebank GMBH, and that money is transferred to Fukovski's Moscow branch account when it appears as ₽1.2 billion.

And there you have it; Fukovski's 1.3 billion "dirty" rubles has been laundered into 1.2 billion in "clean" rubles, using a piece of American real estate, and with a very hinky German international bank as an intermediary and co-conspirator.
 
Money laundering using real estate is simplicity itself - in basic terms

The Players:
Russian Oligarch: Viktor Fukofski
US Property owner: Tronald Dump
Intermediary: Dutchiebank GMBH

1. Fukovski has ₽1.3 billion (~ US$20m) "dirty" Rubles illicitly gained from Russian mob activities that he wants to wash. He deposits that ₽1.3billion in the Moscow branch of Dutchiebank GMBH.

2. Fukovski then buys a US$15m property from Tronald Dump for $20m. Dutchiebank transfers the purchase price from Fukovski's Moscow branch account to Dump's New York branch account.

3. Fukovksi now has a "clean" US$15m property - and Dump pockets $US5m over and above the value of the property.

4. At some future time, Fukovski sells the property for, say $US18m. The purchaser deposits the purchase price into an account at the New York branch of Dutchiebank GMBH, and that money is transferred to Fukovski's Moscow branch account when it appears as ₽1.2 billion.

And there you have it; Fukovski's 1.3 billion "dirty" rubles has been laundered into 1.2 billion in "clean" rubles, using a piece of American real estate, and with a very hinky German international bank as an intermediary and co-conspirator.

There are some reports that suggest that some of the condos Trump sold to Russians were paid for in cash. That cuts out one middle-man.
 
There are some reports that suggest that some of the condos Trump sold to Russians were paid for in cash. That cuts out one middle-man.


Yeah, but that is very risky. Huge crash transactions attract unwanted attention.

$Millions transacted through international banking conglomerates is mere ducksoup by comparison.
 
You seem to be expressing incredulity that real estate can be used to launder money. If that is what you're saying, then I can help: https://newrepublic.com/article/143...ses-dirty-money-international-crime-syndicate



The whole article is worth reading.

If you're just genuinely asking how money laundering works and what real estate has got to do with it, then here you go: https://www.wired.com/story/if-trump-is-laundering-russian-money-heres-how-it-works/

I wasn't incredulous I wanted to get a better understanding to see how President Trump could be involved.
So I think mainly the seller would only be involved if they didn't properly report the transaction including taking unreported income (cash, etc) for the purchase. I would think considering Trump would have been pretty sure of constant audits from the IRS this is unlikely. Not impossible a lot of rich people have done stupid things to hide a little income. As evidenced by some very rich people hiding money in Swiss banks to save (what should have been small amounts of money to them) from taxes on interest income.

I do believe it is a real possibility Trump doesn't want his finances looked into that closely because he does have questionable transactions.
 
Last edited:
Added 6) for you

6) Deutschebank is the only bank who will lend Trump money,
Just because you read something on the internet doesn't make it true.

6) and they were fined $630m in Jan 2017 for laundering $10b of Russian money, and were raided again in Nov 2018 as part of another money laundering probe.
They have been recipients of large fines. They have not been fined (to the best of my knowledge) for money laundering. They have been fined lax controls relating to these types of transactions. Of course the obvious question is did they have the lax controls because they knew the types of transactions. Maybe. Probably? But many other large banks have received large fines too for lax controls. They are about the champions though.
 
Just because you read something on the internet doesn't make it true.

Perhaps you could provide evidence of any other US bank that has leant Trump money, say, in last 10 years

They have been recipients of large fines. They have not been fined (to the best of my knowledge) for money laundering.
Wrong!

Deutschebank%20Fines.png

Recent history of Deutsche Bank fines in the U.S. and the U.K.
Sources: Bloomberg, Deutsche Welle, and Reuters

At least make an effort to find out if your are talking bollocks or not. This took me less than 30 seconds to find

They have been fined lax controls relating to these types of transactions. Of course the obvious question is did they have the lax controls because they knew the types of transactions. Maybe. Probably? But many other large banks have received large fines too for lax controls. They are about the champions though.

Just because you read something on the internet doesn't make it true.
 
Last edited:
IE, I don't care if the POTUS is under the control of a foreign power as long as I get my Supreme Court Justices and my Tax Breaks.

And...he makes all the lousy tree-hugging, do-gooders feel bad. In fact, with a lot of Trump supporters, I get the feeling that's number one. I think it's all about payback.
 
And...he makes all the lousy tree-hugging, do-gooders feel bad. In fact, with a lot of Trump supporters, I get the feeling that's number one. I think it's all about payback.

Yes, and it's a dangerous way to run the world.

It's a sign of weakness, I think, but one that could cost us all dearly.
 
So I think mainly the seller would only be involved if they didn't properly report the transaction including taking unreported income (cash, etc) for the purchase.

And if they didn't follow due diligence for ensuring their buyer wasn't attempting to launder money. And for deliberately allowing people to use their properties in order to launder money.

I would think considering Trump would have been pretty sure of constant audits from the IRS this is unlikely.

With this reasoning, no rich person would commit any financial crimes. I think that seems more unlikely than that Trump would do something stupid.

Or even not that stupid, given how many people get away with laundering money.
 
Perhaps you could provide evidence of any other US bank that has leant Trump money, say, in last 10 years


Wrong!

[qimg]https://www.dropbox.com/s/ae2urizrtobba4m/Deutschebank%20Fines.png?raw=1[/qimg]
Recent history of Deutsche Bank fines in the U.S. and the U.K.
Sources: Bloomberg, Deutsche Welle, and Reuters

At least make an effort to find out if your are talking bollocks or not. This took me less than 30 seconds to find



Just because you read something on the internet doesn't make it true.
This is from the press release for the NYS portion of the fines. I think this was a little over 400,000,000.
https://www.dfs.ny.gov/about/press/pr1701301.htm

The bank has conducted its banking business in an unsafe and unsound manner, failing to maintain an effective and compliant anti-money laundering program.

At least make an effort to find out if your are talking bollocks or not. This took me less than 30 seconds to find
I did make an effort. This took me more than 30 seconds but I went to the original source (I don't know your source but the wording looks biased). I don't think I am talking bollocks. (Although I am not really sure what bullocks is)

Perhaps you could provide evidence of any other US bank that has leant Trump money, say, in last 10 years
I am sure you are aware that it is not unusual for businesses to stick with the same lender for their financing. This doesn't prove any one else would loan money to Trump but the lack of it doesn't indicate anything either.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom