Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

I went to a conference today centered around the 45th anniversary of Apollo 17, and the related geology (OK, selenology). Harrison Schmitt, who is still actively researching and publishing, was there and mentioned picking up some specific samples. So that answers that question - turns out we had guys go to the Moon and bring back part of it!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8419.jpg
    IMG_8419.jpg
    55.9 KB · Views: 14
Last edited:
Zond 5 to Zond 8 all returned from the Moon, so about the same speed as an Apollo re-entry. They used modified Soyuz capsules with thicker heat shields.

Now you've gone and done it! Everyone now knows that the Soviets were part of the conspiracy of silence.
 
Last edited:
I went to a conference today centered around the 45th anniversary of Apollo 17, and the related geology (OK, selenology). Harrison Schmitt, who is still actively researching and publishing, was there and mentioned picking up some specific samples. So that answers that question - turns out we had guys go to the Moon and bring back part of it!
Did the conference include any new observations of any Lunar samples?
 
Harrison Schmitt collected the Troctolite 76535 Moon rock that we have discussed in this thread.
wogoga has the delusion that this rock could be faked using 1960's technology thus implying he believes that Schmitt is lying about collecting the rock on the Moon.


Could be a rather unprofessional fake. Abstract from Fission xenon in troctolite 76535, 1980:

"Xenon released in stepwise heating of troctolite 76535 shows remarkable similarity to that from the gas-rich breccias. The low temperature fractions are highly enriched in fissiogenic xenon from Pu-244. Although the quantity of fission xenon is not inconsistent with reported age data, release patterns demonstrate that this component is not due to in situ decay. However, in contrast with the gas-rich breccias, the parentless radionuclear component in 76535 is not accompanied by solar wind xenon. Mechanisms for the emplacement of this component in 76535 cannot, therefore, involve exposure on the lunar surface but most likely involve adsorption along intergranular boundaries or thermally driven redistribution. The fact that xenon released from a gas-poor igneous cumulate can mimic that from gas-rich breccias, except for the presence of solar wind xenon in the latter, suggests that direct exposure to space is not required for the incorporation of these weakly bound, surface-correlated, parentless radionuclear components in lunar samples."​

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
 
Could be a rather unprofessional fake. Abstract from Fission xenon in troctolite 76535, 1980:

"Xenon released in stepwise heating of troctolite 76535 shows remarkable similarity to that from the gas-rich breccias. The low temperature fractions are highly enriched in fissiogenic xenon from Pu-244. Although the quantity of fission xenon is not inconsistent with reported age data, release patterns demonstrate that this component is not due to in situ decay. However, in contrast with the gas-rich breccias, the parentless radionuclear component in 76535 is not accompanied by solar wind xenon. Mechanisms for the emplacement of this component in 76535 cannot, therefore, involve exposure on the lunar surface but most likely involve adsorption along intergranular boundaries or thermally driven redistribution. The fact that xenon released from a gas-poor igneous cumulate can mimic that from gas-rich breccias, except for the presence of solar wind xenon in the latter, suggests that direct exposure to space is not required for the incorporation of these weakly bound, surface-correlated, parentless radionuclear components in lunar samples."​

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
The conference this paper was presented concerned Lunar rocks, you know the type that could not be manufactured here on Earth. Cherry picking the abstract to prove that the sample did not have to be in space to have the xenon contained in it, proves nothing as the paper no doubt gave particular mechanisms for it to be there. Not very convincing argument from you, but why would I expect anything more from you.
 
Could be a rather unprofessional fake. Abstract from Fission xenon in troctolite 76535, 1980...

1. Exactly how would you determine it was a fake? What are your relevant credentials in geology?
2. Exactly what evidence do you have that it was actually faked? That is, what evidence do you have for the actual effort to fake the samples, let alone the rest of the missions?
3. Exactly how would you attempt to fake such a sample in all properties of said sample?
4. Exactly what evidence do you have that the thoroughly documented missions did not go to the Moon? I don't mean your inability to understand how reentry works, or your comically ignorant notions about spacecraft testing. I mean you need to show exactly how all the imagery and telemetry and teaching and all other evidence was faked, and how this fake has been somehow maintained over five decades of scientific progress and multinational space exploration.
5. The abstract you cited doesn't say or suggest that the rock was faked. It says something altogether different. Have you contacted any of the authors or institutions to see what they think about your assertion? If not, why not?
 
Could be a rather unprofessional fake. Abstract from Fission xenon in troctolite 76535, 1980:

"Xenon released in stepwise heating of troctolite 76535 shows remarkable similarity to that from the gas-rich breccias. The low temperature fractions are highly enriched in fissiogenic xenon from Pu-244. Although the quantity of fission xenon is not inconsistent with reported age data, release patterns demonstrate that this component is not due to in situ decay. However, in contrast with the gas-rich breccias, the parentless radionuclear component in 76535 is not accompanied by solar wind xenon. Mechanisms for the emplacement of this component in 76535 cannot, therefore, involve exposure on the lunar surface but most likely involve adsorption along intergranular boundaries or thermally driven redistribution. The fact that xenon released from a gas-poor igneous cumulate can mimic that from gas-rich breccias, except for the presence of solar wind xenon in the latter, suggests that direct exposure to space is not required for the incorporation of these weakly bound, surface-correlated, parentless radionuclear components in lunar samples."​

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com

Could be that yours is a deliberate misinterpretation of reality.

This site tells you where that sample was collected:

http://an.rsl.wustl.edu/apollo/browser.aspx?m=A17&station=6&is=samp

This video shows them at the site at which it was collected:

https://youtu.be/RWoMW9thdqc?t=9773

If you watch the video long enough you'll see them pan and zoom on to an image of Earth.

Is that image of Earth meteorologically accurate for when it was taken?

wp7489c3c0_05_06.jpg


Yes. It is.

Live broadcast of a location on the moon showing a sample being collected, which was later analysed by expert professionals versus the blinkered and uneducated posturing of someone desperately pushing an agenda in the face of all proof to the contrary. Which to choose....
 
Could be that yours is a deliberate misinterpretation of reality.

This site tells you where that sample was collected:

http://an.rsl.wustl.edu/apollo/browser.aspx?m=A17&station=6&is=samp

This video shows them at the site at which it was collected:

https://youtu.be/RWoMW9thdqc?t=9773

If you watch the video long enough you'll see them pan and zoom on to an image of Earth.

Is that image of Earth meteorologically accurate for when it was taken?

[qimg]http://onebigmonkey.com/apollo/CATM/ch4/a17/wpimages/wp7489c3c0_05_06.jpg[/qimg]

Yes. It is.

Live broadcast of a location on the moon showing a sample being collected, which was later analysed by expert professionals versus the blinkered and uneducated posturing of someone desperately pushing an agenda in the face of all proof to the contrary. Which to choose....

Quality.
 
Could be that yours is a deliberate misinterpretation of reality.
This site tells you where that sample was collected:

http://an.rsl.wustl.edu/apollo/browser.aspx?m=A17&station=6&is=samp

This video shows them at the site at which it was collected:

https://youtu.be/RWoMW9thdqc?t=9773

If you watch the video long enough you'll see them pan and zoom on to an image of Earth.

Is that image of Earth meteorologically accurate for when it was taken?

[qimg]http://onebigmonkey.com/apollo/CATM/ch4/a17/wpimages/wp7489c3c0_05_06.jpg[/qimg]

Yes. It is.

Live broadcast of a location on the moon showing a sample being collected, which was later analysed by expert professionals versus the blinkered and uneducated posturing of someone desperately pushing an agenda in the face of all proof to the contrary. Which to choose....
I used to rebut wogoga's posts when I interpreted them as simple misunderstandings and I hoped to enlighten him. I stopped posting rebuttals when I concluded (see highlight). Of course this is only my humble opinion...
 
Last edited:
Did the conference include any new observations of any Lunar samples?

It did, but since I was in and out I'll have to look up the agenda and papers online to give a coherent sampling.

One thing that startled me was when Schmitt suggested the Moon actually might be undergoing a magnetic field reversal - which would mean that its current lack of a field is only temporary. I'll have to follow up on that to make sure I heard that correctly, and how that would work.

One nice thing about working where I do is that I can drop by the offices of some of his collaborators. :)
 
wogoga: Implied insult of the astronauts who collected the Moon rocks

Could be a rather unprofessional fake.
More like
8 May 2017 wogoga: Implied insult of the astronauts who collected the Moon rocks by implying that they are liars.

Absurd highlighting of text in a abstract does not support the delusion of Moon rocks being fakes. What is does is show your delusions abut the Mon rocks making you unable to understand written English.
8 May 2017 wogoga: Cannot understand the English in "Fission xenon in troctolite 76535, 1980".
The points are
  • This is an examination of a sample that came from the Moon - just ask the astronaut who collected it :eye-poppi!
    Maybe not in person - one deluded person provoked Buzz Aldrin into punching them.
  • The quantity of fission xenon is consistent ("not inconsistent") with the reported age data.
  • However the pattern of release suggests that the fission xenon did not come from decay in the sample itself (in-situ). It is also not accompanied by soar wind xenon.
    Thus the mechanisms of "adsorption along intergranular boundaries or thermally driven redistribution" are preferred.
Thus troctolite 76535 was probably covered in dust or soil that protected it from the solar wind and absorbed fission xenon from the surrounding Lunar material.
 
It did, but since I was in and out I'll have to look up the agenda and papers online to give a coherent sampling.

One thing that startled me was when Schmitt suggested the Moon actually might be undergoing a magnetic field reversal - which would mean that its current lack of a field is only temporary. I'll have to follow up on that to make sure I heard that correctly, and how that would work.

One nice thing about working where I do is that I can drop by the offices of some of his collaborators. :)
Does Schmitt still work at NASA or with a University/Group?
 
Short answer to OP - the energy is dissipated in heating and atmospheric turbulence.

I used to rebut wogoga's posts when I interpreted them as simple misunderstandings and I hoped to enlighten him. I stopped posting rebuttals when I concluded (see highlight). Of course this is only my humble opinion...

I think Buzz Aldrin's fist may be the only applicable argument for some.

==

Bigger issue - what has created this era of paranoiac disbelief & unevidenced faith in silly things ? Why do so many fail to shave with Ockham's Razor ?

Certainly the moon-landing deniers and the 911-truthers are late to the game. Crop circles, and von Daniken's "ancient astronauts" are more speculation/fantasy than outright denial. Global-warming rejectors (in the limited sense of those who deny the CO2&temp evidence, not those who question the more speculative causes & results) are part of this. Then (w/o getting into the politic please) the peculiar, unevidenced beliefs about Russian meddling in the US election.

Are there versions of this sort of thing in previous eras ? Certainly there were all sorts of woo in earlier eras. Diseases caused by 'vapor's & homeopathy cures, but those were at least (at the time) beliefs in the absence of evidence, not in contradiction to available evidence. Certainly ppl subscribe to all sorts of unevidenced religious belief - resulting in things like Creationism, (distinct from anti-Darwinism), deism .....

Do ppl have some innate need to believe in silly stuff ? (well 'not me' of course).

Does the decline of religious silliness cause the silliness to spill over into other areas ? Maybe Dawkin's is wrong and religion serves a purpose aside from tribalism !
 
Short answer to OP - the energy is dissipated in heating and atmospheric turbulence.



I think Buzz Aldrin's fist may be the only applicable argument for some.

==

Bigger issue - what has created this era of paranoiac disbelief & unevidenced faith in silly things ? Why do so many fail to shave with Ockham's Razor ?

Certainly the moon-landing deniers and the 911-truthers are late to the game. Crop circles, and von Daniken's "ancient astronauts" are more speculation/fantasy than outright denial. Global-warming rejectors (in the limited sense of those who deny the CO2&temp evidence, not those who question the more speculative causes & results) are part of this. Then (w/o getting into the politic please) the peculiar, unevidenced beliefs about Russian meddling in the US election.

Are there versions of this sort of thing in previous eras ? Certainly there were all sorts of woo in earlier eras. Diseases caused by 'vapor's & homeopathy cures, but those were at least (at the time) beliefs in the absence of evidence, not in contradiction to available evidence. Certainly ppl subscribe to all sorts of unevidenced religious belief - resulting in things like Creationism, (distinct from anti-Darwinism), deism .....

Do ppl have some innate need to believe in silly stuff ? (well 'not me' of course).

Does the decline of religious silliness cause the silliness to spill over into other areas ? Maybe Dawkin's is wrong and religion serves a purpose aside from tribalism !
I think the internet has caused a resurrection in hoax beliefs. Many can thump their chests and proclaim what a smart guy/girl I am to uncover these "frauds". Very narcissistic if you ask me.
 
I think the internet has caused a resurrection in hoax beliefs. Many can thump their chests and proclaim what a smart guy/girl I am to uncover these "frauds". Very narcissistic if you ask me.

Did the population density of hoaxsters increase, or if they are simply more visible (or more vocal) due to the internet ?

I recall some 'Roswell' type stuff & Kennedy assassination theories from before the internet, but it always smelled of 'campfire stories' or obviously, more than an actual belief, or else were presented by delusional personalities. The water fluoridation fear mongering was pushed by ppl too goofy to take seriously. It could be a lot more difficult to detect on the inet.

It's not like governments or conventional news outlets in recent years elicit much confidence in their accuracy or objectivity but has something triggered a paranoia response in so many ? I think every 3rd title I read is about some mystical "elites" doing secretive, nefarious things, or about 'secrets they don't want you to know'.
 
Did the population density of hoaxsters increase, or if they are simply more visible (or more vocal) due to the internet ?

I recall some 'Roswell' type stuff & Kennedy assassination theories from before the internet, but it always smelled of 'campfire stories' or obviously, more than an actual belief, or else were presented by delusional personalities. The water fluoridation fear mongering was pushed by ppl too goofy to take seriously. It could be a lot more difficult to detect on the inet.

It's not like governments or conventional news outlets in recent years elicit much confidence in their accuracy or objectivity but has something triggered a paranoia response in so many ? I think every 3rd title I read is about some mystical "elites" doing secretive, nefarious things, or about 'secrets they don't want you to know'.

The internet gives people access to some very complicated information that is difficult to understand.

The internet gives access to people who can provide plausible sounding explanations for this information that can be incorrect and/or deliberately false.

People like to feel special and different by belonging to something not many other people do.

If people providing plausible sounding but incorrect and/or false explanations for complex information make you feel special and different and belonging to something not many other people do by telling you that you, yes you lucky reader, are one of the privileged few that can see the truth, then they will gain credence amongst the credulous at the expense of people who actually do know what they're talking about.
 
Did the population density of hoaxsters increase, or if they are simply more visible (or more vocal) due to the internet ?

I recall some 'Roswell' type stuff & Kennedy assassination theories from before the internet, but it always smelled of 'campfire stories' or obviously, more than an actual belief, or else were presented by delusional personalities. The water fluoridation fear mongering was pushed by ppl too goofy to take seriously. It could be a lot more difficult to detect on the inet.

It's not like governments or conventional news outlets in recent years elicit much confidence in their accuracy or objectivity but has something triggered a paranoia response in so many ? I think every 3rd title I read is about some mystical "elites" doing secretive, nefarious things, or about 'secrets they don't want you to know'.
I haven't seen any recent survey, but the internet has made information, both good and poor analysis of historical records. Those that are poorly equipped to judge/analyze science especially physics can easily be mislead by those that individuals claiming fraud. I believe that the internet has made such poor observations much easier to view and as such those individuals are more "vocal"
 
Previously a platform like that to which threadworm alludes was available only by satisfying gatekeeper criteria imposed by editors and publishers. While certainly some of those criteria were ideological, they were also practical. A publisher isn't going to waste his money publishing something that will easily be discredited and lose him the revenue to recover his expenses. To reach a national or global audience just a couple decades ago required convincing another person to buy into it. Today the price we pay for easily reaching a global audience is the loss of filtration. We get more ideological diversity, but we also get a larger variation in credibility.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom