Kim Jong Un - Leader of North Korea brain dead after surgery

Let's make it easier and just call them Larry, Moe, and Curly. The order doesn't really matter.
As the old saying goes: "A psychopathic tyrant by any other name is just as dangerous"

...are you calling the Three Stooges "psychopathic tyrants"? I'll grant the madness, but I don't see them as having been particularly tyrannical. Anybody allowing them into positions of power surely knew what they were getting.
 
Trying to figure out what's going on inside a black-box totalitarian state is fun. Here's my guesses:

<snip>

- It's possible that something has actually gone "right": This could be a coup.

<snip>
I don't think so. If there was a successful coup, the winners would make it very public as a way to cement their position. If it failed, there would be so many executions that intelligence agencies around the world could not miss it. Thus, one of your other conjectures might be correct.
 
To be honest, if a Korean observer of American culture got George, George, and Jeb mixed up, I wouldn't mind.

What distracts me is your complaint about people claiming to read the tea leaves. First nobody's doing that. Second, I think we all understand that guessing and speculation is all we can do. Third, there's nothing wrong with guessing and speculation on this topic.

Also, is there any way we can all agree that we know about the Korean surname thing, and we don't need to keep bringing it up every single time there's a discussion about North Korea? One of the things that bugs me about this forum is the total lack of learning and growth. It's the same boring, inane arguments over and over again.

Is there anything I can tell you, that would cause you to feel like you've said your piece, your concern has been noted, that people are going to do what they're going to do about it, and you don't have to come back to it again and again?
Is there anything I can tell you, that would cause you to feel like you've said your piece, your concern has been noted, that people are going to do what they're going to do about it, and you don't have to come back to it again and again?
 
- Kim Jong Il represents the end of a three-generation cult of personality. Is reverence for the cult of Kim Il Sung the only thing holding North Korea together? I don't know. But the country's power elite have to know that such a cult is unsustainable.

Do they, and is it unsustainable? And do we know there is a monolithic "power elite" in NK any more than there is in the West?

In a paranoid totalitarian state, trust is in really short supply. What we know of these systems from the ones that have fallen (the Third Reich, Stalin-era USSR) is that even though they may present a unified front to the outside world, on the inside they look like crabs in a bucket – bickering factions looking to take the others down. If there’s someone who’s vying for your spot in the hierarchy or otherwise looking to replace you, a misstep like thinking aloud about the country without the current Kim is equivalent to giving them a loaded gun and saying “Shoot me.” That makes it really hard to get together a clique strong and large enough to stage a coup.
 
Is there anything I can tell you, that would cause you to feel like you've said your piece, your concern has been noted, that people are going to do what they're going to do about it, and you don't have to come back to it again and again?

Probably. I think Tragic Monkey is on the right track.
 
Also, although Korean as well, not connected to the Kims in Kims Convenience. Which is something of a pity, I think Mrs Kim would make an excellent head of state. She excels in "sneak attack".

I think Harry Kim should be next in succession. It's the only way he'll ever rise above the rank of Ensign.

Dave
 
Do they, and is it unsustainable?
I would hope they know it's unsustainable. Personality cults generally don't outlive the personalities that established them. I think it's remarkable that the cult of Kim Il Sung has actually persisted so long. And personality cults seem inherently unstable anyway.

And do we know there is a monolithic "power elite" in NK any more than there is in the West?
We don't. That's your assumption. There's nothing monolithic about my estimation of the North Korean power elite. I assume it's a fractured and contentious group, up there at the top.

One of my hopes is that North Korea collapses in my lifetime, and somebody publishes an account of how the regime's power structure was arranged. Who the factions were, what strategies they employed to seize some portion of power and hold it from the others, without failing civil collapse.

Did Kim Il Sung establish such a robust power-sharing structure among his subordinates, that both his son and his grandson had relatively safe positions to step into, among the factions? I think the only way this could have lasted is if one of the factions had a vested interest in perpetuating the cult, and held enough power to enforce that over the other factions. I would love to get a detailed account of how that was set up, and how it played out over the years.
 
I would hope they know it's unsustainable. Personality cults generally don't outlive the personalities that established them. I think it's remarkable that the cult of Kim Il Sung has actually persisted so long. And personality cults seem inherently unstable anyway.

I think the more enduring ones are those established by the successors of the personality that is being cultified.

When some Central Asian or Middle Eastern dictator makes statues to himself, the statues are pulled down soon after the dictator is assassinated, or otherwise ousted from power.

But when some leader dies peacefully (or apparently peacefully) at the height of their popularity, then more enduring personality cults can be established such as the ones that were built around Lenin, Mao, Ho Chi Minh and Kim Il-sung. As long as they go to their graves relatively untarnished, then they can be propped up by those who want to appear their disciples.

As personality cults go, North Korea seems to have pulled off a remarkable stable one.

Do we hear a lot of reports out of North Korea of uprisings, or anti-Kim graffiti or of jokes about the "Oh Dear Leader" or The Onion's Most Charismatic Man, etc...? I haven't had my ear to the ground much recently, but I don't remember hearing much about it.

For the last thirty years we have seen it being claimed that North Korea is about to collapse, there will be a coup any day now, the doves will rise up, or maybe the hawks that the leader is holding off, or the Chinese will activate their sleeper agents.

For me the default is that this goes on as it has done until maybe the Porcine one eats or smokes himself to an early grave.
 
I think Harry Kim should be next in succession. It's the only way he'll ever rise above the rank of Ensign.

The character Harry Kim is undoubtedly the most influential in real life of any Star Trek character ever. They were going to can him until he got named in a list of Sexiest Actors, so they canned Kes instead. Which meant they needed another, sexier female character. So they got Seven. Seven's acting schedule put the final strain on her marriage to Jack Ryan, and in the subsequent divorce the details of the marriage that emerged cast him in such an unfavorable light he dropped out of the senate race against newcomer Barack Obama. Who in turn parlayed his senate exposure into a presidency, which was then counterreacted by a very different president two terms later.

Harry Kim created the world we now live in, just by being handsome. He's modernity's Helen of Troy!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom