Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Did I say we lost a genius? I said we lost someone who is interested in science. As I mentioned before, at his age I didn't do anything more sophisticated than he did, but it led to my life as a scientist. Even if he never becomes a scientist or engineer, there are so many people who don't have any interest in science or any understanding of it. I don't know where he will end up in his career, but he is a 14 year old damn it. And at least he is curious about stuff. And I regret the USA losing him because we need as many people like him as we can get.

And I am thrilled that my "experiments" at that age did receive the same negative reception that he has gotten. He got in the news because he was arrested for a clock, not because he will win the Nobel prize at age 19.
 
Last edited:
Did I say we lost a genius? I said we lost someone who is interested in science. As I mentioned before, at his age I didn't do anything more sophisticated than he did, but it led to my life as a scientist. Even if he never becomes a scientist or engineer, there are so many people who don't have any interest in science or any understanding of it. I don't know where he will end up in his career, but he is a 14 year old damn it. And at least he is curious about stuff. And I regret the USA losing him because we need as many people like him as we can get.

And I am thrilled that my "experiments" at that age did receive the same negative reception that he has gotten. He got in the news because he was arrested for a clock, not because he will win the Nobel prize at age 19.

I still make crap like he made. I've torn two different alarm clock radios apart looking for a unit that will lend itself to a particular casemod. (A mil-spec style alarm clock built to resemble a military radio -project still in progress) I've screwed commercial circuit boards to wooden planks to ruggedize them for bench analysis. I've taken pieces of old consumer electronics apart to salvage discrete components and subassemblies into other things.

What Ahmed built was well within usual activities for a curious explorer of technology.
 
.....
How could carrying around a case with a power cord hanging out of it look less suspicious? It's just a small thing, but I think it shows that he is lying about certain aspects of this.

Okay, suppose he was trying to provoke a reaction? The adults -- and certainly multiple cops -- didn't have to play into it. If he was trying to prove that the authorities are likely to mistreat Muslims, he succeeded. The cops handcuffed him and interrogated him while refusing to call his father. That's why the story got national attention. At most, the school should have taken the thing away from him and told him to pick it up on the way home.
 
And I regret the USA losing him because we need as many people like him as we can get.

As far as I can tell, he's just a normal avergageish kid. There's absolutely no shortage of scientists in this country, so his interest in science doesn't make him more valuable that someone with an interest in art, humanities, or even sports/entertainment.
 
Okay, suppose he was trying to provoke a reaction? The adults -- and certainly multiple cops -- didn't have to play into it. If he was trying to prove that the authorities are likely to mistreat Muslims, he succeeded. The cops handcuffed him and interrogated him while refusing to call his father. That's why the story got national attention. At most, the school should have taken the thing away from him and told him to pick it up on the way home.

Yes, it's not a difficult concept.


I think that it's more likely that he had just been enthusiastic about what he had done and wanted to show someone who should encourage such exploration of design and technology.

It would have been perfectly reasonable for a Y9 kid to show to their D&T teacher in a UK school. Encouragement was the appropriate response; informing them about the safety needs would also seem to have been good.
 
Hope he enjoys the thousands of dollars in maker equipment he was donated. Not that he planned on ever actually using any of it. Except perhaps by taking the cover off the 3D printer and removing the PCB, bringing it to school and telling all his friends "look at this 3D printer I invented".
 
Did I say we lost a genius? I said we lost someone who is interested in science. As I mentioned before, at his age I didn't do anything more sophisticated than he did, but it led to my life as a scientist. Even if he never becomes a scientist or engineer, there are so many people who don't have any interest in science or any understanding of it. I don't know where he will end up in his career, but he is a 14 year old damn it. And at least he is curious about stuff. And I regret the USA losing him because we need as many people like him as we can get.

And I am thrilled that my "experiments" at that age did receive the same negative reception that he has gotten. He got in the news because he was arrested for a clock, not because he will win the Nobel prize at age 19.

He got in the news because he brought something that a normal teacher would consider suspicious (teachers are not bomb experts). He got into the news because he was arrested because of it and almost immediately posted about it (maybe it was his sister who posted). There is a good chance he was arrested and taken in because of answers or non answers he gave to the police (There is also a chance he was arrested because the police overreacted because he was a Muslim.)
We are not aware of what he said to the police or of his prior problems with school because of privacy issues.
The media took this and turned it into a cause celebre for the obvious reasons. Personally I find it hard to believe a 14 year old did not realize it would have caused the problems it did. I would have fully expected my kids to be suspended for 3 days for a similar stunt. I would not have expected an arrest and questioning by police without me being present. But the school says there are reasons for the arrest that have not been disclosed because of privacy issues.
 
Last edited:
Hope he enjoys the thousands of dollars in maker equipment he was donated. Not that he planned on ever actually using any of it. Except perhaps by taking the cover off the 3D printer and removing the PCB, bringing it to school and telling all his friends "look at this 3D printer I invented".

If this post is intended to move the intellectual hurdle down another notch by trolling a child, you need to work harder to overcome the efforts of other members upthread. Best of luck.
 
He got in the news because he brought something that a normal teacher would consider suspicious (teachers are not bomb experts). He got into the news because he was arrested because of it and almost immediately posted about it (maybe it was his sister who posted). There is a good chance he was arrested and taken in because of answers or non answers he gave to the police (There is also a chance he was arrested because the police overreacted because he was a Muslim.)
We are not aware of what he said to the police or of his prior problems with school because of privacy issues.
The media took this and turned it into a cause celebre for the obvious reasons. Personally I find it hard to believe a 14 year old did not realize it would have caused the problems it did. I would have fully expected my kids to be suspended for 3 days for a similar stunt. I would not have expected an arrest and questioning by police without me being present. But the school says there are reasons for the arrest that have not been disclosed because of privacy issues.
Gee, you are in a tough school district! In a separate thread I highlighted another student in a Texas school who just also got 3 days suspension, and no arrest, for supergluing a girls hair, causing burns, a trip to urgent care, and having to have her hair shaved off. What would your school system have done with this latter kind of physical assault if bringing a clock would result in a 3 day suspension and an arrest? Capital punishment? Tell your kids to be extra careful, okay- don't pull out their pens from their pockets in the wrong manner or they may be arrested for a felony.

Personally I am fed up with all purely speculative personal attacks on a 14 year old boy who simply brought a reconstructed clock to class to show his teacher and was suspended for 3 days and arrested for it. Apparently people have to demean his science skills/abilities, and have to invent all sorts of malevolent motives and behavior for him that have never been shown to exist in reality. Okay, he may be less than a MERIT Scholarship finalist- I don't know. But I did the same things he did when I was 14, was never suspended or arrested, and I did okay in science later even though I never did win a MERIT scholarship.

This thread is only repeating itself and prolonging the right wing meanness that has to make this arrested kid the target of insults and empty speculation driven purely by a political agenda. I once read that conservatives differ from liberals typically by having less empathy- I have had that confirmed here.
 
Hey Qatar in is the Middle East. And as already noted, the kid is a Muslim. Is there anything more to be proven? [sarcasm]

Well we lost yet another person whose interest in science and technology could have helped the USA. I wonder why if this is one reason we are losing our ability to lead the world in these areas?

So exactly how was this kid going to help the US?
 
Giordano posted
Gee, you are in a tough school district! In a separate thread I highlighted another student in a Texas school who just also got 3 days suspension, and no arrest, for supergluing a girls hair, causing burns, a trip to urgent care, and having to have her hair shaved off. What would your school system have done with this latter kind of physical assault if bringing a clock would result in a 3 day suspension and an arrest? Capital punishment? Tell your kids to be extra careful, okay- don't pull out their pens from their pockets in the wrong manner or they may be arrested for a felony.

Personally I am fed up with all purely speculative personal attacks on a 14 year old boy who simply brought a reconstructed clock to class to show his teacher and was suspended for 3 days and arrested for it. Apparently people have to demean his science skills/abilities, and have to invent all sorts of malevolent motives and behavior for him that have never been shown to exist in reality. Okay, he may be less than a MERIT Scholarship finalist- I don't know. But I did the same things he did when I was 14, was never suspended or arrested, and I did okay in science later even though I never did win a MERIT scholarship.

This thread is only repeating itself and prolonging the right wing meanness that has to make this arrested kid the target of insults and empty speculation driven purely by a political agenda.

Putting crazy glue in hair is not an uncommon prank. But certainly worthy of a suspension.
I am not speculating when I state what the school said or that his prior school issues are not disclosed. I'm not speculating when I say the police state they arrested him because of his answers/non answers.
He was not arrested for simply bringing a reconstructed clock. I have not demeaned his science skills or invented malevolent motives. Although I have pointed out he may of had bad motives. You don't think it is a real possibility he knew full well what he was doing?


I once read that conservatives differ from liberals typically by having less empathy- I have had that confirmed here.
you don't think it would be easy to find internet posts from liberals showing a lack of empathy? This thread should not confirm anything of that sort.
 
Last edited:
Unlike all those retro bomb engineers out there who still make digital timers from discrete crystals and seven segment LEDs and 7400-series TTL chips?
This is why I don't even fuss with timers. I just put a cute little pin inside that has a note which says "please pull" and a heart next to it.

Works everytime.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom