Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

So now people are going to dis the kid? Is he being admired for being an engineering genius?

He was falsely accused, not falsely praised.
 
And?

Seriously. What is the point?

That a 14 year old rearranged the guts of a clock and called it an invention? That it was more art than science? So what? I'm at a loss to see what people are thinking here..

It is reverse engineering. People are trying to reverse engineer the incident so that it is okay to suspend and arrest the kid because he claimed it was an invention and maybe it wasn't.

It was never about a hoax bomb, it was about a false claim of inventing something. Drink the Flavor-Aide, and believe.
 
Years ago, when I was a kid, I made a radio (Crystal Set) and took it to school. See below (which is not the one I made)

Would this be mistaken for a Bomb if I told my teacher it was just a radio?

CrystalSet.jpg


Norm
 
Years ago, when I was a kid, I made a radio (Crystal Set) and took it to school. See below (which is not the one I made)

Would this be mistaken for a Bomb if I told my teacher it was just a radio?

[qimg]http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z191/fromdownunder_bucket/CrystalSet.jpg[/qimg]

Norm

That depends. Are you a brown person?
 
I too see this need among certain people to make the kid the bad guy in all this: He intended it to look like a bomb. Or his father did. Even if they were so bad at it it looks like a clock. And of course it was just being protective of the other kids to arrest him. And it's not such a great invention anyway-it 's just a re-cased clock. And it's his fault for trying to get attention for his academic interests. He listened to his engineering teacher and kept it in his backpack but shouldn't have. Or maybe he should have hidden it better.

Well, he is just a 14year old geek. He is probably not a genius, but his skills are not that different from what mine were at his age. And now I have a career as a researcher. So give the poor guy some support: he was handcuffed and arrested for bringing a clock project to school and telling his teachers about it. And if you wanted to grumble about something, you may want to grumble about his arrest, not for being a 14 year old geek.
 
And you others
The surest way to kill imagination and innovation in children is to denigrate the "inventor" from a point of superior age, education, and experience.
You want to encourage, not put-down, a kid.
Yes, he "Invented" this clock. He recased it, on his own, by taking it apart, moving it, and reassembling it into a different form factor, by himself. Without adult hovering supervision and direction.
I was doing the same thing with radios and stereos at his age, and making different speaker cabinets, as well as different antennas, trying to improve performance.
Now I do random vibration and acoustic analysis for a living, 50 years down the road.
Exactly! The kid did a much better job than I would have at his age. Or perhaps even now.

I like the double think of some: well it looked like a bomb, and it was too identical to a commercial clock!?!
 
And?

Seriously. What is the point?

That a 14 year old rearranged the guts of a clock and called it an invention? That it was more art than science? So what? I'm at a loss to see what people are thinking here.

I’ve already said what I am thinking: He had existing electronics projects that he could have brought in to show his teacher, but instead just rearranged clock in case to look somewhat like a bomb (a “suspicious” “threat” to use his own words) because he knew some teachers would freak out over this “innocent” project and expose their racism and Islamophobia. It worked. Much better than I think he could have ever hoped.

Ok. So he made a case mod of a clock, and called it a clock. I'll go one better. I'm thinking he may very well have known, and may very well have intended, that people would see it and think "bomb". Now, he made sure that people would know that it wasn't a bomb. He immediately showed it to a teacher to say, "This is a clock. Check it out." So, there was absolutely zero chance that anyone would think he had a bomb, and, this is important, no one did, in part because he made sure they wouldn't.

Let's step back a moment. Why does this matter? Because he was accused of building a hoax bomb. A key part of a hoax is that it is meant to be believed. It is not a crime to build a fake bomb. It is not a crime to build something that looks like a bomb. It is not a crime to build something that reminds someone of a bomb. The law says a "hoax" bomb for a reason. In order for it to be a hoax, you have to do it in such a way that someone might believe you. He clearly did not intend for anyone to think it was a bomb, and they clearly didn't think it was a bomb. In other words, there was absolutely zero evidence that any crime was committed, and yet he was arrested, handcuffed, and interrogated.

There was no crime committed, which is why the police did not charge him with anything. He was arrested (or at least detained, I’m not sure if he was actually arrest), handcuffed, and interrogated because the school reported the device to the police and when the police investigate this suspicious device he refused to explain his intentions, he he built it, and why he brought it to school.

He would only say that it was a clock. The police could clearly see that it was a clock. But it was a clock that clearly some people in some circumstances might perceive to be a bomb. So the police wanted to know what he was up to. He wouldn’t tell them. So they took him downtown until they could sort out what was going on. Once they figured things out, they let him go and determined no charges would be filed because he did not have intentions to use the device to cause alarm.

If he had told the police right away that he was into electronics and had made a homemade clock to show his skills to his engineering teacher and talk to him about staring an electronics or robotics club, I expect the officers would have checked out his story and soon sent him back to class without incident. But he didn’t do that. In fact, it appears the police found out more about this case through newspaper reports than they did from their own interrogation.

Why did he not tell the police all of this when they asked in order to prevent this whole incident, while he so willingly and readily told all of it to the press?
 
That's what I am leaning towards. A media stunt of some sort.

What, the kid and/or his father were expecting the school and police to act the way they did?

Why did he not tell the police all of this when they asked in order to prevent this whole incident, while he so willingly and readily told all of it to the press?

Maybe the police phrased their questions in a way that he didn't get their point? Maybe he was rattled because they would neither let him talk to his father nor let his father be present during the questioning?
 
Last edited:
Why did he not tell the police all of this when they asked in order to prevent this whole incident, while he so willingly and readily told all of it to the press?

Because he now lives in a free country, and in a free country you are not compelled to do something just because a cop thinks you ought to. In a free country the police cannot interrogate you on a whim. They have to be investigating a crime, and there was no evidence of any crime. He did not claim to have a bomb, and they had enough information to verify that he had gone out of his way to ensure that they knew it was not a bomb. Therefore, by definition, there was no hoax.

He does not owe the police, or the media, or the populace, or you and the rest of us on ISF any explanation of his behavior. He did not commit a crime, and the police knew he did not commit a crime.

This isn't hard. They cuffed, and fingerprinted, and took mug shots of this kid. They isolated him, without access to his parents or an attorney. If cops can do that to people just because people don't answer their questions to their satisfaction, then this country is not free.
 
The kid is 14. What do you expect. Nanotechnolgy

Kid rearranged an existing clock which obviously is still a clock and half the police force went to catch the Muslim
 
Originally Posted by Noztradamus View Post
The preferred term is "Art Engineering Project"

ftfy

And engineering project a 14 yr old might construct.
original was better. It's always an "Art Project" not a "Social Engineering Project" when a fiction is created to highlight a "concern"

http://jezebel.com/emma-sulkowiczs-newest-art-project-is-a-disturbing-sex-1709234401

http://www.ubspectrum.com/article/2...ite-only-and-black-only-signs-for-art-project
 
original was better. It's always an "Art Project" not a "Social Engineering Project" when a fiction is created to highlight a "concern"

http://jezebel.com/emma-sulkowiczs-newest-art-project-is-a-disturbing-sex-1709234401

http://www.ubspectrum.com/article/2...ite-only-and-black-only-signs-for-art-project

I don't think the kid was highlighting a political concern nor creating a fiction when he made his clock project. He was making (remaking) a clock. But maybe the clock represents the oppression of women in a racist society and I missed the point. I can be pretty obtuse: my teacher told me that Moby Dick is symbolic, but I thought it was a book about a whale.
 
Way to try to justify ganging up on a 14 year old and trying to dig up dirt

Next dad will have only gone to Muslim shops
 
Way to try to justify ganging up on a 14 year old and trying to dig up dirt

Next dad will have only gone to Muslim shops

Yeah- psst-i heard that his dad was a (don't tell anyone) a Democrat!
And that his mom once had an overdue book at the library!
And that the kid has a Jabba the Hut toy because Jabba is a "white slaver"

They should all just be deported because they aren't TRUE AMERICANS! They are just low-down foreign immigrants. Like my grandparents. But darker.
 
I’ve already said what I am thinking: He had existing electronics projects that he could have brought in to show his teacher, but instead just rearranged clock in case to look somewhat like a bomb (a “suspicious” “threat” to use his own words) because he knew some teachers would freak out over this “innocent” project and expose their racism and Islamophobia. It worked. Much better than I think he could have ever hoped.



There was no crime committed, which is why the police did not charge him with anything. He was arrested (or at least detained, I’m not sure if he was actually arrest), handcuffed, and interrogated because the school reported the device to the police and when the police investigate this suspicious device he refused to explain his intentions, he he built it, and why he brought it to school.

He would only say that it was a clock. The police could clearly see that it was a clock. But it was a clock that clearly some people in some circumstances might perceive to be a bomb. So the police wanted to know what he was up to. He wouldn’t tell them. So they took him downtown until they could sort out what was going on. Once they figured things out, they let him go and determined no charges would be filed because he did not have intentions to use the device to cause alarm.

If he had told the police right away that he was into electronics and had made a homemade clock to show his skills to his engineering teacher and talk to him about staring an electronics or robotics club, I expect the officers would have checked out his story and soon sent him back to class without incident. But he didn’t do that. In fact, it appears the police found out more about this case through newspaper reports than they did from their own interrogation.

Why did he not tell the police all of this when they asked in order to prevent this whole incident, while he so willingly and readily told all of it to the press?

You've never been "interviewed" by cops with preconceived notions, I take it.
 
Yeah- psst-i heard that his dad was a (don't tell anyone) a Democrat!
And that his mom once had an overdue book at the library!
And that the kid has a Jabba the Hut toy because Jabba is a "white slaver"

They should all just be deported because they aren't TRUE AMERICANS! They are just low-down foreign immigrants. Like my grandparents. But darker.

I'm worse than that. I'm a white native-born American who voted for a Muslim running for president. :jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom