Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Is bringing that up useful to any reasonable conversation?

I assume you are posting it because this is a Conservative Christian argument, ignoring their own issues?

It;s a bigoted argument from ignorance,frankly,and a lot of Conservative Christians are very guilty of those faults.
 
The thing on Facebook now is some kid who made a "rebuttal" video criticizing Obama for inviting the guy to the White House. He's like, "If I made a clock and brought it to school, could I go to the White House, too?"

Nice straw man, of course. But hey, republicans are wetting themselves all over it.
 
Catsmate (quote function not working for me today)
Now it seems that paragon of sensible decision making Bristol Palin objects to President Obama's invitation:
"This is the kind of stuff Obama needs to STAY out of". and "This encourages more racial strife that is already going on with the 'Black Lives Matter' crowd and encourages victimhood. The police made a mistake, clearly. But why put more people against them? Why egg it on? Childish games like this from our president have divided our country… even more today than when he was elected."

I wouldn't necessarily agree with that (though maybe the first half of the last sentence, second half makes no sense), but it is interesting how Obama selects the "victims" he invites to the White House. A Muslim kid built a clock, whoopee. If you fit into his personal politics appropriately you get the invitation. There are people in national news that have suffered much more - Kate Steinle's family for example. Nope, that wouldn't fit in with his push for everyone to accept illegal aliens. No invitation - not even a phone call.

I don't think this event makes the police look bad, I think this is the result of the irrational fear that permeates our society. The police knew it wasn't a bomb immediately. Remember the 7 year-old kid who made his Pop Tart resemble a gun by chewing on it? He has a suspension on his record, but no invitation to the White House. He was just an innocent kid like Clock Boy.

The whole "invitation to the White House" practice is kind of silly anyways, for the most part. It's always political.
 
But if you have a student who makes a clock, says it's a clock and you know the kid is a nerdy engineering type, where does the fake bomb threat even come from here? How did that even become an issue?

Was the school evacuated?
Did the kid joke it was a bomb?


I don't agree that a white kid with a briefcase clock would have been ignored. But I do think if a nerdy engineering type white kid told his teacher it was a clock he made, none of the rest would have happened.

They didn't accuse him of making a bomb threat they accused him of trying to make a fake bomb, they knew it wasn't actually a bomb. They thought it looked like a bomb..not really different than if a kid brought a toy gun to school. You wouldn't evacuate the school over a toy gun, but the kid would probably get into pretty big trouble given how much over reaction occurs in public schools. I'm not saying the situation wasn't absolutely ridiculous. But equally ridiculous situations have happened to white students, that's why I see no reason to invoke anti-mulsim bigotry.
 
I wouldn't necessarily agree with that (though maybe the first half of the last sentence, second half makes no sense), but it is interesting how Obama selects the "victims" he invites to the White House. A Muslim kid built a clock, whoopee. If you fit into his personal politics appropriately you get the invitation. There are people in national news that have suffered much more - Kate Steinle's family for example. Nope, that wouldn't fit in with his push for everyone to accept illegal aliens. No invitation - not even a phone call.

I don't think this event makes the police look bad, I think this is the result of the irrational fear that permeates our society. The police knew it wasn't a bomb immediately. Remember the 7 year-old kid who made his Pop Tart resemble a gun by chewing on it? He has a suspension on his record, but no invitation to the White House. He was just an innocent kid like Clock Boy.

The whole "invitation to the White House" practice is kind of silly anyways, for the most part. It's always political.

Palin's comment reminds me of the 1960s quotes from segregationist legislators and governors: "Them kneegrows are happy here. Why many of them feel right attached to the white families who they serve as maids and shoeshine boys. It's them outside agitators who create all the problems by stirring them kneegrows up. We'd all just get along fine if it wasn't for those outsiders creating problems!"

As to your view: sure, there are other kids who have been punished unjustly. But I would remind everyone that (1) the clock looked like a clock, and was never meant to look even like a cartoon bomb, (2) the cops obviously took it seriously as a crime, if only as the crime of creating a false weapon with the idea of terrorizing people. The cops arrested the 14 year old in handcuffs, prevented him from speaking to his parents, threatened him with jail, and questioned him for over an hour, (3) I think that it very difficult to not equate the overreaction on the part of the school and the police with the religion and ethnicity of the boy. Can I prove it- of course not- no official is going to say now that they did it from bigotry. But that is the way to bet in my opinion.

I would finally add that being punished for doing something scientific and ambitious in an environment designed to encourage such efforts deserves a bit more Presidential attention than biting a Poptart into the shape of a gun. This is not to say that the latter deserves punishment, but it is not like the former. Even more so if the punishment was almost clearly due to racial and religious bigotry.
 
I wouldn't necessarily agree with that (though maybe the first half of the last sentence, second half makes no sense), but it is interesting how Obama selects the "victims" he invites to the White House. A Muslim kid built a clock, whoopee. If you fit into his personal politics appropriately you get the invitation. There are people in national news that have suffered much more - Kate Steinle's family for example. Nope, that wouldn't fit in with his push for everyone to accept illegal aliens. No invitation - not even a phone call.

I don't think this event makes the police look bad, I think this is the result of the irrational fear that permeates our society. The police knew it wasn't a bomb immediately. Remember the 7 year-old kid who made his Pop Tart resemble a gun by chewing on it? He has a suspension on his record, but no invitation to the White House. He was just an innocent kid like Clock Boy.

The whole "invitation to the White House" practice is kind of silly anyways, for the most part. It's always political.
I don't think this kid was an illegal alien, and I don't think the pop tart kid was marched out in handcuffs.
 
Last edited:
They didn't accuse him of making a bomb threat they accused him of trying to make a fake bomb, they knew it wasn't actually a bomb. They thought it looked like a bomb..not really different than if a kid brought a toy gun to school. You wouldn't evacuate the school over a toy gun, but the kid would probably get into pretty big trouble given how much over reaction occurs in public schools. I'm not saying the situation wasn't absolutely ridiculous. But equally ridiculous situations have happened to white students, that's why I see no reason to invoke anti-mulsim bigotry.

But they only thought it looked like a bomb because they were stupid, and IMHO, racist and bigoted. Yes, it is very different from bringing in a toy gun- a toy gun is meant to look somewhat like a gun. Here with the 14 year old it wasn't intended to look at all like a bomb, in fact it didn't look like a bomb (fake or real) and the boy, when asked, explained that it wasn't either a fake or real bomb. It lacked the most crucial component of any bomb, fake or real- anything that looked like explosives. He brought in a clock! It looked like a clock. It showed time like a clock. It was a clock. He explained it was a clock. Yet for some reason the principal and the police it looked like a (fake) bomb. I wonder what that reason might have been...

An example: if I bring in a fully normal umbrella to school and someone thinks it looks like a sword because they have no idea what a sword looks like, should I be arrested and suspended as a consequence? What if someone thinks that my Nikes look like shoe bombs- not for any real reason, just that shoes look like shoe bombs to them? Or my pencils look like knives, again because that person has no clue what the real things look like?
 
I don't think this kid was an illegal alien, and I don't think the pop tart kid was marched out in handcuffs.

I missed that in the actual post. Thanks! Exactly why does this issue bring up illegal aliens in the post fagin quoted?
 
They didn't accuse him of making a bomb threat they accused him of trying to make a fake bomb, they knew it wasn't actually a bomb. They thought it looked like a bomb..not really different than if a kid brought a toy gun to school. You wouldn't evacuate the school over a toy gun, but the kid would probably get into pretty big trouble given how much over reaction occurs in public schools. I'm not saying the situation wasn't absolutely ridiculous. But equally ridiculous situations have happened to white students, that's why I see no reason to invoke anti-mulsim bigotry.

It's not the same as bringing a toy gun to school. If you bring a toy gun, you are intentionally bringing a toy gun. This is like bringing a slide rule and being suspended because someone thinks it looks like a gun.
 
Whoops! Took a pressure cooker in to school cookery lesson now on my way to Gitmo.

Sorry, but it did look like real a bomb to me. One can't be too careful. And I am certain that eventually this little issue will get clearred up after a bit of... questioning... at Gitmo. And then they might release you.. to Sudan.

Just a quick question: on a scale of 1 to 10 how dark is your skin? Of course that has nothing to do with if you get an A in cooking or spend some time in Cuba. Your answer to the skin question vs your treatment would only be a coincidence.
 
It's not the same as bringing a toy gun to school. If you bring a toy gun, you are intentionally bringing a toy gun. This is like bringing a slide rule and being suspended because someone thinks it looks like a gun.

Slide rules reminded me of retractable knives, and did anyone else notice that calculators also look a bit like bombs?

I still remember log tables at the backs of math books. Now those were dangerous!
 
The whole "invitation to the White House" practice is kind of silly anyways, for the most part. It's always political.

Politicians are supposed to be political. That's kind of the point.

The President, in particular, has a "bully pulpit". Part of his job is to make symbolic statements that encourage people to do the things he wants them to do, to adopt the values he thinks ought to be the country's values.

In this case he is encouraging science while chastising overreactions, especially overreactions which an awful lot of people think are based on bigotry.


Should "pop tart boy" have gotten an invite? If he had been handcuffed, fingerprinted, and had a mug shot taken, he very well might have gotten one. However, perhaps not, because while there was an overreaction to the pop tart incident, it wasn't something that we necessarily want to encourage. We shouldn't care very much if kids chew pop tarts into the shape of a gun and use it as a toy, but we do want kids to wire up electric circuits in novel ways.
 
Politicians are supposed to be political. That's kind of the point.

The President, in particular, has a "bully pulpit". Part of his job is to make symbolic statements that encourage people to do the things he wants them to do, to adopt the values he thinks ought to be the country's values.

In this case he is encouraging science while chastising overreactions, especially overreactions which an awful lot of people think are based on bigotry.


Should "pop tart boy" have gotten an invite? If he had been handcuffed, fingerprinted, and had a mug shot taken, he very well might have gotten one. However, perhaps not, because while there was an overreaction to the pop tart incident, it wasn't something that we necessarily want to encourage. We shouldn't care very much if kids chew pop tarts into the shape of a gun and use it as a toy, but we do want kids to wire up electric circuits in novel ways.

As the boy is a minor, were the police entitled to question him without representatives?
 
Politicians are supposed to be political. That's kind of the point.

The President, in particular, has a "bully pulpit". Part of his job is to make symbolic statements that encourage people to do the things he wants them to do, to adopt the values he thinks ought to be the country's values.

In this case he is encouraging science while chastising overreactions, especially overreactions which an awful lot of people think are based on bigotry.


Should "pop tart boy" have gotten an invite? If he had been handcuffed, fingerprinted, and had a mug shot taken, he very well might have gotten one. However, perhaps not, because while there was an overreaction to the pop tart incident, it wasn't something that we necessarily want to encourage. We shouldn't care very much if kids chew pop tarts into the shape of a gun and use it as a toy, but we do want kids to wire up electric circuits in novel ways.
And pop tart gun kid had a history of disruptive behavior and disciplinary problems:
Nussbaum wrote: “As much as the parents want this case to be about a ‘gun,’ it is, rather, a case about classroom disruption from a student who has had a long history of disruptive behavior and for whom the school had attempted a list of other strategies and interventions before resorting to a suspension.”

Nussbaum said he was convinced that “had the student chewed his cereal bar into the shape of a cat and ran around the room, disrupting the classroom and making ‘meow’ cat sounds, the result would have been exactly the same.”
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/hearing-examiner-backs-suspension-of-boy-who-chewed-pastry-into-gun-shape/2014/06/30/f3aee730-004b-11e4-b8ff-89afd3fad6bd_story.html
 
Slide rules reminded me of retractable knives, and did anyone else notice that calculators also look a bit like bombs?

I still remember log tables at the backs of math books. Now those were dangerous!

I think the 'passive aggression' may mean he mentioned evolution. I think I mentioned evolution once (in Texas), but I think I got away with it.


Whoops! No on the way to hell. (And you have no idea how annoying that is since I only just escaped from a demon dimension.)
 
They didn't accuse him of making a bomb threat they accused him of trying to make a fake bomb, they knew it wasn't actually a bomb. They thought it looked like a bomb..not really different than if a kid brought a toy gun to school. You wouldn't evacuate the school over a toy gun, but the kid would probably get into pretty big trouble given how much over reaction occurs in public schools. I'm not saying the situation wasn't absolutely ridiculous. But equally ridiculous situations have happened to white students, that's why I see no reason to invoke anti-mulsim bigotry.

They had about a half dozen cops for what was obviously a clock.

I think your average "white" kid wouldn't be treated so stupidly

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2
 
As the boy is a minor, were the police entitled to question him without representatives?

I'm not sure why you are asking me this. I don't see the connection to my post.

According to posts earlier in the thread, a minor is entitled to ask for his parents, who then are supposed to be called. I have no idea if that's accurate, but they did post some reference material on the subject.
 
bwhxu3rpk7wkjv1qtch0.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom