Karen - Stop!

When they hound people in public like prima donnas, bother the manager etc, they get what they deserve, it has nothing to do with this attempt to paint it as chauvanism, there are male karens to, the title isnt the stereotyping tradegy some want it to be, it is fitting and deserved.

I think most people are just complaining about the word used, not the fact that there's a stereotype. I don't care about the stereotyping (although including the haircut seems really stupid) - just, why do they have to be called karens? Why not "prima donnas" as you keep saying or something else like that.

Reading through this thread is odd, because one gets the impression people aren't actually reading their opponent's posts. There's like fifty different arguments happening at once.

The issue is that the stereotype uses a common name as a pejorative, not that the stereotype exists.

Yeah, yeah, other names exist as pejoratives. I know, y'all mentioned that a few times. *Engage broken record program* - None of them have the popularity of "karen;" the pejorative "dick" has been around for decades, so any Richard choosing to go by that is doing it with full knowledge; "john" is an absurd one to even include and weakens your overall argument, because nobody makes fun of people for being called john. "Chad" and "stacey" are equally rude as karen, I hate those terms, but they also aren't anywhere near as widely known as karen.

Repeat, repeat, repeat. I feel like a bot now.

The fact that "karen" is as popular a meme as it is right now means it will burn out fairly soon, regardless. But the name will still be tainted for awhile.
 
In no way comparable. I didn’t say there weren’t words to insult men. Apart from the never used word Chad, none of these are words designed to tell men to shut up.
All of them are designed to tell men to shut up. The whole point of these derogatory terms is to dismiss a man and invalidate his opinions. That's the whole point of insults generally.

ETA what is the male version of harridan?
Harrier.

You're making a fetish of linguistic symmetry, instead of recognizing the same underlying mechanism.

If you were a quantum physicist, you'd be insisting that the electron can't have the opposite charge from a proton because they don't have exactly the same mass.
 
BTW....

For those that keep asking about the origins....

It seems that the Karen meme as it is today has four parts to the origin.

In 2004 in Mean Girls, Amanda Seyfried plays the part of Karen Smith. In one part of the movie Karen asks a fellow student a question to do with their race..



A year later Dana Cook added the following to his comedy routine...

I think you mean Dane Cook. And if Dane Cook started this or helped start the karen thing then I'm officially out!!! No longer will I use the word karen for anything other than a person's name.


**** you, Dane Cook, you suck!



Heh! "Ever notice how bathroom floors are always wet?"

the Associated Press wasn't so sure, publishing an article in 2006 titled, "Is Dane Cook Funny?" (its answer wasn't entirely yes). The harshest critics were other comedians who couldn't fathom why Cook's seemingly jokeless material ("Ever notice how bathroom floors are always wet?") could fill up arenas.

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/features/bring-haters-dane-cook-plots-a-comedy-comeback-1185532

End Rant
 
Last edited:
I think you mean Dane Cook. And if Dane Cook started this or helped start the karen thing then I'm officially out!!! No longer will I use the word karen for anything other than a person's name.


**** you, Dane Cook, you suck!

The good news is that you know if Dane Cook used it, he got it from someone else and it didn't start with him.
 
I think most people are just complaining about the word used, not the fact that there's a stereotype. I don't care about the stereotyping (although including the haircut seems really stupid) - just, why do they have to be called karens? Why not "prima donnas" as you keep saying or something else like that.

Reading through this thread is odd, because one gets the impression people aren't actually reading their opponent's posts. There's like fifty different arguments happening at once.

The issue is that the stereotype uses a common name as a pejorative, not that the stereotype exists.

Yeah, yeah, other names exist as pejoratives. I know, y'all mentioned that a few times. *Engage broken record program* - None of them have the popularity of "karen;" the pejorative "dick" has been around for decades, so any Richard choosing to go by that is doing it with full knowledge; "john" is an absurd one to even include and weakens your overall argument, because nobody makes fun of people for being called john. "Chad" and "stacey" are equally rude as karen, I hate those terms, but they also aren't anywhere near as widely known as karen.

Repeat, repeat, repeat. I feel like a bot now.

The fact that "karen" is as popular a meme as it is right now means it will burn out fairly soon, regardless. But the name will still be tainted for awhile.

Because "Karen" makes it stick and makes it personal. It's even funnier when they try to shut the meme down and it only gets reinforced all the more.
 
Because "Karen" makes it stick and makes it personal. It's even funnier when they try to shut the meme down and it only gets reinforced all the more.

Personal to whom, though?

EDIT: I don't deny that people bitching about it probably breathes life into it, at least for now. That's the same basic premise as the Streisand Effect (I think).
 
Last edited:
Personal to whom, though?

EDIT: I don't deny that people bitching about it probably breathes life into it, at least for now. That's the same basic premise as the Streisand Effect (I think).

I think I can agree with that, but being called by a name, a personal name, is the same as hey YOU! Stop that, it's not okay.
 
I never claimed it was a woman’s name. I put it out there with words like harpy and now Karen as shorthand for “shut up woman”.

I wasn't suggesting you were - I was just musing that if you could get "harridan" in vogue as a lazy insult to replace Karen, it's not going to be anyone's name.

Reading through this thread is odd, because one gets the impression people aren't actually reading their opponent's posts.

Holy crap, we need a .gif emoji with eyes popping!

That sort of thing never happens here.
 
It is quite funny how people on this thread have suddenly started writing Karen with a small "k" to try to separate it from a person's name, as if this backs their argument, when it isn't normally.
As I said before, if I saw the word spelled with a lower case k even occasionally in the media, I might buy the argument that it's being used as a descriptor and not as a name.
 
Really? How about bitch, cow, moo, whore, slut, harlot, cougar, moll, hag, tart, dragon, ho, crone & ratchet



Nuff for ya!?
No not really.

I have never heard of half of those and I could name a shed load more for dudes but would be banned

It is an interesting point actually. Female ones seem less offensive

Since when have people called women moos?, dragon or ratchet?

I don't even no what they mean
 
Railing against the use of "Karen" to describe an entitled, arrogant, obnoxious woman is rather like complaining after the stable door has been left open and the horse has bolted... too late to bitch about it now!
 
Railing against the use of "Karen" to describe an entitled, arrogant, obnoxious woman is rather like complaining after the stable door has been left open and the horse has bolted... too late to bitch about it now!

"Railing against"

Slightly over blowing the sentiment.

But that is the way "Smartcookies" exaggerate.
 
"Railing against"

Slightly over blowing the sentiment.

But that is the way "Smartcookies" exaggerate.

Your problem is that I wasn't even talking to you (when I'm talking to you, I will quote your post or start with "@cullenz")

I was addressing the overall topic, which IIRC, begins with TheAtheist railing against the "Karen" meme.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom