Johnny Gosch Conspiracy Theory?

Let's take out the Bohemian Grove and Gannon. The links at the top of this thread claim to substantiate a wider network of pedophiles including powerful men centered but not exclusive to Ohama. Has this CT been authoritatively debunked yet? If so, links please.

I have put together a very careful proof that shows that no powerful men centered on but not exclusive to Ohama are guilty. Now, if you're talking about Omaha, that I have not been able to rule out conclusively.
 
I have put together a very careful proof that shows that no powerful men centered on but not exclusive to Ohama are guilty. Now, if you're talking about Omaha, that I have not been able to rule out conclusively.

Show me, please. Thanks.
 
I didn't see anything like that substantiated, I just saw quotes from Noreen Gosch to that effect. Where did you see anyone else but her saying these things?

Did you read the links? Particularly the last one.

http://www.franklincase.org/indepth.htm

They consisted of a lot more than Noreen Gosch quotes. There was a whole court case and political battle in Omaha about this according to them. Not to say that this CT is true, but it does seem to have a wider base than quotes from Noreen Gosch.
 
There was a similar conspiracy theory e few years ago here in NSW alleging state parliamentarians and high court justices in some kind of pedophile ring.
IIRC it was being spread by the religious right wing nutters in parliament.
I don't recall anything ever coming out of it.
 
@Dave: Are you aware of the so called "Call Boys Scandal" that took place in Washington DC at the same time?

Frontpage of the Washington Times, June 29 1989

KARLYN BARKER, WASHINGTON POST, JULY 24, 1990: The alleged leader of what authorities have called the largest male prostitution operation in the Washington area surrendered to federal agents yesterday and pleaded not guilty to racketeering charges that have been filed against him and three alleged accomplices. Henry W. Vinson, 29, of Williamson, W.Va., a coal miner's son accused of setting up the homosexual escort service, was arraigned in U.S. District Court here yesterday afternoon after turning himself in to Secret Service agents . . . At a news conference after the arraignment, [U.S. Attorney Jay] Stephens said the investigation into the alleged prostitution ring "is concluded" and that the indictment, which was unsealed yesterday, focused on those who allegedly set up the ring rather than on clients who reportedly patronized it. Asked about earlier reports that some of those clients included high-level officials in the Reagan and Bush administrations, Stephens said the investigation had not revealed "additional conduct which suggests criminal conduct on behalf of other people." . . . The Vinson case provoked additional notice after The Washington Times published reports last summer suggesting that the alleged prostitution ring had been patronized by government officials. The Times named as clients several low-level government employees and Craig J. Spence, a Washington lobbyist and party-giver who, the paper said, took friends and prostitutes on late-night tours of the White House. Spence was found dead in a Boston hotel room last fall, and authorities ruled his death a suicide . . . To date, however, investigators have disclosed no evidence linking any high-level government official to the escort service.

Craig Spence was, according to John DeCamp, closely connected to Lawrence King and the Franklin Case.

Archive of articles mostly from the Washington Times covering the "Call Boys Scandal"
(Collected by Sander Hicks, so feel free to concentrate on the articles and ignore his comments if you think he is a "CT").

These links are from my archives. I havn't looked into it very much and don't know how credible the whole story is. Unfortunately there seem to be similar stories in a lot of countries.
 
Is this case related to "satan worshippers made me kill children in the pentagram in their basement" stories that were going around in the 80's? or was that just the "recovered" memory movement that set that off?
 
@Dave: Are you aware of the so called "Call Boys Scandal" that took place in Washington DC at the same time?

Frontpage of the Washington Times, June 29 1989



Craig Spence was, according to John DeCamp, closely connected to Lawrence King and the Franklin Case.

Archive of articles mostly from the Washington Times covering the "Call Boys Scandal"
(Collected by Sander Hicks, so feel free to concentrate on the articles and ignore his comments if you think he is a "CT").

These links are from my archives. I havn't looked into it very much and don't know how credible the whole story is. Unfortunately there seem to be similar stories in a lot of countries.

Interesting. So, where are the thorough skeptical analyses of these CT's? Particularly of the strongest forms of these CT's. I've been impressed by the thorough skpetical critiques of the strongest of the 9/11 CTs.
 
Is this case related to "satan worshippers made me kill children in the pentagram in their basement" stories that were going around in the 80's? or was that just the "recovered" memory movement that set that off?

I'm more interested in critiques of the strongest forms of these CT's rather than the weaker, more strawmanesque forms of them. Theories that satanists are in high positions of govt. or that Gannon is Gosch seem far-fetched to me. The highest positions of govt. are filled by narcissists, they're not going to waste their time worshipping anything else behind closed doors.
 
Did you read the links? Particularly the last one.

http://www.franklincase.org/indepth.htm
Well, I didn't read that link, because it's not in the OP. That page describes a sordid investigation that sounds like the McMartin preschool case. Some of the snippets that I thought were telling:
Through Paul’s abuse and trauma he had developed multiple personality disorder. One of Paul’s personalities used his mind as if it were a computer, storing information: names, dates, and places. Paul’s ability to remember exact places, dates, and names helped Caradori corroborate much of Alisha Troy, and Danny’s testimonies.
Anyone with the slightest understanding of "recovered memories" would have their baloney detector blaring at that point.

Then the grand jury decided:
Two and half years after Franklin’s doors had been closed in November of 1988 the Grand Jury finally issued its Franklin Case Report. Only twelve days after Caradori’s death, the Grand Jury testified that the entire case was "A Carefully Crafted Hoax."
By 1988, they could see what had been going on.

Thanks for pointing out that site. Yes, there were allegations of a wider scandal, from other people besides Noreen, but that had about as much credibility as Noreen's: next to zero.
 
Well, I didn't read that link, because it's not in the OP. That page describes a sordid investigation that sounds like the McMartin preschool case. Some of the snippets that I thought were telling:

Anyone with the slightest understanding of "recovered memories" would have their baloney detector blaring at that point.

Then the grand jury decided:By 1988, they could see what had been going on.

Thanks for pointing out that site. Yes, there were allegations of a wider scandal, from other people besides Noreen, but that had about as much credibility as Noreen's: next to zero.

You found some weak points. such as any mention of multiple personalities. But this doesn't read to me like a strong debunking of many of the CT's elements. Anyone have such a debunking? There would be strong stakeholders in it being put together, given the people accused, their significant resources, and a reasonable desire to more thoroughly clear their names.
 
A side question would be what's the largest (in terms of adult participants) true child sexual exploitation CT, and the one that implicates the most powerful people. Given the many allegations that seem to pop up throughout time and geography, I wonder to what degree any have been substantiated. I have the sense that a few times in the Roman Catholic church hierarchy there have been multiple colluding priest-abusers, but I haven't read a lot of authoritative material about that. Also, I've heard more than once about british boarding schools with customary rapings of underclassmen by senior classmen, but I haven't actually read news accounts of exposes or investigations. I'm asking to get a sense whether this ever happens in modern society, or if like the Salem Witchtrials, it says more about irrational human tendencies to engage it particular types of -- witchhunts.
 
Trinity Grammar School in Sydney was the scene of some horrific ritual soddomisation. There was a big court case and I think it mostly involved students who were borders there.
 
A side question would be what's the largest (in terms of adult participants) true child sexual exploitation CT, and the one that implicates the most powerful people. Given the many allegations that seem to pop up throughout time and geography, I wonder to what degree any have been substantiated. I have the sense that a few times in the Roman Catholic church hierarchy there have been multiple colluding priest-abusers, but I haven't read a lot of authoritative material about that. Also, I've heard more than once about british boarding schools with customary rapings of underclassmen by senior classmen, but I haven't actually read news accounts of exposes or investigations. I'm asking to get a sense whether this ever happens in modern society, or if like the Salem Witchtrials, it says more about irrational human tendencies to engage it particular types of -- witchhunts.

I don't know whether all her victims were children (I believe a percentage were young women), but for sheer number of victims and powerful perpetrators, it's hard to top the case of Erzsebet Bathory, a Polish contess and niece of the King. She and her palace henchmen dispatched as many as 650 village girls. The Countess believed that she could remain eternally youthful if she continually bathed in the blood of young women, so she worked very hard to ensure there was always a fresh supply on tap. Come to think of it, she'd have made a nice little wife for Ted Bundy, don't you think?
 
talked about on the radio in DC on 9/8

The very popular DC101 morning radio show here in Washington is giving a ton of air time to the Johnny Gosch case and the conspiracy theories that go with it (XXXXX scroll down to Thursday). Although it is interesting that after talking about this on Friday with a rep from Americas Most Wanted (who seems to have gotten all of her conspiracy facts from the Noreen Gosch’s website) EITM did not mention it in the review. Maybe they are finally getting skeptical too.

I found this from a 1996 article by CSICOP about speakers at a conference on mind control: XXXXXXX (scroll down or search for “Bonacci”, be sure to read through the part about Senator DeCamp and the Franklin Cover-up)

It won’t post the link since this is my <15th post. If you search CSICOP for “franklin cover up” it is the third result, but you MUST FIRST include the “index of articles in Skeptical Inquirer” in the search by clicking on it.

I would also like to see a full scale debunking or at least a summary of the claims and evidence. And can I get that 15 post link rule waived? I’m not going to go through this deleting links and explaining of searches again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom