John Maddox Prize for standing up for science

Acleron

Master Poster
Joined
Oct 15, 2007
Messages
2,290
The John Maddox Prize

The prize is open to nominations for any kind of public activity, including all forms of writing, speaking and public engagement, in any of the following areas:

Addressing misleading information about scientific or medical issues in any forum.
Bringing sound evidence to bear in a public or policy debate.
Helping people to make sense of a complex scientific issue.

It is open for anyone in any country and especially for those at the beginning of their career.
 
What a ridiculous award!

I did not find Maddox to be a defender of scientific standards.

He did not address misleading information about scientific or medical issues in any forum, in fact he published such material and refused outright to correct it.

He did not bring sound evidence to bear in a public or policy debate. He ignored sound evidence and stood in defiance of reason.

He did not help people to make sense of complex scientific issues. He obfuscated reason to cover up his own failings and those of his chums.

Maddox was as big a liar as ever walked the halls of science.
 
What a ridiculous award!

I did not find Maddox to be a defender of scientific standards.

He did not address misleading information about scientific or medical issues in any forum, in fact he published such material and refused outright to correct it.

He did not bring sound evidence to bear in a public or policy debate. He ignored sound evidence and stood in defiance of reason.

He did not help people to make sense of complex scientific issues. He obfuscated reason to cover up his own failings and those of his chums.

Maddox was as big a liar as ever walked the halls of science.

Please, some cites would be useful.
 
Interesting person, is it his HIV blunder you are referring to, John? Your criticism seems a tad inconsistent with his position as the editor of Nature.
The AIDS Editorial 1983

Maddox penned an editorial in April 1983 entitled "No Need for Panic about AIDS" that voiced the then-common thinking that "male homosexuals should be persuaded to change their ways" of "pathetic promiscuity" and described AIDS as a "perhaps non-existent condition".[9]
For the record, the HIV virus was not identified until 1985 IIRC.
 
Last edited:
What a ridiculous award!

I did not find Maddox to be a defender of scientific standards.

He did not address misleading information about scientific or medical issues in any forum, in fact he published such material and refused outright to correct it.

He did not bring sound evidence to bear in a public or policy debate. He ignored sound evidence and stood in defiance of reason.

He did not help people to make sense of complex scientific issues. He obfuscated reason to cover up his own failings and those of his chums.

Maddox was as big a liar as ever walked the halls of science.

That's a rather curious claim, considering that Maddox accompanied Randi to France to investigate Benveniste.
 
What Maddox was doing, when he "investigated" Benveniste, was engaging in a piece of public piss-taking and equally famously did the same with Sheldrake. In both cases the work being made fun of had no scientific foundation but the fact is that doing what Maddox did was not appropriate to his role as editor of a major journal. It actually shows him to have been a partisan bully.

And it shows Nature in the role of propaganda magazine, a scientific Pravda if you like, and certainly not as a platform for debate. That is not what a scientific journal is supposed to be, nor is it what Maddox claimed it to be. The idea is that space is allowed for dissent and originality, even if it's wrong. The fact is that Nature, under Maddox, did not do that and, so far as I can see, it still doesn't.

More importantly, Maddox's partisan behaviour extended way beyond soft targets like homeopathy and morphic fields. At the end of the day, Nature defends the scientific establishment into the teeth or reason and, so it seems to me, "Sense about Science" does the same thing.

The discovery of the AIDS virus is a case in point. Montagnier's paper reporting that discovery was rejected by Nature on completely spurious grounds. So far as I know, Nature still hasn't disclosed the identity of its incompetent referee but the suspicion that it was Gallo remains very strong. The rest of that story is history but it was chance and a Newspaper reporter (John Crewdson) that enabled the truth to come out; it was not Maddox or Nature.

However, I was not refering to that incident, I was referring to my own experiences with Maddox, which are described in "A Habit of Lies." In my field Nature, under Maddox, prominently published outright lies which would clearly mislead anybody reading those papers. They reported that there were two theories in a field when in fact there were, and are, three.

I did contact him and complained but, when he eventually deigned to respond, the reply was just stupid nonsense and a refusal to address the issue. It was just Maddox as a partisan bully, completely indifferent to the truth. Eventually he threatened me with legal action, but descended into silence when I told him to go ahead. Nonetheless, the lies that Nature published are still on record and are still able to deceive readers.
 
Last edited:
I did contact him and complained but, when he eventually deigned to respond, the reply was just stupid nonsense and a refusal to address the issue. It was just Maddox as a partisan bully, completely indifferent to the truth. Eventually he threatened me with legal action, but descended into silence when I told him to go ahead.

Normally a person might threaten legal action because they are sick of being pestered by the same person over the same thing. He may have "descended in to silence" after you told him to go ahead because you stopped pestering him. Certainly I don't see how him threatening to take you to court and then not doing so supports your argument in any way.
 
I think there are two threads here. I'd like to hear more about the prize, myself, like the OP said.
 
Normally a person might threaten legal action because they are sick of being pestered by the same person over the same thing. He may have "descended in to silence" after you told him to go ahead because you stopped pestering him. Certainly I don't see how him threatening to take you to court and then not doing so supports your argument in any way.
My arguments are not a matter of maybes or might bes, they are matters of fact. They are described at length on my web site well and suported by evidence. They are not something that Maddox or anybody else would have needed an expert peer reviewer's opinion on, unless of course the difference between 3 and 2 was beyond him. The evidence supporting my position is very clear.
In fact I did not pester Maddox and that accusation is cheap, offensive and outrageous. The entire correspondence between him and me is available for you to read, should you choose to do so - and I do not imagine for one moment that you will.
I asked him to correct the false papers he had published. He refused to do so. He also refused to intercede with the authors and ask them to explain themselves. That does not display Nature as a platform for debate but as a platform for propaganda.
If you follow current affairs at all, you will know that press lying has victims, and lying in Nature produces victims just as certainly as lying in the News of the World does. I am one of Maddox's victims and I do object to seeing him lauded as some sort of defender of scientific standards. He was never that and neither is Nature today.
 
I think there are two threads here. I'd like to hear more about the prize, myself, like the OP said.

Thank you.

I am thinking of nominating Rhys Morgan for the award.

But I'm interested in what other candidates others would propose.
 
My arguments are not a matter of maybes or might bes, they are matters of fact. They are described at length on my web site well and suported by evidence. They are not something that Maddox or anybody else would have needed an expert peer reviewer's opinion on, unless of course the difference between 3 and 2 was beyond him. The evidence supporting my position is very clear.
In fact I did not pester Maddox and that accusation is cheap, offensive and outrageous. The entire correspondence between him and me is available for you to read, should you choose to do so - and I do not imagine for one moment that you will.
I asked him to correct the false papers he had published. He refused to do so. He also refused to intercede with the authors and ask them to explain themselves. That does not display Nature as a platform for debate but as a platform for propaganda.
If you follow current affairs at all, you will know that press lying has victims, and lying in Nature produces victims just as certainly as lying in the News of the World does. I am one of Maddox's victims and I do object to seeing him lauded as some sort of defender of scientific standards. He was never that and neither is Nature today.

Look, you said that he threatened legal action and didn't go through with it. The fact that he didn't go through with it does not, as far as I can see, support (or detract from) your argument. From an outsiders point of view all it says is that he didn't go through with it. It may be because he didn't think he'd win, it may be because you left him alone after telling him to go ahead or maybe he didn't think you were worth the time, effort and expense. Or something else.
There seems little value in discussing this further since, if what you say is true (that he descended in to silence), then by your own statements you cannot possibly know for certain his motivations behind not taking legal action against you.
 
Look, you said that he threatened legal action and didn't go through with it. The fact that he didn't go through with it does not, as far as I can see, support (or detract from) your argument. From an outsiders point of view all it says is that he didn't go through with it. It may be because he didn't think he'd win, it may be because you left him alone after telling him to go ahead or maybe he didn't think you were worth the time, effort and expense. Or something else.
There seems little value in discussing this further since, if what you say is true (that he descended in to silence), then by your own statements you cannot possibly know for certain his motivations behind not taking legal action against you.
This conversation was about whether Maddox had the right to publish three as two. I don't think the difference is a matter of anybody's opinion. At the time I was writing "A Habit of Lies." I sent him a copy of the relevant sections.

Paraphrased:
He said, "If you circulate this, I will sue you."
I replied "I will circulate this, so go ahead!"

And I did. Nonetheless, and despite my efforts, I did not hear from him again.
I would call his behaviour lying and bullying. You may, if you wish, claim that he reported three as two out of concern for scientific standards. But then, if the insinuation tickles your funny bone, you might also want to hint that pig's have wings.
 
So let me see if I understand the story correctly. Tell me where I go wrong:

1) You submit your pet theory to Nature
2) It gets rejected
3) You demand to know why it was rejected
4) The editor explains why
5) You demand the editor publish it
6) He refuses
7) Rather than make a better experiment demonstrating your hypothesis or find another journal with lower standards, you write a book calling him a biased liar
8) He threatens to sue, but then realizes it's a waste of time based on how obviously crazy it makes you look
9) He then ignores all of your subsequent attempts to contact him
 
So let me see if I understand the story correctly. Tell me where I go wrong:

1) You submit your pet theory to Nature
2) It gets rejected
3) You demand to know why it was rejected
4) The editor explains why
5) You demand the editor publish it
6) He refuses
7) Rather than make a better experiment demonstrating your hypothesis or find another journal with lower standards, you write a book calling him a biased liar
8) He threatens to sue, but then realizes it's a waste of time based on how obviously crazy it makes you look
9) He then ignores all of your subsequent attempts to contact him
You go wrong everywhere.
If you want to discuss "A Habit of Lies" reopen the thread on that topic and read it - or read and try to understand the site!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom