Jew=Israeli=Zionist

Okay, got it, you were representing other peoples' opinions. It wasn't clear from your OP. So who are these people arguing that Israeli = Zionist = Jew?

Neo-Nazis and other right-wing anti-Semites do it.

Arab nationalists and Islamic extremists often do it.

And right-wing Jews do it.

There are no Muslim extremists on JREF, but a few of the Neo-Nazis and right-wing Jews have indeed used Israeli, Zionist, and Jew interchangeably. Especially when its convenient for their agenda of the hour.

I won't name them for that would be labeled a personal attack by the Mods, but many of us know exactly who they are.
 
Last edited:
Who cares about MaGZ? Really.

Well, he really doesn't seem to lack defenders. That's one point.

The problem, though, is that there are rational people who make the same equation, and it would make no sense to most of us. Thunder has a point here, though I would say this is not an error made on this board by many.
 
One of the people on this forum who thinks Jew = Israeli = zionist is Thunder, who, in this thread, declared that a group of thugs who stoned a Jewish dance group were "really" being just "anti-zionist".

At least Thunder thinks Jew = Israeli = zionist when he tries to explain away violence against Jews in general as legitimate. Jew =/= Israeli =/= zionist for Thunder, of course, when he tries to explain away violence against Israelies as legitimate (and not "really" antisemitic).
 
One of the people on this forum who thinks Jew = Israeli = zionist is Thunder, who, in this thread, declared that a group of thugs who stoned a Jewish dance group were "really" being just "anti-zionist".

At least Thunder thinks Jew = Israeli = zionist when he tries to explain away violence against Jews in general as legitimate. Jew =/= Israeli =/= zionist for Thunder, of course, when he tries to explain away violence against Israelies as legitimate (and not "really" antisemitic).

this post has three lies in it. can anyone here point them out?

oh, and thanks for identifying yourself Skeptic, as one of the JREF members who considers non-Zionist, anti-Zionist, and even simply Zionists who are critics of Israel, as being "self-hating, Judenrat, good-for-nothing Jews".

You even made a thread ALLLL about it. :)

I guess, according to Skeptic, only a right-wing Zionist, is a true Jew.
 
Last edited:
There are no Muslim extremists on JREF.

I consider this deplorable.
How can we possibly have no Muslim extremists, when, as we all know, the entire planet is positively stiff with the fellows?

I blame the government.:mad:
 
btw, we also have folks at JREF who ALWAYS use the word "Jews", when discussing Israelis settlers. why do they do this?

clearly, to try and portray the settlements as an issue of discrimination against Jews, not the legality of Israeli civilian settlements in occupied territories.
 
btw, we also have folks at JREF who ALWAYS use the word "Jews", when discussing Israelis settlers. why do they do this?

clearly, to try and portray the settlements as an issue of discrimination against Jews, not the legality of Israeli civilian settlements in occupied territories.
Or it could be in order to tarnish all Jews with the bad behaviour of some extremists. Either way, I don't see much reason to be too upset when this label is both correct and relevant. Yes, some people have agendas I very much disagree with, but I prefer criticizing them over something they say that is clearly wrong, rather than trying to 'interpret' their motives in every single line that they write.
 
btw, we also have folks at JREF who ALWAYS use the word "Jews", when discussing Israelis settlers. why do they do this?

clearly, to try and portray the settlements as an issue of discrimination against Jews, not the legality of Israeli civilian settlements in occupied territories.
Who?

Coming up, map of Jerusalem...

This is exactly like Groundhogs Day will Bill Murray, except all in text and even more predictable.
 
Last edited:
this post has three lies in it. can anyone here point them out?
...
You even made a thread ALLLL about it. :)
Shot yourself in the foot by actually linking the thread.

I guess, according to Skeptic, only a right-wing Zionist, is a true Jew.
Source? Where does it say that?

And try and quote it rather than linking an entire thread of page of wiki, ta. :rolleyes:

Let this thread die just like all the others
 
Shot yourself in the foot by actually linking the thread.


Source? Where does it say that?

And try and quote it rather than linking an entire thread of page of wiki, ta. :rolleyes:

Let this thread die just like all the others

missed the part about self-hatred, huh?

;)
 
missed the part about self-hatred, huh?

;)
This is what you stated:
oh, and thanks for identifying yourself Skeptic, as one of the JREF members who considers non-Zionist, anti-Zionist, and even simply Zionists who are critics of Israel, as being "self-hating, Judenrat, good-for-nothing Jews".
...
I guess, according to Skeptic, only a right-wing Zionist, is a true Jew.

Went to the thread, read the article linked and the conclusions you've made is simply another hapless attempt at a 'fixed that for ya' Parky moment as well as a bunch of made up fiction...

Didn't miss anything, but thanks for playing.
 
Went to the thread, read the article..

apparently not.

tell us, bigjel, what is "Otto Weininger Syndrome"?

did you fail to notice the extreme anti-Semitism and self-loathing, even racial anti-Semitism, that Otto Weininger expressed?

its like you didn't read ANYTHING in the thread or the link in it.

how does Skeptic describe such Jews?

and I quote: "for many Jews, alas, self-hate is the main motivation and all the talk of peace and happiness and equality and criticism "more in sorrow than in anger" is just fluff.
 
Last edited:
apparently not.

tell us, bigjel, what is "Otto Weininger Syndrome"?

did you fail to notice the extreme anti-Semitism and self-loathing, even racial anti-Semitism, that Otto Weininger expressed?

its like you didn't read ANYTHING in the thread or the link in it.

how does Skeptic describe such Jews?

and I quote: "for many Jews, alas, self-hate is the main motivation and all the talk of peace and happiness and equality and criticism "more in sorrow than in anger" is just fluff.
Still a bit slow today I see. The issue I have is that you attribute what was previously quoted (as in what you stated) to Skeptic.

Try again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom