Israel Setting up worlds largest prison?

DrBenway said:

The Taliban used a football stadium for their executions, which happened daily.

Does "any other religion" include Scientologists? How about Branch Davidians? Jehovah's Witnesses? Mormons? the Heaven's Gate? Hare Krishnas?

When will you allow that the explicit beliefs and practices of a religious group are to be opposed?

yep, the taliban were a bunch of fundie kooks. as were the spanish inquisition. have you heard about the women who tried to pray at the wailing wall, or the jewish fundie who shot his own democratically elected PM. As far as he was concerned, he was obeying the will of his godl
 
a_unique_person said:
yep, the taliban were a bunch of fundie kooks.
Would you consider other Islamic regimes "a bunch of fundie kooks"? I'm thinking of Saudi Arabia and Pakistan, particularly.
 
DrBenway said:



When will you allow that the explicit beliefs and practices of a religious group are to be opposed?

Any time you like. However you want to go much further than that. You do not wish to simply oppose or criticize certain muslim extremist teachings, you wish to propose that they are practiced by the mainstream. As this is clearly not the case, reality will continue to contradict your claims.

I live next door to the largest Muslim country in the world. Why are they not following your claims and butchering us? For as long as reality fails to match your image of islam you will continue to be wrong.
 
The Fool said:
I live next door to the largest Muslim country in the world. Why are they not following your claims and butchering us? For as long as reality fails to match your image of islam you will continue to be wrong.
Until quite recently, it was forbidden for Indonesian political parties to use Islamic names or symbols as identifiers. Since this rule was changed, Islamic political groups have been gaining power. Yet the country is still a long way from universal Shari'at.

Malaysia, on the other hand, is closer to putting Islamic law into real practice.

Islamic law is fairly explicit. There are many reasons why it is not fully put into practice in much of the world. That doesn't mean that a majority of Muslims don't still believe the Shari'at is valid and ought to be practiced widely.
 
Ok Doc, call me when all these things that may happen, are close to happening, could, should or might happen actually do......

Criticise the teachings, Condemn those that actually put them into practice.

Try to avoid deciding what other people believe.
 
I have had the pleasure , many times so far, to debate serious anti-semites, scholars mostly, that they base their knowledge to studies and not to Google...

We have debated everything. History, Politics and we have even visited the Dark Sides of the issue. Yes, I have debated Biology and Blood Libels as well...

Mr.Unique. I assure you ,Sir ,that you are very far away from debating Israeli policy seriously.

In fact, you seem to me that you don't know what do you debate.

Please decide. Are you objecting to the Policy or to the existence of the State of Israel or do you object the Race ( Hey! Don't be afraid, it happens you know and I am willing to discuss about races as well...), do you despise Israeli people for voting for Sharon? What makes you think that you are smarter than the average Israeli?

What gives you the right, Sir, to mock at a democratically elected Prime Minister?

I haven't voted for Sharon but you see, I am not a follower of Saddam's mentality as well. I believe in Democracy, I respect the decision the majority has taken and I fight for a better world.

Keep in mind that I am not like other here who despise their country and they wished they were something else.

I don't allow to you and to anybody that sits comfortably on his chair, miles away from Israel, to make such comments for an elected PM.

You don't care about my palestinian fellow-citizens, you don't care about my Arab neighbours and I can prove it to you by using your own words.

First, you decide on what you object and I will be glad to have any kind of discussion with you. Don't expect me to participate in discussion that will blacklash outcomes of free elections, though.
 
I am sure that nothing I say here can change the mind of anybody on such a longstanding issue. But, the complete inability of some people in this thread to understand the frustrations of the Palestinian people to the continued incursions into what the world tells them is their land is disheartening.

Does anybody that has posted to this thread have the slightest doubt that more Jews and more Palestinians have been killed because of Sharon's actions? Sharon, wants settlements. and Sharon doesn't want anthing resembling Palestinian autonomy. Sharon has acted as a naked provacateur to accomplish these goals. No amount of racist bashing of the Palestinians can hide this fact.

Of course, the death of innocent Israeli's is terribly sad. But Isn't it true that Palestinian deaths continue to far outnumber Israeli deaths? Israel continues to knock down homes, businesses and orchards as a way of controlling the suicide bombers. Can any of Israel's defenders not see how those measures might do nothing but piss off the Palestinian population to the point that they feel that there is little choice but to attack Israel in any way they can.

This is a link to an article about the settlements by a Jewish group opposed to the settlements.
http://www.btselem.org/English/Publications/Summaries/Land_Grab_2002.asp#anchor-Background
 
Cleopatra said:
I have had the pleasure , many times so far, to debate serious anti-semites, scholars mostly, that they base their knowledge to studies and not to Google...


i have a family, job and other obligations. i do not see myself as an anti semite, for reasons i have stated many times. this is a forum for discussion, not a think tank for paid experts.



We have debated everything. History, Politics and we have even visited the Dark Sides of the issue. Yes, I have debated Biology and Blood Libels as well...


well, bully for you



Mr.Unique. I assure you ,Sir ,that you are very far away from debating Israeli policy seriously.

In fact, you seem to me that you don't know what do you debate.


i could say the same for you.



Please decide. Are you objecting to the Policy or to the existence of the State of Israel or do you object the Race ( Hey! Don't be afraid, it happens you know and I am willing to discuss about races as well...), do you despise Israeli people for voting for Sharon? What makes you think that you are smarter than the average Israeli?


dear me, did you read anything I wrote. Sharon has the israeli people just where he wants them, terrified.

I am willing to debate anything, but please don't accuse me of debating something i am not.

In what way have I claimed i am smarter than the 'average' israeli? i have the luxury of living in a distant land. sometimes, when you are right in the middle of something, it is hard to get a sense of perspective. i can understand that. skeptic, for example, was a member of the IDF. once you have been a member of a military force, you often keep that loyalty for life. If you wanted to see the shape of a mountain, you cannot see that shape when you are on that mountain.

I think i have said it many times before, but for your benefit, i will say it again. i am against the current policy of israel, the state, towards palestinians, the people.

What gives you the right, Sir, to mock at a democratically elected Prime Minister?

i am not mocking sharon. he is not someone to mock. i mock my own prime minister. he is the perfect target for such an act.



I haven't voted for Sharon but you see, I am not a follower of Saddam's mentality as well. I believe in Democracy, I respect the decision the majority has taken and I fight for a better world.


the majority needs to be informed. as i have shown before, the state of israel, as it is involved in a war, manipulates the media for it's own ends. truth is the first casualty of war. the majority is also influenced by emotions, and the current reigning emotion appears to be one of fear. sharon does not know fear, so they feel he is the best person to handle it.

there are many israelis, as i have also shown before, who do question what their government is up to, and do not approve. those who are willing to go to this effort are in the minority.

israel also suffers from one of the vagaries of democracy, the state that needs fragile co-alitions between disparate groups to form a majority. this in itself is not so bad, except when you get groups such as the extremists who wield influence out of proportion to their numbers. this is part of the reason for the settlement policy, which i believe is a major part of the reason for the current problems.



Keep in mind that I am not like other here who despise their country and they wished they were something else.


you can love your country, and not approve of the government's actions.



I don't allow to you and to anybody that sits comfortably on his chair, miles away from Israel, to make such comments for an elected PM.

You don't care about my palestinian fellow-citizens, you don't care about my Arab neighbours and I can prove it to you by using your own words.


?????



First, you decide on what you object and I will be glad to have any kind of discussion with you. Don't expect me to participate in discussion that will blacklash outcomes of free elections, though.
 
a_unique_person said:
. this is a forum for discussion, not a think tank for paid experts.

Lifts left eyebrow with wild sarcasm...

The fact that some people do not Google to get informed but they study, doesn't make them paid experts...

Sharon has the israeli people just where he wants them, terrified.

You are wrong. It was the Arabic fanatism that made Barak look ridiculous for participating in the Peace Talks...
From the moment Israelis started participating in peace talks and they have started giving back lands, the violence against Israeli civilians multiplied.This is a fact and it brought all of us who belive in peace, look ridiculous.

In what way have I claimed i am smarter than the 'average' israeli?

In a very simple way. You make comments about the sanity of a newly elected PM. Not very flattering for those who voted for him, don't you think?

i have the luxury of living in a distant land.

Why do you have to be so melodramatic? Say it in a simple way. You leave in your country, why on earth you should be living in Israel????

I don't live in Israel too. I have a life in my other half country.But I visit at least every 3 months and I have served the Israeli army as well.

sometimes, when you are right in the middle of something, it is hard to get a sense of perspective. i can understand that.

Hmmm... Interesting thought. So, do you suggest to the Israelis to ask from citizens from other countries to vote in their place?


the majority needs to be informed. as i have shown before, the state of israel, as it is involved in a war, manipulates the media for it's own ends.

I am afraid that you are rather misinformed your self. I asked you, in another thread, what do you know about Israeli peace activists and I didn't get a reply.Why?

Maybe because "The Guardian"doesn't report anything on them... It spoils the image of the blood thirsty Israelis who kill innocent civilians...

truth is the first casualty of war. the majority is also influenced by emotions, and the current reigning emotion appears to be one of fear.

Influenced by emotions? Emotions? Have you ever been to the funeral of your best friend? have you ever been to the funeral of your neighbour? Have you ever heard the shouts of injured people?

Have you ever seen blood on the streets?

Close your eyes and try to imagine it! You take your coffee with your wife and suddenly you hear a noise and the walls of the coffee shop turn red and it's human blood...

Israelis, of all people, are in the position to understand how the Palestinians feel. That's why they have difficulties in accepting lectures by ambitious illuminators...

there are many israelis, as i have also shown before, who do question what their government is up to, and do not approve. those who are willing to go to this effort are in the minority.

Really? What exactly do you know? Spare me with the vague referencies you read in Media... Do you know who share prison cells with Palestinians? Do you know why young Israelis are sent to prison? Have you heard about the Israeli human shields that have made life in the refugee camps a bit more tolerable? What do you know?

israel also suffers from one of the vagaries of democracy, the state that needs fragile co-alitions between disparate groups to form a majority. this in itself is not so bad, except when you get groups such as the extremists who wield influence out of proportion to their numbers. this is part of the reason for the settlement policy, which i believe is a major part of the reason for the current problems.

Montesqieu or Rousseau-I don't remember right now who- has once said that the best way to abolish a Law is to obey to it. You focus on the settllements because this is where the Media focus.

No, the settlements is not the cause for the current situation.
If you are interested in this topic we can discuss about it.
 
Cleopatra said:


Lifts left eyebrow with wild sarcasm...

The fact that some people do not Google to get informed but they study, doesn't make them paid experts...



You are wrong. It was the Arabic fanatism that made Barak look ridiculous for participating in the Peace Talks...
From the moment Israelis started participating in peace talks and they have started giving back lands, the violence against Israeli civilians multiplied.This is a fact and it brought all of us who belive in peace, look ridiculous.



In a very simple way. You make comments about the sanity of a newly elected PM. Not very flattering for those who voted for him, don't you think?



Why do you have to be so melodramatic? Say it in a simple way. You leave in your country, why on earth you should be living in Israel????

I don't live in Israel too. I have a life in my other half country.But I visit at least every 3 months and I have served the Israeli army as well.



Hmmm... Interesting thought. So, do you suggest to the Israelis to ask from citizens from other countries to vote in their place?




I am afraid that you are rather misinformed your self. I asked you, in another thread, what do you know about Israeli peace activists and I didn't get a reply.Why?

Maybe because "The Guardian"doesn't report anything on them... It spoils the image of the blood thirsty Israelis who kill innocent civilians...



Influenced by emotions? Emotions? Have you ever been to the funeral of your best friend? have you ever been to the funeral of your neighbour? Have you ever heard the shouts of injured people?

Have you ever seen blood on the streets?

Close your eyes and try to imagine it! You take your coffee with your wife and suddenly you hear a noise and the walls of the coffee shop turn red and it's human blood...

Israelis, of all people, are in the position to understand how the Palestinians feel. That's why they have difficulties in accepting lectures by ambitious illuminators...



Really? What exactly do you know? Spare me with the vague referencies you read in Media... Do you know who share prison cells with Palestinians? Do you know why young Israelis are sent to prison? Have you heard about the Israeli human shields that have made life in the refugee camps a bit more tolerable? What do you know?



Montesqieu or Rousseau-I don't remember right now who- has once said that the best way to abolish a Law is to obey to it. You focus on the settllements because this is where the Media focus.

No, the settlements is not the cause for the current situation.
If you are interested in this topic we can discuss about it.

if you do not want to know my opinion, that is fine.
 
Cleopatra said:
Why did you quit Mr.Unique?



author: A Unique Person



Who will carry out this mission, if you quit?

it was never going to be my mission, i am not going to be the guy who solves the middle east problem. all i am doing is stating my opinion.

sharon has a history of extreme violence.

I know there is an israeli peace movement, i have read some of their information. you have assumed i don't know anything about them. i read just recently of a village that was bombed by a suicide bomber. the reason the village was bombed was it was a rare one, where the israelis and arabs had got on well with each other. the bombing was meant to end that.

from what i have seen of the IRA, what happens is a movement gets hijacked by a few people who, in other lives, would have been serial killers, but in these situations, find they are heroes. this happens on both sides of such conflicts.
 
If you haven't been so harsh in your criticism, I wouldn't expect you or anyone to know anything about what Israeli civilians do for peace.

But you seem so sure and persuaded!

PEACE NOW! This is the name of the movement. When a suicide bomber explodes and kills OUR people, Israelis take candles in their hands and go out to the streets,circulate the area the bomber exploded and ask the government and the general public not to respond to the attack...And it's not only that!!

Check here :PEACE NOW!

There will be a day that they will listen...

Last April, when the Jenin events took place and the Army refused to let the Red Cross to get into the camps, Israeli women, mothers of soldiers, created human shields and BROKE the forces of the Israeli Army and helped Red Cross to reach those people.

Many young Israelis soldiers prefer to go to prison than to take part in demolishing houses and properties of Palestinian civilians...

Israeli people don't really need the Zionists that drink their coctails in NY , miles away from the zone of War and expect from Israelis to realize the dream of Zion but they don't need easy and sterile criticism of Sharon government as well. This kind of criticism doesn't promote the peace process. It makes pacifists look rediculous.
 
Originally posted by a_unique_person:
from what i have seen of the IRA, what happens is a movement gets hijacked by a few people who, in other lives, would have been serial killers, but in these situations, find they are heroes.

The raison d'etre of the IRA is the expulsion of the British presence in Ireland by force. They weren't suddenly taken over by a few psychopaths, murdering people has always been part of their philosophy.

And exactly regards the IRA as "heroes"? A few dimwits no doubt, but most people are able to see them for what they are.
 
Cleopatra said:
If you haven't been so harsh in your criticism, I wouldn't expect you or anyone to know anything about what Israeli civilians do for peace.

But you seem so sure and persuaded!

PEACE NOW! This is the name of the movement. When a suicide bomber explodes and kills OUR people, Israelis take candles in their hands and go out to the streets,circulate the area the bomber exploded and ask the government and the general public not to respond to the attack...And it's not only that!!

Check here :PEACE NOW!

There will be a day that they will listen...

Last April, when the Jenin events took place and the Army refused to let the Red Cross to get into the camps, Israeli women, mothers of soldiers, created human shields and BROKE the forces of the Israeli Army and helped Red Cross to reach those people.

Many young Israelis soldiers prefer to go to prison than to take part in demolishing houses and properties of Palestinian civilians...

Israeli people don't really need the Zionists that drink their coctails in NY , miles away from the zone of War and expect from Israelis to realize the dream of Zion but they don't need easy and sterile criticism of Sharon government as well. This kind of criticism doesn't promote the peace process. It makes pacifists look rediculous.

there has been more than one general from the army who has gone on to try to achieve a political solution rather than a military one. Sharon has never shown any such inclination.

If you bother to search back through my posts you will see that i have referred to peace movements. don't worry, the pacifists are seen as being ridiculous without me.

i don't know why you think that they will listen some day. Sharon is doing very well with his current plan. as the heading to this topic states, this wall is not intended to keep palestinians apart so they can no longer attack each other. it is intended to imprison the palestinians. they will have a fraction of the land they had in the first place.

as for the zionists living is the US, they probably serve just the same function as the IRA living in the US, propagating death while not having to get their hands today.
 
First of all. I didn't mean that you make pacifists look ridiculous.
It's the Palestinians with their attitude that make Israeli pacifists look ridiculous.

When we try to persuade people for the need to stop this War, another one explodes and kills 20 civilians and then people have this look in their face when you talk to them about peace...

You know, fear turns people into animals, however strong you might be, you cannot always control your fear. So don't expect so civilized reactions by " animals" ( she just hopes that she won't see the word "animals" mocked and used... )

What makes me think that both sides will understand? History and mathematics.

All societies in crisis, when they hit the bottom they stop. Also, crime and violence, any form of crime and violence ,have a periodical circle, in Middle east this circle lasts about 10-14 years.
The second circle comes to an end.

Of course , as a friend has once pointed out to me, circles are not good for crime, because they begin where they end...

what happens is a movement gets hijacked by a few people who, in other lives, would have been serial killers, but in these situations, find they are heroes.

This is very true and it applied to many situations. It has to do with the nature of crime and the way a society perceives Justice but this can be a topic for another thread...
 
Cleopatra said:
First of all. I didn't mean that you make pacifists look ridiculous.
It's the Palestinians with their attitude that make Israeli pacifists look ridiculous.


i think you will also find it was the israeli govt who made the palestinian pacifists look ridiculous long ago.



When we try to persuade people for the need to stop this War, another one explodes and kills 20 civilians and then people have this look in their face when you talk to them about peace...


if northern ireland and the balkans are anything to go by, even if peace is made, there will still be bombings.



You know, fear turns people into animals, however strong you might be, you cannot always control your fear. So don't expect so civilized reactions by " animals" ( she just hopes that she won't see the word "animals" mocked and used... )


agreed. that is part of the point of terror, which both sides have used in this context, to provoke fear and an irrational reaction.



What makes me think that both sides will understand? History and mathematics.

All societies in crisis, when they hit the bottom they stop. Also, crime and violence, any form of crime and violence ,have a periodical circle, in Middle east this circle lasts about 10-14 years.
The second circle comes to an end.


Of course , as a friend has once pointed out to me, circles are not good for crime, because they begin where they end...


yet the world has made progress, even if it is painfully slow.



This is very true and it applied to many situations. It has to do with the nature of crime and the way a society perceives Justice but this can be a topic for another thread...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom