Split Thread Is there an underground oligarchy ruling the world?

SHC,

What's ridiculous about believing in a wealthy, oligarchical ruling class?

I'm curious. Do the guys that THINK that they're the "ruling class", (i.e., president, congress, governors, state congressmen, etc.) know that they are not "the real ruling class"?

Did they give up their ruling status willingly or was coercion involved?

What can you provide in the way of evidence for this transfer of power?

What's ridiculous about believing that they'd try to hide their control and influence over the government from the public?

So this implies that the gubbamint is not the real ruling class, but that they are "controlled & influenced" by the real ruling class.

There are about a thousand guys in this country (called investigative reporters, public interest & government watch organizations) whose daily business is trying to uncover AND PUBLISH as many instances as possible of inappropriate influence applied to members of gubbamint, all the way from the Pres thru congress down to local petty bureaucrats taking bribes. Are these reporters ALL part of your grand conspiracy?

No exceptions?

If you believe that there are some exceptions, could you name a few, please.
Alex Jones?
Rachael Maddow?
Rush Limbaugh?
Keith Olberman?
Anyone?

When there are such bitter political rivals in Congress, has no one ever taken to dropping a dime on a rival's being influenced?

Or do "they" then just disappear the loose cannon dime-dropper?

Does this explain the dozens of Senators & Congressmen that have mysteriously disappeared over the last several decades?

You're asking the wrong question, here?

It's not "what's ridiculous …?"
EVERYTHING about your scenario is ridiculous.

The right question is "what is unusual about the belief that ...?"
And the answer is "Nothing is unusual about that belief."

It is incredibly common. It's a belief that saturates the minds of kids at their first political awakening (usually in college), and endures in brain-addled hyper-liberals & brain-addled hyper-conservatives throughout their lives.

Most of the rest of us grow out of it.

You can delude yourself with false notions of freedom and democracy all you like, but it won't change the fact that you are essentially just human livestock to these people.

And by "you", I presume you include yourself. Or have you found some magic way to extract yourself from The Matrix?

Was it the Red pill or Blue pill?

I presume from your vernacular that you live in the US, as I do. True?

I am going to send multiple checks to the state & feds this weekend.

Then I'm going jump on my motorcycle this weekend & take a ride up the California coast. I hope to make it as far as Santa Barbara for a bread & breakfast. Then a return trip thru the inland mountains & back to San Diego.

Towards the end of this year, I plan on retiring for a year of around-the-world travel. And then back here to finish out my last big project before a very active, fun permanent retirement.

Somehow my "false notion of freedom & democracy" seems to be going pretty well.

To tell you the truth, your interpretation of existence ("just human livestock") makes it sound like your life just plain sucks.

Or, much more likely, it sounds just like a typical adolescent's rendition of their oh-so-miserable existence.

Just sayin'.
 
Last edited:
I'm curious. Do the guys that THINK that they're the "ruling class", (i.e., president, congress, governors, state congressmen, etc.) know that they are not "the real ruling class"?

The politicians don't think they are the ruling class. Hell, they know they aren't the real ruling class. They most likely realize that they are just the middlemen between the ruling class and the people. In other words, they are the public relations department who sell the policies of the ruling class to the people and then take the blame when those policies fail.

Did they give up their ruling status willingly or was coercion involved?

With the exception of the short period following the founding of this country and Constitutional Convention, they never had that status to begin with, as politicians are dependent on such things as favorable media coverage and generous donations from wealthy financiers to run successful campaigns and get elected.

What can you provide in the way of evidence for this transfer of power?

Just look around you. The evidence is everywhere. The politicians aren't representing the interests of the American people by running up debts that can't be repaid, debasing the dollar, waging war all over the world, occupying numerous countries, meddling in the internal affairs of foreign nations, passing unpopular domestic legislation, etc... Multinational banks and corporations are fully running the show and have been since at least the turn of the 20th Century.

So this implies that the gubbamint is not the real ruling class, but that they are "controlled & influenced" by the real ruling class.

Of course they are controlled and influenced. Again, it's nearly impossible to get elected above the local and state levels anymore without the right mixture of favorable corporate media coverage and favorable corporate campaign funding. Politicians who don't toe the line are either marginalized or destroyed by the media and don't receive the necessary campaign funding. At the end of the day, he who holds the gold makes the rules.

There are about a thousand guys in this country (called investigative reporters, public interest & government watch organizations) whose daily business is trying to uncover AND PUBLISH as many instances as possible of inappropriate influence applied to members of gubbamint, all the way from the Pres thru congress down to local petty bureaucrats taking bribes. Are these reporters ALL part of your grand conspiracy?

They are not a part of it in the sense that they are "in on it" at the highest levels of awareness, but they are a part of it in the sense that the investigative reporters with the most resources and connections to investigate big stories tend to work for large corporate news agencies who have an interest in maintaining the status quo.

At any rate, two things control news media coverage of an issue, in no particular order of importance: Advertising money (from large corporate sponsors) and corporate ownership of the media. For instance, NBC is owned by General Electric - one of the U.S. government's biggest defense contractors. War is very profitable for General Electric, which means NBC has an interest in supporting the wars that its parent company profits from.

No exceptions?

There are likely some exceptions, but they are not about to buck the status quo and risk their paycheck, reputation, or their lives.

If you believe that there are some exceptions, could you name a few, please.

I don't know. I assume nobody is either controlled or uncontrolled.

Alex Jones?

Highly suspicious. Won't touch certain issues and will cut off callers who ask about those issues. There's a good chance that Jones is controlled opposition. Then again, he seems to believe a lot of the things he says.

Rachael Maddow?

Represents the left side of the phony left-right paradigm. Corporate controlled.

Rush Limbaugh?

Represents the right side of the phony left-right paradigm. Corporate controlled.

Keith Olberman?

Again, represents the left side of the phony left-right paradigm. Corporate controlled.


Nobody I would bet my life on, but I think you are more likely to find honest journalists outside the mainstream corporate media.

When there are such bitter political rivals in Congress, has no one ever taken to dropping a dime on a rival's being influenced?

A lot of the politics in Washington is just theater. There may be some rivalry between politicians, but a lot of it manufactured for the cameras. I remember watching a presidential debate in 2004 between Bush and Kerry which got a little personal and a bit heated. On camera, both Bush and Kerry looked pretty pissed at each other, but as soon as the debate ended, they were on stage embracing and laughing about the whole thing like a couple of professional wrestlers who just acted out a fierce wrestling match.

The Democrats and Republicans are really just two wings of the same political party.

Or do "they" then just disappear the loose cannon dime-dropper?

Some politicians are likely either assassinated or they have their careers destroyed. Others might just be marginalized by the media, which makes their re-election damn near impossible. They know the game.

Does this explain the dozens of Senators & Congressmen that have mysteriously disappeared over the last several decades?

Killing or "disappearing" people is highly suspicious. It's much easier to just get rid of them by blackmailing them, getting them involved in a scandal, or destroying their chances at re-election.

You're asking the wrong question, here?

It's not "what's ridiculous …?"
EVERYTHING about your scenario is ridiculous.

It's only ridiculous because you've been brainwashed to believe in a false paradigm. If you were born inside of a darkened box and only ever saw black, my trying to explain to you about the bright, sunny, colorful world outside the box would sound ridiculous too.

And by "you", I presume you include yourself. Or have you found some magic way to extract yourself from The Matrix?

Nobody is outside the Matrix. Even the people living under bridges, in the forest, or even in Somalia are dealing with the effects of the Matrix.

I am going to send multiple checks to the state & feds this weekend.

Then I'm going jump on my motorcycle this weekend & take a ride up the California coast. I hope to make it as far as Santa Barbara for a bread & breakfast. Then a return trip thru the inland mountains & back to San Diego.

Towards the end of this year, I plan on retiring for a year of around-the-world travel. And then back here to finish out my last big project before a very active, fun permanent retirement.

Somehow my "false notion of freedom & democracy" seems to be going pretty well.

Sure, that's because you are essentially a free-range slave. Your owners allow you to move about and spend most of your time as you wish because happy slaves/livestock are more productive than unhappy slaves/livestock.

To tell you the truth, your interpretation of existence ("just human livestock") makes it sound like your life just plain sucks.

Nobody ever said self-awareness was easy.
 
Anybody planning on going to go find that undetonated missile lying around in the Hudson River?
 
Whoever told you you were free? You're not. You're a tax slave.

[Off Topic]
It really bothers when these suburban kids start talking about "suppression" and "lack of human rights" and "losing our freedoms" when they know not the first thing about human rights abuses beyond the false rhetoric that comes from an Alex Jones rant!

Really? Paying taxes is the worst you've had to endure? While enjoying the services that those taxes provide for you and every citizen? Perhaps you feel the evil govt should just provide roads, fire departments, education, company regulatory boards for free? Yeah! That'll happen! The magic elves will just cover it with their pot of gold!

I'm sorry if I don't get choked up about your false impressions of who is or who is not "living free". I suggest you try talking to Bosnian Women who had to endure rape camps.
Survivors of Rawanda who had to endure ethnic Cleansing.
People who live in Syria; Sudan; N. Korea. People who ACTUALLY understand what it's like to have their freedoms taken away and live in ACTUAL suppressed societies. They may be unsympathetic to your plight that a Starbucks took over your favorite coffee shop!
[Back on Topic]

Sorry for the rant.

Cantonear
 
it would appear that being ahappy and contented free range slave is a pretty good life

whats the downside?

It's mind over matter. Anyone can achieve a measure of happiness under even the worst of circumstances. Our human psychology has numerous self-defense mechanisms built into it that serve to protect us from uncomfortable information.
 
Anybody Guess When SHC is going to offer facts in defense of his theories instead of just more rhetoric?
About when the Devil can step outside his front door and go Ice Skating, me thinks.
 
I'd like to hear his thoughts on the active missile still lying around out there in New York's harbour, according to MaGZ's theory.
 
Anybody Guess When SHC is going to offer facts in defense of his theories instead of just more rhetoric?
About when the Devil can step outside his front door and go Ice Skating, me thinks.

I'm just following your lead. You guys don't bother to provide any facts, so why should I?
 
I'd like to hear his thoughts on the active missile still lying around out there in New York's harbour, according to MaGZ's theory.

It's ultimately irrelevant whether or not there is a missile at the bottom of the Hudson River. It's pointless and has absolutely no effect on the core 9/11 debate.

Why would you even care about that theory? It's a waste of time.
 
It's ultimately irrelevant whether or not there is a missile at the bottom of the Hudson River. It's pointless and has absolutely no effect on the core 9/11 debate.

Why would you even care about that theory? It's a waste of time.

Then why are you posting in a thread about MaGZ's theory?

I don't think it's a waste of time, it gave me a nice chuckle.
 
Anybody Guess When SHC is going to offer facts in defense of his theories instead of just more rhetoric?
About when the Devil can step outside his front door and go Ice Skating, me thinks.

Never.

It will never happen. He (she) doesn't even believe this stuff. It's all a ruse designed to be contrarian. That's all it is.

It's not even clever. It's just more tenacious than normal trolls are.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom