Is sexual addiction real?

Great posts everyone. I love this forum.
Let me clear my situtation up a little further: I did want sex like twice a day but I know that wasn't possible. I would've settled for twice a week. If I was lucky it was once a month. I used to go to the strip club across the street from my work once a week or so on my lunch. Never ever cheated or took anyone home. When she heard about my strip club activities, she considered that cheating and it was one of the basis of the "addiction" claim. That was seven years ago.
So then, it could be considered an addiction because it was one of the catalysts that added to the divorce.

Now I have a gf who goes to strip clubs with me, loves the swing parties and BDSM clubs. When we are together (she's in Germany, I'm in the Northern East Coast of the US) we are ... well, very active. Now, I am the same person. I haven't changed my philosophy at all, and my sex drive is exactly the same.
So you could say that I am not a sex addict, I just have a very healthy sex drive.

I would think that addiction is not as subjective. You either are or your not.

Did sex cause my divorce? Or was it caused by her lack of wanting sex?
Are both my present gf and I both sex addicts or is it just very healthy libedo? (With alcoholism or drug the addiction is clear. Two drug addicts are clearly drug addicts.)

And to throw another log in the think tank, what about "food addiction"? I used to be 320 pounds, but in two years, I have lost 130 pounds. Now I have to control my eating, otherwise I'll be right back up there. Does this make it an addiction too?
 
And to throw another log in the think tank, what about "food addiction"? I used to be 320 pounds, but in two years, I have lost 130 pounds. Now I have to control my eating, otherwise I'll be right back up there. Does this make it an addiction too?


This is an interesting point. I find eating properly to be very challenging, despite knowing that much of what I ingest is less than good for me, particularly with how often I eat the stuff. Is this addiction? I don't know, but I imagine there would be some people who would call me a food addict.

As for sexual addiction, I'd say it's probably a real thing, but rather difficult to diagnose. How negative does one's behaviours have to be before the label of "addict" is applicable?

:confused:
 
I have mixed feelings about calling things like this addictions along with things like gambling and eating. I think addiction should be restricted to things that create a physical change - heroin, cocaine, alcohol.
The proper medical term for long-term compulsive use of substances which induce a physical tolerance effect and withdrawl symptoms is "dependence".

"Addiction", in medical terms, is primarily a behavioural phenomenon. While these behaviours do not cause a physical tolerance or withdrawl effect, they do, however, have a small physical component (ie. adrenaline/serotonin modification induced by the behaviour) which is the basis for the addiction.
 
Her claim that you are a sex addict neither means you are or aren't a sex addict. IOW, her assessment of your behavior is not a valid diagnosis of this pathology.

My ex-wife thought that by pleasuring myself to a Playboy magazine I was "Literally raping the woman in the picture."



Really? Hmmm. In that case, I gotta plead "GUILTY your honor".
That's funny..I don't feel like a rapist :cool:
Oh well...............


Cheers,
DrZ
 
And to throw another log in the think tank, what about "food addiction"? I used to be 320 pounds, but in two years, I have lost 130 pounds. Now I have to control my eating, otherwise I'll be right back up there. Does this make it an addiction too?

That's impressive.
 
Couples need to make sure they have the same expectations and needs before marriage, be it financial, sexual, or any number of other subjects for that matter.
 
Couples need to make sure they have the same expectations and needs before marriage, be it financial, sexual, or any number of other subjects for that matter.


That might not be nearly as simple as it sounds.

In my opinion, that might actually be impossible.

Expectations change all the time. Even individually.
 
That might not be nearly as simple as it sounds.

In my opinion, that might actually be impossible.

Expectations change all the time. Even individually.


Agreed. I believe that part of being in a relationship is allowing your partner to grow. Change in expectations is definate.
 
This is an interesting point. I find eating properly to be very challenging, despite knowing that much of what I ingest is less than good for me, particularly with how often I eat the stuff. Is this addiction? I don't know, but I imagine there would be some people who would call me a food addict.

bulimia and binge eating disorder totally qualify as food addictions, imo.
 
bulimia and binge eating disorder totally qualify as food addictions, imo.

Completely agree. However, someone like me, who doesn't do bulimia and binging, still has to keep watch over food (and consequently, think about food more than people who aren't dieting), still could qualify as an addiction.

The point I'm curious about, is at what point does natural human drives; (e.g. sex and hunger) can be considered an addiction?

I mean, both are something that our bodies tell us we need. Sometimes, our minds override our bodies or our bodies tells us "more" when we don't need it.

In most cases with drugs, the mind is changed physically so that the body craves the drug. However, with sex and food, especially sex, there is no physical change. With food, there is a clear danger for eating too much or the wrong thing. But with sex, it seems to me that there is a moral thing going on moreso than a danger thing.

Also, luchog said
The proper medical term for long-term compulsive use of substances which induce a physical tolerance effect and withdrawl symptoms is "dependence".

"Addiction", in medical terms, is primarily a behavioural phenomenon. While these behaviours do not cause a physical tolerance or withdrawl effect, they do, however, have a small physical component (ie. adrenaline/serotonin modification induced by the behaviour) which is the basis for the addiction.

which I can go along with, but that opens the door for people to say, for example, "Let's stamp out bowling. There are people hopelessly addicted to bowling." or "I'm not responsible for knocking that row of people down, I'm addicted to bowling, it's all Brunswick's fault" or even "He ignores me because he's addicted to bowling."

I know I'm being silly, but it makes my point. Addiction to X, especially sex, is subject to people saying either it needs to be stamped out, or the person "addicted" is not responsible for their actions, or that others will see it as a "cause of being bad" instead of it being a symptom, or even harmless.

Maybe I'm over analyzing, (I do that often. Maybe I'm addicted to analyzing :-) ) but I have a causal interest in psychology, especially things that make people make choices. This is a biggie. And you guys came up with very intelligent, insightful and polite answers. :-)
 
Completely agree. However, someone like me, who doesn't do bulimia and binging, still has to keep watch over food (and consequently, think about food more than people who aren't dieting), still could qualify as an addiction.

The point I'm curious about, is at what point does natural human drives; (e.g. sex and hunger) can be considered an addiction?

I mean, both are something that our bodies tell us we need. Sometimes, our minds override our bodies or our bodies tells us "more" when we don't need it.

In most cases with drugs, the mind is changed physically so that the body craves the drug. However, with sex and food, especially sex, there is no physical change. With food, there is a clear danger for eating too much or the wrong thing. But with sex, it seems to me that there is a moral thing going on moreso than a danger thing.

Also, luchog said


which I can go along with, but that opens the door for people to say, for example, "Let's stamp out bowling. There are people hopelessly addicted to bowling." or "I'm not responsible for knocking that row of people down, I'm addicted to bowling, it's all Brunswick's fault" or even "He ignores me because he's addicted to bowling."

An addiction can be entirely or primarily psycological. You could therefore theoretically get addicted to almost anything.

Here's the question about food: Lets say, for example, you have trouble eating the right food because you just love sweets and baked goods to the point that you way overeat them or maybe the same with some high calorie/low nutrition fast food.

You have a heart attack or surgury or something which lands you in the hospital. The doctor tells you that you cannot deviate from the hospital's meals which are balanced and that having a high fat meal during your recovery could cause major problems. The food at the hospital does not leave you physically hungry or nutritionally deficient...

Could you deal with this? For a week? For a month? Would you end up considering leaving the hospital against doctor's orders? Would you try to get friends to sneak stuff into you? Would you try to hide food somewhere? Would you consider it?

That's the sort of thing an addict would do because they would feel an overriding need for it beyond "Wow, this sugar free pudding is so bland and this is a real drag"


What if you were told by a doctor that you could not eat more than one big desert per week? Would you be able to? Would you slip up once in a while and do two in a week? Or would slip up nearly every week... and then do three a week and four... and then end up driving to the store to buy cookies and eating them in your car so nobody would find out.


That would be the difference. It's one thing to think "Damn I wish I could have that cake" or even to occasionally cave to cravings... nobody is perfect.

But when it becomes a pattern of feeling an absolute need to even at the expense of other stuff, then it's a problem.
 
Thank you, Dr.Buzzo. Great post. :-) I'd like to ask a question about that, not to be rude, but just for my clarification, and it makes a good debate, IMHO. :-)

I completely agree and understand what you are saying. But that still means that addiction is a subjective thing.

For example, let's take my "sexual addiction". As I said before,

I did want sex like twice a day but I know that wasn't possible. I would've settled for twice a week. If I was lucky it was once a month. I used to go to the strip club across the street from my work once a week or so on my lunch. Never ever cheated or took anyone home. When she heard about my strip club activities, she considered that cheating and it was one of the basis of the "addiction" claim.


Now I have a gf who goes to strip clubs with me, loves the swing parties and BDSM clubs. When we are together (she's in Germany, I'm in the Northern East Coast of the US) we are ... well, very active. Now, I am the same person. I haven't changed my philosophy at all, and my sex drive is exactly the same.

In the first paragraph, you could argue that I do have a sex addiction. It was part of the reason of my marriage dissolving, (whether you agree with my ex or not about her philosophy of strip clubs, it was used as a basis to prove my addiction).

However, in the second paragraph, I'm the same person with the same drives and wants, but this time, it's not hurting my relationship. In fact, it's enhancing it. No damage, no addiction.

Basically what I'm asking is this: Is sex addiction a completely subjective thing? To put it further, is any other psychological addiction (not physicological addiction), completely subjective?


Edited to add:

By the way, the "
and then end up driving to the store to buy cookies and eating them in your car so nobody would find out.
" thing I've done before. Many times, even during my weight loss.... :-)
 
Last edited:
most diagnosis of mental illness include something along the lines of 'the behavior impacts the persons life in a negetive way'. it has to have consequences that arent favorable but dont seem to deter the behavior, like sex addicts who find themselves taking risks for sex that they didnt really want to ake, or hurting their loved ones w/their behavior, getting fired for being innapropriate at work, etc. thats what makes it a problem imo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom