Is it ok to confuse "Jew" with "Israeli"??

the fact remains that while ofcourse, it is stupid to allign all jews with israelis and zionists, since one can be a perfectly good religous jew without living in israel or being involved with Israel, many anti-Semites make no distinction between them..for their bigoted and hateful reasons..and many Zionists make no distinction between them...for their nationalistic and narrow religious view reasons.

there were jews before the state of israel..and if it disappears..there will be jews after the state of israel.
 
One of the problems that people face, is when anti-Israel rhetoric is voiced, it often comes out sounding exactly like anti-Jewish (anti-Semitism) ranting. It is hard to differentiate between legitimate criticism of the State of Israel and some policies of that nation, and an overall hatred for Jews, in general.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1026026.html

For instance, when someone says: "Israel has no right to exist" are they expressing dissatisfaction with Israel (like saying "Canada has no right to exist") or are they really saying it because they just plain hate Jews and would rather all Jews on Earth just vanish? Hard to tell, honestly, and the only way to understand is to view their attitudes in context and try to see what other statements are being expressed by that person.

Does "Israel has no right to exist" by itself show anti-Semitism? Not really.
However, when seeing an individual is offering that opinion in the context that he just hates Jews in general, then the meaning changes.
 
i have never seen someone say "israel should not exist" and they actually mean jews should be removed from the planet. they usually mean they want israel deconstructed and the jews sent to the nations where they came from..and a few want a secular bi-national state.
 
i have never seen someone say "israel should not exist" and they actually mean jews should be removed from the planet. they usually mean they want israel deconstructed and the jews sent to the nations where they came from..and a few want a secular bi-national state.

My preferred solution - the peaceful bi-national state. Anyone who wanted to non-violently protest any policy should have the right to do so. Anyone who wanted to take other people's land, kill people, hold innocents hostage, or anything else could have the right to a proper dosage of lead in the diet.
 
My preferred solution - the peaceful bi-national state. Anyone who wanted to non-violently protest any policy should have the right to do so. Anyone who wanted to take other people's land, kill people, hold innocents hostage, or anything else could have the right to a proper dosage of lead in the diet.

wishing for a secular, bi-national, Arab-Jewish utopia state is like wishing for Ron Paul or Ralph Nader to become King of America.

It just ain't gonna happen, dont'cha know.
 
It does exist and a lot of jews aren't happy about it.

You'll need to familiarise yourself with the definitions of "theocracy" and "apartheid". It can be deduced from your many posts here in reference to the Israel-Arab conflict that your understanding of these terms relates to their usage for polemical purposes rather than their actual meanings.

http://www.slate.com/id/2155277/


Do the Basic Laws of Israel specify immediate divine guidance for governance?

While your poor understanding of the terms may serve you well in the formulation of the sort of mushy-headed opinions that one expects from those with the mindset of a mindless left wing activist, you offer no insight into the legitimate points of discussion in regard to the Israel-Arab conflict despite your frequent ramblings. Though you may feel proud of yourself for employing these sorts of anti-Israel talking points with regularity, rest assured that such viewpoints will eventually be discarded ignominiously into the dustbin of history.
 
Last edited:
You'll need to familiarise yourself with the definitions of "theocracy" and "apartheid".
If the word Apartheid makes you squeamish what would you suggest should be used in its place? Would you subject the word "democracy" to the sort of massaging normally required to tag it onto Israel?
 
You'll need to familiarise yourself with the definitions of "theocracy" and "apartheid". It can be deduced from your many posts here in reference to the Israel-Arab conflict that your understanding of these terms relates to their usage for polemical purposes rather than their actual meanings.

http://www.slate.com/id/2155277/


Do the Basic Laws of Israel specify immediate divine guidance for governance?

While your poor understanding of the terms may serve you well in the formulation of the sort of mushy-headed opinions that one expects from those with the mindset of a mindless left wing activist, you offer no insight into the legitimate points of discussion in regard to the Israel-Arab conflict despite your frequent ramblings. Though you may feel proud of yourself for employing these sorts of anti-Israel talking points with regularity, rest assured that such viewpoints will eventually be discarded ignominiously into the dustbin of history.

I'm just going on the evidence. If it looks like apartheid, is run like apartheid, and is enforced like apartheid, then it probalby is apartheid. The West Bank and Gaza fit the bill.
 
wishing for a secular, bi-national, Arab-Jewish utopia state is like wishing for Ron Paul or Ralph Nader to become King of America.

It just ain't gonna happen, dont'cha know.

Given that the people who are actually living there are pretty much willing to bury the hatchet, and in fact mostly already have, I think its very possible. Now there are a bunch of hardcores on both sides, and governments who don't want to back down, but the actual population would be fine with it.

The governments could both use to be thrown out on their ear though. I suggest we send them on a joint delegation to Greenland to negotiate, then fix the country when they're gone.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom