Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Thimerosal has resource saving and an economic benefit. It allows us to use multi-dose vials. Without it bacteria could grow in multi-dose vials after one starts to use them.
I once mailed a box full of hundreds of empty little boxes of single dose packaging for pediatric hepatitis B vaccine to the Clinton White House when they were working on health care reform. It's was obviously a wasteful use of health care dollars.
As for unneeded risk, it should always be about risk/cost vs benefit/cost of not using, not just the risk side or the benefit side of the equation alone.
In this case, when there is no influenza risk in the area, there is no cost to delaying the vaccination. The benefit is peace of mind.
If flu is anticipated soon or has already arrived, the benefit of preventing a potentially deadly disease outweighs the cost of peace of mind.
The same equation applying the benefit of thimerosal containing vaccine is lowered cost. To Rocketdodger there may be zero lowered cost, the vaccine providers generally have one price for vaccine, single dose vial or not. The benefit of one less dose of thimerosal is peace of mind.
If there was a shortage of thimerosal free vaccine, then the risk of influenza or the cost of not preventing it would outweigh the peace of mind benefit.
I once mailed a box full of hundreds of empty little boxes of single dose packaging for pediatric hepatitis B vaccine to the Clinton White House when they were working on health care reform. It's was obviously a wasteful use of health care dollars.
As for unneeded risk, it should always be about risk/cost vs benefit/cost of not using, not just the risk side or the benefit side of the equation alone.
In this case, when there is no influenza risk in the area, there is no cost to delaying the vaccination. The benefit is peace of mind.
If flu is anticipated soon or has already arrived, the benefit of preventing a potentially deadly disease outweighs the cost of peace of mind.
The same equation applying the benefit of thimerosal containing vaccine is lowered cost. To Rocketdodger there may be zero lowered cost, the vaccine providers generally have one price for vaccine, single dose vial or not. The benefit of one less dose of thimerosal is peace of mind.
If there was a shortage of thimerosal free vaccine, then the risk of influenza or the cost of not preventing it would outweigh the peace of mind benefit.