Is BLM or Antifa a group or just an ideology?

Just so everyone is on the same page, the BLM and Antifa "groups" I'm calling fictional are the ones creepy, Jonestown maga-weirdo freaks call terrorist "groups".

I should've made this clear earlier. I'm sorry, and I hope everyone can forgive me, but that's also not the ones I want to join, although I'd love to go to one of their meetings and raise hell.


ETA: I'd still like to go to the non-violent ones, but not to raise hell of course. So, any help in that regard would be appreciated.
 
Last edited:
Ideology.
People coalesce around similar beliefs and forms groups, usually temporary and dynamic.
 
So... the way these things work is like this:

Fascists announce that they're going to do something, e.g. "we're going to have a parade calling for the death of all black people".

Around the area where this has been planned, many people talk to their local community organisations, e.g. churches, cycling groups, hiking groups, weed control groups, book reading groups, etc. etc. etc. saying things like this:

"I'm going to protest against these fascists, if anyone wants to join me, I'll be at this place, at this time, please spread the word, to anyone who might like to join me."

Someone else might be saying: "If you want to help making signs, my shed is available."

40 times the number of fascists turn up to stop the fascists from spreading their hate.

Fascists say:

"Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah this secret organisation is terrorising us!"

No Fascist, that's the people standing up to your hate and bullying behaviour.

There's no secret organisation.
 
So... the way these things work is like this:

Fascists announce that they're going to do something, e.g. "we're going to have a parade calling for the death of all black people".

Around the area where this has been planned, many people talk to their local community organisations, e.g. churches, cycling groups, hiking groups, weed control groups, book reading groups, etc. etc. etc. saying things like this:

"I'm going to protest against these fascists, if anyone wants to join me, I'll be at this place, at this time, please spread the word, to anyone who might like to join me."

Someone else might be saying: "If you want to help making signs, my shed is available."

40 times the number of fascists turn up to stop the fascists from spreading their hate.

Fascists say:

"Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah this secret organisation is terrorising us!"

No Fascist, that's the people standing up to your hate and bullying behaviour.

There's no secret organisation.
Indeed, they are simply a group of like-minded citizens who oppose people they see as fascist*... they wouldn't exist if fascists didn't exist.


* the word "fascist" has pretty much lost its impact these days. It actually means "adherent, follower, or promoter of far-right, authoritarian, and ultranationalist political ideology" but the progressive left have diluted its meaning to refer to pretty much anyone, anywhere on the political spectrum whom they disagree with. Those who are opposed to free movement of people across borders, those who hold gender critical beliefs, and those who wish to preserve traditional roles regarding gender, the nuclear family, and sexual orientation, are deemed "fascist" by the progressive left.

Same thing with "communist". It actually means "an adherent to a political and economic ideology that aims to create a classless, moneyless, and stateless society based on the common ownership of the means of production (such as factories, land, and resources". But its meaning has been diluted by ultra-conservatives who use it to attack ideas and people they don't like. Those who recognize that climate change is anthropomorphic, those who support the idea of a a welfare state, and those who advocate for universal healthcare, are all deemed "communist" by ultra-conservatives.
 
ETA: I'd still like to go to the non-violent ones, but not to raise hell of course. So, any help in that regard would be appreciated.
If the antifa group.is non violent, they are probably not antifa. They are just people who dont like fascists.The whole antifa credo revolves around "playtime is over, bitches. We are not asking politely for fascists to be civil". You don't need to get your personal hands dirty, but you better be prepared to cover for your fellow travellers who do.
 
If the antifa group.is non violent, they are probably not antifa. They are just people who dont like fascists.The whole antifa credo revolves around "playtime is over, bitches. We are not asking politely for fascists to be civil". You don't need to get your personal hands dirty, but you better be prepared to cover for your fellow travellers who do.

So, you've been to one of their meetings. Please tell me where I can go to raise hell.
 
So, you've been to one of their meetings.
More than one, lol. But they are not having meetings. There's no clubhouse or licensed swag. The brothers are more like minutemen who share information and rare event plannings via text. Back when antifa was gaining steam a few years back, I reached out to some of my old anarchist buddies from my younger days, and damned if they weren't getting back together, with some new youngbloods.

In fairness, neither fascists or antifascists are a big presence in my neck o' the woods, and the brothers are more like old school anarchists that really hate white supremacists and doxx them at every opportunity.

{Eta: it was skinheads v anarchists in my day, but neither were gaining political power the way a fascist seeks to. Plus or minus, that's still how it is here on the NE Coast. Groups like the Proud Boys and those Keystone twats are the opposite number}

Please tell me where I can go to raise hell.
It's easier than you think. You can Google them and find their postings online in your local area. Post on their threads. You might need someone to vouch for you if they are into/are planning activities that aren't exactly legally compliant. Kinda on your own there.

Get in contact via the local postings, and don't seem too eager. They kinda think police are out to infiltrate, so... you know, a little wary.

Eta: oh, and obviously don't use your real name when posting or have personally identifiable stuff like links to anything Amy Srrange related. Anonymity is antifas friend, but it can be a double edged sword
 
Last edited:
Different groups of people briefly gathered together in different places at different times.

Decide for yourself if that meets your concept of a group.
"Ideology" if you don't really know each other and just turned up at a publicized event to throw down. "Group" if you are in regular contact about this stuff even when they are not showing up in your neighborhood.
 
More than one, lol. But they are not having meetings. There's no clubhouse or licensed swag. The brothers are more like minutemen who share information and rare event plannings via text. Back when antifa was gaining steam a few years back, I reached out to some of my old anarchist buddies from my younger days, and damned if they weren't getting back together, with some new youngbloods.

In fairness, neither fascists or antifascists are a big presence in my neck o' the woods, and the brothers are more like old school anarchists that really hate white supremacists and doxx them at every opportunity.

{Eta: it was skinheads v anarchists in my day, but neither were gaining political power the way a fascist seeks to. Plus or minus, that's still how it is here on the NE Coast. Groups like the Proud Boys and those Keystone twats are the opposite number}


It's easier than you think. You can Google them and find their postings online in your local area. Post on their threads. You might need someone to vouch for you if they are into/are planning activities that aren't exactly legally compliant. Kinda on your own there.

Get in contact via the local postings, and don't seem too eager. They kinda think police are out to infiltrate, so... you know, a little wary.

Eta: oh, and obviously don't use your real name when posting or have personally identifiable stuff like links to anything Amy Srrange related. Anonymity is antifas friend, but it can be a double edged sword

Thank you, but that doesn't really tell me if I'm hooking up with the violent ones or not, because those are the ones I want to go and raise hell.
 
Personally, I think that unless there's a leader or a way to organize things, then it's not a group, it's just a crowd who follow an ideology, even if the only reason they're there is through word of mouth.

I mean, if a store has a big sale and a lot of people go there, is that a group or a crowd?

This question has bothered philosophers for centuries.

Anyway, all this is just my opinion.

Your mileage may vary of course.
 
Thank you, but that doesn't really tell me if I'm hooking up with the violent ones or not, because those are the ones I want to go and raise hell.
In my most humble of opinions, if they are loud and easy to find online, they are probably non violent. People who are outside the four corners of the law are kinda shy about the limelight. See Anonymous for a style tip, there.

If you want to raise hell, go to where hell is likely to be raised (like a well publicized white supremacist speaker doing the rounds- youl l know about it if you are following public postings) and wear black and have a black backpack full of goodies (all improvised stuff, no overt weapons).{Eta: small backpack! Not some huge military thing to weigh you down. Like, bookbag sized}. You'll blend right in and since many don't know each other's faces, you're in uniform. Do what the others do (run when they run, etc) because they likely know something you don't. *Do not get separated from the main group*. Don't become the easy to pick off straggler. And remember that getting violent is a two way street. The other team wants a piece of your ass and aren't pulling punches. Have fun! I've gotten too old for a lot of that ◊◊◊◊.
 
Last edited:
In my most humble of opinions, if they are loud and easy to find online, they are probably non violent. People who are outside the four corners of the law are kinda shy about the limelight. See Anonymous for a style tip, there.

If you want to raise hell, go to where hell is likely to be raised (like a well publicized white supremacist speaker doing the rounds- youl l know about it if you are following public postings) and wear black and have a black backpack full of goodies (all improvised stuff, no overt weapons). You'll blend right in and since many don't know each other's faces, you're in uniform. Do what the others do (run when they run, etc) because they likely know something you don't. *Do not get separated from the main group*. Don't become the easy to pick off straggler. And remember that getting violent is a two way street. The other team wants a piece of your ass and aren't pulling punches. Have fun! I've gotten too old for a lot of that ◊◊◊◊.

I'd love to be invited to a maga weirdo rally.

Not to hurt anyone you understand, but just to yell out something inappropriate every now and then.
 
Personally, I think that unless there's a leader or a way to organize things, then it's not a group, it's just a crowd who follow an ideology, even if the only reason they're there is through word of mouth.
That's how it works, in my limited experience. A few guys/gals are natural organizers, but no one in an antifa/anarchist group is really going to be a leader. Rigid Chains of Command are fash, lol.
I mean, if a store has a big sale and a lot of people go there, is that a group or a crowd?
Crowd if spontaneous, group if pre-arranged and coordinated, IMO. But I'm pretty sure it's all-access and walk-ins are welcome.
 
I'd love to be invited to a maga weirdo rally.

Not to hurt anyone you understand, but just to yell out something inappropriate every now and then.
Just go, and do it. Stay near the sidelines if you don't want to fight outright. You'll be welcomed for your support, and the rowdier attendees will likely jump in if you get accosted. Not kidding though- do whatever the crowd does. A lot suddenly moving in one direction might mean a gun was pulled out. Don't be standing there with your dick in your hand when everyone else beat feet.
 
Last edited:
Just go, and do it. Stay near the sidelines if you don't want to fight outright. You'll be welcomed for your support, and the rowdier attendees will likely jump in if you get accosted. Not kidding though- do whatever the crowd does. A lot suddenly moving in one direction might mean a gun was pulled out. Don't be standing there with your dick in your hand when everyone else beat feet.

Yeah, they'll be sooooo happy to get my support... bwahahahahaha

Remember, this a maga-weirdo rally I'm going to.

Maybe I should get some bumper stickers printed up that says "Trump's Memorial Site," and put them on every trash can, and then shout out something inappropriate every once in a while.

I get hurt, I get hurt, but it won't be me doing the hurting.

Hmmmmm... maybe I should get a friend to come along to film the whole thing.

That's all for now but be here for our next fun-filled episode when you'll hear Amy shout, "THE FAT CLOWN IS A MURDERER!!!"
 
Last edited:
I assumed you meant as a protestor, where antifa would fo sho welcome your support.

THE FAT CLOWN IS A MURDERER!!!

I'm sure they would, but I like to go to where the enemy is and raise hell there. It's one of the many, many reasons why I'm registered as a republican. My chances are better at getting an invitation to one of these rallies if they think I'm one of them.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom