Merged Invasion of the Brain Snatchers / Toxoplasma Gondii

Gord_in_Toronto

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jul 22, 2006
Messages
26,940
How Your Cat Is Making You Crazy

Jaroslav Flegr is no kook. And yet, for years, he suspected his mind had been taken over by parasites that had invaded his brain. So the prolific biologist took his science-fiction hunch into the lab. What he’s now discovering will startle you. Could tiny organisms carried by house cats be creeping into our brains, causing everything from car wrecks to schizophrenia? A biologist’s science- fiction hunch is gaining credence and shaping the emerging science of mind- controlling parasites.

More at: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2012/03/how-your-cat-is-making-you-crazy/8873/2/

Quite scary if true. :scared:
 
Fascinating stuff. So my question is, what would the parasites be doing that makes controlling some of our behavior useful? We are nudged to keep cats as pets? All of these mind altering parasites so far encourage prey to make themselves accessible to predators which consume the victims. No animal I know of is trying to eat us on a regular basis.
 
Last edited:
Fascinating stuff. So my question is, what would the parasites be doing that makes controlling some of our behavior useful? We are nudged to keep cats as pets? All of these mind altering parasites so far encourage prey to make themselves accessible to predators which consume the victims. No animal I know of is trying to eat us on a regular basis.

"A dog owner and a cat owner each die alone, at home. The dog starves."
 
Fascinating stuff. So my question is, what would the parasites be doing that makes controlling some of our behavior useful? We are nudged to keep cats as pets? All of these mind altering parasites so far encourage prey to make themselves accessible to predators which consume the victims. No animal I know of is trying to eat us on a regular basis.

Human brains and mouse brains function with similar biochemistry. The parasite's adaptations are not geared toward affecting human brains in a particular direction, but rather toward affecting mouse behavior in a particular direction: that of making them more likely to be eaten by cats. Chemicals that interfere with judgement and promote risk taking in mice are likely to have similar affects in humans.

To anyone interested in this fascinating subject I recommend Carl Zimmer's Parasite Rex. Toxoplama gondii is only one of the remarkable parasites he discusses in that book.
 
Human brains and mouse brains function with similar biochemistry. The parasite's adaptations are not geared toward affecting human brains in a particular direction, but rather toward affecting mouse behavior in a particular direction: that of making them more likely to be eaten by cats. Chemicals that interfere with judgement and promote risk taking in mice are likely to have similar affects in humans.

To anyone interested in this fascinating subject I recommend Carl Zimmer's Parasite Rex. Toxoplama gondii is only one of the remarkable parasites he discusses in that book.
But the risk taking was specific to an attraction to cat urine, it wasn't risky behavior per se. The other parasite this has been documented in was ants staying at the top of grass blades where cattle would be grazing. Again that was not general risk taking but rather a specific action that was risky.

I can see, however, some random unrelated effect in humans if the parasite evolved to spread in a rat/cat life cycle but humans were also infected.
 
Would you care to elaborate on what it is you find "scary" about this article?

Lots of people live with cats.

Cats have a parasite that can be transmitted to people.

This parasite may cause a variety of serious medical issues including schizophrenia.

Other than that, nothing.

:boggled:
 
Lots of people live with cats.

Cats have a parasite that can be transmitted to people.

This parasite may cause a variety of serious medical issues including schizophrenia.

Other than that, nothing.

:boggled:
I'm pretty sure if there had been an epidemiological relationship between any parasite and schizophrenia we'd have found it by now. Viruses are still potential suspects but they are a tad harder to detect than an organism the size of a parasite.
 
That is old news, as in decades old news. I read article on toxoplasma gondi a long time ago, as well as study & speculation on the effect on human behavior. Although some effect have been demonstrated, as far as I know something as drastic as schizophrenia was not demonstrated to be one, or at least only be a contributing factor. But since I did not follow it really closely, maybe in the mean time they found more ?


*caress my cat head* time to go bungee jumping from a plane.
 
But the risk taking was specific to an attraction to cat urine, it wasn't risky behavior per se. The other parasite this has been documented in was ants staying at the top of grass blades where cattle would be grazing. Again that was not general risk taking but rather a specific action that was risky.

As I understand it, it's both general risky behavior and an attraction to the scent of cat urine.

I don't really see why the latter couldn't function in human brains in much the same way it does in rat brains. Again, suggesting that the parasite's biochemistry is adapted to rat brains and only happens to have similar affects on humans. Particularly since the effect they found in humans was simply less aversion to the smell of cat urine, rather than the actual attraction found in rats.
 
As I understand it, it's both general risky behavior and an attraction to the scent of cat urine.
Feel free to point to the specific 'general risk taking' conclusion you refer to. I missed it.

I don't really see why the latter couldn't function in human brains in much the same way it does in rat brains. Again, suggesting that the parasite's biochemistry is adapted to rat brains and only happens to have similar affects on humans. Particularly since the effect they found in humans was simply less aversion to the smell of cat urine, rather than the actual attraction found in rats.
I'm not saying the parasite doesn't affect human brains.

So people with the parasite like cat pee. It's a neutral effect as far as natural selection pressures are concerned unless you think you can make a case that humans keep cats as pets and that is enhanced by the parasite.
 
Lots of people live with cats.

Cats have a parasite that can be transmitted to people.

This parasite may cause a variety of serious medical issues including schizophrenia.

Other than that, nothing.

:boggled:


The privilege and pleasure of living with cats far outweighs any risks.

People, on the other hand...
 
Last edited:
Feel free to point to the specific 'general risk taking' conclusion you refer to. I missed it.
Will do: in a bit of a rush to leave now, but I'll take a look later today. :)

I'm not saying the parasite doesn't affect human brains.
I recognise that. I suppose I should clarify what I'm saying: the parasite evolved in the environment of mouse/rat bodies/brain --> cat bodies --> cat poop --> mouse/rat bodies/brains. Sometimes it accidentally happens to infect humans, but that's not the environment that it is generally adapted to, because that's not it's natural life cycle. If you look at the ancestry of the t. gondii in any particular human's body, chances are that it's "ancestors" lived generally in that cat-mouse environment, and thus it's biochemistry is adapted to it.

Part of those adaptations are chemical signals that have the effect, on rats of causing them to be attracted to cat urine. Because human brains and rat brains are quite similar, this affects human brains in a similar way.

(note, I'm not suggesting any of the above is evidence that my view is correct, just trying to sum up what I'm saying in case I haven't been clear)

So people with the parasite like cat pee. It's a neutral effect as far as natural selection pressures are concerned unless you think you can make a case that humans keep cats as pets and that is enhanced by the parasite.

As I said above, I'm not suggesting that the parasite has been selected for it's affect on human brains, so in my view there is no meaningful selection pressure with regards to humans here. This is only the byproduct of the selection pressures in the rat-cat environment that has been the dominant environment for most of the parasite's ancestors.

Anyway, sorry for the quick reply, I'm already late! Will be back later. :)
 
Correlation, not necessarily causation.

We all know that, right? :rolleyes:

I'm pretty sure if there had been an epidemiological relationship between any parasite and schizophrenia we'd have found it by now. Viruses are still potential suspects but they are a tad harder to detect than an organism the size of a parasite.

Was I not sufficiently skeptical in my original post and my second post?

I said both "if" and "may". :boxedin:
 
And also; neither I, nor my children, nor my grandchildren, have ever had a known parasitic infection, despite having been around cats all our lives.

Anecdotal as all heck, I know. But still ...

V.
 
Last edited:
Was I not sufficiently skeptical in my original post and my second post?

I said both "if" and "may". :boxedin:
I am merely pointing out it's unlikely and has for all intents and purposes most likely been ruled out.

As for other milder forms of mental illness or traits, perhaps.
 
My cat is perfectly capable of driving me crazy all by himself, without the assistance of protozoa.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom