Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

:rolleyes:

No one is claiming that he is qualified but The Big Dog has failed to show that he is not qualified.

Such is what passes for skepticism nowadays....

Yeah, it's pretty common around here, actually. You remember back to when you used to be a critical thinker? Someone makes a claim, they're generally expected to support it.
 
The latest on Hillary's pay for play scandal

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/records-sought-clinton-foundation-donor-intel-board/story?id=41341105

incompetent person seeking a position to which they are unqualified due solely to money and connections? Sounds like the Clinton campaign in a nutshell.

:D

TDS in 3,2,1....

The latest ?

It's re-hashed outrage from june ?

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/clinton-donor-sensitive-intelligence-board/story?id=39710624
Jun 10, 2016, 6:59 AM ET

I guess I missed the new facts :rolleyes:

It will probably imply be dismissed, but MM does have an article that touches on the boards charter:

http://mediamatters.org/research/20...linton-sold-seat-intelligence-advisory/210871

ISAB Charter States The Board “Shall Reflect A Balance Of Backgrounds.” The board’s charter, posted on the State Department’s website, states of its membership: “The ISAB shall reflect a balance of backgrounds, points of view, and demographic diversity and shall include a wide variety of scientific, military, diplomatic, and political backgrounds. All members shall hold a Top Secret security clearance.” [State.gov, accessed 6/11/16]

ABC Notes Fernando Was Technical Expert Who “Specialized In Electronic Investing.” From ABC’s report ...


It goes on to show that he does meet many criteria for a position on the board.

Now, if The Big Dog wants to present his evidence regarding an
"incompetent person seeking a position to which they are unqualified due solely to money and connections?"

I'd be happy to see him actually support a claim.

I'm not holding my breath.
 
http://mediamatters.org/research/20...linton-sold-seat-intelligence-advisory/210871

ISAB Charter States The Board “Shall Reflect A Balance Of Backgrounds.” The board’s charter, posted on the State Department’s website, states of its membership: “The ISAB shall reflect a balance of backgrounds, points of view, and demographic diversity and shall include a wide variety of scientific, military, diplomatic, and political backgrounds. All members shall hold a Top Secret security clearance.” [State.gov, accessed 6/11/16]

ABC Notes Fernando Was Technical Expert Who “Specialized In Electronic Investing.” From ABC’s report ...

Oh Media Matters! Oh well that certainly settles that!!! :rolleyes:

"a wide variety of scientific (FAIL), military(FAIL), diplomatic(FAIL), and political (FAIL)backgrounds. All members shall hold a Top Secret security clearance (FAIL)."

He was a high frequency security trader, just what they needed "to advise Hillary Clinton on the use of tactical nuclear weapons and on other crucial arms control issues."

And when you ask them about it? They "stall," he "abruptly resigns," and threatens to have an ABC reporter "arrested."

Say: MORE INFORMATION:

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/clinton-donor-sensitive-intelligence-board/story?id=39710624

Say, maybe you can get the latest from propaganda outfit media matters???
 
So predictable ...

It will probably imply be dismissed, but MM does have an article that touches on the boards charter:

Oh Media Matters! Oh well that certainly settles that!!! :rolleyes:

"a wide variety of scientific (FAIL), military(FAIL), diplomatic(FAIL), and political (FAIL)backgrounds. All members shall hold a Top Secret security clearance (FAIL)."

He was a high frequency security trader, just what they needed "to advise Hillary Clinton on the use of tactical nuclear weapons and on other crucial arms control issues."

:sdl: You dismiss my evidence, yet ....

Now, if The Big Dog wants to present his evidence regarding an
"incompetent person seeking a position to which they are unqualified due solely to money and connections?"

I'd be happy to see him actually support a claim.

I'm not holding my breath.

Yet don't present any evidence. Shocking. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You mean except that 2200 word long article from ABC which contained links to 14 emails and supporting video?

And people wonder why we do not take Shillaries seriously.

FANTASTIC!

:dl:

Full circle :rolleyes:

The only thing you presented was that article, which did not support your claim. If you feel that you can cherry pick some out of context phrase that may support you, please quote it.
 
Oh Media Matters! Oh well that certainly settles that!!! :rolleyes:

"a wide variety of scientific (FAIL), military(FAIL), diplomatic(FAIL), and political (FAIL)backgrounds. All members shall hold a Top Secret security clearance (FAIL)."

He was a high frequency security trader, just what they needed "to advise Hillary Clinton on the use of tactical nuclear weapons and on other crucial arms control issues."

And when you ask them about it? They "stall," he "abruptly resigns," and threatens to have an ABC reporter "arrested."

Say: MORE INFORMATION:

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/clinton-donor-sensitive-intelligence-board/story?id=39710624

Say, maybe you can get the latest from propaganda outfit media matters???

You mean except that 2200 word long article from ABC which contained links to 14 emails and supporting video?

And people wonder why we do not take Shillaries seriously.

FANTASTIC!

Full circle :rolleyes:

bwhahahaha!!

It was two separate articles.

But "skeptics" have declared that they do not support the claim! sure they do not seem to have read either, but... Hillary 2016!

FANTASTIC!!!
 
bwhahahaha!!

It was two separate articles.

But "skeptics" have declared that they do not support the claim! sure they do not seem to have read either, but... Hillary 2016!

FANTASTIC!!!

FANTASTIC.

Tell us which of those 14 emails or what part of the video provides evidence for your claim:

"incompetent person seeking a position to which they are unqualified due solely to money and connections?"
 
FANTASTIC.

Tell us which of those 14 emails or what part of the video provides evidence for your claim:

"incompetent person seeking a position to which they are unqualified due solely to money and connections?"

FANTASTIC!!!! He read the article!

The part where it says he was a flash trader from Chicago

This part:
The emails further reveal how, after inquiries from ABC News, the Clinton staff sought to “protect the name” of the Secretary, “stall” the ABC News reporter and ultimately accept the resignation of the donor just two days later.

This part:

T
he Chicago securities trader, who specialized in electronic investing, sat alongside an august collection of nuclear scientists, former cabinet secretaries and members of Congress to advise Hillary Clinton on the use of tactical nuclear weapons and on other crucial arms control issues.

“We had no idea who he was,” one board member told ABC News.

:D

this part:

Fernando attended Beloit College, where he earned bachelor's degrees in economics and history.

We had no idea who he was.

Say, maybe you can quote media matters again, skeptic.

:thumbsup::D:thumbsup:
 
FANTASTIC!!!! He read the article!

The part where it says he was a flash trader from Chicago

This part:


This part:

T

:D

this part:



We had no idea who he was.

Say, maybe you can quote media matters again, skeptic.

:thumbsup::D:thumbsup:

To be clear, you are saying that getting a Bachelors degree makes Fernando incompetent? Or that an anonymous board member didn't know who he was? Or that he was a flash trader from Chicago? Are you certain any of those things is a clear sign of incompetence?

Maybe the bit about being from Chicago is a sign of incompetence for some. Aren't you from Chicago?
 
FANTASTIC!!!! He read the article!

The part where it says he was a flash trader from Chicago

This part:


This part:

T

:D

this part:



We had no idea who he was.

Say, maybe you can quote media matters again, skeptic.

:thumbsup::D:thumbsup:

That makes him unqualified....how?
 
The topic of the thread is not each other.

Will all participants on both sides of this argument please make more effort to stay on topic, to be civil and polite and refrain from attacking each other.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
That makes him unqualified....how?

What qualifications does a financial trader, with no background in nuclear science or US foreign policy, have to sit on a board that discusses US nuclear policy? Zero. The board is comprised of people who have a background in nuclear science and US foreign policy. What possible input of value could he have? It's like having a nuclear scientist, with no background in finance or economics, sit on the Federal Reserve Board.

From the International Security Adisory Board's website:

The Board provides its recommendations to the Secretary of State. Board members are national security experts with scientific, military, diplomatic, and political backgrounds.

Mr. Fernando does not have any experience in the fields cited above.
 
What qualifications does a financial trader, with no background in nuclear science or US foreign policy, have to sit on a board that discusses US nuclear policy? Zero. The board is comprised of people who have a background in nuclear science and US foreign policy. What possible input of value could he have? It's like having a nuclear scientist, with no background in finance or economics, sit on the Federal Reserve Board.

From the International Security Adisory Board's website:



Mr. Fernando does not have any experience in the fields cited above.
can you go through the media matters link above and point out to us where they are wrong.
 
can you go through the media matters link above and point out to us where they are wrong.

Can you go through the actual post right in front of you and explain how he was wrong?

C'mon guys, how was this flash trader with no national security or scientific, military, diplomatic, and political backgrounds qualified? (keeping in mind that they refused to release his qualification, they stalled responding, he immediately resigned and when asked threatened to have the reporters arrested)

/media matter, cripes it is like a truther saying you should watch loose change
 
can you go through the media matters link above and point out to us where they are wrong.

I have no desire to unspin the spin. Let's just deal with the plain facts and you can tell me where I'm wrong.

We have no evidence that Mr Fernando actually has any experience in any security-related matters. His expertise is in financial matters. I don't see anything in his education or background that would qualify him to advise anyone on cyber security or any of the subjects outlined in the ISAB. He is undoubtedly a smart guy with an interest in national security but that doesn't seem enough to get appointed to such an advisory board.

Sec. Clinton was given a list of people who had the qualifications. This guy, who wasn't on the list and happens to be a big donor to her and her charity simply asked to be put on the board and Clinton and her staff made it happen. Even her own staff members ridiculed the appointment. See the released emails.

Now, these are facts that are not in dispute. Do you disagree?
 
I think Julie better find something with a little more meat to it, if you noble warriors are going to bring down the wicked witch's castle. Firstly, this crap was floated back in June. You guys had bigger fish to fry, what with the pending complete condemnation by the crackerjack witch burning committee that never happened, and the planned,.... how was it referred to at the dog pound?... oh, yes... "frog-marching off to prison".

Eight weeks later?

"Hey, Louie, whadda we got to release this week?"
"Well, Lew Rockwell says he knows a guy in the produce section at Kroegers who saw her sampling too many grapes, once."
"Radar Online has proof that she's been sniffing bicycle seats since her college days."
"Oooh, I know. Where's that non-article on that supporter guy who she put on some do-nothing board. What was it.... the Scary-Sounding Security Coffee Klatch or something like that."
"Yeah, but they acknowledged that was dumb and pulled his name, didn't they?"
"Doesn't matter. Sounds all serious. "Security Advisors..." Woooooo. We got nothing else, might as well spill this out in the dog dish and get them to lap it up."
 
I think Julie better find something with a little more meat to it, if you noble warriors are going to bring down the wicked witch's castle. Firstly, this crap was floated back in June. You guys had bigger fish to fry, what with the pending complete condemnation by the crackerjack witch burning committee that never happened, and the planned,.... how was it referred to at the dog pound?... oh, yes... "frog-marching off to prison".

Eight weeks later?

"Hey, Louie, whadda we got to release this week?"
"Well, Lew Rockwell says he knows a guy in the produce section at Kroegers who saw her sampling too many grapes, once."
"Radar Online has proof that she's been sniffing bicycle seats since her college days."
"Oooh, I know. Where's that non-article on that supporter guy who she put on some do-nothing board. What was it.... the Scary-Sounding Security Coffee Klatch or something like that."
"Yeah, but they acknowledged that was dumb and pulled his name, didn't they?"
"Doesn't matter. Sounds all serious. "Security Advisors..." Woooooo. We got nothing else, might as well spill this out in the dog dish and get them to lap it up."

I hadn't heard of this before the recent email release. And the release gives us the behind the scenes scrambling that happened at State trying to justify Fernando's appointment. When the jig was up, he resigned.

The whole thing illustrates that Clinton did indeed do favors for her big donors. All he had to do was ask and BOOM, he was fast tracked onto a board he had no business being on. That sure sounds like pay-to-play to me.

ETA: And to be clear, the didn't acknowledge it was dumb and they didn't pull his name. He actually attended a meeting and if not for the questions he'd probably still be on the board.
 
Last edited:
From the International Security Adisory Board's website:
The Board provides its recommendations to the Secretary of State. Board members are national security experts with scientific, military, diplomatic, and political backgrounds.
Mr. Fernando does not have any experience in the fields cited above.

Is that list descriptive or prescriptive?

http://www.state.gov/t/avc/isab/charter/index.htm

12. Membership and Designation.
The ISAB shall be composed of not more than 30 members who shall serve in the capacity of Government employee (special Government employee or full-time Government employee). Appointments and termination of appointments, for both members and staff of the ISAB, shall be made by the Under Secretary.

Members serve under the pleasure of the Under Secretary and shall be appointed to the Board for a term of two years and the employment of special Government employees shall be renewed each year. The Under Secretary may reappoint Members for consecutive terms.

The ISAB shall reflect a balance of backgrounds, points of view, and demographic diversity and shall include a wide variety of scientific, military, diplomatic, and political backgrounds. All members shall hold a Top Secret security clearance.

What qualifications does a financial trader, with no background in nuclear science or US foreign policy, have to sit on a board that discusses US nuclear policy? Zero. The board is comprised of people who have a background in nuclear science and US foreign policy.

http://www.state.gov/t/avc/isab/c27632.htm

Why are these people on the board, then ?

  • Hon. Douglas Bereuter, former Republican Congressman from Nebraska
  • Mr. Robert N. Rose, President of Robert Rose Consulting, LLC and former Senior Advisor to the Chairman of Bridgewater Associates, one of the largest hedge funds in the world
  • Mr. Joseph Cirincione, President of Ploughshares Fund
  • Amb. Robert E. Hunter, former U.S. Ambassador to NATO
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom