Initial reaction

If you can remember, who did you initially think was responsible for the attack while it was unfolding and before the suspect was officially announced?

Terrorists. Seemed logical, since they keep pulling that kind of stuff. Thought of course that time they did so much more loudly.
 
Alright originally I thought it was the japanese whose suicidal pilots are well known for pulling kamikaze acts, and wanted to avenge the US for what had happened in the US happy camps and the bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki during the WW2.

You thought WHAT ?

Well, that does it for me.

If somebody can possibly come up with something that stupid, nothing he says can POSSIBLY be taken seriously.

Seriously.
 
I dont see how it is stupid to think the japanese wanted to avenge for what had happened in WW2. I studied japan, south asia, etc while I was in middle school. My grandfather served in WW2 for the navy. I know, I'm on the other side of the fence, i'm supposed to be the most hated kind here and everything I say to you is dumb. That's how it is in the "game". duh duh duh.

I'm sorry but plastering osama bin laden's face all over the tv is NOT evidence. Talking about the history of terrorism relating to al-qaeda and not 9/11 isn't evidence either. Alright, the reason why I'm asking is because recently I had watched 8 hours compilation dvd of the first 24 hours of the day on 9/11 that was put together by a friend who started recording everything from the moment after the second hit up until late that night. I have to admit, I did not get a glimpse of one single evidence that was supposedly presented to the public pointing out osama and al qaeda's guilt.
 
I dont see how it is stupid to think the japanese wanted to avenge for what had happened in WW2. I studied japan, south asia, etc while I was in middle school. My grandfather served in WW2 for the navy. I know, I'm on the other side of the fence, i'm supposed to be the most hated kind here and everything I say to you is dumb. That's how it is in the "game". duh duh duh.

I'm sorry but plastering osama bin laden's face all over the tv is NOT evidence. Talking about the history of terrorism relating to al-qaeda and not 9/11 isn't evidence either. Alright, the reason why I'm asking is because recently I had watched 8 hours compilation dvd of the first 24 hours of the day on 9/11 that was put together by a friend who started recording everything from the moment after the second hit up until late that night. I have to admit, I did not get a glimpse of one single evidence that was supposedly presented to the public pointing out osama and al qaeda's guilt.

That would be quite logical geggy, considering it was just the first 24 hours. The US had just been hit - hard - and people were in shock and terrified. The investigation into those terrible attacks was just getting underway. It takes time to conduct an investigation, even more so with something of this scale.
 
That would be quite logical geggy, considering it was just the first 24 hours. The US had just been hit - hard - and people were in shock and terrified. The investigation into those terrible attacks was just getting underway. It takes time to conduct an investigation, even more so with something of this scale.

It would also suggest that the authorities weren't trying to blame this on Al-Qaeda from the word go, which is also not very surprising.
 
If you can remember, who did you initially think was responsible for the attack while it was unfolding and before the suspect was officially announced?

I read a book a ways back, before 9/11, called "Culture of Fear," written by Barry Glassow. It claimed that 70 percent of americans initially thought muslims were responsible for the OKC bombing before the real perpetrator was caught.

Seriously, Geggy. I never use to get my opinions from
books at all ... They are meant to make money.

Cheers,
Oliver
 
I dont see how it is stupid to think the japanese wanted to avenge for what had happened in WW2. I studied japan, south asia, etc while I was in middle school. My grandfather served in WW2 for the navy. I know, I'm on the other side of the fence, i'm supposed to be the most hated kind here and everything I say to you is dumb. That's how it is in the "game". duh duh duh.

OK I'm not going to accuse you of being dumb, but would you agree that:

1. middle school is not the highest level of study in the history of Japan;

2. one person who has fought on one side of a war is not likely to be an expert on the motivations of the people on the other side, 46 years later; and

3. there is no evidence of any previous attempts by any Japanese group to harm the US in any way?

Edited to Add: there is some evidence of attacks on the US by Japanese marxist groups in the 70s and 80s http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2081774#post2081774 but nothing to suggest that these were in revenge for WWII or in any way represented the Japanese state or the feelings of the people of Japan.
 
Last edited:
geggy said:
Alright originally I thought it was the japanese whose suicidal pilots are well known for pulling kamikaze acts, and wanted to avenge the US for what had happened in the US happy camps and the bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki during the WW2.
geggy said:
I dont see how it is stupid to think the japanese wanted to avenge for what had happened in WW2. I studied japan, south asia, etc while I was in middle school. My grandfather served in WW2 for the navy. I know, I'm on the other side of the fence, i'm supposed to be the most hated kind here and everything I say to you is dumb. That's how it is in the "game". duh duh duh.
No, that comment about the Japanese was total nonsense and you know it (troll), all you are doing now is trying to legitimize what you said, but failing miserably I might add.

The Japanese have no history of terrorism towards the US or anyone for that matter.
 
I dont see how it is stupid to think the japanese wanted to avenge for what had happened in WW2. I studied japan, south asia, etc while I was in middle school. My grandfather served in WW2 for the navy. I know, I'm on the other side of the fence, i'm supposed to be the most hated kind here and everything I say to you is dumb. That's how it is in the "game". duh duh duh.

When the US embassys in Kenya and Tanzania were bombed, did you suspect the Japanese then?. What about when the USS Cole was attacked?

I'm sorry but plastering osama bin laden's face all over the tv is NOT evidence. Talking about the history of terrorism relating to al-qaeda and not 9/11 isn't evidence either. Alright, the reason why I'm asking is because recently I had watched 8 hours compilation dvd of the first 24 hours of the day on 9/11 that was put together by a friend who started recording everything from the moment after the second hit up until late that night. I have to admit, I did not get a glimpse of one single evidence that was supposedly presented to the public pointing out osama and al qaeda's guilt.

Geggy, you and other CTs need to stop looking for evidence from media speculation in the days immediately after 9/11. Time didn't stop then, things have happened.Things like Bin Laden admitting involvement on multiple occasions.
 
That in not entirely true, remember the sarin gas attack at the subway.

But that was not Japan as such, just some ◊◊◊◊◊◊ up Japanese.

and also:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_Red_Army

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chukaku-Ha

But both Marxist Revolutionary groups and so in no way state-sponsored (or even nationalistic). Any attacks on the US were part of a more general attack on capitalism, as they saw it. Also, neither of these groups was active in the decade leading up to 2001.
 
That in not entirely true, remember the sarin gas attack at the subway.

But that was not Japan as such, just some ◊◊◊◊◊◊ up Japanese.
Yes, I remember the sarin nerve gas attack, I was going to mention it but I didn't bother because I think there is still some doubt why they did it...

Terrorism is a term used to describe violence or other harmful acts committed (or threatened) against civilians by groups or persons for political, nationalist, or religious goals.
..was it for political, nationalist, or religious reasons, or were they just a kooky cult?

:confused:
 
and also:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_Red_Army

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chukaku-Ha

But both Marxist Revolutionary groups and so in no way state-sponsored (or even nationalistic). Any attacks on the US were part of a more general attack on capitalism, as they saw it. Also, neither of these groups was active in the decade leading up to 2001.
Wasn't aware of these though, thanks for the links. I think it's safe to say they weren't responsible for 9/11 though. ;)
 
..was it for political, nationalist, or religious reasons, or were they just a kooky cult?

:confused:

Where do you draw theline between Religion and Kookiness, I suppose you can argue that Al-Qaeda has a polical dimension but I suspect that martyrdom is more imporant to them than any coherent political strategy. At any rate:

The EU has designated Aum Shinrikyo as a terrorist organisation [6].
On December 11, 2002, The Canadian government added Aum to its list of banned terrorist groups.
The United States also maintain Aum on its list of foreign terrorist groups.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aum_Supreme_Truth
 
Where do you draw theline between Religion and Kookiness, I suppose you can argue that Al-Qaeda has a polical dimension but I suspect that martyrdom is more imporant to them than any coherent political strategy. At any rate:



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aum_Supreme_Truth
I don't, I think all religions are kooky (varying degrees of kookiness).

As I said there is still doubt why AUM/Aleph did it.

Since the sarin nerve gas attack they have not been linked to any further terrorist acts. AUM/Aleph has announced a change of its policies, apologized to victims of the subway attack, and established a special compensation fund. Aleph members convicted in relation to the attack or other crimes are not permitted to join the new organization, and are referred to as "ex-members" by the group.

The group reportedly still has about 2,100 members, and continues to recruit new members under the new name "Aleph". Though the group has renounced its violent past, it still continues to follow Asahara's spiritual teachings. Members operate several businesses, though boycotts of known Aleph-related businesses, in addition to searches, confiscations of possible evidence and picketing by protest groups, have resulted in closures.

So are they a terrorist organization, using terrorism in the pursuit of religious or political goals, or a (kooky) religious organization, also who cares j/k.

Regarding Al-Qaeda, they do have political and religious goals. But Al-Qaeda are not a terrorist organization in the true sense, it's a brand name...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Power_of_Nightmares
 
Last edited:
I vividly remember my first thoughts when viewing the disaster at the WTC.

1) Shock. I thought "This can't be happening." (And before you make some big amnesia-type deal out of this, Geggy, this is a perfectly natural reaction for humans in the face of *any* sort of tragedy.)

2) Concern. My uncle works in Manhattan, though I didn't know exactly where, and I was hoping he was ok.

3) Support. I live in the Philadelphia area, and wondered whether I should make the trip up to help with the clean-up.

At no time do I recall making a supposition about who was responsible, other than the general "must be terrorists" theory. Until evidence was found, I wasn't going to guess either way, though I do remember thinking that several groups (I had none in particular in mind) would probably initially take credit.
 
If you were an adult in 93 and had paid any attention to the news then you new Islamic terrorists were behind the first WTC bombing. That they were likely behind this one is what you call a no brainer.
 
If you were an adult in 93 and had paid any attention to the news then you new Islamic terrorists were behind the first WTC bombing. That they were likely behind this one is what you call a no brainer.

Kind of contradicts with the troofers intellectual capabilities :D
 
I must admit even though I saw it live it never really entered into my mind that could possibly have done such a dreadful thing at the time. I think it was just a "Holy crap....." type reaction

It was only the following day when the all the UK papers carried the story through on everything single page did I become aware that it was possibly the work of Al Quada and even then I must admit I knew very little about them and again in all honestly had never even heard of Bin Laden. Had I paid closer attention to events from previous years, which I should have, I probably would have made the connection straight away.

Having seen it live and the follow on events I am now pretty comfortable with the belief that it was in fact Al Quada who did this and it was the US that was actually the victim. I find it unfathomable why anybody would make out that the US was the perpetrators and not the victim of this terrorist act.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom