Induced Hypothermia Set for Human Trial in Trauma Cases

Cylinder

Philosopher
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Messages
6,062
Location
Arkansas
Gunshot Victims to be Suspended Between Life and Death

Doctors will try to save the lives of 10 patients with knife or gunshot wounds by placing them in suspended animation, buying time to fix their injuries

NEITHER dead or alive, knife-wound or gunshot victims will be cooled down and placed in suspended animation later this month, as a groundbreaking emergency technique is tested out for the first time.

Surgeons are now on call at the UPMC Presbyterian Hospital in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, to perform the operation, which will buy doctors time to fix injuries that would otherwise be lethal.

"We are suspending life, but we don't like to call it suspended animation because it sounds like science fiction," says Samuel Tisherman, a surgeon at the hospital, who is leading the trial. "So we call it emergency preservation and resuscitation."

The technique involves replacing all of a patient's blood with a cold saline solution, which rapidly cools the body and stops almost all cellular activity. "If a patient comes to us two hours after dying you can't bring them back to life. But if they're dying and you suspend them, you have a chance to bring them back after their structural problems have been fixed," says surgeon Peter Rhee at the University of Arizona in Tucson, who helped develop the technique.
 
Yeah, I thought this sounded pretty cool. I like how they won't call it suspended animation because it sounds too science-fictiony. If there's a way to describe keeping dead people alive for hours by replacing all their blood without sounding like science fiction, I'd love to hear it.
 
Yeah, I thought this sounded pretty cool. I like how they won't call it suspended animation because it sounds too science-fictiony. If there's a way to describe keeping dead people alive for hours by replacing all their blood without sounding like science fiction, I'd love to hear it.
If it works, we'll call it science.
 
"NEITHER dead or alive...."

Pretty sure they are alive.

No, they're clinically dead by definition. Whether they are dead dead would be somewhat open to debate depending on how you define it. It gets a bit tricky there, firstly because telling the difference between someone whose brain is actually dead and one whose brain activity is just below a detection threshold is obviously not easy, and secondly because such a definition generally rests on whether the condition is reversible or not, and again that's rather difficult to know until you've actually reversed it and the question is no longer relevant.

So yeah, "neither dead or alive" seems a pretty good description really. Depending on how you try to define death they're either dead, alive, or not sure.
 
If someone is injured seriously enough to warrant this treatment, how do the doctors obtain permission to get them to participate in the trial?

"Blink twice if you don't want us to freeze you like a Popsicle."

Curious about the ethics on this one.
 
Schrodinger's patient? :)

Heh, cute, but no. Erwin's famous feline was both dead and alive, by any definition. These are either dead or alive, depending on your definition.

(You may know this perfectly well, in which case I apologize for stepping on your joke, but not for trying to keep the "E" in JREF.)
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_hypothermic_circulatory_arrest

"Controlled clinical death", so technically not clinical death.

From the article:
"It takes about 15 minutes for the patient's temperature to drop to 10 °C. At this point they will have no blood in their body, no breathing, and no brain activity."

This sounds like it ticks all the boxes for "dead."

With any luck (and some successful cases) they can do some tests for afterlife stuff.

"We still can't say there's no afterlife or heaven, but we can say it takes longer than a couple hours to go."
 
It's mind-bending science. Speaking of which, I think one crucial question will be to see if patients suffer any brain damage/functionality after undergoing such a procedure.
 
What interests me is the implications for the concept of a soul which leaves your body at death, as well as the reports of OBE's.

If we can kill you (by the definition that we've used for centuries until now) for 2 hours and then bring you back to life, then one of the following must be true:
1) there is no soul
2) you're brought back without your soul,
3) your soul is wrenched from wherever it went and is returned to your body
4) the soul hangs around until you're *really* dead.

2 implies these patients should develop an insatiable craving for braaaains.
3 implies these patients should have interesting OB experiences to relate.
4 implies the soul is somehow able to distinguish *real* death from clinical death, invalidating ALL existing OB experiences.
 
What interests me is the implications for the concept of a soul which leaves your body at death, as well as the reports of OBE's.

If we can kill you (by the definition that we've used for centuries until now) for 2 hours and then bring you back to life, then one of the following must be true:
1) there is no soul
2) you're brought back without your soul,
3) your soul is wrenched from wherever it went and is returned to your body
4) the soul hangs around until you're *really* dead.

2 implies these patients should develop an insatiable craving for braaaains.
3 implies these patients should have interesting OB experiences to relate.
4 implies the soul is somehow able to distinguish *real* death from clinical death, invalidating ALL existing OB experiences.

Let's not jump the gun. First, you have to bring someone back. :)
 
I'm hoping to see some super powers.

Once we can kill someone for a whole 4 days and resurrect them, we will have surpassed the most well-known example of divine intervention and power.

Surely by then, it's time to give up such pre-historic superstitions?
 
Don't they do this already for cardiac surgery in Russia?
I've seen something similar done in the US, for cardiac arrest and brain injury, where they pack the patient in ice and infuse chilled saline or shunt their blood through a cooling loop. Recent studies suggest the promise of the technique is, as yet, unrealised.
 
Last edited:
If there's a way to describe keeping dead people alive for hours by replacing all their blood without sounding like science fiction, I'd love to hear it.

How about "cardiopulmonary bypass"?

(OK, not all the blood. But a pretty good percentage...)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom