In the minds of '9/11 Truthers', what was the motivation behind the 9/11 attacks?

Tinfoil Hater

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jan 8, 2010
Messages
1,440
The '9/11 Truthers' insist 9/11 was an inside job...but they seldom spell out why they think it was done, and who would profit from it. How would American profit from attacking it's own cities and killing it's own citizens?

Of course Truthers seldom if ever provide 'proof' that 9/11 was an inside job- they don't understand that they need to back up their claims- and whenever 'proof' is put forward, it is quickly exposed and discredited.

For a time many truthies claimed GW Bush was behind 9/11, and they claim it was done so Bush and Cheney could stay in power indefinatly- but now that Bush is out of power, that scratches that theory..Or do they now think Obama was in on it?.

There are rabid anti-semitic Truthers on both the radical left and the radical right who accuse the Jews of being behind eveything, and the Jew-bashing Truthers numbers are growing- In my mind, they reduce the Truther movement as being little more than a hate group, just another branch of neo-Nazi Holocaust deniars...

I suspect many of the Truthers, on both the left and the right, are fueled by a deep rooted hatred of the American government, of America, and American people. They assume that all Americans share their hatred, so engage in projection, and think the government, the media, the airlines, the military and citizens would have no problem being in on a massive conspiracy of mass murder that would have involved thousands of people.............yet nobody talked? No papertrail?
Truthies assume everyone approached to be part of such a conspiracy would have accepted the job...because given the chance to have been part of such a conspiracy, these Truthers would have accepted the job in a heartbeat. So the idea of an inside job is a wet dream to these nutcases...


I think Truthers WISH it had been an inside job...they crave it more than anything....

In addition to blaming 9/11 on the Jews and parroting Nazi propaganda about the Jews wanting to take over the world , what are the other reasons Truthers give for the 9/11 attacks? Is it something vague, like 'assuring strength for the military industrial complex?' Do they think Tony Blair was in on it?

Remember when Noam Chomsky (a leading intellectual of the American political left, and former MIT prof in linguistics) denounced the 9/11 conspiracy theories as being absurd? Ultra left truthers turned on him in droves, and accused him of being part of the conspiracy

You can't accuse Bush and Cheney of being inept- but then accuse them of master minding & carrying out and covering up what would be the most complex coverup in history....I am NO fan of GW Bush or Dick Cheney- but they were NOT behind 9/11. They may have exploited the fear and paranoia created in it's wake to push for a war in Iraq, but that's another story.

If Bush was behind 9/11, why has inept in every other action?
The war in Iraq has been one bungle after another...

The reality was that a group of religious/cult members took advatage of very lax airport seurity, hijacked 4 planes, and commited mass murder.
Period. Thats what happened.

But for the Truthies who still insist it was an inside job- who do they think gave the order, and why was it carried out?

I know most of the Truthers are ignorant, others are bigots, and a good number of them have mental illness- I'm just curious WHY they think the things they do.....
 
There are rabid anti-semitic Truthers on both the radical left and the radical right who accuse the Jews of being behind eveything, and the Jew-bashing Truthers numbers are growing- In my mind, they reduce the Truther movement as being little more than a hate group, just another branch of neo-Nazi Holocaust deniars...

We have talked all about this. While anti-Semetic Truthers make a lot of noise, I am convinced they have not been the major force behind the movement in the USA.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=5254515#post5254515

Remember when Noam Chomsky (a leading intellectual of the American political left, and former MIT prof in linguistics) denounced the 9/11 conspiracy theories as being absurd? Ultra left truthers turned on him in droves, and accused him of being part of the conspiracy

I was not here when this happened, but my reading of what happened is quite different. The left Truthers that I have read and watched appeared quite apologetic about Chomsky, the same way that the real right wing nuts jobs still left have brushed aside Ron Paul's refusal to accept their explanations. I may be wrong and am willing to accept the opinions of those more experienced than I. But that's my interpretation. Besides, Ultra-left Truthers appear to have always been a small portion. There may appear to be more of them left since the real right-wingers grew up and became Obama Birthers, but most Truthers I know politically are very right wing.

Honestly, you're thinking a little bit too much about all this. 90% of people involved in this 911 stuff are high school students. Our 911 Truther friends here make it sound like there's a huge voice from the construction industry that's calling for justice. If you watch what passes for 911 Truth demonstrations, it's all high school kids. Their thought is extremely disorganized and incoherent. I have talked with Truthers who tell me they want free health care but Ron Paul makes a lot of sense. It sounds like a political position, but it's not. It's just a bunch of ideas with no ideology behind it.

By far the most active demonstrators for 911 Truth remain the We Are Change organizations. They are 90% high school students. I know most of them personally and I have counted who shows up at their demonstrations. Some of the others are marginally employed or mentally ill. Others are involved in extreme right-wing Christian politics and use these groups to make calls for money.

Every once in while, the Truth Movement produces a new icon to speak out for the silent majority. Recently it's been Derek Johnson. Mr Johnson holds this status because he claims to be a mechanical engineer. This has produced a split of opinions on the forum. There are those who want to make JREF such a welcoming place that Mr Johnson and his ilk will feel they want to come here and talk about their belief. Others, like me, make fun of Mr Johnson and his followers for being retards.

The reason for this is that there really is no Truth Movement anymore. There is no coherent political philosophy that backs it up. Some Truthers are anti-Semitic right wing nuts. Others are, as I said, confused high school radicals. Asking about the motivations of Truthers is like asking about the motivations of astrologers or Chinese herbal therapists. There may be a coherent psychological motive, but there is no political motive behind any of this. It's just as idea that different kinds of people latch on to.

So to ask what Truthers think was the motivation behind 911 misses the fact that there is no 'opinion' to be understood, even by asking them about it. They just have no common opinion. All they have is a babbling message that goes on and on like a tape recorder. Most of the original Truthers have by now found girlfriends and boyfriends and lost interest. The handful who are left are losers, politically confused kids, or the mentally ill.
 
Last edited:
A few key phrases:

NWO
Illuminati
Oil
War
Martial Law

And we're still waiting :)
 
Theories? We Don't Need No Stinkin' Theories!

But for the Truthies who still insist it was an inside job- who do they think gave the order, and why was it carried out?

Excerpt from the updated BBC The Conspiracy Files, 9/11 - The Truth Behind The Third Tower program. Truthers don’t need a plausible theory or a coherent narrative of what happened on 9/11/01 because they’re “just asking questions” and, according to Dylan Avery, they don’t want to be “backed into a corner.”

 
Welcome- Titanic Explorer..... Boston's newest member of the NWO! Go Pats!
 
We have talked all about this. While anti-Semetic Truthers make a lot of noise, I am convinced they have not been the major force behind the movement in the USA.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=5254515#post5254515



I was not here when this happened, but my reading of what happened is quite different. The left Truthers that I have read and watched appeared quite apologetic about Chomsky, the same way that the real right wing nuts jobs still left have brushed aside Ron Paul's refusal to accept their explanations. I may be wrong and am willing to accept the opinions of those more experienced than I. But that's my interpretation. Besides, Ultra-left Truthers appear to have always been a small portion. There may appear to be more of them left since the real right-wingers grew up and became Obama Birthers, but most Truthers I know politically are very right wing.

Honestly, you're thinking a little bit too much about all this. 90% of people involved in this 911 stuff are high school students. Our 911 Truther friends here make it sound like there's a huge voice from the construction industry that's calling for justice. If you watch what passes for 911 Truth demonstrations, it's all high school kids. Their thought is extremely disorganized and incoherent. I have talked with Truthers who tell me they want free health care but Ron Paul makes a lot of sense. It sounds like a political position, but it's not. It's just a bunch of ideas with no ideology behind it.

By far the most active demonstrators for 911 Truth remain the We Are Change organizations. They are 90% high school students. I know most of them personally and I have counted who shows up at their demonstrations. Some of the others are marginally employed or mentally ill. Others are involved in extreme right-wing Christian politics and use these groups to make calls for money.

Every once in while, the Truth Movement produces a new icon to speak out for the silent majority. Recently it's been Derek Johnson. Mr Johnson holds this status because he claims to be a mechanical engineer. This has produced a split of opinions on the forum. There are those who want to make JREF such a welcoming place that Mr Johnson and his ilk will feel they want to come here and talk about their belief. Others, like me, make fun of Mr Johnson and his followers for being retards.

The reason for this is that there really is no Truth Movement anymore. There is no coherent political philosophy that backs it up. Some Truthers are anti-Semitic right wing nuts. Others are, as I said, confused high school radicals. Asking about the motivations of Truthers is like asking about the motivations of astrologers or Chinese herbal therapists. There may be a coherent psychological motive, but there is no political motive behind any of this. It's just as idea that different kinds of people latch on to.

So to ask what Truthers think was the motivation behind 911 misses the fact that there is no 'opinion' to be understood, even by asking them about it. They just have no common opinion. All they have is a babbling message that goes on and on like a tape recorder. Most of the original Truthers have by now found girlfriends and boyfriends and lost interest. The handful who are left are losers, politically confused kids, or the mentally ill.

That sums it up rather nicely.
 
We have talked all about this. While anti-Semetic Truthers make a lot of noise, I am convinced they have not been the major force behind the movement in the USA.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=5254515#post5254515



I was not here when this happened, but my reading of what happened is quite different. The left Truthers that I have read and watched appeared quite apologetic about Chomsky, the same way that the real right wing nuts jobs still left have brushed aside Ron Paul's refusal to accept their explanations. I may be wrong and am willing to accept the opinions of those more experienced than I. But that's my interpretation. Besides, Ultra-left Truthers appear to have always been a small portion. There may appear to be more of them left since the real right-wingers grew up and became Obama Birthers, but most Truthers I know politically are very right wing.

Honestly, you're thinking a little bit too much about all this. 90% of people involved in this 911 stuff are high school students. Our 911 Truther friends here make it sound like there's a huge voice from the construction industry that's calling for justice. If you watch what passes for 911 Truth demonstrations, it's all high school kids. Their thought is extremely disorganized and incoherent. I have talked with Truthers who tell me they want free health care but Ron Paul makes a lot of sense. It sounds like a political position, but it's not. It's just a bunch of ideas with no ideology behind it.

By far the most active demonstrators for 911 Truth remain the We Are Change organizations. They are 90% high school students. I know most of them personally and I have counted who shows up at their demonstrations. Some of the others are marginally employed or mentally ill. Others are involved in extreme right-wing Christian politics and use these groups to make calls for money.

Every once in while, the Truth Movement produces a new icon to speak out for the silent majority. Recently it's been Derek Johnson. Mr Johnson holds this status because he claims to be a mechanical engineer. This has produced a split of opinions on the forum. There are those who want to make JREF such a welcoming place that Mr Johnson and his ilk will feel they want to come here and talk about their belief. Others, like me, make fun of Mr Johnson and his followers for being retards.

The reason for this is that there really is no Truth Movement anymore. There is no coherent political philosophy that backs it up. Some Truthers are anti-Semitic right wing nuts. Others are, as I said, confused high school radicals. Asking about the motivations of Truthers is like asking about the motivations of astrologers or Chinese herbal therapists. There may be a coherent psychological motive, but there is no political motive behind any of this. It's just as idea that different kinds of people latch on to.

So to ask what Truthers think was the motivation behind 911 misses the fact that there is no 'opinion' to be understood, even by asking them about it. They just have no common opinion. All they have is a babbling message that goes on and on like a tape recorder. Most of the original Truthers have by now found girlfriends and boyfriends and lost interest. The handful who are left are losers, politically confused kids, or the mentally ill.



Excellent points, thank you
 
The '9/11 Truthers' insist 9/11 was an inside job...but they seldom spell out why they think it was done, and who would profit from it. How would American profit from attacking it's own cities and killing it's own citizens?

Of course Truthers seldom if ever provide 'proof' that 9/11 was an inside job- they don't understand that they need to back up their claims- and whenever 'proof' is put forward, it is quickly exposed and discredited.

For a time many truthies claimed GW Bush was behind 9/11, and they claim it was done so Bush and Cheney could stay in power indefinatly- but now that Bush is out of power, that scratches that theory..Or do they now think Obama was in on it?.

There are rabid anti-semitic Truthers on both the radical left and the radical right who accuse the Jews of being behind eveything, and the Jew-bashing Truthers numbers are growing- In my mind, they reduce the Truther movement as being little more than a hate group, just another branch of neo-Nazi Holocaust deniars...

I suspect many of the Truthers, on both the left and the right, are fueled by a deep rooted hatred of the American government, of America, and American people. They assume that all Americans share their hatred, so engage in projection, and think the government, the media, the airlines, the military and citizens would have no problem being in on a massive conspiracy of mass murder that would have involved thousands of people.............yet nobody talked? No papertrail?
Truthies assume everyone approached to be part of such a conspiracy would have accepted the job...because given the chance to have been part of such a conspiracy, these Truthers would have accepted the job in a heartbeat. So the idea of an inside job is a wet dream to these nutcases...


I think Truthers WISH it had been an inside job...they crave it more than anything....

In addition to blaming 9/11 on the Jews and parroting Nazi propaganda about the Jews wanting to take over the world , what are the other reasons Truthers give for the 9/11 attacks? Is it something vague, like 'assuring strength for the military industrial complex?' Do they think Tony Blair was in on it?

Remember when Noam Chomsky (a leading intellectual of the American political left, and former MIT prof in linguistics) denounced the 9/11 conspiracy theories as being absurd? Ultra left truthers turned on him in droves, and accused him of being part of the conspiracy

You can't accuse Bush and Cheney of being inept- but then accuse them of master minding & carrying out and covering up what would be the most complex coverup in history....I am NO fan of GW Bush or Dick Cheney- but they were NOT behind 9/11. They may have exploited the fear and paranoia created in it's wake to push for a war in Iraq, but that's another story.

If Bush was behind 9/11, why has inept in every other action?
The war in Iraq has been one bungle after another...

The reality was that a group of religious/cult members took advatage of very lax airport seurity, hijacked 4 planes, and commited mass murder.
Period. Thats what happened.

But for the Truthies who still insist it was an inside job- who do they think gave the order, and why was it carried out?

I know most of the Truthers are ignorant, others are bigots, and a good number of them have mental illness- I'm just curious WHY they think the things they do.....

I will concur with what Scott in Taiwan said and express my severe discontent by your hint twoofers might have minds.

McHrozni
 
I will concur with what Scott in Taiwan said and express my severe discontent by your hint twoofers might have minds.

McHrozni



I suspect its just a case that Truthers are a mix of crazy people and stupid people- many of them see conspiracies in everything (Isn't severe paranoia is a sign of metal illness?)-
Some of them are just stupid, and blindly parrot the talking points of their websites......

Whichever side of the political spectrum truthers are on..in my book, they're nuts...or stupid...and it may very well be a waste of time to assume they have minds...

I have discovered that many truthies who insist thermite was used to bring down the WTC have little understanding of thermite. If you ask them to define it, and explain how it is used and applied, you'll get blank stares...
 
Last edited:
TE.

Notice how the resident trolls... sorry truthers are avoiding this thread? They don't have alternate theories, nor alternate motives... They can't come up with a coherent narrative of the day which stands up to any scrutiny (notice the fractures in truthers, no planers, DEW, thermite, etc...)
 
I take it that you are using the word mind in it's loosest possible sense.
 
TE.

Notice how the resident trolls... sorry truthers are avoiding this thread? They don't have alternate theories, nor alternate motives... They can't come up with a coherent narrative of the day which stands up to any scrutiny (notice the fractures in truthers, no planers, DEW, thermite, etc...)

I've asked our resident truthers many times for their detailed theories about what happened on 9/11,I have yet to recieve a reply.
 
My own favorite is the insistence that a major part of the motivation for 9/11 by the Evil Guvment was to gain possesion of Afghanistan so a massive Natural Gas pipeline could be built. Nine years later, no signs of a pipeline being built.
I lost a LOT of respect for Michael Moore when he repeated this crap in F 9/11.
 
My own favorite is the insistence that a major part of the motivation for 9/11 by the Evil Guvment was to gain possesion of Afghanistan so a massive Natural Gas pipeline could be built. Nine years later, no signs of a pipeline being built.

Easily explained! The omniscient cabal responsible for flawlessly executing the most insanely complicated evil plan in history is made up of bumbling incompetents that can't complete a simple construction project.
 
the point of the 9-11 attack was to create a New Pearl Harbor, that would be used as a catalyst for conspiracy theorists to grow exponentially so they could make lots more money and get lots more attention.
 
the point of the 9-11 attack was to create a New Pearl Harbor, that would be used as a catalyst for conspiracy theorists to grow exponentially so they could make lots more money and get lots more attention.

The truth movement has got to be the mother of all pyramid schemes. There are a few charlatons at the top who make money, but the great majority end up just surrendering what few dollars they can bum off their parents for the good of the "cause".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom