• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

In God you trust?

mummymonkey

Did you spill my pint?
mummymonkey
Joined
Dec 3, 2002
Messages
2,052
Location
Scotland
This piece in today's Scotsman is probably typical of the way the US is seen just now by most people in the UK. Is it fair?

More than 200 years after its foundation, the American people - whose dollar bills bear the motto ‘In God We Trust’ and whose president invokes God’s name at the end of virtually every speech - remain at odds as to precisely where the line of separation between church and state should be drawn.
Click to expand...
 
Just a little additional information...
Myth: The fact that US money is stamped with the phrase "In God we trust" and the US pledge of allegiance contains the phrase "under God" is evidence that the founding fathers believed that religion should be endorsed by the state.

Fact: Neither phrase was used until about a century or more after the US was founded. The phrase "In God we trust" first appeared on US coins shortly after the Civil War. It did not appear on paper money until the McCarthy era when pious politicians wanted to distinguish the US from the "Godless Communists". The pledge of allegiance was also adulterated during the McCarthy era; the original pledge did not contain the phrase "under God".
Click to expand...
(Source: http://freethought.freeservers.com/reason/xtian.html)

The McCarthy Era (or Cold War era), to be openly atheist was considered taboo. Any openly atheist politician was scapegoated as an ally to Communism. No politician would ever want that to happen. To continue showing that America was not a godless and communist nation, we started printing "In God We Trust" on our paper money (hey look, it says that in the piece I cited). If anything, we never put "In God We Trust" on our money for religious reasons, we did it (loosely) as a spite to communism. And today, it appears that the phrase favors and promotes Christianity, some people dont appreciate that.
 
is being seen by many Christians as an assault on their faith and an affront to the national motto ‘In God We Trust’.
Click to expand...
That's the official national motto? I don't think so. Do your frickin research first before pretending to be a journalist.

He and others are determined to take on those who insist the US is a secular state.
Click to expand...
Like George Washington.
 
On July 30, 1956 a law was passed stating that "the national motto of the United States is hereby declared to be 'In God we trust'." (70 Stat. 732. 36 U.S. Code 186). The House Judiciary Committee recognized that the phrase E Pluribus Unum had also received wide usage in the United States, and the joint resolution did not repeal or prohibit its use as a national motto. In 1963 the Department of State took the following position: "'In God we trust'" is the motto of the United States. It seems to the Department, nevertheless, that there is ample basis both in history and I law for calling 'E Pluribus Unum' a motto of the United States." The Congress has used both.
Click to expand...

http://www.usscouts.org/flag/sealmotto.html

That's what the scouts say. Is this not right then?
 
mummymonkey said:

http://www.usscouts.org/flag/sealmotto.html

That's what the scouts say. Is this not right then?
Click to expand...
OK, you got me. But it seems it's only one of two mottos.

Further on the same page:

Have federal court cases cast doubt on the constitutionality of the motto "In God we trust"?

The federal courts have held that the motto symbolizes the historical role of religion in our society, Lynch, 465 U.S. at 676, formalizes our medium of exchange, see O'Hair v. Blumenthal, 462 F. Supp. 19, 20 (W.D. Tex.), aff'd sub nom. O'Hair v. Murray, 588 F.2d 1144 (5th Cir. 1978) (per curiam), and cert. denied, 442 U.S.930 (1979), fosters patriotism, see Aronow v. United States, 432 F.2d 242, 243 (9th Cir. 1970), and expresses confidence in the future, Lynch, 465 U.S. at 692-93 (O'Connor, J., concurring). The motto's primary effect is not to advance religion; instead, it is a form of "ceremonial deism" which through historical usage and ubiquity cannot be reasonably understood to convey government approval of religious belief. Allegheny, 492 U.S. at 625 (O'Connor, J., concurring); Lynch, 465 U.S. at 693 (O'Connor, J., concurring); id. at 716 (Brennan, J., dissenting). Finally, the motto does not create an intimate relationship of the type that suggests unconstitutional entanglement of church and state. O'Hair, 462 F. Supp. at 20. "After making [inquiries], we find that a reasonable observer, aware of the purpose, context, and history of the phrase "In God we trust," would not consider its use or its reproduction on U.S. currency to be an endorsement of religion. (Gaylor vs USA, 10th Cir. 1996)
Click to expand...
A "reasonable observer" wouldn't think that putting "In God we trust" on our currency is an endorsement of religion? I'm not following their line of thought there. Expressing trust in something would seem to be an acknowledgment of its existence, which in this case is most definitely a religious position.
 
Our money does indeed bear the words "In God we trust". But I've noticed that prostitutes, drug dealers, and television evangelists accept it as legal tender anyway. ;)
 
espritch said:
Our money does indeed bear the words "In God we trust". But I've noticed that prostitutes, drug dealers, and television evangelists accept it as legal tender anyway. ;)
Click to expand...

And we have to trust God for prostitutes, drug dealers, and television evangelists.
 
I'd like to start a petition having it changed to "In Money We Trust". Who is with me?
 
arcticpenguin said:

That's the official national motto? I don't think so. Do your frickin research first before pretending to be a journalist.


Like George Washington.
Click to expand...

Arcticpenguin, I so enjoy your posts - but this time you are (sadly) incorrect.

The US officially has 2 mottos - the original, and the [Blech!] "New and Improved! [/Blech!]
 
mummymonkey said:
This piece in today's Scotsman is probably typical of the way the US is seen just now by most people in the UK. Is it fair?
Click to expand...

Mummy, I just now read the article and I must say, with some regret, that yes, it is accurate. While these issues aren't at the forefront of everyone's daily lives, the small but energetic and vocal hyper-Christians do make these issues ongoing sources of drama and strife.

Oh, and litigation. ;)
 
calladus said:


Arcticpenguin, I so enjoy your posts - but this time you are (sadly) incorrect.

The US officially has 2 mottos - the original, and the [Blech!] "New and Improved! [/Blech!]
Click to expand...
OK, I will reiterate my acceptance of the fact more clearly. I was wrong. I of course knew that "In God we trust" appears on our currency, but was unaware that it had been declared an 'official motto' of the USA.
 
Hey AP imagine the egg on your face if you had to admit that the phrase appears in the national anthem too... albiet in the 4th and last stanza, but it does.
 
Has (is) there any sort of movement to get this removed from our Pledge and our currency? If so how (where) do we sign the petition?
 
UnrepentantSinner said:
Hey AP imagine the egg on your face if you had to admit that the phrase appears in the national anthem too... albiet in the 4th and last stanza, but it does.
Click to expand...
Well... the National Anthem includes a variation of the phrase: "And this be our motto, 'In God Is Our Trust.'" It can be argued, however, that Key used "is our" instead of "we" to obtain a more pleasing meter in his poem.
 
Brown, salient as always. It was just embarassing for me to insist in chat that our National Anthem did not contain a God reference based on the first stanza when indeed a God reference did occur in the fourth.
 
E Pluribus Unum
Click to expand...

This is the first time I've heard that this was a motto of the US, and I must say that this seems much more inclusive (and fitting for a secular nation) than "In God we trust".

But then again, I'm not an American, so what do I know.
 
Considering that this is money we're talking about, shouldn't it read "In Gold We Trust"? Gold being the foundation for the value of the money and we're trusting in the value of that gold?
 
But the value of the $ isn't attached to the value of gold anymore - Nixon de-linked the two in 1971. We must place our trust in the dollar alone.

did
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom