Imprisoned for Doubting God - Alexander Aan

Marplots: I didn't sign the petition, but I'm praying for him.

I'm trying to work out if you're being deliberately passive aggressive or just accidentally passive aggressive.

I only recently found out I could use this: ;)

It just seems like we'd want to approach the problem from both ends -- secular and religious. You know, to hedge our bets. That and I don't believe online petitions do much good.

It's not like God couldn't free him if He wanted to.

If he is freed, we can argue about whether prayer or an online petition had more effect.
 
Then why would you not sign the petition as well?

Good point. I ran into this: " Sign this Petition
A whitehouse.gov account is required to sign Petitions."

Troubling. I don't want a whitehouse.gov account.
 
Good point. I ran into this: " Sign this Petition
A whitehouse.gov account is required to sign Petitions."

Troubling. I don't want a whitehouse.gov account.
That's why I posted a different petition link.
 
That's why I posted a different petition link.

I tried the mulitnational one as well. They want your personal information too.

With prayer, you aren't giving up any information God doesn't already know. ;)
 
Whether he is or is not, for me the issue is that he should have the freedom to query religion, and reference actual passages from religious text without fear of violence or loss of freedom (or even a fine).

Very well said.
 
I tried the mulitnational one as well. They want your personal information too.

All petitions need a level of confirmation that people who sign only do so once. A petition with no informaiton is pratically useless and an indication of nothing. One with a little detail indicates a level of support. You can usually be quite vague about that information, and I have used this site before. They are an established site, and don't use the information for anything - other than confirming your support.
 
All petitions need a level of confirmation that people who sign only do so once. A petition with no informaiton is pratically useless and an indication of nothing. One with a little detail indicates a level of support. You can usually be quite vague about that information, and I have used this site before. They are an established site, and don't use the information for anything - other than confirming your support.

Thanks.
 
Whether he is or is not, for me the issue is that he should have the freedom to query religion, and reference actual passages from religious text without fear of violence or loss of freedom (or even a fine).

+1
 
hmm... what reason could someone facing 25 years in prison for being an atheist possibly have for recanting their atheism?

I'm at a loss.

I thought he got two or two and a half years?
I could see God using the threat of prison to nudge a non-believer into the believer camp. I don't even think it would make a blip on the miracle scale.

But isn't the real question about how far a society should allow free speech when that speech is deemed harmful? I have recently spent time on WikiLeaks and this is the main issue being played out there.

If the fear is that a dismissal of a foundational idea (Islam in this case) harms the society, how could they do otherwise than punish it? This is the very sort of line drawing that defines what a society is.

In the US, the Smith Act is still law. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_Act
 
I don't think there is any need for a miracle, no matter how small, or for any god's intervention.
I think perhaps the possibility of further beatings, and the dark shadow of time in an indonesian prison would make any atheist consider reducing their pain if they can. Unlike believers, atheists don't need to be concerned about betraying any supernatural force and inviting their wrath. They just need to deal with their own conscience on the matter.

I am not saying this is what has happened here, but I definitely personally don't believe god pushed him anywhere ... other than pushing him into the prison in the first place, through the actions of his/her/its believers.
 
I thought he got two or two and a half years?

Missing full stop. Apologies.

I could see God using the threat of prison to nudge a non-believer into the believer camp. I don't even think it would make a blip on the miracle scale.

Suit yourself. I couldn't see god doing anything at all. There are plenty of reasons for him to have recanted that do not involve the supernatural.

But isn't the real question about how far a society should allow free speech when that speech is deemed harmful? I have recently spent time on WikiLeaks and this is the main issue being played out there.

If the fear is that a dismissal of a foundational idea (Islam in this case) harms the society, how could they do otherwise than punish it? This is the very sort of line drawing that defines what a society is.

In the US, the Smith Act is still law. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_Act

That is a real question, but I think there are clear and present differences between restrictions on someone giving out sensitive pieces of information and restrictions on someone expressing their beliefs. There is a difference between saying something someone doesn't like, and saying something that causes direct physical danger.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom