If there were objective morality - how would you tell?

By 'truth reference' I mean a mutually acknowledged standard. Examples are: a certain edition of a dictionary, a widely accepted industry reference manual, a set of published laws...anything that can serve as a point of reference.
That's exactly why morality isn't objective, ever- anything can serve as a point of reference. People have to agree to use "X" as a point of reference. If "X" were objective, agreement would be irrelevant.

Otherwise, everything is relative, your 'truth' and my 'truth' may be different, and the idea of objective anything (let alone morality) loses meaning.
Getting two people to agree about morality does not make that morality objective. Getting 100k, or even 6B people to agree does not make morality objective. This is for two reasons: as long as a set exists that includes people that don't agree, you still have "our truth" and "your truth", and second, everybody that agrees may not (and probably does not) agree for the same reasons. That means that the impetus for agreement isn't coming from a mutually understood, discovered "morality", but a mutually created, prescribed morality.

Discussion would devolve into one person's strongly-held belief vs. someone else's strongly-held belief. You see that here on this website.
You see that everywhere. If there were an objective morality, why is any discussion necessary?
 
Otherwise, everything is relative, your 'truth' and my 'truth' may be different, and the idea of objective anything (let alone morality) loses meaning.
Yes, I think it is fair to say that according to most modern philosophical thought, the whole concept of "objective truth" is considered highly problematic. Philosophies that don't do away with it completely, at least acknowledge that "objective truths" are ultimately unknowable.

Basing one's morality on such a problematic concept is a bit like trying to build a house on quicksand that may not even exist.
 
If there were an objective morality, why is any discussion necessary?

Even in cases in which there is an objective standard or confirmatory evidence to refer to, people still disagree.

There are folks, as you know, who argue that the moon landing was a hoax, despite all evidence to the contrary and the debunking of every one of their claims.

So even if it turns out there is some objective moral standard available to us, it doesn't mean everyone will recognize it for what it is.

It also wouldn't mean that such a standard would be able to resolve every moral dilemma.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom