I read the Demon Haunted World by Carl Sagan -- it sucks.

Well, if "Amy" is so good at being a straight man, will "she" know the Susquehanna Hat Company?

Michael

My college drama department recently performed "Godspell," using the SHC as the backdrop. No one really got it.
 
Worst Troll...EVER

There's an opinion is that "Amy Wilson" is a roughly 15yo teenage boy with a penchant for trolling internet-wide..

Apart from help with VBA and SQL, this is pretty much the only forum I visit. It took me a while to understand what the term 'troll' actually meant. (and I was too scared to ask, hehe). But I think I understand now. I think the dictionary definition will say 'see AmyWilson'. I had formed a mental image of AW and it definately wasn't of a 32 college educated woman. Have attached a pic of how I imagine him.

And it's probably true :)
 

Attachments

  • TheRealAmyWilson.jpg
    TheRealAmyWilson.jpg
    27.8 KB · Views: 16
Geist ist Geist!

.




I've been wondering lately, what is the supposed difference between a 'spirit' and a 'ghost'?

I went to Babel Fish and inserted your question and had ittranslated into German and here's the output:

"Ich habe mich kürzlich, was bin der angenommene Unterschied zwischen einem ' Geist ' und einem ' Geist ' gewundert?"

It appears that English has too many words!
 
seriously,
It would be nice if skeptics could add something they really like about Sagan's work. If not here then at the swiki

[swiki]The Demon-Haunted World[/swiki]
 
I think Amy left some words out. I've taken the liberty of interpolating my reconstruction of what they would have been had he remembered to type them instead of the rest of his squib.

I just got done reading the Demon Haunted World by Carl Sagan. To put it bluntly -- the book sucks
... ignorance out of the reader's brain and replaces it with awareness while promoting the kind of intelligently inquisitive mindset that can help the overly credulous to break free of their self-imposed shackles. If they dare to.
 
I just got done reading the Demon Haunted World by Carl Sagan. To put it bluntly -- the book sucks. What I found between the pages was pointless drivel from a tiresome self-promoter. No one can judge anything until they have experienced it for themselves. Science as a candle in the dark? Guess what: No one cares.

What people should make a book about is God, Heaven, the spirit world, angels, spirits, ghosts, UFO's, etc, and other awesome stuff on the Earth. No one wants to hear some pointless garbage from a dumb "scientist" who thinks he understands the world. What people want to hear about is God, Heaven, angels, spirits, UFO's, etc, and other awesome stuff. That's why the paranormal books sale by the millions (and billions) and are NYC Times best sellers. They kick butt. :)

One word: avoid. Avoid the Demon Haunted World at all costs. I got dumber after reading it. It's true. :)

As do you (thread), come on now, nothing could make you dumber - that's true!! Oh so terribly sorry for you!!:jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp
 
I read this feeble attempt at iconoclasm thread and it sucked! But that was only the initial post.

Charlie (only you can prevent trollism) Monoxide
 
I went to Babel Fish and inserted your question and had ittranslated into German and here's the output:

"Ich habe mich kürzlich, was bin der angenommene Unterschied zwischen einem ' Geist ' und einem ' Geist ' gewundert?"

It appears that English has too many words!

I went to an online dictionary and checked 'ghost'.

http://www.yourdictionary.com/ahd/thes/g/g0676100.html

A supernatural being, such as a ghost

It appears that English doesn't have enough words to define them without circular definitions, although in fairness the complete definition was:

A supernatural being, such as a ghost: apparition, bogey, bogeyman, bogle, eidolon, phantasm, phantasma, phantom, revenant, shade, shadow, specter, spirit, visitant, wraith.

And for a real answer to the difference between a ghost and spirit is that a spirit can be defined as:

The vital principle or animating force within living beings: breath, divine spark, élan vital, life force, psyche, soul, vital force, vitality.
and
The essential being of a person, regarded as immaterial and immortal

So spirit can mean the same as ghost. But ghost does not always mean the same as spirit (context).

But how scary would it be to sit around the campfire telling 'spirit stories'?
 
I went to an online dictionary and checked 'ghost'.

http://www.yourdictionary.com/ahd/thes/g/g0676100.html

It appears that English doesn't have enough words to define them without circular definitions, although in fairness the complete definition was:

And for a real answer to the difference between a ghost and spirit is that a spirit can be defined as:

So spirit can mean the same as ghost. But ghost does not always mean the same as spirit (context).

But how scary would it be to sit around the campfire telling 'spirit stories'?
There have been some [relatively] recent articles written on this topic, as the Harry Potter books have been translated into scads of languages. Each culture has its own "things that go bump in the dark", so the various elves, witches, giants, etc., get tweaked. I remember one article spoke of the difficulty of finding a Japanese equivalent of a "stoat sandwich".
 
I went to an online dictionary and checked 'ghost'

I'm sorry, but you need a better dictionary:
ghost (gōst)
n.
1 The spirit of a dead person, especially one believed to appear in bodily likeness to living persons or to haunt former habitats.
2 The center of spiritual life; the soul.
3 A demon or spirit.
4 A returning or haunting memory or image.
 
I went to Babel Fish and inserted your question and had ittranslated into German and here's the output:

"Ich habe mich kürzlich, was bin der angenommene Unterschied zwischen einem ' Geist ' und einem ' Geist ' gewundert?"

It appears that English has too many words!
Actually, it doesn't. "Geist" can be used for "ghost" in German (just like "spirit" in English), but the more usual word is "Gespenst."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom