I do believe I've found something more extreme than Rapture Ready


​
Why Can't You Believe?​

Many of you are probably wondering by now why you can't believe in Jesus. You think to yourself, what is wrong with you as a person?

Must...believe...in...Jesus...

NOOOO!!! I can't do it! What's wrong with me as a person?!
 
Yeah, I think Troy is just running one long, complex joke.

I mean, that proof alone is hilariously ridiculous! And inviting people to challenge his proof, but banning everyone before they can post?

No nicknames?

And what's that about e-mails?

Nope, this guy is having a laugh at us. He's probably a Satanist, because he's certainly doing Satan's work.
 
Troy, how can we be assured that if someone does refute your proof, that you won't simply say they haven't? If you are sole arbiter your challenge is pointless.
 
Must...believe...in...Jesus...

NOOOO!!! I can't do it! What's wrong with me as a person?!


I'd rather believe in Santa Claus. The worst thing he's ever done is leave a bad kid a bundle of switches or a lump of coal, both of which have it hands down over eternity in hell.
 
OK, let's look at this critically:

In order to take the challenge, you have to post your rebuttal on that thread, in his forum.

In order to gain access to his forum, you have to not use a nickname... apparently in your email, either.

Further, you have to correctly answer all of his questions, or you're banned.

Now, if you make it that far, and then post a rebuttal, chances are, he's going to claim that you lied when answering his questions, and are therefore bearing false witness. Banned.

If you really answered truthfully to all his questions, chances are you already believe his nonsense proof anyway.

So he can't possibly lose.

What cowardice. What stupidity. What sheer ignorance. Why even bother with this 'proof', and this 'challenge', if you so strongly conceal it from those who would show you its flaws, its errors? After all, if you had another intelligent person look it over, they could help you refine it... because, at the moment, it's rather sloppy.

Of course, all these safeguards are simply because he knows, somehow, that he'd be paying out $10,000 in the first minute if this were an honest and open challenge.

Troy Brooks is a liar.
 
It's just a badly stated version of the cosmological argument preceded by a teleological assumption (in his step one) about evolution (which is, of course, erroneous). He doesn't seem to realize that he merely ends up where all discussions of the cosmological argument end -- in an eternal presence or an eternal regress.

Take his point one -- everyone can look at the proof in Iacchus's link above -- which assumes that life if present eternally must become perfect. This assumes that progression is inherent in "evolution". There are many other possible explanations, not least of which is a universe that begins, spawns life, which may move in a general trend toward more complexity (if you start with little complexity there is only one direction to trend toward), and then end. Rinse. Repeat. An endless succession of life's beginnings with repetition of this process in various forms is one possibility. "Evolution" makes no assumption of a move toward perfection, or a move toward anything. Step one is based on some whopper assumptions. The rest of the "proof" from what it looks to me, and as I mentioned above, is simply a version of the general cosmological proof, which gets you nowhere but to that eternal presence (or endless regress -- take your pick). It never places anyone near the God of the Bible.
 
Oh, I didn't realise it was no nicknames at all, I just thought it was no offensive nicknames.

Heck, I should've used my Johnnypixels email address and then challenged him to prove it's not my real name, using it to buy some time and change my name by deed poll. Except I'd change it to Jonathan Picture-Elements, so much more class.
 
I read this and it reminded me of a piece of standup I heard a long time ago (sadly, I can't remember who by)

"For God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him will not perish

Now, let's think about this - God so loved the world, that he didn't come himself, he sent his little boy.

Derail over, sorry.
 
Dammit, when I posted I thought I was on the last page (when I was only on 2 of 6).

My original comment, therefore, is now completely irrelevant so, instead, I'll do a little dance:

tippety-tap-tap-tappy-tippety-tappy-tap-"chaaa" *jazz hands*

Thank you, I'm here all week.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I got in using one of my top secret alternate IP addresses, and clicked on your profile, and... No proof. No links to proof. Lots of drivel, but no proof.

You want to post your proof here, Troy? Because I don't believe it exists.

I suspect he means the link in his profile here. But I can't check because I've been pre-banned.
 
Hey Troy

Yor nickname is like and ancient pagan city.
You are banned


Concluding thoughts from Biblocality Christian Forums regarding the 4 Step Perfect Proof for God of the Bible...​

Get a Conscience!​

Before posting, if you are up to the challenge, realize these important points so you don't waste our time:

- people are misreading the proof, in which it is shown how they are misreading it be quoting the words they misread. Please put more effort into reading slowly to really understand what is being said. For example, many are calling the cause and effect feature we witness in creation as being evolution since the amoeba, not realizing before the amoeba there was a cause also. Do not confuse these two terms (evolving and evolution). This is explained in the first sentence of the Proof, so if people can't even get past the first sentence, DO NOT be surprised if you get banned for being this obstinate.
- over 100 people have tried and failed.
- read the 3rd item under Board Etiquette.
- please stop just giving mindless self-declarations; back up what you say with reasons. Humility is needed.
- stop trying to make yourself look smart by using big words, but apply those words with reasoning and intelligence.
- when you try to make a point, do so by being specific. If you can't be conscientious enough to be specific, then don't bother attempting a disproof. You need to be courteous, not belligerent. Vagueness and obfuscating thought of your flesh is retarded.
- try to read what has already been posted so there is not more duplication. There has been way too much duplication.
- the 4 Step Perfect Proof for God of the Bible is very refined, and I have noticed there has been nothing to tweak in this latest round of efforts to disprove it (that is, no new thoughts have been introduced that I have not heard before); the same 4 Steps have been the same since inception. The tweaking is simply to add clarification to be courteous. Please show the same courtesy.
- surely the most talented and cream of the crop atheists/agnostics can provide a thought worth discussing rather than imposing your self-declarations by blind faith. Or was that your best effort already?

Why Can't You Believe?​

Many of you are probably wondering by now why you can't believe in Jesus. You think to yourself, what is wrong with you as a person?

Let me tell you that sin has so permeated your entire being that it is difficult to know whether you are coming or going, whether to believe one thing or another. You are stuck in your head's rationalizations, moving from one thought to the next about what you are actually doing here on earth, or at the very least, asking why your thoughts are so garbled? Yet no answer satisfies. What is going on? What is going to happen? How can you know instead of bouncing around in your head? Through your spirit you can know, which is your inner man or inner woman in the deepest inner recesses of your being with its intuition and conscience and ability to commune. It is in that still small voice and inner registrations where God can impart His life to you. Once you are born-again, you may not sense His presence right away, yet you have believed. Therefore, know the Spirit is in your spirit after so believing and will work within you in your cooperation with the Son. You will begin to sense His abiding presence. The more you abide in Him, the more His grace touches your spirit, then reaching your soul and body, from inner to outer.

If you can just accept this about yourself: you sin and you do make mistakes, that it is not your fault for being born into sin, but you were born into sin which causes you to do the things you do. Sin leads to death; unforgiveness of sins leads to hell, no matter how desensitized you are to your sin nature. It may not be your fault that you were born into sin, but it is your fault if you don't come out of sin by giving your life to Christ. How can you give up self? Come to the cross as a helpless sinner to receive Jesus as your Lord and Savior. Through His death on the cross there is the promise of forgiveness of all you have ever done, as well as power over sin and self as the Holy Spirit will apply the cross to your life. We are speaking about not only sin but the selfishness of self which is not obedient to the One who created you in His image, that image by which you have a right to know God is the great I AM personally and intimately. The Father who is in heaven is perfectly loving. How well do you treat your parents who are flawed? How are you treating God the Father who spoke forth and the Son created and the Holy Spirit renewed over all of creation to allow you to make the choice.

Jesus is speaking...

John 3.16 "For God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him will not perish but have eternal life. 18 There is no judgment awaiting those who trust him. But those who do not trust him have already been judged for not believing in the only Son of God."

Conclusion to this Whole Thread​

The Holy Spirit has shown us in this thread that not only does an atheist/agnostic not have anything to go up against the 4 Step Perfect Proof for God of the Bible, but they really don't even try. This is how belligerent and obstinate they are in their approach. Myself also having been unsaved once just like you, I know all the struggles the flesh goes through to not accept Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior. The wisdom that can be imparted is this: when you choose God it is an authentic choice which happens because it is your right, made in the image of God (Gen. 1.26,27), to believe in the truth to accept and receive God's mercy, love and saving grace.

He loves you, and the last thing He wants is for you to perish, but He will not coerce you, nor can He annihilate your existence. To do either of these two things is against His righteousness (way of doing things) and holiness (His nature). Thus, putting you in hell, is necessary if you continue to refuse to come to the cross. Jesus said, even if He were to come before you right this minute in Person, still you would not be convinced. You would find some way to rationalize yourself in rejecting Christ. Don't think you will be convinced with 10 miracles. Even 1000 miracles would not convince you.

What the atheist/agnostic needs to look at I can not force them to look at. They have to look at it of their own volition and this requires they read with a conscientiousness to bring them to understanding which shows why they are still unregenerates and what keeps them separated from God.

The furthest any agnostic/atheist got never even approached getting past Step 1 in which they do not see the exponential velocity in man's conscience. I could not get anyone to confront this in any meaningful way, because it is their conscience that is the problem, the very thing they don't want to look at in their inner man or inner woman which God is showing them if they would only listen. This is why the greater portion of the Bible is the OT law which no man could keep except Jesus Christ. In a very simple way we can say it this way: we will not keep killing each other for another million years. Ergo, Step 1 shows us God created because it doesn't take forever to be perfected into sinlessness.

The avoidance (not inability to see) of this very point about the exponential improvement in conscience is where the unregenerated is stuck. His mind does not want to investigate this. He will do anything with his time, except look at this information. If the consideration is not given to stop repeating things which had already been addressed, then expect to be banned. If a person makes point A, and someone responds with point B, don't regress back to repeating point A, leaving point B undealt with. You are not a clanging bell.

Those who join unethically have nothing to offer. They should not fabricate their answers since this is dishonest. Because of this persistent problem from spammers, the forum reserves the right to remove any account not being used and disallow any registrant suspected of being a spammer. After hundreds of people have tried, but failed, to disprove the 4 Step Proof in their petty self, we can conclude convincingly the Proof is perfect.
 
- people are misreading the proof, in which it is shown how they are misreading it be quoting the words they misread.

I guess I'll have to counter that ridiculous proof, here.

- over 100 people have tried and failed.

No... over 100 people have tried and have been banned.

- please stop just giving mindless self-declarations; back up what you say with reasons. Humility is needed.

If you consider disagreement to be arrogance, then nothing can ever be said to you.

- stop trying to make yourself look smart by using big words, but apply those words with reasoning and intelligence.

Translation: Troy isn't smart.

- the 4 Step Perfect Proof for God of the Bible is very refined,

No... it's not. It's the same trash that fundies have been spewing for decades. You're just backwards.

Why Can't You Believe?​

Because it's just a load of crap.

Many of you are probably wondering by now why you can't believe in Jesus. You think to yourself, what is wrong with you as a person?

No, I don't. I don't believe in Jesus because there is no GOD to be found. End of story.

Let me tell you that sin has so permeated your entire being that it is difficult to know whether you are coming or going, whether to believe one thing or another. You are stuck in your head's rationalizations, moving from one thought to the next about what you are actually doing here on earth, or at the very least, asking why your thoughts are so garbled? Yet no answer satisfies. What is going on?

Nothing. No God, no angels, nothing.

Through your spirit you can know, which is your inner man or inner woman in the deepest inner recesses of your being with its intuition and conscience and ability to commune. It is in that still small voice and inner registrations where God can impart His life to you. Once you are born-again, you may not sense His presence right away, yet you have believed. Therefore, know the Spirit is in your spirit after so believing and will work within you in your cooperation with the Son. You will begin to sense His abiding presence. The more you abide in Him, the more His grace touches your spirit, then reaching your soul and body, from inner to outer.

You need medication, man.

After hundreds of people have tried, but failed, to disprove the 4 Step Proof in their petty self, we can conclude convincingly the Proof is perfect.

Ha.,..hahahahahaah!! Ah. Good one.
 
Allright...

(edited for clarity)

Troy said:
Step 1 - Simply stated, If for eternity things have been evolving, by this very definition of evolving, you would have had an eternity to be perfected (without sin) irrespective of when you personally started in the evolving chain according to calculus where the approximation of eternity is taken as eternity.

That's not what evolution is, and sin has nothing to do with perfection outside of religious dogma. There is no such thing as eternity. Woah. 3 errors right there. Very refined, you said ?

The assumption by many unsaved souls is that the universe has always been going on in the past for eternity.

Strawman. I don't believe that. No serious scientists considers time to be "eternal" in the past.

Therefore, what must follow, is that you have also had an eternity to be perfected and since you are not, this proves that such evolving eternally in the past is incorrect.

Congratulations, you've pinned your strawman for the count. 1... 2... 3... ring the bell! However, defeating strawmen is a bad way to be taken seriously.

As proof of this, we can see in just a few short years (approximately 6000 years ago) since the first Adamic man (the first man with God-consciousness), we have changed and matured in leaps and bounds; thus, we will not need another 6000 years to be perfected (speaking of those who have God's uncreated life).

Again, you're mistaking social evolution with biological evolution.

We are referring to only man, not animals, and only those men and woman who are saved. One observes an exponential curve in our development, not just technologically, but also in our conscience, historically and scientifically undeniable.

If you ignore the animal kingdom, then your entire dissertation is useless.

It will do nothing for your spirit and your life in Christ for it can not explain first cause, and that is where it will always fall short of the glory of God since man can not know all God's ways, nor does God need you to know all the aspects of the "dust" to be saved.

Well, at least you'd be a good formula-1 race track designer: everything in there is perfectly circular.

If you knew everything, then you would be God and would not need to be saved, but God gloriously saves without you needing to know all things. And only the smart people would be saved if you needed to know so much, but recall "that God is no respecter of persons" (Acts 10.34).

How does this help your "proof", anyway ?

Let us not be so restrictive in the petty self or vague with words by generalizing (being unspecific) so as not confuse the definitions of evolving and evolution differentiated that were provided for the sake of clarity. Nor should we behave legalistically like a bad lawyer or bear false witness against what is said here since that would be deflecting and circumventing. Let us not be belligerent or obstinate by misreading this most excellent first step.

All you've proven, so far, is that you don't know what evolution is, and assume your conclusion in advance. Although this pretty much destroys the other 4 steps, we'll come back to them, later.
 
I suggest that Troy starts a thread here to discuss his proof, although I feel he'll degenerate to insults within seconds when deprived of the ability to ban people at will...

Someone should also explain to him that 4.5 billion years is not eternity, like it would do any good.

Just because he has trouble counting past 6000 doesn't mean that anyone else does...

Edit: damn you Belz, you'd only just posted and I thought you'd at least stop for breath ;)
 
Time for step 2 (edited for clarity, again):

Step 2 - If, in response, an unsaved evolutionist, cosmologist, atheist or agnostic comes to you and says the big bang is the beginning, again, that is false also since nature doesn't happen all by itself. There is always a cause to the effects in nature.

Within the universe. Outside of time, however, the very concept of cause and effect is meaningless.

Nothing in nature happens all by itself. Material (or the smallest of particles) only knows how to react to the elements and its environment. It does not make a choice. But God does choose, and He chose for a reason.

You're assuming again. In fact, I'd say you're overassuming.

Part fact and part assumption in the desperate accusation of a fallacy of composition by the atheist or agnostic to accuse Christians is used as an intellectually dishonest smokescreen to surmise that there can possibly be such a thing as a Godless "causelessness" outside the known composition of the evolving universe of cause and effect - which is false

Please provide evidence that Quantum Physics is wrong on this point. Merely SAYING something does not make it true. If there is NO TIME, how can there be causes ?

but there is a tinge of truth in this statement, as it pertains to God who is uncreated, that is, the One Whom is, in fact, Causeless.

I'd like to scream TU QUOQUE by saying that you've just said that the universe cannot be the first cause, but gave no reason, and then say that GOD can be a first cause, without reason. How can you accuse people of doing something you do yourself ?

The misapplied use in accusing of a fallacy of composition leads us, ironically, to the conclusion that God created since there is no first cause that is causeless for the creation of the universe except that which is outside the composition, rendering God the uncreated causelessness;

Sorry, Troy. That is NOT the only available conclusion, even if you were correct about the premise. In short, it doesn't follow.

He chose to create out of His glory. His glory is distinct, since only God of the Bible fulfills this condition as revealed through Christ being sinless and giving His life as the only begotten Son of God for forgiveness of sins and giver of eternal life.

This does not advance your argument. You are banned.

This leading explanation, conscience and mind of God reveals how the universe came to be, why, and what the purpose is for us. None can compare to these answers.

I'm sure some follower of Ganesha would object.

The Bible says if you seek God with all your heart, then you will surely find Him. It's the person who wants to know God that God reveals Himself to. And if a person doesn't want to know God: - well, God has created the world and the human mind and human spirit in such a way that he doesn't have to know God, live for God or His kingdom. The choice is a free-choice to receive God's grace to live in Christ by the Holy Spirit for the kingdom of God or for the god of this world, to be controlled by the world, with a foretaste of hell.

That is so convenient. Just like the spoon-bender who says the skeptics "negative thoughts" are preventing him from working his magicks.
 
pant...pant... next:

Step 3 - The next trick that a charlatan evolutionist, cosmologist, atheist or agnostic tries to pull over your eyes is through the question, "why can't God have a creator?" Because, by definition that no longer makes God uncreated, now does it? The subject matter, God of the Bible, of the 4 Step Proof then changes. By definition, God IS the Great I AM and is uncreated (as proven in Step 1 and Step 2). The subject is God uncreated, not as a god able to be created. Do not speak of God, then redefine Him, while remaining calling Him God or calling him a god. You would then be trying to disprove something else, which is misreading the 3rd Step.

I agree that redefining terms to destroy them is a fallacy. However, the God-of-the-gaps theory does not answer the question. Nor does the assumption that God answers the question solve the problem, because now we're just working with ASSUMPTION, not proof.

Not only is this disrespectful, but cunning, unethical and coy. Be "not doubletongued" (1 Tim. 3.8).

You're beign circular again.

It is important to realize when you draw a false conclusion based on a misreading of Step 3, all that stems from your misreading is flawed and considered of no account since you are operating from false premise by misreading.

Operating on false premises ? Who does THAT remind me of ?

Simply do not bring this misreading into your attempt to refute this Proof since then you would be talking about oranges, while the proof is talking about apples. For example, don't arbitrarily self-declare Step 3 is about why bad things happen in the world (this is your idol thought), since this is not the point of Step 3 at all. Don't presuppose the third step in the Proof means something this or something else nonsensically, for I assure you, I wrote it, because it is a legitimate question to ask only if asked correctly (which, if asked correctly, takes you immediately to Step 4 to ask correctly).

Aren't you far off course, right now ? Is your entire "proof" at this step saying that you musn't use fallacies to disprove God ?

But, praise God, He will not let atrocities go on forever (even though to us it sure seems like it has been going on for a long time in man's tiny perspective, but in the backdrop of 13.7 billion years, a couple thousand years is less than a grain of sand on earth). Ergo, Hell is awaiting those who refuse His salvation. Nothing is by chance.

Indeed, nothing is. However, this STILL doesn't prove anything. At least you were claiming SOMETHING in points 1-2.

I have God's uncreated life in my spirit which affords me eternal life - His life. You may speak of gods or idols or other mechanisms, but debasing God has eternal consequences, since God is, by the definition of the word, Uncreated when referring to God of the Bible as so many verses in the Scriptures testify across 1500 years by 40+ spiritual writers in agreement.

Circular again. Not making progess.

Not once has He ever sinned in the 66 books of God's Word.

Well, if a sin is an act against God, then he can't sin, by definition. However, if sin is going against God's LAWS, then he has, numerous times.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom