Human Body Parts Mailed in Canada

CBC is reporting he was arrested in Berlin today. No story online yet.
 
Kevin,

Sorry...I don't get your argument/position here at all. Luka originally uploaded the video to a site that specializes in gore. There was no 'baiting' as such, it was presented as just what it was (although sadly police didn't take initial reports about the video seriously, assuming that it was faked with special effects).

Since then, other people have copied the video, and posted it elsewhere...often in an effort to get traffic. So yes, in those cases, it could be that it is "bait", where the person posting it is trying to lure you in. However, this has nothing to do with Luka, or his initial motivations in making this video. And there seems to be no indication that he's the one re-posting the videos (at the very least, that would put him in danger of giving the authorities a way of tracing where he is).

Do you have any evidence that it is Luka posting these videos, and not other attention-seekers?

The footage was different than the original I only saw a minute and phoned it in and shut it off it was disgusting didn't want to see anymore it could of been heavily edited of the original. Even if it was fake Police did have the footage promptly removed. I know there will be many copies on different sites now of the original things spread fast on the web. Hiding your location on the web is not hard to do. Any networking guys reading this post can vouch for that.

Glad to see he's been arrested.

Edit: Re-read my post about bait. I used the word twice and the context was not obvious. The youtube video could been anyone baiting. The second time where I said he was baiting people. He setup accounts and was advertising and providing means for people to find this video 10 days in advance. He didn't just upload it to Gore and let it fester on it's own. It was promoted.
 
Last edited:
Parallels with the 'Dnepropetrovsk Maniacs' who started with animals then progressed to filming snuff and mutilation videos, killing 20+ people along the way. One of their efforts was called '3 guys 1 hammer', which was obviously where this sicko got his idea from. (BTW, seriously, don't even think about looking for it. It's beyond the worst thing you could possibly imagine)
Almost right. Snuff is - in theory - made for profit. (Just as vampires - in theory - must drink human blood to survive.)
Well he's famous now, so he got what he wanted
he's been wiki'd
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luka_Magnotta
;)
But what is this?

3) Publishing obscene material;
4) Mailing "obscene, indecent, immoral or scurrilous" material;

Please! He filmed the butchering of a body and posted two body parts. Using "obscene" in this context make it sounds like it's the 60's and some rock band is charged for so-called obscenity* because the cover girl of their last record had too little clothes.

Magnotta is damaged goods, period. But charging him for this is against better judgement.

*) Hard to define. Easy to recognize. Not the stuff laws should be made of.
 
Last edited:
I'm surprised that nobody has mentioned the most shocking factoid in this entire affair:

The public mail system delivered a package to the proper address in a relatively timely fashion.
 
Please! He filmed the butchering of a body and posted two body parts. Using "obscene" in this context make it sounds like it's the 60's and some rock band is charged for so-called obscenity* because the cover girl of their last record had too little clothes.
.
"obscene material" is a legal definition
According to a Supreme Court decision, material is obscene, and hence not protected by the free-speech provision of the First Amendment if it has three elements: It must have prurient appeal, as decided by the average person applying the standards of the community; it must portray sexual conduct in an offensive way; and it must be lacking in serious artistic, literary, scientific, or political value
if only he'd added some dancing girls
;)
 
There's no capital punishment in Canada, but because of the torture involved in the murder he will most likely spend the rest of his life in prison.

Unless he pleads that some kind of mental illness or drug caused him to do those acts. Sadly, we've let some worst criminals run free because of that, like Guy Turcotte.
 
"obscene material" is a legal definition
According to a Supreme Court decision, material is obscene, and hence not protected by the free-speech provision of the First Amendment if it has three elements: It must have prurient appeal, as decided by the average person applying the standards of the community; it must portray sexual conduct in an offensive way; and it must be lacking in serious artistic, literary, scientific, or political value
if only he'd added some dancing girls
;)
I see. But it's revolting that they make it an issue of freedom of speech, sorta.

And doesn't a law gain legitimacy every time it's exercised? Call me a tinfoil, but it sounds like a pretty convenient way to piece by piece reinstate the canadian ban on porn.
 
3) Publishing obscene material;
4) Mailing "obscene, indecent, immoral or scurrilous" material;

Please! He filmed the butchering of a body and posted two body parts. Using "obscene" in this context make it sounds like it's the 60's and some rock band is charged for so-called obscenity* because the cover girl of their last record had too little clothes.

Magnotta is damaged goods, period. But charging him for this is against better judgement. *) Hard to define. Easy to recognize. Not the stuff laws should be made of.

Insurance policy - remember Al Capone only ever went to jail for tax evasion and contempt of court. This appears an open and shut case, still no reason to veer from your SOP
 
I see. But it's revolting that they make it an issue of freedom of speech, sorta..
Its standard procedure to include as many charges as possible on an international warrant, it makes him a bigger target, most of those will be dropped when he's charged with murder, there'd be no point sending him to prison for a year for the obscenity when he gets life without parole for the murder.

And doesn't a law gain legitimacy every time it's exercised? Call me a tinfoil, but it sounds like a pretty convenient way to piece by piece reinstate the canadian ban on porn.
Yeah I know, just in case I'm downloading as much porn as possible now in case I can't get enough to keep my right hand going later
btw, does anyone have any old hard drives they don't need
;)
 
I still for the life of me cannot understand why he did what he did. Not the murder. I chaulk that up to being disturbed. Murders at least what I know about them try to hide themselves.

He did the exact opposite. It is like he wanted to be caught. examples below

- mickey mouse shirt in terminal alone at his age(29) = draws attention
- use of personal cell phone. ditch yours and pick up a pre-paid one.
- open face in public, internet cafe, bar, airport terminal
- murder in his apartment.
- murder is of ex boyfriend
- promoted video tape online
- police claim investigation of his apartment lead them to believe he went to Paris.

You are on the run from the law and don't do a better job covering your tracks.....
I just don't get it. Unless he wanted to be caught. Which then begs the question why?
 
you're confusing a disturbed homicidal maniac with a calculating thinker attempting to evade justice.
thats why
;)

If he is of low IQ, then sure it fits. Murders who plan are generally of very high IQ. People who kill, IE gang bangers shooting on the streets are generally of low IQ.
 
thats usually only applicable to serial killers
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serial_killer#Organized.2C_disorganized.2C_and_mixed
this murder was apparently a result of jealousy, so all bets are off
;)

That was a good read, It had a somewhat fitting part in the article. I have quoted it.

"Disorganized serial killers, on the other hand, often have average to below average intelligence, with a mean IQ of 92.5.[45] They are usually far more impulsive, often done with a random weapon available at the time, and usually not attempting to hide the body. They are likely to be unemployed and/or a loner with very few friends. They often turn out to have a history of mental illness,[45] and their m.o. or lack thereof is often marked by excessive violence and sometimes necrophilia and/or sexual violence."

That was my thinking was a form of mental illness to explain the more bizarre aspects of this case. (walking through a plane terminal wearing a mickey mouse shirt) You have every cop in the world on the look out and you do that lol. Very strange.

It'll be interesting to see what the shrinks say in the trial when they interview him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom