Huge Spiral UFO Seen Over Eastern Australia.

In what way does it make sense? Aurorae involve huge numbers of charged particles hitting the atmosphere and ionising and exciting the atoms in it, which emit light when they regain electrons or drop back to the ground state. Man-made rockets, well, don't.?


well this was one hell of a sexy rocket that got those atoms so excited they couldnt contain themselves anymore, its called the john holmes effect

Maybe they just don't like Australians?

that wasn't mY quote.
 
A. I don't understand your comment about not being able to satellites that high. You can satellites in geosynchronous orbit if they catch the sun just right.

B. How do you know how much fuel was left in the rocket? Rocket boosters venting fuel have been seen before over the years. Why would this be any different.

A. All your seeing is the reflected light, if you signal a plane with a mirror using the sun from the ground the pilot only sees the reflected sunlight, he can't see the mirror.

b.please show us another example of rocket booster venting fuel in orbit that could be seen from over a 1000km stretch of ground with the naked eye.
how many litres of fuel would be needed to make that swirl in the sky?
 
"Thirdly, why would anyone launch a rocket on a maiden test flight with a trajectory that would take it over the most heavily populated parts of Australia?


Maybe they just don't like Australians?


that wasn't mY quote.


And yet, when I quote your post, exactly the same line appears. How curious.


"Thirdly, why would anyone launch a rocket on a maiden test flight with a trajectory that would take it over the most heavily populated parts of Australia?


Anyway, it was a blimp.
 
A. All your seeing is the reflected light, if you signal a plane with a mirror using the sun from the ground the pilot only sees the reflected sunlight, he can't see the mirror.

<snip>
my bolding


How exactly do you think we see most things, if not by means of the light they reflect?
 
Last edited:
well this was one hell of a sexy rocket that got those atoms so excited they couldnt contain themselves anymore, its called the john holmes effect

So when you say that your theory is better, what you actually mean is you don't have the slightest clue what you're talking about but have decided that the people who actually do must all be wrong. Got it.

that wasn't mY quote.

Yet there it is in your post. And regardless of whether it was your original thought or merely a quote from elsewhere, my point stands that whoever launched the rocket may well hate Australians.

A. All your seeing is the reflected light

How exactly do you think vision works? I'll give you a hint, it doesn't involve shooting magic vision rays out of your eyes, it simply involves your eyes detecting the light reflected off things. OK, that wasn't so much a hint as just the answer.

b.please show us another example of rocket booster venting fuel in orbit that could be seen from over a 1000km stretch of ground with the naked eye.

How many would you like?

how many litres of fuel would be needed to make that swirl in the sky?

Not sure exactly, but I'd estimate it's approximately the amount left in the spent booster stage of a Falcon 9 rocket.
 
"Thirdly, why would anyone launch a rocket on a maiden test flight with a trajectory that would take it over the most heavily populated parts of Australia?

They were originally going to launch over the ocean, but if the rocket hit the water some fish might be injured. So they sent it over Australia instead.
 
But Doug Moffett from UFO Research NSW says he has a few problems with this theory.

"Firstly, the time of the launch was 18.45 GMT, which translates to 4.45am EST, the duration of the flight was 9 minutes 38 seconds - this is a full hour before the reported sightings," he said.

"Secondly, where was the glow from the boosters or from the friction created by the craft moving through the atmosphere, where was the tail of the rocket?

"Thirdly, why would anyone launch a rocket on a maiden test flight with a trajectory that would take it over the most heavily populated parts of Australia?

"And how big must this rocket have been to be seen so clearly, at the same time, over such a vast distance?"


http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/06/05/2919095.htm

I meant i didn't say it, Doug Moffet said it in the abc article, i am only intrested in his last question.
 
So when you say that your theory is better, what you actually mean is you don't have the slightest clue what you're talking about but have decided that the people who actually do must all be wrong. Got it..

sorry if i offended you, i was merely joking.

Yet there it is in your post. And regardless of whether it was your original thought or merely a quote from elsewhere, my point stands that whoever launched the rocket may well hate Australians..


only muslims hate us.

How exactly do you think vision works? I'll give you a hint, it doesn't involve shooting magic vision rays out of your eyes, it simply involves your eyes detecting the light reflected off things. OK, that wasn't so much a hint as just the answer..


correct.



in 50 years of rocket launches you would think there would be more videos of this happening instead of just in the last 7 months in norway,russia,china and australia.

Not sure exactly, but I'd estimate it's approximately the amount left in the spent booster stage of a Falcon 9 rocket.

must of been 1000s of litres to be seen from a 1000kms away.
 
in 50 years of rocket launches you would think there would be more videos of this happening instead of just in the last 7 months in norway,russia,china and australia.


I think you'll find that the number of videos we're seeing relates more directly to the number of video cameras out there than it does to the number of rocket launches.
 
A. All your seeing is the reflected light, if you signal a plane with a mirror using the sun from the ground the pilot only sees the reflected sunlight, he can't see the mirror.

Do you actually believe they saw the rocket itself or the reflection of the rocket and the venting gases?


b.please show us another example of rocket booster venting fuel in orbit that could be seen from over a 1000km stretch of ground with the naked eye.

I can list many examples if you desire. The Norwegian sprial is a good one but I will try to give you a less obvious one:

August 31, 2004. http://www.space.com/spacewatch/mystery_cloud_040901.html

If you examine the NUFORC (National UFO reporting center) data base for that date, you will discover many reports up and down the eastern seaboard (as far south as florida and as far north as Canada - well over 1000km):

http://www.nuforc.org/webreports/ndxe200408.html

The basic descriptions in these reports are similar to what was reported in this event (A cloud of gas surrounding a bright light).


how many litres of fuel would be needed to make that swirl in the sky?

Not as much as you might think. See the above example.
 
must of been 1000s of litres to be seen from a 1000kms away.

How did you arrive at that number? I saw the space shuttle vent some waste water overboard a day before landing. It was a pretty bright cloud. I doubt that was thousands of liters. My guess would be a couple of hundred at most but I don't have an exact value. It does not take much fuel/water in space to create an interesting display.
 
I SAID:
"You can't see satellites up that high, you see the sun reflecting off the satellites that high"

Do yuo think you could still see the same satellite in the earths shadow lit up by a 100 watt bulb?
 
AND I ASKED:
"Er, what? Isn't that how we see everything?"

Do you yuo have an answer to this question?
 
I SAID:
"You can't see satellites up that high, you see the sun reflecting off the satellites that high"

Do yuo think you could still see the same satellite in the earths shadow lit up by a 100 watt bulb?
That's the point -- Falcon booster was NOT in Earth's shadow. Nobody would have seen it if it were. The sun was below horizon for ground observers, but the rocket was in sunlight. Which is why it was easily seen.

And regarding your earlier question -- astronauts most certainly CAN see Eiffel Tower and Sears Tower, if their orbit passes near Paris or Chicago. But that's rather irrelevant because normally Eiffel Tower and Sears Tower are no more and no less brightly lit than surrounding land. Something really bright and on a dark background, like a lit-up carnival boat on sea at night, can be seen from space even if it is much smaller than Sears Tower. Astronauts would not see it as a boat, just a point of light, but they would see it.
 
AND I ASKED:
"Er, what? Isn't that how we see everything?"

no, a bulb generates its own light it doesn't reflect light.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom