How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Many people assume a deflationary model is automatically bad. However, if you look at Japan, which for a long time was the 2nd biggest economy in the world, and has been responsible for much innovative technology, this concept is disproved.

Deflation only really encourages saving if there is large deflation over short periods of time. Someone isn't going to put off buying a shirt because in 2 months they might save $.50.

Just like massive inflation is bad, so is massive deflation. Just like minor inflation is fine, so is minor deflation.

My understanding of Japan's situation is that they are having problems because of their deflation. It has not proved that deflation is ok. And you should note I said nothing about people buying shirts. I said capital investments, like building factories.
 
However, I fear that when an article about this appears in Wired, it's not going to be too long before it gets busted up.

Actually, that seems to had been the consensus in the comments section of the article - however some postings that suggest fighting back by sending "packages" to innocent parties make me kind of uneasy...:(
 
Of course they do. Either you accept the mandated currency of your nation or the government closes your business.

WTF???? Maybe in some goosestepping nazi nightmare. No - that's ridiculous and merits the 'fascist lunacy' misunderstanding award. If I want to set up a shop that only accepts krugerrands of looneys or firewood in exchange I can do so. I can even issue private currency (with come restrictions) and demand it's use.

Printed right on the US currency is states "This note is legal tender for all debts public and private". That does not mean that all contracts involve an exchange of local currency. It means that any financial debt is payable currency. We can agree to exchange any particular items or services - it does not have to be dollars. Now if you fail to supply your half of the exchange then a court may award me some amount of dollars, but that's after a contract breach.

Of course a barter exchange (as someone has already noted) does not relieve the tax burden.
 
Last edited:
My understanding of Japan's situation is that they are having problems because of their deflation. It has not proved that deflation is ok. And you should note I said nothing about people buying shirts. I said capital investments, like building factories.

Exactly. Why start a company and make jobs in order to profit, when you can profit simply by stuffing the money under your virtual mattress and waiting?
 
So there I was, thinking "why would anyone really wanna use Bitcoins?" Then I came across this:

Underground Website Lets You Buy Any Drug Imaginable
Sellers feel comfortable openly selling hard-core drugs because the real identities of those involved in Silk Road transactions are utterly obscured. If the authorities wanted to ID Silk Road’s users with computer forensics, they’d have nowhere to look. TOR masks a user’s tracks on the site. As for transactions, Silk Road doesn’t accept credit cards, PayPal or any other form of payment that can be traced or blocked. The only money good here is Bitcoins.
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/06/silkroad/
 
Interesting. I was just about to post this article myself. Maybe these bitcoins do have a use after all.



However, I fear that when an article about this appears in Wired, it's not going to be too long before it gets busted up.

There's something too awesome about this - The new, high-tech libertarian currency... Backed by the entire wealth and credit of the drug industry!
 
Many people assume a deflationary model is automatically bad. However, if you look at Japan, which for a long time was the 2nd biggest economy in the world, and has been responsible for much innovative technology, this concept is disproved.

Certainly Japan flirted with deflation during their “lost decade” but it isn’t called Japans lost decade because their economy was thriving...
 

PONZI PONZI PONZI PONZI PONZI PONZI....

I think these people who are getting excited about bitcoins are completely insane.

This "currency" is backed by absolutely nothing, and is totally dependent on the complex infrastructure of the modern industrialised world. It's exactly like gold, except for when everything goes screwy (and its looking well dodgy right now) you are left with....a file on your PC worth precisely nothing at all. "Virtual gold"....no thanks. It's like "owning gold" where you pay somebody else to store the actual physical gold whilst you hold on to a piece of paper. Great while The System is still up and running but absolutely useless if you think it is going down. And it *IS* going down.

Fools and their money are easily parted. If you want to buy drugs from some online website then sure...use bitcoins. If you want to preserve the value of your wealth against hyperinflating paper currencies then buy gold. Seriously...these people are bonkers.
 
Last edited:
WTF???? Maybe in some goosestepping nazi nightmare. No - that's ridiculous and merits the 'fascist lunacy' misunderstanding award. If I want to set up a shop that only accepts krugerrands of looneys or firewood in exchange I can do so. I can even issue private currency (with come restrictions) and demand it's use.

Printed right on the US currency is states "This note is legal tender for all debts public and private". That does not mean that all contracts involve an exchange of local currency. It means that any financial debt is payable currency. We can agree to exchange any particular items or services - it does not have to be dollars. Now if you fail to supply your half of the exchange then a court may award me some amount of dollars, but that's after a contract breach.

Of course a barter exchange (as someone has already noted) does not relieve the tax burden.


Oops sorry, I was confused with businesses trying to create competing currencies.
 
There are two types of deflation.

One type is where the value of money increases because the productive capacity of the economy has increased.

More goods in circulation while the supply of money remains constant means the value of the money goes up (ie, prices come down). This is what we see happening in technology markets where there is very little State intervention.

This is entirely normal, healthy, and beneficial to consumers.

The other type is due to defaults in a fractional reserve ponzi scheme.

Which, depending on who you happen to be, is generally considered to be a bad thing by Keynesian economists. I on the other hand argue it is simply bankers getting wiped out when their criminal debt pyramids collapse. So I personally see both types of deflation as a good thing.
 
Last edited:
Which type of deflation happens when someone with a great deal of purchasing power corners the market on the currency, thus forcing deflation and making their exorbitant wealth even more exorbitant? 'Cause that's what people tend to worry about with bitcoins, here.
 
What Beelzebuddy said, plus I suggest even your first option is not necessarily beneficial because it encourages hoarding over investing. (I'm using "hoarding" here to mean 'keeping without using')

Does anyone know what the initial conditions of the bitcoin exchange were?

Did everyone start at zero when "mining" and transaction validation began?

What if the first accounts were given an initial supply--and if so, how large was that supply?
 
Which type of deflation happens when someone with a great deal of purchasing power corners the market on the currency, thus forcing deflation and making their exorbitant wealth even more exorbitant? 'Cause that's what people tend to worry about with bitcoins, here.

Think really hard about what you just said.

If a person buys up bitcoins and drives up the market, it is impossible that they have profited from the bidding up of the coins.

If they were to sell all of the coins, they would make no profit.

Keeping everything else constant, prices would fall by exactly the amount they drove up if they were to sell the currency. Only if prices go up after the person had finished buying (unlikely) would they make a profit if they were to sell all of those coins.

Your argument makes no sense, since logically speaking, it could be done to any stock in the stock market.
 
Last edited:
michaelsuede said:
If a person buys up bitcoins and drives up the market, it is impossible that they have profited from the bidding up of the coins.

If they were to sell all of the coins, they would make no profit.

And you like to think of yourself as an economist? This is operating in libertariland, right, where the markets are infinitely flexible and everyone acts with perfectly-informed rational self-interest?
 
And you like to think of yourself as an economist? This is operating in libertariland, right, where the markets are infinitely flexible and everyone acts with perfectly-informed rational self-interest?

If I can see why driving up a stock by buying it doesn't actually get me any profits, and the rest of the entire world can see why doing so does not actually generate any profits, I think you are the one who operating in krugmanland.

If what you suggest actually worked, we would see every penny stock in the stock market explode in value overnight as everyone rushed out to buy up cheap stocks to make "profits"

Clearly such actions would be ridiculous.
 
If I can see why driving up a stock by buying it doesn't actually get me any profits, and the rest of the entire world can see why doing so does not actually generate any profits, I think you are the one who operating in krugmanland.

If what you suggest actually worked, we would see every penny stock in the stock market explode in value overnight as everyone rushed out to buy up cheap stocks to make "profits"

Clearly such actions would be ridiculous.

Yeah, you can’t really make a profit yourself by buying up stocks, gold, bitcoins, or some other commodity and then selling them on your own. The way to do it is to quietly buy up the commodity at a low price, then convince a bunch of other people to buy up the commodity, raising its price. Heck, once the price goes up you can use the fact that the price has gone up to convince more people to buy driving up the price even higher. Then you quietly sell off the commodity that you bought at a lower price.

Pump and DumpWP
 
So instead of stock market ******** making a killing by screwing over other people, we have internet business ******** making a killing by screwing over other people.

Your libertarian utopia brings a tear to my eye, it is just so awesome and perfect. Not at all just a different group of idiots trying the same thing.
 
Isn't bitcoin anyway a bit of a pyramide scheme ? The initial people had to do very few work to generate them, the more people come in the more CPU is needed for 1 bitcoin, and the one from early adopter is worth. As time pass and new bitcoin are generated, the new comer have to give disproportionally more CPU power to get the same amount of "money".

That is how I see it at least.
 
What Beelzebuddy said, plus I suggest even your first option is not necessarily beneficial because it encourages hoarding over investing. (I'm using "hoarding" here to mean 'keeping without using')

Agreed. It doesn’t matter if deflation is created by a general increase in productivity. If the purchasing power of my money drops when invested and rises when I keep it in my pocket I’m not going to invest it and will hold off on any purchase as long as possible.

When everyone does this (as they should) all that extra productivity means is that there are more goods sitting around un-purchased so their value drops even more and no reason to invest in new productivity gains because the there is already more then you can sell.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom