How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
You mentioned enforcing its acceptance as legal tender. If I own a business and decide I only want to accept bitcoins and refuse to accept dollars, are you saying the government has the ability to force me to accept dollars?

You can demand payment in zorkmids if you like; but soon as you accept debt the whole game changes; debt must be payable in USD by law.
 
http://macrobusiness.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/bubblesandmanias.gif

The investment craze has subsided, fortunately. As I stated originally, what's important is that Bitcoins maintain SOME consistent value, even if it's one penny. Then they can serve their purpose.

Who drew that dotted line in the last graph and what's it supposed to mean? It's not a moving average. What is it exactly?

Also, each stage is labelled (funny joke--"smart investors" in a theoretical currency) except the last one. Who are those people supposedly representing?

The facts are that Bitcoins are worth $0.00, EGarrett. Not one penny.
 
I think that graph was originally drawn to represent fraudulent stock market bubbles (like in "pump-and-dump" scams), not Bitcoin per se.
 
I had been occasionally watching this thread and was reminded of it when I chanced upon this article:

http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2011-10/18/bottom-drops-out-of-bitcoin

Clearly, the bubble has burst. Are any bitcoin supporters still around? What's their take regarding what's been going on?

ETA:Another article: Bitcoin value crashes below cost of production as broader use stutters

From the first article:

"At the moment there is no need to use bitcoin, as anything that can be bought for BTC can be bought for 'real money' elsewhere,"

That will ALWAYS be the case, since Bitcoin is not legitimate money in any way shape or form. At best it's an intercurrency transfer meduim, and more likely is out and out counterfeiting.

Anyone hoarding Bitcoin against an economic collapse is delusional. At least paper fiat dollars (yen, whatever) have minimal utility value as toilet paper if nothing else.

There is NO utility value whatsoever in Bitcoin. It's 1s and 0s on a computer somewhere.
 
What is "legitimate" money?

The authorized legal tender of a particular nation, as legislated by it's governing body and defended by it's laws.

In the US, the US dollar is the only legitimate money. Merchants can chose to take other currencies as a courtesy (converted to their equivalents in dollars), but they have no legal force within US borders.
 
The authorized legal tender of a particular nation, as legislated by it's governing body and defended by it's laws.
So money is legitimate only if the government forces you to use it?

Under your definition, cheques, credit cards, promissory notes etc are all illegitimate.
 
Under your definition, cheques, credit cards, promissory notes etc are all illegitimate.

None of those are actualy money. They are basicaly methods to move money around.
 
None of those are actualy money. They are basicaly methods to move money around.
I know that.

Mulder is basically claiming that only "legal tender" is legitimate money. Since other ways of settling a debt are not compulsory on the creditor, they are not legal tender so under Mulder's definition, they are illegitimate.
 
So money is legitimate only if the government forces you to use it?

Under your definition, cheques, credit cards, promissory notes etc are all illegitimate.


Are you being deliberately obtuse or what?

Checks, credit cards, and promissory notes are not currencies; they are various ways of implementing a line of credit. When you write a check for $100 USD, you're paying one hundred monetary units in the currency of US dollars.

Try making a purchase by writing out a check in some non-legally negotiable currency like bitcoins, bottlecaps or "simoleons" and see what happens.

Government does not really force you to use its currency. If two private citizens agree on a trade or exchange that doesn't involve money, they can legally trade goods and services directly. As far as I know, there's no law against this kind of barter.

What government (and the Federal Reserve System) do is provide the security and stability that make the US dollar a preferred currency all around the world. The Federal Reserve maintains the stability of the currency by adjusting its lending rates (thereby setting the interest rates for the rest of the country); the US government provides a system of laws to protect transactions and insure the banking system against fraud and failure.

There is no law whatsoever to protect consumers who choose to deal in bitcoins. You get screwed, you're S.O.L. Your bank collapses? You're S.O.L. Why do you think so many scammers have been attracted to this whole Bitcoin thing? The FBI and secret service don't bother to investigate theft of funny money. Bitcoins are immaterial, and they're not legal tender. It doesn't even constitute petty theft. Might as well try to have somebody arrested on suspicion of stealing a chewing gum wrapper off the floorboard of your car.

What happened to the people who had their computers hacked and bitcoin "wallets" stolen, or all the people who got scammed when MyBitcoin just suddenly up and vanished along with all their customers' money? People got screwed, with no legal recourse. If they'd had their money fraudulently stolen from a bank transfer, it would have been recovered. If they had their money in an FDIC-insured account and their bank collapsed, it would have been recovered, at least up to $250,000.00 worth.


Looks like they're worth about $3 now. That would be an actual fact, verified by looking at trading values.


If you actually look at the market, you'll see that the different exchanges are actually trading at different rates. Its "market" is so volatile, that tomorrow it might be worth $2, or .02¢, or nothing at all.
 
Last edited:
I know that.

Mulder is basically claiming that only "legal tender" is legitimate money. Since other ways of settling a debt are not compulsory on the creditor, they are not legal tender so under Mulder's definition, they are illegitimate.

Two different scenarios, and I think you know it. The OP way back at the beginning was touting Bitcoin as "real money". I'm simply pointing out that it has no legitimate nation/state as an issuing authority, no backing in real terms of any kind (not even the rather spurious backing of "full faith and credit"), and no one is required to accept Bitcoin in settlement of bills or trade.
 
Why is it that so many of these libertarian fairy tales end up being total scams in the long run?
 
Are you being deliberately obtuse or what?

Checks, credit cards, and promissory notes are not currencies; they are various ways of implementing a line of credit. When you write a check for $100 USD, you're paying one hundred monetary units in the currency of US dollars.
I am only being partially obtuse.

In response to my question, Mulder defined "legitimate money" as "The authorized legal tender of a particular nation, as legislated by it's governing body and defended by it's laws." Only Federal Reserve Notes (and coins to a certain value) are legal tender. Everything else is optional for a creditor. "Currency" didn't make it into Mulder's definition.

Clearly, checks, credit/debit cards, promissory notes etc are as legitimate as federal reserve notes in business but they are not "legal tender".

Had Mulder used the expression "legal tender" in his recent postings, they would not have had the same effect so he invented the term "legitimate money" instead.

The truth is that there is no such thing as "legitimate money" - only media of exchange. When deciding whether to accept a particular medium to settle a debt, the creditor would have to consider its liquidity, legality, stability, portability etc. If he is offered a federal reserve note then he no longer has a choice.
 
The truth is that there is no such thing as "legitimate money" - only media of exchange. When deciding whether to accept a particular medium to settle a debt, the creditor would have to consider its liquidity, legality, stability, portability etc. If he is offered a federal reserve note then he no longer has a choice.


This is not true. People can still barter or trade.

As I pointed out in my earlier post:

What government (and the Federal Reserve System) do is provide the security and stability that make the US dollar a preferred currency all around the world. The Federal Reserve maintains the stability of the currency by adjusting its lending rates (thereby setting the interest rates for the rest of the country); the US government provides a system of laws to protect transactions and insure the banking system against fraud and failure.


No other currency in the United States can offer that. One would be a fool to go through the extra trouble and risk of using something like "bitcoins" when there's a perfectly serviceable, stable, convertible, and damn near universal currency readily available everywhere. The only logical reason for using bitcoins would be to pay for something illegal, that you don't want the authorities to trace back to yourself.
 
If you actually look at the market, you'll see that the different exchanges are actually trading at different rates. Its "market" is so volatile, that tomorrow it might be worth $2, or .02¢, or nothing at all.

That's the exact web page I looked at. You'll note that all the markets that trade in USD are about $3. I didn't bother calculating the exchange rates and non USD market values, but it appears at first glance to be at about the same.

It's now been a day and still trading at 3$...
 
What people use bitcoins anyway? I thought some of you people said that everyone and their dog would be using them by now. The only people I've heard that use it have been child pornographers and drug dealers on-line.
 
Why is it that so many of these libertarian fairy tales end up being total scams in the long run?

Because Libertarianism is the natural philosophical home of people who thrive by shamelessly manipulating other people to their own benefit.
 
What people use bitcoins anyway? I thought some of you people said that everyone and their dog would be using them by now. The only people I've heard that use it have been child pornographers and drug dealers on-line.
(Assuming that the value of bitcoin was stable) one possibly legitimate use of bitcoins is as a way of avoiding the monstrous charges associated with transferring money internationally.

Several years ago, I deposited a small amount of money into an on-line gambling site for an experiment. Surprisingly, I found myself in front after a week or so and decided to take out my winnings. That was when I discovered that for some reason, the Australian government has blocked almost every legitimate method of getting the money back into my bank account bar one - the "telegraphic transfer". The cost of that was $30 plus other charges and to add insult to injury, my bank charged me an additional $8 for allowing the deposit. Maybe not a huge amount in the grand scheme of things but I was only trying to access $100.

If I ever take an interest in on-line gambling, I will make sure that the site I choose deals in bitcoins.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom