How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Those numbers merely confirm that most bitcoiners regard bitcoin as a "buy and hold" commodity only. Did you suspect something else?

I don't know that this necessarily confirms that. It would not surprise me in the least to find that a significant percentage of these 4.5 million unused coins are actually lost/destroyed. A whole lot of people played with mining bitcoins early on, as you could solo mine successfully with almost any computer. And for the first 2 years, the value of bitcoins in USD remained very low (under $.04). Hard drives crash, computers get wiped, private keys get forgotten. I suspect that there are hundreds/thousands? of people that threw away, wiped off or otherwise disposed of hundreds/thousands? of bitcoin wallets because at the time it seems like a worthless endeavor that was just sucking up hard drive space, or the computer crashed and it just didn't seem worth the effort to try to save them.
 
Just removed Bitcoin Mining Trojans from 4 workstations at a customer site today.
 
It would not surprise me in the least to find that a significant percentage of these 4.5 million unused coins are actually lost/destroyed.
"Significant percentage" is a very vague term. Certainly there are bitcoins that are lost forever and some notable cases have made the news. How many are lost, nobody knows and it is meaningless to speculate.

If people were careless in the beginning, it seems unlikely that they would be anywhere near as careless in the last two years.
 
Those numbers merely confirm that most bitcoiners regard bitcoin as a "buy and hold" commodity only. Did you suspect something else?

It shows that very few people who own bitcoins actually uses bitcoin as a currency.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't bitcoin get its value as a commodity because people think it might be a currency now or in the future ?

If so, this is quite a blow.
 
"Significant percentage" is a very vague term. Certainly there are bitcoins that are lost forever and some notable cases have made the news. How many are lost, nobody knows and it is meaningless to speculate.
If people were careless in the beginning, it seems unlikely that they would be anywhere near as careless in the last two years.
My point is that this:
Those numbers merely confirm that most bitcoiners regard bitcoin as a "buy and hold" commodity only.

is an equally meaningless speculation. Those numbers do not confirm any such thing. The only thing those numbers confirm is that there are somewhere around 4 million “zombie” coins out there. And nobody knows how many are actively owned by someone and how many are lost.

As is the speculation that people would be less careless with bitcoin wallets in the last 2 years.

People blow up their computers, wipe their hard drives, forget to back things up, delete important files, forget their passwords, or otherwise do “careless” things with data all the time. Paper wallets get lost or filed away and forgotten or burned up in fires. On line wallets get forgotten. Data gets corrupted.

It just happens.
 
It shows that very few people who own bitcoins actually uses bitcoin as a currency.
Only if you ignore that 2/3 of all bitcoins are actively trading.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't bitcoin get its value as a commodity because people think it might be a currency now or in the future ?

If so, this is quite a blow.

Bitcoin gets its value because people think it has value. Some think it's a commodity, some a currency, some a kind of group sourced banking. I think most people think it's some kind of combination of all of them, and nobody's figured out exactly what it is or exactly how it's going to impact our lives.

My personal opinion is that bitcoin is gaining value because a great many people (myself included) believe it, or cryptocurrency in general, has the potential to be a Really Big Thing. Bitcoin, Litecoin, and other cryptocurrencies are the AOL, Compuserve, and little ISPs of the early internet days. How they all will play out, who will "win", or what it will all evolve into are anybody's guess.
 
My point is that this:
Those numbers merely confirm that most bitcoiners regard bitcoin as a "buy and hold" commodity only.
is an equally meaningless speculation.
It is a reasonable conclusion to be drawn from the quoted statistic that of the top 150,000 "bitcoiners", 130,769 did not spend any bitcoins. It is far more reasonable than supposing that the reason for this is most of these bitcoiners lost or destroyed their coins.

Those numbers do not confirm any such thing. The only thing those numbers confirm is that there are somewhere around 4 million “zombie” coins out there.
So 4M bitcoins are held by people who don't spend them. Using an emotive term like "zombie" coins is intended to imply without any justification whatsoever that these are lost rather than simply held by the bitcoiners involved.

And nobody knows how many are actively owned by someone and how many are lost.
Exactly, yet you still insist on using expressions like "significant percentage" or "zombie coins" to imply that bitcoin holders are less likely to safeguard their bitcoin investments than they would other investments.

As is the speculation that people would be less careless with bitcoin wallets in the last 2 years.
That was your own speculation:
A whole lot of people played with mining bitcoins early on, as you could solo mine successfully with almost any computer. And for the first 2 years, the value of bitcoins in USD remained very low (under $.04).
Yet now you would have us believe that bitcoin holders are equally careless with their bitcoins regardless of what the price might be.
 
It shows that very few people who own bitcoins actually uses bitcoin as a currency.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't bitcoin get its value as a commodity because people think it might be a currency now or in the future ?

If so, this is quite a blow.
I don't see how that would be a "blow".

Bitcoin ATM is a speculative long term investment. If its use as a medium of exchange becomes commonplace then that would enhance its speculative value but we don't know that it will become a "currency" or not.
 
Zombies is not my made up term, psion10. It is a fairly common term used by bitcoin advocates to describe these very coins. The idea being, are they alive or dead or something in between?

For instance, in the site TsukasaBuddha linked to, http://codesuppository.blogspot.com/2014/01/show-me-money-scatter-graph-of-all.html?view=sidebar if you click on the chart called "Number of Bitcoins Associated with Addresses Unused Since Prior to January 2013" you will see it is named "zombies.png"
 
Obviously no argument will ever change your mind about bitcoin because michaelsuede posted in its favour and you don't want to be seen to be associated in any way with a woomeister.

Although that tends to be true, I assure you that this is not the only source of information on bitcoin I have seen. None of them came close to assuring me of any functional need for it or of safety in it's use. And I have no problem being associated with woomeisters - in the sense of association by disproving, disapproval, providing evidence of the wooness and related. And if it is raining and they say it is raining, I will happily agree with them on that point.
 
Are you guys seriously telling me BTC isn't the most important creation in the history of mankind?!
You could safely list many tens of thousands of things of importance long before bitcoin would come up - in a rational way.:)
 
Although that tends to be true, I assure you that this is not the only source of information on bitcoin I have seen. None of them came close to assuring me of any functional need for it or of safety in it's use. And I have no problem being associated with woomeisters - in the sense of association by disproving, disapproval, providing evidence of the wooness and related. And if it is raining and they say it is raining, I will happily agree with them on that point.

Regardless of what chartmeisters and beer swilling illiterates might say, bitcoin is analogous to small explosives carefully placed....

lol...

It shows that very few people who own bitcoins actually uses bitcoin as a currency.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't bitcoin get its value as a commodity because people think it might be a currency now or in the future ?

If so, this is quite a blow.
I routinely use and have used for some time, bitcoin as a currency, to buy and sell things. Works fine. If something is a better deal with bitcoin, bitcoin gets the business, if not; it does not get the business. Pretty dam simple.

You could safely list many tens of thousands of things of importance long before bitcoin would come up - in a rational way.:)
The general idea is that bitcoin could be, could become, to money what the internet was to communications. That's a very big idea, because we all know - more or less - what the advent of the internet meant. It changed the world. It enabled third world countries to start to move up.

So I have no problem at all with the OP title.
 
Last edited:
Zombies is not my made up term, psion10. It is a fairly common term used by bitcoin advocates to describe these very coins. The idea being, are they alive or dead or something in between?

For instance, in the site TsukasaBuddha linked to, http://codesuppository.blogspot.com/2014/01/show-me-money-scatter-graph-of-all.html?view=sidebar if you click on the chart called "Number of Bitcoins Associated with Addresses Unused Since Prior to January 2013" you will see it is named "zombies.png"
No wonder you were fooled into believing that a "significant percentage" of bitcoins are either lost or destroyed.
 
I find that hard to believe, given that BTC cannot and will not be anything like the most important creation in the history of man. That title, in my opinion, lays with what Bitcoin was created to replace: money.

well, nobody said that an internet thread title should not be written so as to be provocative. And I don't think 'replace money' is accurate. There have been serious economic discussions about bitcoin as being to money what the internet was and is to human communications. This is a subject that simply has to be delt with or not as you choose. It exists, regardless of your choice.

some of the most ridiculous, insane thread titles ever created are on the jrats forum. here's an example.

It's proven: Republicans are idiots.

You don't need more examples, but if you do, look to your own style of posting...lol...

Having noted that, then I must comment that after two years, most of those posting on this thread do not actually understand the OP title and/or it's implications. Does not really matter to me, of course. What you/anyone can't do, though, and what I find rather amusing, is use the standard (here) insult and criticize version of 'skeptical' to produce the following:

It's proven: Those who bought bitcoin in 2011 are idiots.

So, deal with it. Get a life somewhere. Learn some new things. If not about bitcoin, try...well, try bowling, maybe.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom