How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, well, take my transaction for the sbux card. I bought, the btc went into escrow. I received the numbers and pin for the sbux.

Suppose that it's a day before I get around to checking the box that I received the goods - a day before the seller can get deliver of my bitcoins and thus before he can redeem them for whatever currency he has.

The seller might receive bitcoin of higher or lower value at that 24 hour mark, than at the time the transaction was initiated. The seller would presumably incorporate his risk estimate for this into the selling price.

How do you estimate risk like that ? Again, if I want to buy a carton of milk for 3$, and the dollar varies wildly from minute to minute, when I get to the cashier that 3$ might be worth 90 cents. That's great for the consumer, in this instance, but it's a terrible day for the grocer. In fact, a few days of that and he might have to close down permanently. The opposite isn't very good either, because although it's good for the grocer, people might just not buy there because it's too expensive right now. They'll go somewhere where the prices are more stable.

Where am I making a mistake, here ?
 
How do you estimate risk like that ? Again, if I want to buy a carton of milk for 3$, and the dollar varies wildly from minute to minute, when I get to the cashier that 3$ might be worth 90 cents. That's great for the consumer, in this instance, but it's a terrible day for the grocer. In fact, a few days of that and he might have to close down permanently. The opposite isn't very good either, because although it's good for the grocer, people might just not buy there because it's too expensive right now. They'll go somewhere where the prices are more stable.

Where am I making a mistake, here ?

Nowhere. That's why the prices are anchored to local fiat currency. A milk carton will be $3 regardless of whether it means 0.003 bitcoin or 30 bitcoins. The exchange rate check will be made at the time of the purchase and the only loss or gain to be had here is during the time escrow processes the purchase.
 
No, then there would be said to be 600,000 merchants.

But yeah, there are reasons and places where immediate clearing to cash and placing it in the merchant's account would be desirable. This is a perceived need and a business opportunity, thus coinbase moves to offer it to merchants. That is exactly the same as what I previously mentioned about a multi currency cash register system - likely after closing for the day, the bank deposit made is in a single currency.

I don't know why you refuse to acknowledge that Coinbase merchants don't accept Bitcoin; they accept the USD they get from Coinbase. Practically no merchants accept Bitcoin directly. That's not my opinion; that's just a fact, and no amount of dervish-style spin from you will change it.

Actually, I do know why you refuse to accept it; it conflicts with your quasi-religious dogma regarding Bitcoin.
 
I don't know why you refuse to acknowledge that Coinbase merchants don't accept Bitcoin; they accept the USD they get from Coinbase. Practically no merchants accept Bitcoin directly. That's not my opinion; that's just a fact, and no amount of dervish-style spin from you will change it.

Actually, I do know why you refuse to accept it; it conflicts with your quasi-religious dogma regarding Bitcoin.

Hey, thanks jhunter...for contributing to misinformation YET ONE MORE TIME by being wrong YET AGAIN.

JREF...the place where people who are not members or users of Coinbase and MtGox lecture and pontificate solemnly on how Coinbase and MtGox operate to people who have been long term members and users of Coinbase and MtGox.

Really, truly amazing.

I mean, so...you want to discuss the coinbase API for merchants and what it does?

Coinbase provides a simple and powerful REST API to integrate bitcoin payments into your business or application.
Through the API you can:

  • Buy and sell bitcoin (exchange it to your local currency)
  • Send and request bitcoin by email or bitcoin address
  • Accept bitcoin payments as a merchant
  • Securely store bitcoin and create new bitcoin accounts
  • Look up data on the bitcoin network (blocks, transactions, addresses, etc)
  • Handle micro-transactions and recurring payments
All requests use the application/json content type and go over https. The base URL is https://coinbase.com/api/v1/.


Nope? Didn't think you would. Coinbase merchants do what ever they choose to do. Not what you would like them to do or what you think they'd do. Oh, and what's with this USD thing you have? These merchants are all over the world. They might not like your USD.
 
Last edited:
I don't know why you refuse to acknowledge that Coinbase merchants don't accept Bitcoin;

:rolleyes: Evidence that none of the 16,000 merchants accept bitcoins? Because coinbase provides both "instant exchange" service (the one where merchants only ever receive local fiat currency on payout) and bitcoin payout.


Practically no merchants accept Bitcoin directly. That's not my opinion; that's just a fact, and no amount of dervish-style spin from you will change it.

Well then you are simply mistaken. The reality of the situation is that there are many merchants who accept bitcoins. But since you admit you won't change your mind, even in the face of evidence provided to you, there's nothing else left to do.
 
Nowhere. That's why the prices are anchored to local fiat currency. A milk carton will be $3 regardless of whether it means 0.003 bitcoin or 30 bitcoins.

In my example, it's the dollar that varies in value wildly. But let's go with BTC again: If your carton of milk is labeled at 0.005 BTC, and at the time of the labeling, 1 BTC = 850 USD, and at the time of the purchase, it has increased to 1200 USD, then what do you pay at the cashier ? That 0.005 BTC has jumped from $4.25 to $6 in a few minutes. I'm not buying a carton of milk for that much money.

I still don't get how that system would work.
 
In my example, it's the dollar that varies in value wildly. But let's go with BTC again: If your carton of milk is labeled at 0.005 BTC, and at the time of the labeling, 1 BTC = 850 USD, and at the time of the purchase, it has increased to 1200 USD, then what do you pay at the cashier ? That 0.005 BTC has jumped from $4.25 to $6 in a few minutes. I'm not buying a carton of milk for that much money.

I still don't get how that system would work.
It will not be labeled specific to bitcoin, except for certain items which are done that way kind of by tradition.

For example, bitcoin mining equipment is priced in bitcoins. But the carton of milk would be labeled in a currency and at the register the equivalent price in alternate currency computed (here, bitcoin) and payment rendered. Exactly the same as if I walk into a Mexican store and buy things labeled in pesos, handed the store clerk USD. The register receipt shows the translation as of that instant.

There is no btc output on any of those registers either. You are living on a fantasy island.
Oh, so now you are claiming what?

Some yet-agin-made-up-thing?

Frankly I don't even know what you might be referring to when you say "btc output on any of those registers".
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes: Evidence that none of the 16,000 merchants accept bitcoins?

If they accepted Bitcoins directly, why would they need Coinbase?

Well then you are simply mistaken. The reality of the situation is that there are many merchants who accept bitcoins. But since you admit you won't change your mind, even in the face of evidence provided to you, there's nothing else left to do.

I don't deny that there are merchants that accept Bitcoins. But your definition of "many" and mine are obviously quite different.
 
If they accepted Bitcoins directly, why would they need Coinbase?

For the ESCROW service and API.

I don't deny that there are merchants that accept Bitcoins.

Ok, good. Because you said "Practically no merchants accept Bitcoin directly", and that lead me to believe otherwise.

But your definition of "many" and mine are obviously quite different.

So, the problem is that there aren't enough merchants who accept bitcoins? Accepting bitcoins would be a good thing then?
 
For the ESCROW service and API.
...

That API....

I guess all that has to happen is it gets worked into some mainstream retailing software, then suddenly hundreds of thousands of businesses accept bitcoin....

Well, say HELLLLLLOOOOOO!!!!, chart woo readers!
 
Oh, so now you are claiming what?

Some yet-agin-made-up-thing?

Frankly I don't even know what you might be referring to when you say "btc output on any of those registers".

There is no bitcoin conversion on these cash registers you keep referring to. Thus you are living in some kind of fantasy land kind of like Walt Disney world. The made up nonsense is all coming from you.
 
For the ESCROW service and API.



Ok, good. Because you said "Practically no merchants accept Bitcoin directly", and that lead me to believe otherwise.



So, the problem is that there aren't enough merchants who accept bitcoins? Accepting bitcoins would be a good thing then?

The principle behind Bitcoin (creating a secure and anonymous vehicle to store and transfer value) is not inherently bad; it made the Swiss banking industry what it is today. The problems, though (volatility and the unfortunate tendency of people to abscond with large amounts of it) make BTC unsuitable for large-scale use, and I don't see that changing any time soon.
 
There is no bitcoin conversion on these cash registers you keep referring to. Thus you are living in some kind of fantasy land kind of like Walt Disney world. The made up nonsense is all coming from you.

So after explaining how the Coinbase API works, and what it's merits to retailers are, and then after explaining how merchants in countries and places were multiple currencies are an everyday thing....

....That is exactly the same as what I previously mentioned about a multi currency cash register system - likely after closing for the day, the bank deposit made is in a single currency.

.....you've still got some negativity to dump?

I've seen numerous small business taking bitcoin using the Ipad/cash drawer/wireless method, which of course allows bitcoin transaction at the point of purchase.

I have seen them also, operating with a credit card machine and simply an app on their android or iPhone.

Clearly, though, integration of bitcoin acceptance into something like large chain restaurants, with local networked point of sale systems and a server, require integrating the API into the software.
 
Last edited:
The principle behind Bitcoin (creating a secure and anonymous vehicle to store and transfer value) is not inherently bad; it made the Swiss banking industry what it is today. The problems, though (volatility and the unfortunate tendency of people to abscond with large amounts of it) make BTC unsuitable for large-scale use, and I don't see that changing any time soon.

It is true that increased interest in bitcoin causes more demand which drives the price up. There is a bit of a catch 22 there, since there will be a lot more waves of increased interest on the path to significant market penetration for bitcoin. Hence, there are likely several future big price increases for bitcoin.

Therefore, you can save the arguments (bolded above) and be safe using them several times in the future....

ROFL....

Then this does not meet my requirement. If you label your products in USD, who cares if you pay in BTC or not ? That's not what I'm discussing.
I don't get it. Use my example of buying in a Mexican store. Who cares what I do? Who cares what the product is labeled price? The UPC code is scanned, the machine does it's thing. Why is some particular interpretation - your 'requirement' - important at all?

It may interest you, there is a debit card product fixing to come out which is backed by bitcoin - not a bank account. With that, you will actually only be using the local currency at the register. But the back end is 100% bitcoin.

Many varieties, many yet to be thought out, too.
 
Last edited:
I don't get it.

It's very simple: if your currency CANNOT reasonably be expected to be used to directly pay for items, then it's not a currency, and loses much of its potential use. You have to convert the price value to BTC at the time of the purchase, but no one will ever label their prices in BTC.
 
It's very simple: if your currency CANNOT reasonably be expected to be used to directly pay for items, then it's not a currency, and loses much of its potential use. You have to convert the price value to BTC at the time of the purchase, but no one will ever label their prices in BTC.
As I already mentioned; yes, some categories are so labeled.

Secondly (and this I mentioned twice, but you seem to ignore) the situation is exactly the same as the Mexican store which accepts various national currencies.

Thirdly, on this very thread, you will find numerous mention of direct purchase with buyer and seller both using bitcoin. If you choose to ignore considerable evidence to the contrary of your opinion, look in mirror. Say hi to Woo for me.

:)
 
As I already mentioned; yes, some categories are so labeled.

Secondly (and this I mentioned twice, but you seem to ignore) the situation is exactly the same as the Mexican store which accepts various national currencies.

Thirdly, on this very thread, you will find numerous mention of direct purchase with buyer and seller both using bitcoin. If you choose to ignore considerable evidence to the contrary of your opinion, look in mirror. Say hi to Woo for me.

We seem to be talking past each other, so let's try it again:

In a store LABELED IN BTC, what happens when I get to the cashier and the price has changed radically since the label was put there ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom