How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think jhunter1163 is suggesting that the number of bitcoins offered for sale could triple. I suppose it's possible if those holders wanted to foul their nest.

By the same token, the FBI could dump all their seized bitcoins on the market at once and cause a crash. (https://blockchain.info/address/1F1tAaz5x1HUXrCNLbtMDqcw6o5GNn4xqX). They could only do it once though and I suspect the $30M is more attractive to them than that.

What $30m?
If they can't cash it out without causing a crash that would essentially make that 30m worthless then it's already worthless.
They don't have $30m.
They have 30,000 bitcoins.
 
Your $100m on deposit is effectively worthless. Unless the Cashwhale wants to gamble, buy drugs or buy CP.

Actually not, you can spend it using a check with no problem. Buy homes, real-estate, stocks, gold, silver, food, boats, cars. None of that can be bought with bitcon.
 
What $30m?
If they can't cash it out without causing a crash that would essentially make that 30m worthless then it's already worthless.
They don't have $30m.
They have 30,000 bitcoins.

Exactly what people with dotcom stocks found out the hard way. It just takes a few failures for the reality to set in. The first one was the collapse off the double top. The next one is the drop below $500 from which it never recovers.
 
Actually not, you can spend it using a check with no problem. Buy homes, real-estate, stocks, gold, silver, food, boats, cars. None of that can be bought with bitcon.
Ah, yes they can.

But we are not discussing using a promise to pay instrument from a fractional reserve con game.

We are discussing the process of actually cashing out of one system or the other.
 
That's the whole point. Only a complete noob would think you could place a sell order for 100,000 BTC and get anywhere near $100M.
Actually I do not think it would be hard to do that. The method would be to call some of the guys that do deals, private placements and offer something of a discount over the going market rate. Some cashcow like Buffet might well be interested.

It'd never show on the exchanges, but it would show up in blockchain. Or maybe it would be split and resplit and hard to pry out of the raw data.
 
Ah, yes they can.

But we are not discussing using a promise to pay instrument from a fractional reserve con game.

We are discussing the process of actually cashing out of one system or the other.

What else is cashing out other than converting to another holding? That is all you do with money or assets, give them away, convert them or sell them for cash or trade them for something else. So if you get rid of your bitcons, what do you get for them? Nothing of value.
 
Actually I do not think it would be hard to do that. The method would be to call some of the guys that do deals, private placements and offer something of a discount over the going market rate. Some cashcow like Buffet might well be interested.

It'd never show on the exchanges, but it would show up in blockchain. Or maybe it would be split and resplit and hard to pry out of the raw data.

You know this because.....................
 
Ah, yes they can.

But we are not discussing using a promise to pay instrument from a fractional reserve con game.

We are discussing the process of actually cashing out of one system or the other.

You seem very confused. If writing a check for an asset is not cashing out then what is it? Similarly, if I can not turn bitcoins into any asset sve other bitcoins then what good is it to me?

It seems that bitcoin may be a currency, but it probably is not money. (In the sense that it probably does not meet the market liquidity definition anymore, ie it is no longer a Medium of exchange.)
 
Last edited:
What $30m?
If they can't cash it out without causing a crash that would essentially make that 30m worthless then it's already worthless.
They don't have $30m.
They have 30,000 bitcoins.

Yeah, look at how much "fun" Beelzebuddy is having just trying to offload 2.

Even assuming they actually intend to stay partly in Bitcoin and try to cash out no more than 100 at once, it looks like no exchange has the capitalization necessary to turn over $80k (at the time of this writing) in any reasonable timeframe.

If I were Bitcoiners I'd be far more worried about one of the early miners selling off everything he has to cash out* -- he won't care if he causes a market crash, he didn't pay anything for them anyway so anything he gets is gravy. He just needs to bring a bunch of bitcoins to the table and clean out the bid stack from the top down. Right now, that would be... well, bitstamp has ~1200 worth of offers between 860 and 830. You should be able to get all those gone before anyone sees what's happening -- and then you'd probably still be able to get a bunch offloaded between 800 and 700. After that, depends on how many you started with, but you could certainly be a paper millionaire quite rapidly, and really who cares what happens to the market? You're out.

Why "paper" millionaire? Because you still have to get your money. :D



* It's not at all unreasonable to think that BTC will be targeted and actively prevented from being anything other than a means to purchase drugs and CP. It's one of the major risks in bitcoin "investment" right now; if Japan decides to sweep MtGox off the table, or that Polish bank they use suddenly goes under or is forbidden from making transfers anymore, what happens to everything stuck in it? Exactly.
 
Yeah, look at how much "fun" Beelzebuddy is having just trying to offload 2.

Even assuming they actually intend to stay partly in Bitcoin and try to cash out no more than 100 at once, it looks like no exchange has the capitalization necessary to turn over $80k (at the time of this writing) in any reasonable timeframe.

If I were Bitcoiners I'd be far more worried about one of the early miners selling off everything he has to cash out* -- he won't care if he causes a market crash, he didn't pay anything for them anyway so anything he gets is gravy. He just needs to bring a bunch of bitcoins to the table and clean out the bid stack from the top down. Right now, that would be... well, bitstamp has ~1200 worth of offers between 860 and 830. You should be able to get all those gone before anyone sees what's happening -- and then you'd probably still be able to get a bunch offloaded between 800 and 700. After that, depends on how many you started with, but you could certainly be a paper millionaire quite rapidly, and really who cares what happens to the market? You're out.

Why "paper" millionaire? Because you still have to get your money. :D



* It's not at all unreasonable to think that BTC will be targeted and actively prevented from being anything other than a means to purchase drugs and CP. It's one of the major risks in bitcoin "investment" right now; if Japan decides to sweep MtGox off the table, or that Polish bank they use suddenly goes under or is forbidden from making transfers anymore, what happens to everything stuck in it? Exactly.


Yeah, GOX has given up, they disconnected their real-time trading socket and now bots can no longer trade. So Gox has only miniscule volume since yesterday at this time. They are done as a trading platform it would appear. Now it seems BTCchina and bitstamp are the remaining players that allow for automated trading and so it goes.

The guy that does Clarkmoody is working on a fix for his site but I think that Gox is done aside from printing numbers above the rest of the market.
 
You seem very confused. If writing a check for an asset is not cashing out then what is it? Similarly, if I can not turn bitcoins into any asset sve other bitcoins then what good is it to me?

It seems that bitcoin may be a currency, but it probably is not money. (In the sense that it probably does not meet the market liquidity definition anymore, ie it is no longer a Medium of exchange.)
It's not I that is confused. I am just trying to show a parallel.

Bitcoin is a digital form of cash. A check is not cash, it is a promise to pay. The Euro, peso, or USD are cash.

The comparable to changing a bitcoin into cash, as disparagingly discussed by the jrats, is to walk out of a bank with cash.
 
It's not I that is confused. I am just trying to show a parallel.

Bitcoin is a digital form of cash. A check is not cash, it is a promise to pay. The Euro, peso, or USD are cash.

The comparable to changing a bitcoin into cash, as disparagingly discussed by the jrats, is to walk out of a bank with cash.

No it isn't. I am pretty sure that "turning them into cash" is the same as "having a record of a deposit in a local currency equivalent to the stated market value of the bitcoins I wanted to liquidate".

The point is that Bitcoins are illiquid when compared to cash, be that cash is held in reserve in a bank or in its currency form.

Have you ever heard the term "land rich" (or nowdays it is termed house rich)? If I have millions of dollars of land, but I can't improve it or sell it it means nothing! All the appraisals in the world mean nothing if I can't sell the land, or use it to build wealth.

I am hearing stories of those who are Bitcoin rich, and the point is that until either a) they can get a more liquid form of money with it, or b) they can buy most or all of the goods they regularly buy without severe discounts to make bitcoins more liquid then their bitcoin horde is nigh meaningless.

I would say the same for any currency then, be it fiat, virtual, corporate whatever.... If I can not do anything with it but hold it then it is effectively an appendix for my wealth.
 
Exactly what people with dotcom stocks found out the hard way. It just takes a few failures for the reality to set in. The first one was the collapse off the double top. The next one is the drop below $500 from which it never recovers.

Is this prediction more reliable than the last ones ?
 
Have you ever heard the term "land rich" (or nowdays it is termed house rich)? If I have millions of dollars of land, but I can't improve it or sell it it means nothing! All the appraisals in the world mean nothing if I can't sell the land, or use it to build wealth.

But at least you have a safe value: people will always need land.

 
But at least you have a safe value: people will always need land.

Heh. I could have predicted that quote would crop up.

But fun quotes aside, that is why I specified land that I can not improve or otherwise use to build wealth. After all it's not like I can make Capital improvements to my Bitcoins, or rent them out.
 
The Bitcorps has gotten kind of quiet... they're facing threats from within and without. Exchanges closing, the exchanges that aren't going under practically insolvent, DHS knocking on the door, and the looming shadow of JPMorgan's USD-denominated Bitcoin knockoff falling across the whole edifice.

Can you sell Bitcoins short?

ETA: Actually, is there any other way?
 
Yeah, GOX has given up, they disconnected their real-time trading socket and now bots can no longer trade. So Gox has only miniscule volume since yesterday at this time. They are done as a trading platform it would appear. Now it seems BTCchina and bitstamp are the remaining players that allow for automated trading and so it goes.

The guy that does Clarkmoody is working on a fix for his site but I think that Gox is done aside from printing numbers above the rest of the market.

I am seeing no problem with MtGox, am logged in now. Yet another made up thing from you, wrs?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom