How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
You still have not scoped the issue correctly. Here is the rub. In order to get access to this capitol I will have to at some point change from Bitcoins to USD unless the entire supply chain, labor pool and capital investment services operate in bitcoins. I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will laugh if I propose to pay them with these bitcoins. I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will only make a loan to my company in USD (or other local gov't backed currency).

So at some point I will have to pay these transaction costs to a financial intermediary. You have scoped the problem to where you pushed those transaction upstream, but they still exist. Sure - I will probably get a discount based on volume, but I am now paying possibly 2 exchange fees AND assuming a larger currency risk than if I dealt in the local currency only.

Not to mention - what business am I in again? Because it looks to me like the company you described sells widgets and sets up bitcoin exchanges in a different continent. That brings a lot of risk and a need to gather expertise that I really don't want to deal with - I am trying to sell widgets here.

Finally - what is the use case that I present to my suppliers that will convince them to use me over B & C? If I want them to accept payment in the form of bitcoins, I have to give them a reason. What is that reason that I present to stop them from saying "Forget you" and using B & C because they pay in a currency they can buy food with?

Again - I see a use for Bitcoin, but I do not think that it will be able to supplant or threaten any local gov't backed currency. I also kinda doubt that is what they want to do, and that the founders understand their market well enough. And perhaps their market would not react kindly if Bitcoin out and out stated that they see it as a niche currency mainly useful in retail transactions over the internet. But I have no way of knowing that.
 
Last edited:
This has no bearing on what I said regarding backing. You are trying to make some claim about cpu cycles translating to backing which has nothing to do with what backs real money and real currency.
It's not a claim, I'm simply noting that if the value of bitcoin drops below the cost of mining, mining stops and the bitcoin quantity remains constant. If the market value increases above mining costs, miners gear up and start paying for lots of electricity to run the machines to find the next batches of bitcoins. This is non trivial.

Yes it's not 'backing' per se. It is more similar to precious metals mining. If demand increases, price rises, mines open back up. Same with oil wells.

As for what backs 'real money and real currency', that's being made into a joke by the vast amounts that are being printed. But the utility of bitcoins for ecommerce is relatively unaffected by that, being a side effect of the crypto architecture.
 
You still have not scoped the issue correctly. Here is the rub. In order to get access to this capitol I will have to at some point change from Bitcoins to USD unless the entire supply chain, labor pool and capital investment services operate in bitcoins. I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will laugh if I propose to pay them with these bitcoins. I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will only make a loan to my company in USD (or other local gov't backed currency).......

No to your assertion of "entire supply chain..."

That is literally like saying "entire supply chain..." must operate on Paypal, or MC/Visa, or EURO, yada yada yada, before it could possibly work. Movements of value between currencies is routine, as is movement between currency and bitcoin.

"I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will laugh"


Given the high number of venture capitalists who have been courting Bitcoin developers, I wouldn't be so sure about that.

If you go into a bank and talk about a bitcoin based business and they laugh at you, you need to find another bank.
 
Last edited:
As for what backs 'real money and real currency', that's being made into a joke by the vast amounts that are being printed. But the utility of bitcoins for ecommerce is relatively unaffected by that, being a side effect of the crypto architecture.

It's not being made into a joke exactly. What backs the money is the economy to spend it in. That the money is being printed allows govt debt to be absorbed without the proper consequences. This is the complaint I am making elsewhere around here. This debt should actually be priced according to the real demand for it. If it were really sold into the secondary market, the inability of the US populace to actually pay it off would be far more obvious due to the skyrocketing interest rates we would be seeing.

At $750 the total notional value of all present bitcoin is only $9B. It's not even a week of Fed Treasury purchases. Hardly suitable for running any kind of real economy on. I would have to say that bitcoin is a long way from being able to function as currency or money.
 
It's not being made into a joke exactly. What backs the money is the economy to spend it in. That the money is being printed allows govt debt to be absorbed without the proper consequences. This is the complaint I am making elsewhere around here. This debt should actually be priced according to the real demand for it. If it were really sold into the secondary market, the inability of the US populace to actually pay it off would be far more obvious due to the skyrocketing interest rates we would be seeing.

At $750 the total notional value of all present bitcoin is only $9B. It's not even a week of Fed Treasury purchases. Hardly suitable for running any kind of real economy on. I would have to say that bitcoin is a long way from being able to function as currency or money.

Nonsense. You have perhaps mistaken conceptions. Somehow not using proper comparables. "Running any kind of real economy on"????

Headline from 2011. (LOL I'm too lazy to look up current, this first thing came up in google)

PayPal Now Processing $315 Million In Payments Per Day

Current bitcoin transaction volume of bitcoin, per day last 30 days.

http://coinometrics.com/bitcoin/btix

100-600M / day.
 
Last edited:
Nonsense. You have perhaps mistaken conceptions. Somehow not using proper comparables. "Running any kind of real economy on"????

Headline from 2011.
PayPal Now Processing $315 Million In Payments Per Day

Current bitcoin transaction volume, per day last 30 days.


100-600M / day.

Not sure what you are talking about here. Are you relating bitcoin to paypal? By the way, drop the last month and tell me what the actual volume was before bitcoin quadrupled in price?

Why would I buy stuff with bitcoin at it's current price when I know it's just a windfall to whomever I purchase bitcoin from? I can buy the same thing with $ and not give someone a windfall.
 
No to your assertion of "entire supply chain..."

That is literally like saying "entire supply chain..." must operate on Paypal, or MC/Visa, or EURO, yada yada yada, before it could possibly work. Movements of value between currencies is routine, as is movement between currency and bitcoin.

"I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will laugh"


Given the high number of venture capitalists who have been courting Bitcoin developers, I wouldn't be so sure about that.

If you go into a bank and talk about a bitcoin based business and they laugh at you, you need to find another bank.

You still are not getting what I am saying. I am saying
a) IF Bitcoins wants to become a significant alternative to a gov't backed currency
THEN
b) it will need to do these things.

You keep comparing Bitcoins to Paypal, which is an apt comparison. However, Paypal is not a currency. It has no aspirations to funding capital or infrastructure. So, I think you are right. Bitcoin's competitor is Paypal, it is not the USD. As such, even though bitcoin is technically a currency it is competing with traditional money transfer services, and as such is in a price competitive business. It is a product masquerading as a service, which is a great marketing tool.

Bottom line - If I am operating an on-line retail service I would probably add a bitcoin payment option. If I am manufacturing composite materials, or outsourcing a company's Payroll, or building condos, or making loans to buy houses, or selling time-shares, or paving roads, or any number of economic activities that dwarf the retail sector, I have no use whatsoever for Bitcoins or Paypal for that matter.

Also - please do not edit my posts to improve your arguments. I clearly said

"I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will laugh if I propose to pay them with these bitcoins."

You edited that to not include the bolded phrase. I think probably that is because you know full well that no bank will accept bitcoin as payment on a loan. And yet this was precisely my point. In that I will incur extra transaction costs for the privilege of using bitcoins. So if I need capital I am going to have to deal with USD because bitcoins do not have a capital market, and they probably never will.

If you can show me one VC that will loan bitcoins and accept equity valued as bitcoins, I will gladly retract my statement. I will also be very surprised.
 
Last edited:
You still are not getting what I am saying. I am saying
a) IF Bitcoins wants to become a significant alternative to a gov't backed currency
THEN
b) it will need to do these things.

You keep comparing Bitcoins to Paypal, which is an apt comparison. However, Paypal is not a currency. It has no aspirations to funding capital or infrastructure. So, I think you are right. Bitcoin's competitor is Paypal, it is not the USD. As such, even though bitcoin is technically a currency it is competing with traditional money transfer services, and as such is in a price competitive business. It is a product masquerading as a service, which is a great marketing tool.

Bottom line - If I am operating an on-line retail service I would probably add a bitcoin payment option. If I am manufacturing composite materials, or outsourcing a company's Payroll, or building condos, or making loans to buy houses, or selling time-shares, or paving roads, or any number of economic activities that dwarf the retail sector, I have no use whatsoever for Bitcoins or Paypal for that matter.

Also - please do not edit my posts to improve your arguments. I clearly said

"I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will laugh if I propose to pay them with these bitcoins."

You edited that to not include the bolded phrase. I think probably that is because you know full well that no bank will accept bitcoin as payment on a loan. And yet this was precisely my point. In that I will incur extra transaction costs for the privilege of using bitcoins. So if I need capital I am going to have to deal with USD because bitcoins do not have a capital market, and they probably never will.

If you can show me one VC that will loan bitcoins and accept equity valued as bitcoins, I will gladly retract my statement. I will also be very surprised.
Oh, okay. I see the specific circumstances in which you suggested a bank might laugh. But if the loan documents specified payment in a currency, then of course you would not be able to pay with a different method or different currency.

It's easy enough to read about the current state of venture capital vis a vis bitcoin. RE your suggestions about the lack of utility of btc in various forms of business, I have no comment.

That is to say, I have offered some simple scenarios where most would agree btc utilitization is plausible, but this is a wide area and innovative ideas are coming up very quickly.
 
Not sure what you are talking about here. Are you relating bitcoin to paypal? By the way, drop the last month and tell me what the actual volume was before bitcoin quadrupled in price?....

Yes, I think relating bitcoin to paypal is reasonable. It would sort of paypal on steroids.

The actual volume before bitcoin quadrupled?

Equally reasonable would be for me to cite a prior headline, heralding when Paypal transaction surpassed $2M per day (2001).

...
Why would I buy stuff with bitcoin at it's current price when I know it's just a windfall to whomever I purchase bitcoin from? I can buy the same thing with $ and not give someone a windfall.

This is a classic issue in economics called Gresham's law - bad money drives out good (eg, good money is hoarded).

That you even mention it indicates that the 'good' is the bitcoin....
 
I actually am very interested in trying to see if it is possible to raise equity with bitcoins. I wonder how someone trying to raise equity would fare if they added Bitcoins as an option.

I doubt it would do well precisely because no business I can think of can compete with the sky high returns that Bitcoins investors expect. Nor would any business survive the deflation of bitcoins if the bubble pops. They would have to switch to USD (or local currency) ASAP.

Its interesting to think about though.
 
Yes, I think relating bitcoin to paypal is reasonable. It would sort of paypal on steroids.

The actual volume before bitcoin quadrupled?

Equally reasonable would be for me to cite a prior headline, heralding when Paypal transaction surpassed $2M per day (2001).

Hardly, I am only asking about 45 days ago, much more relevant than 12 years ago.

This is a classic issue in economics called Gresham's law - bad money drives out good (eg, good money is hoarded).


That you even mention it indicates that the 'good' is the bitcoin....

No, read about Gresham's Law. Bitcoin isn't money and it's not legal tender and by the definition, if it is money, it's bad money.
 
Last edited:
I actually am very interested in trying to see if it is possible to raise equity with bitcoins. I wonder how someone trying to raise equity would fare if they added Bitcoins as an option.

I doubt it would do well precisely because no business I can think of can compete with the sky high returns that Bitcoins investors expect. Nor would any business survive the deflation of bitcoins if the bubble pops. They would have to switch to USD (or local currency) ASAP.

Its interesting to think about though.
Good questions.

I am seriously convinced that all charities and non profits should accept bitcoin as a donation method, for these very reasons. If I 'believe in the cause XYZ' I would then LIKE to give them something that might have a high return for them.

There are other reasons, some quite interesting. If you give to a charity, you usually get crap bull calls and junk mail for years. I hate that. With bitcoin, they don't even know who you are unless you choose to tell them.

My option - not their option.

Why wouldn't it be similar say with Kickstarter?

sky high returns that Bitcoins investors expect
Not really, I mean there are investors in various Bitcoin related companies and services, but these people uniformly all feel the real money is in applying the benefits of the btc algorithm to commercial payment processes, not in "currency speculation". They are programmers, hacker types and people from the mc/visa/paypal type industries.

They may be the inadvertent beneficiaries of owning some bitcoins and having this craziness happen, yeah.
 
Last edited:
Hardly, I am only asking about 45 days ago, much more relevant than 12 years ago.

No, read about Gresham's Law. Bitcoin isn't money and it's not legal tender and by the definition, if it is money, it's bad money.
RE is it money, yes it is defined as money by the US. The issue of legal tender has no bearing on gresham's law. And I'm not following how you could define it as 'bad money' as the term is used in gresham's formulation. I responded to a post about 'bitcoin being hoarded' - that's the 'good money' lol...

45 days ago? Well you can check that. Remember, the block chain is public. So every big and small transaction is exactly known. No problem with governments misrepresenting numbers for one or another political purpose.

http://bitcoincharts.com/
 
Nonsense. You have perhaps mistaken conceptions. Somehow not using proper comparables. "Running any kind of real economy on"????

Headline from 2011. (LOL I'm too lazy to look up current, this first thing came up in google)

PayPal Now Processing $315 Million In Payments Per Day

Current bitcoin transaction volume of bitcoin, per day last 30 days.

http://coinometrics.com/bitcoin/btix

100-600M / day.

From the same link:

Average number of transactions/day:

PayPal: 7,700,000
Bitcoin: 64,000

So it would seem that the transaction stats are skewed by some high-dollar users. Also, I wonder if transfers between wallets belonging to the same user are counted in those stats.
 
Last edited:
RE is it money, yes it is defined as money by the US. The issue of legal tender has no bearing on gresham's law. And I'm not following how you could define it as 'bad money' as the term is used in gresham's formulation. I responded to a post about 'bitcoin being hoarded' - that's the 'good money' lol...

From the link:

This law applies specifically when there are two forms of commodity money in circulation which are required by legal-tender laws to be accepted as having similar face values for economic transactions. The artificially overvalued money tends to drive an artificially undervalued money out of circulation[2] and is a consequence of price control.

Notice that the two forms are legal-tender, bitcoin isn't but it is important to notice the context of Gresham's law supports my assertion and not yours.

Now granted that bitcoin isn't legal tender and thus doesn't qualify for treatment under Gresham's law but consider this and tell me what bitcoin sounds the most like:

"Good" money is money that shows little difference between its nominal value (the face value of the coin) and its commodity value (the value of the metal of which it is made, often precious metals, nickel, or copper.)

In the 1960s the govt allowed sandwich coins and silver to circulate together at face value, what happened to the silver coins? Gresham's law happened...........

Bitcoin has no face value. I do not think it is money. It might be a cyber commodity.
 
Last edited:
From the same link:
Average number of transactions/day:
PayPal: 7,700,000
Bitcoin: 64,000
So it would seem that the transaction stats are skewed by some high-dollar users. Also, I wonder if transfers between wallets belonging to the same user are counted in those stats.
Or paypal is thriving on very low dollar transactions - I do bunches for $4-40. RE the same user moving bitcoins around could be. Not sure how anyone could figure that out exactly. There was a technical paper about money flows a while back by some economist who analyzed the block chain. I'll see if it is around.
 
From the link:

This law applies specifically when there are two forms of commodity money in circulation which are required by legal-tender laws to be accepted as having similar face values for economic transactions. The artificially overvalued money tends to drive an artificially undervalued money out of circulation[2] and is a consequence of price control.

Notice that the two forms are legal-tender, bitcoin isn't but it is important to notice the context of Gresham's law supports my assertion and not yours.

Now granted that bitcoin isn't legal tender and thus doesn't qualify for treatment under Gresham's law but consider this and tell me what bitcoin sounds the most like:

"Good" money is money that shows little difference between its nominal value (the face value of the coin) and its commodity value (the value of the metal of which it is made, often precious metals, nickel, or copper.)

In the 1960s the govt allowed sandwich coins and silver to circulate together at face value, what happened to the silver coins? Gresham's law happened...........

Bitcoin has no face value. I do not think it is money. It might be a cyber commodity.
I see your point about the traditional issue of Gresham's law being one of legal tender currency.

However, there is no need for 'money' to be 'legal tender'. That's a fairly new concept, historically in many epochs banks issued their own notes and so forth. Substitute currencies flow in when the debasement of a country's currency is so severe as to cause it, and there are numerous cases where even with laws on the books that using other than the King's coin would be immediately delt with by beheading, after some time the substitute (the good money) became an integral part of society and a necessary part, to the extent that the guys supposed to do the beheading wanted to be paid in it....
 
However, there is no need for 'money' to be 'legal tender'.
Yes, that is a govt imposed requirement.

That's a fairly new concept, historically in many epochs banks issued their own notes and so forth. Substitute currencies flow in when the debasement of a country's currency is so severe as to cause it, and there are numerous cases where even with laws on the books that using other than the King's coin would be immediately delt with by beheading, after some time the substitute (the good money) became an integral part of society and a necessary part, to the extent that the guys supposed to do the beheading wanted to be paid in it....

I am not sure how recent legal tender laws are but you observation about substitute currencies is a good one. The Hamiltonian dollar specified in the Coinage act of 1792, was based on a statistical analysis of the weight of Spanish pieces of eight which I believe were what the Constitution referred to as dollars. Those pieces of eight were preferred to Continentals.

I don't have anything against bitcoin. I think alternate currencies are a good thing, they can mean more freedom of economic choice. Right now bitcoin looks to me more like a bubble than a currency but that has every thing to do with how most people see it and not how I do. That is to say, if more people start using it, it's value will have to rise and it will be sustainable. TWT.
 
Yes, that is a govt imposed requirement.

I am not sure how recent legal tender laws are but you observation about substitute currencies is a good one. .

A bit more, re substitute currencies...not always but often a substitute currency is by definition 'not legal tender', since it's move in is based on the debasing of the national currency. It may have been legal tender somewhere, but not in the country in question. A substitute currency is a fundamental threat to the state.

So when we say 'legal tender is a government imposed requirement' well, that sort of works to the extent that anyone cares. Many times, in the American West, 1800s, a guy running a bar would see a dozen different types of money in the course of a single evening, and make change for each. Such was the lore of those times, and one would need to be cunning to stay ahead of a sharp operator. Legal tender was actually, not a consideration, but what was accepted in commerce was very important.

Here in the US, we are not required to conduct transactions in the US dollar, but we are required to accept them if the other party so desires. Yet banks can only work with the USD. Bitcoin may be the American public's first experience with a substitute currency, although in many countries, multiple currencies have been common. Unless one considered the vast recent movement of wealth into precious metals as a move to a substitute currency, which I do not but by some measures would qualify.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom