pantsorama
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2013
- Messages
- 439
You still have not scoped the issue correctly. Here is the rub. In order to get access to this capitol I will have to at some point change from Bitcoins to USD unless the entire supply chain, labor pool and capital investment services operate in bitcoins. I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will laugh if I propose to pay them with these bitcoins. I can guarantee you the bank (or VC) will only make a loan to my company in USD (or other local gov't backed currency).
So at some point I will have to pay these transaction costs to a financial intermediary. You have scoped the problem to where you pushed those transaction upstream, but they still exist. Sure - I will probably get a discount based on volume, but I am now paying possibly 2 exchange fees AND assuming a larger currency risk than if I dealt in the local currency only.
Not to mention - what business am I in again? Because it looks to me like the company you described sells widgets and sets up bitcoin exchanges in a different continent. That brings a lot of risk and a need to gather expertise that I really don't want to deal with - I am trying to sell widgets here.
Finally - what is the use case that I present to my suppliers that will convince them to use me over B & C? If I want them to accept payment in the form of bitcoins, I have to give them a reason. What is that reason that I present to stop them from saying "Forget you" and using B & C because they pay in a currency they can buy food with?
Again - I see a use for Bitcoin, but I do not think that it will be able to supplant or threaten any local gov't backed currency. I also kinda doubt that is what they want to do, and that the founders understand their market well enough. And perhaps their market would not react kindly if Bitcoin out and out stated that they see it as a niche currency mainly useful in retail transactions over the internet. But I have no way of knowing that.
So at some point I will have to pay these transaction costs to a financial intermediary. You have scoped the problem to where you pushed those transaction upstream, but they still exist. Sure - I will probably get a discount based on volume, but I am now paying possibly 2 exchange fees AND assuming a larger currency risk than if I dealt in the local currency only.
Not to mention - what business am I in again? Because it looks to me like the company you described sells widgets and sets up bitcoin exchanges in a different continent. That brings a lot of risk and a need to gather expertise that I really don't want to deal with - I am trying to sell widgets here.
Finally - what is the use case that I present to my suppliers that will convince them to use me over B & C? If I want them to accept payment in the form of bitcoins, I have to give them a reason. What is that reason that I present to stop them from saying "Forget you" and using B & C because they pay in a currency they can buy food with?
Again - I see a use for Bitcoin, but I do not think that it will be able to supplant or threaten any local gov't backed currency. I also kinda doubt that is what they want to do, and that the founders understand their market well enough. And perhaps their market would not react kindly if Bitcoin out and out stated that they see it as a niche currency mainly useful in retail transactions over the internet. But I have no way of knowing that.
Last edited: