How the tower did not fell

So Tabouere means what, exactly? I mean the word, not the poster. My familiarity with French stops at Fromage and cést la vie.
 
(He also dabbles in anti-zionism.... Unfortunately a very common strain amongst some Quebecois, even well-educated ones who should know better.)


I find this last paragraph a little insulting. Be careful to not make gross generalizations. Anti-zionism is not as bad as anywhere else in the world.

Quite frankly, I never come across it here.
 
So Tabouere means what, exactly? I mean the word, not the poster. My familiarity with French stops at Fromage and cést la vie.

See link....http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tabarnak
Look in the notes under "Mild Forms". I missed it, but Pardalis pointed me back to it and I located the note.

"Tabernacle!" was the grand-daddy of all French-Canadian curses. Pronounce it ta-ber-nak. Second most popular, and much more French-sounding, so I use it more often when trying to sound cosmpolitan.... "Chalice!" (pronounced ka-liss).

Quebec society was totally dominated by The Church for three hundred years, so the underground reaction (or reaction of the working classes) was to take sacred items and turn them into oaths.
 
Tabouere, you may want to re-read the rules by which you agreed to abide when joining, especially the rule against hot-linking images.
 
See link....http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tabarnak
Look in the notes under "Mild Forms". I missed it, but Pardalis pointed me back to it and I located the note.

"Tabernacle!" was the grand-daddy of all French-Canadian curses. Pronounce it ta-ber-nak. Second most popular, and much more French-sounding, so I use it more often when trying to sound cosmpolitan.... "Chalice!" (pronounced ka-liss).

Quebec society was totally dominated by The Church for three hundred years, so the underground reaction (or reaction of the working classes) was to take sacred items and turn them into oaths.

Thanks for that. I have learned something new. Not what I expected when I started reading this thread.

I wonder if M. Tabouere will also learn something in this thread.
 
Thanx

A ton of flour in a bag that keep the floor in a kind of one piece solid state, yes, it will kill me, but remove it from the bag

if i hear this analogy, obviously taken from the "addressing faulty assumptions of greening" website one more time i will puke. how can you say you are addressing the Greening paper, when you know don't know anything about physics? contact surface area and impulse are first year concepts. It is perfectly acceptable to use center of mass approximations for very large systems of particles, as large as say, um, i don't know a 17 story chunk of a skyscraper. And the Greening paper isn't faulty, it's lacking. It's a first order approximation of a very complex system. Why? well if you know a little about physics you know that dynamics can be very, very complicated when you try to account for variable mass and variable resistance.
 
3bodyproblem:

Welcome to the forum. It can get pretty nasty in here from time to time, but overall they are a good bunch trying to keep it honest where the truthers would have lies rule the day.

TAM:)
 
Time to get up off the floor, stop laughing, and start paying attention, dude. The Madrid Windsor building had a floor plan 1/4 the area of one WTC tower. The north tower photo you showed depicts fire stretching almost the entire length of the 208-foot (63.4m) wall. What else does that photo show? The bowing of the exterior columns. Try to reserve your arrogance for a subject on which you are informed.



Actually the Windsor Tower was only about 1/20th the floor area of one WTC tower.

When comparing the photos, one has to consider scale. The WTC towers were FOUR TIMES as high as the Windsor Tower, with a footprint 6.5 times as large.

A fire that would appear localised and minor in the WTC would totally engulf the Windsor Tower.

The period of time is also misleading.

Fire fuel sources will not burn for 24 hours. Obviously the entire Windsor Tower did not burn all at once, thus the actual extent of severe fire at any given moment in time would be minimal. The fire spread gradually from a localised site on the 21st floor.

In contrast, fires were ignited by jet fuel on multiple WTC floors SIMULTANEOUSLY. Not only this but these simultaneous fires were not localised on each floor where they began, but covered the entire expanse of each floor.

Thus the extent of severe fire at any given moment in time was enormous.

-Gumboot
 
Actually the Windsor Tower was only about 1/20th the floor area of one WTC tower.
Yep. I was referring to the floor plan (footprint).

"We were looking at two large bodies of fires that neither of us in our 33-year careers had ever seen anything that enormous. So it's pretty much, you know, I thought we would lose a company or two possibly. I didn't think we would come out of this unscathed at all. It was just too enormous." –FDNY Chief of Safety Albert Turi
 
879045fd54c8e5e6c.jpg


This isn't the inferno you are looking for, move along.
 
So people jumped out of the buildings despite the lack of heat, and the steel structureof the building collapsed. WTC was an inferno, denying that makes you look foolish.



This is a rather brassy thing to say for someone who admits they did not read the report.

There was plenty of evidence. You might want to read it some time.



It was not stronger. It looked brighter because your photo was taken at night and is a close up of the structure. Wheras the WTC photo was taken during the day and covers more of the side of a much larger structure



Look at your WTC photo, it is doing much the same thing. The building is bigger is all.



This is reading way too much into apparent color of a photograph. It is nonsense as far as evidence. Colors can appear different.

Here is an example: http://www.michaelbach.de/ot/lum_adelson_check_shadow/index.html

People jump out of the tower because the staircase door were locked and they were suffocating because there were too much smoke, of course there was no inferno, there's was no flame rising against the wall like in the Madrid Windsor. Are you telling me, the color of the flame mean nothing, tell that to the NIST because it's an evidence they use for there EVALUATION with simulation data and computer model but they never take the temperature at inside of the WTC.


You, poor believer, you accept that without question?

Only dummies accept an answer without question.

Do you read the NIST report? I've read a lot of it and they have no base for their claim, everthing is SPECULATION but the for the defender of the oficial version it's pure truth.

There were people alive on floor where a inferno is supposed to rage, there is no flame that goes out of the windows, the color of the flame is more red than orange, there is a lot of black smoke etc etc etc.
 
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/879045fd54c8e5e6c.jpg[/qimg]

This isn't the inferno you are looking for, move along.

There is a litle inferno on top right of the building, but not near the big hole.

But it's nothing in comparison with that

windsor3.JPG


windsor.jpg


Madrid_Windsor.jpg


And this fire reach a peak temperature of 800 degrees C
 
I nominate gumboot for the following post:
Actually the Windsor Tower was only about 1/20th the floor area of one WTC tower.

When comparing the photos, one has to consider scale. The WTC towers were FOUR TIMES as high as the Windsor Tower, with a footprint 6.5 times as large.

A fire that would appear localised and minor in the WTC would totally engulf the Windsor Tower.

The period of time is also misleading.

Fire fuel sources will not burn for 24 hours. Obviously the entire Windsor Tower did not burn all at once, thus the actual extent of severe fire at any given moment in time would be minimal. The fire spread gradually from a localised site on the 21st floor.

In contrast, fires were ignited by jet fuel on multiple WTC floors SIMULTANEOUSLY. Not only this but these simultaneous fires were not localised on each floor where they began, but covered the entire expanse of each floor.

Thus the extent of severe fire at any given moment in time was enormous.

-Gumboot

Absolutely and totally false, there was living people on the floors were the fire rage.
 
This fire is one of the fires Conspiracy theorist like to point to when talking about high raise office fires. This fire lasted 26 hours. But what they don't tell you is that the first collapse happened only 2 hours and 30 minutes after the fire began. But why didn't the building fall completely? It was on fire for 26 hours. The answer is very simple. The building were constructed very differently than the WTC. Reinforced concrete was used in the core and under the 17th floor. Below are detailed descriptions of how the Madrid tower was constructed and the reason for it not collapsing...

[qimg]http://www.debunking911.com/madrid.jpg[/qimg]

The building totaled 32 story's, with 29 floors above ground and three below. A concrete core and concrete frame supported the first 16 floors. Above that was a central support system of concrete columns, supporting concrete floors with steel perimeter columns. An additional feature was the presence of two 'technical floors' - concrete floors designed to give the building more strength. One was just above the ground level and the other at the 17th floor.

http://www.concretecentre.com/main.asp?page=1095

The fire protection on the existing steelworks below the 17th floor had been completed at the time of fire except for the 9th and 15th floors. When the fire spread below the 17th floor, those protected perimeter columns survived, except for the unprotected columns at the 9th and 15th floors which all buckled in the multiple floor fire (see Figure 2). However, they did not cause any structural collapse. Obviously, the applied loads supported by these buckled columns had been redistributed to the remaining reinforced concrete shear walls. Nevertheless, structural fire analysis should be carried out before such a conclusion can be drawn.

http://www.mace.manchester.ac.uk/pr...Study/HistoricFires/BuildingFires/default.htm

A survey of the fire damaged structure of the Windsor Tower, Madrid, has concluded that the concrete structure “performed extraordinarily well in a severe fire”. The study, ‘Fire in the Windsor building, Madrid: Survey of the fire resistance and residual bearing capacity of the structure after the fire’ was carried out by the Spanish Instituto Technico de Materiales y Construcciones (INTEMAC). It underlined the need for fireproofing structural steel concluding that the “need for fireproofing of steel members to guarantee their performance in the event of fire was reconfirmed”.

The Windsor Tower fire started on the 21st floor of the 32 storey building in February 2005. The fire quickly spread due to a lack of fire stops between the curtain wall façade and the concrete floor slabs. Designed and built in the 1970s, the tower was built using traditional design methods. Extensive refurbishment was underway at the time of the fire. Ironically, part of the refurbishment programme was to bring the building’s fire standards up-to-date with the installation of active fire prevention and resistance measures.

Structural failure happened with the collapse of the steel perimeter columns which resulted with the floor slabs collapsing as the edge support was taken away. The massive concrete transfer slab at the 20th floor prevented further progressive failure.

http://www.cjconnect.com/article.asp?articleid=1224&lastestnews=1

The building had a concrete central core with two rows of reinforced concrete columns in the north-south direction, aligned with the core side walls. The structure above ground was characterized by two transition floors at 3rd and 17th Floor levels, which housed plant and services.

The typical floor slab construction was reinforced concrete bi-directional ribbed slabs, spanning onto composite steel beams in the east-west direction. The slabs were supported along the perimeter by steel columns, supplemented by reinforced concrete columns on two sides below 17th Floor level.

The transition floors were formed with solid RC slabs and deep beams. The original facade mullions and transoms were fixed to the steel perimeter columns, and a new facade structure had been added to outside of old facade. The perimeter columns in turn were supported by transition structures at 17th and 3rd Floor levels.

The central concrete core appeared to perform well in the fire and on initial observations seems to have played a major role in ensuring the stability of the building throughout the incident. The role of cores in multiple floor fires is now an immediate area of study required for the industry, and Arup have commenced investigating this issue.

A thermo-mechanical assessment of this structural design, an understanding of why the structure performed as it did and why total collapse did not occur would provide valuable information for future structural fire analysis in design.

It would assist in the strong move now towards structural fire engineered buildings, and therefore help with the move away from reliance on Building Code based single element testing and associated fire proofing techniques which do not address real and structural behavior in real fires.

http://www.arup.com/fire/feature.cfm?pageid=6150

The towers and building 7 were essentially bolted together like an erector set. No concrete was used to create a ridged block or protect the columns. The steel webbing was pushed to the outer walls.

A challenge to conspiracy theorist:

1) Find a steel frame building at least 40 stories high

2) Which takes up a whole city block

3) And is a "Tube in a tube" design

4) Which came off its core columns at the bottom floors (Earthquake, fire, whatever - WTC 7)

5) Which was struck by another building or airliner and had structural damage as a result.

6) And weakened by fire for over 6 hours

7) which had trusses that were bolted on with two 5/8" bolts.

And after all seven tests are met the building didn't fall down.

Anything less than meeting these seven tests is dishonest because it's not comparing apples with apples. Showing a much lighter 4, 5 or even 15 story building which doesn't even take up a city block, and has an old style steel web design leaves out the massive weight the 47 story WTC 7 had bearing down on it's south face columns. Yes, this is "moving the bar" back to where it should have started.

It is an absurdity to expect these buildings to perform the same during a collapse. This is why it's the first time in history these buildings fell as they did. It's the first time in history buildings constructed like this collapsed.

So what have we learned from the conspiracy theorist? Something the NIST realized long ago. Concrete makes good insulation.

Another guy who don't understand a simple argument, I don't care if the Windsor Madrid fire last 2 hours or if the building stand or not, my point is quite simple, the fire in the Windsor Madrid reach a peak temperature of 800 degrees C and the NIST tell us the fire in the WTC reach a temperature of 1000 degrees C, but... The fire of WTC look like a spark in comparison with the Windsor Madrid inferno.

For those who is interested, i'm a from Quebec, and tabouere mean nothing at all, it's a kind of swearword.
 
Last edited:
People jump out of the tower because the staircase door were locked and they were suffocating because there were too much smoke, of course there was no inferno, there's was no flame rising against the wall like in the Madrid Windsor. Are you telling me, the color of the flame mean nothing, tell that to the NIST because it's an evidence they use for there EVALUATION with simulation data and computer model but they never take the temperature at inside of the WTC.


You, poor believer, you accept that without question?

Only dummies accept an answer without question.

Do you read the NIST report? I've read a lot of it and they have no base for their claim, everthing is SPECULATION but the for the defender of the oficial version it's pure truth.

There were people alive on floor where a inferno is supposed to rage, there is no flame that goes out of the windows, the color of the flame is more red than orange, there is a lot of black smoke etc etc etc.
Number one - nobody here with the exception of you is a dummy and it is against the forum rules you agreed to when you signed up...do you have a problem with that?

Number two - The flames were 30 feet high...what kind of woogic™ says that isn't an inferno?

Number 3 - Are you going to admit who you are Mr. Frenchman :)
 
As to the sock issue....

I, too, thought PDOH at first. The adoration of Ross would lend to that, too. But I caught the name, and there's no way that PDOH would know a blasphemy-light expression like "Tabouere". Most Quebecois cursing is based on The Church (caps intentional) and objects associated with it. Tabouere is not an expression I'd ever seen in writing before - it's local and it was street talk when I lived there. I guess it's elevated to more common usage.

I agree with Pardalis. The structure is of someone translating from French to English, on the fly, as he's writing . If I know my Quebec, I'm sure there are a goodly number of conspiracy theorists out there, and I'm equally sure they have a number of blogs and forums they play in, using their own language. There is a fairly large minority willing to believe anything bad about government, any government.

(He also dabbles in anti-zionism.... Unfortunately a very common strain amongst some Quebecois, even well-educated ones who should know better.)

So funny how you try to isolate the disbeliever of the official version, pure manipulation and association without argument, is it a caracteristic of the official version defender?
 
I nominate gumboot for the following post:


Absolutely and totally false, there was living people on the floors were the fire rage.



What on earth do you mean?


I have decided to demonstrate the misleading way in which Conspiracy Theorists use the Windsor Tower, in a way that makes the dishonesty in their methods painfully obvious...

We were given two images in this thread - one of the Windsor Tower belching fire from every floor, and one of WTC1, with some, but not as much fire.

However, these images are not in scale.

For anyone who is not familiar IN PERSON with the WTC, they perhaps don't appreciate just how significant this scale variation is.

So I decided to demonstrate.

Below are the same images, adjusted for scale. The small back insert is the picture of the Windsor Tower.



-Gumboot
 
People jump out of the tower because the staircase door were locked

Locked? LOCKED?!

I sure as [rule8] hope you meant 'blocked'.

and they were suffocating because there were too much smoke,

Oh, and you were there?

Sorry bub, in the history of fires, people don't jump from smoke exposure. They tend to succumb to it first. They jump from the heat and approaching flames.


of course there was no inferno,

Look at Phantomwolf's picture and tell me why you should be taken seriously in the least?

there's was no flame rising against the wall like in the Madrid Windsor.

Except where there was.

Are you telling me, the color of the flame mean nothing,

I mean the way you are using it it does not.

tell that to the NIST because it's an evidence they use for there EVALUATION with simulation data and computer model

Wrong. You again show your ignorance of NIST.

but they never take the temperature at inside of the WTC.

And how the flip coupld they do that?

You, poor believer, you accept that without question?

Whereas you doubt and mock that which you have nto read and assuredly do not understand.

Only dummies accept an answer without question.

But when the questions are answered, why should you not accept the reasonable answer.

Do you read the NIST report? I've read a lot of it

In the beginning of this thread you said otherwise, are you lying now or lying then?

and they have no base for their claim, everthing is SPECULATION but the for the defender of the oficial version it's pure truth.

Explain the exact problem with NIST, with references to the appropriate chapters and pages. Otherwise you are whining about something you admit you did not read.

There were people alive on floor where a inferno is supposed to rage,

Because the building was very, very large. Get it? Not all of it was an inferno.

there is no flame that goes out of the windows,

Again, look at Phantomwolf's photo. There are hunderds of photos showing this.

the color of the flame is more red than orange,

This has been explained to you already.

there is a lot of black smoke etc etc etc.

A lot of black smoke? Wow. Just like what happens when you burn polymers and other similar materials. Smoke is not a full indicator of fire temperature.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom