How Dylan Avery could become a decent film-maker

The thing is, all that Dylan has managed to do so far is edit a bunch of clips, website screencaps and graphics together; and to add a soundtrack, a narration and some text captions. Real filmakers have don't make a collage out of already existing material. They have to compose their film, usually to tell a story, by working with camera crews and art directors and actors (or interviewees, if its a documentary) and lighting and sound and many others. They have to oversee the edit to make the finished product effective. Dylan has no experience or training in any of this - and so far has shown no natural aptitude for it (the epic "look a us getting on a subway train" ground zero footage on Google Video is painful).

Michael Moore is far better at making polemical documentaries than Dylan Avery, and has made a lot of money for Hollywood doing it, but I doubt that anyone is offering him a fictional film.

If Dylan sees Loose Change as a way into directing dramatic fiction (and most successful films are dramas - Moore is a big exception, here) then I think he will be sorely disappointed.

Oh, and his ability to finish projects on schedule is looking pretty suspect, too.
 
You make some really good points, maccy, as usual.

I think Dylan should stick to documentaries, and the 9/11 subject for the time being, as he has found a niche, despite the fact that he has basically plagiarised his way into it.

He could plagiarise himself, by showing video of his appearances and travels that he has already recorded.

I suspect that he would prefer to keep the "big bad gubmint" angle that has served Michael Moore and "Press for Truth" so well, and if he's going for the notoriety, if not the dollars, he should.

I believe that doing a Do-Over to End all his Do-Overs would give him the angle that would increase the interest in his next film, especially from non-truthers, in that making it more personal by detailing his dilemmas over the last couple of years, as I outlined in the OP would be a way of giving the film "heart", in my opinion, no matter how nefarious that sounds.

But whether he could meet his deadline for LCFC is the question no matter what he puts in it.
 
There's a vindictiveness and arrogance to Dylan that will prevent from adding "heart" to his project, I think. The most annoying thing about Loose Change is the whole punk kid, "are we supposed to believe this?" tone in Dylan's narration.

When confronted with things he and his associates have said in the past, Dylan is evasive rather than apologetic and prefers to attack the questioner. His attempt to deal with questions about donations to 911 charities from LC:FC by accusing the makers of United 93 and World Trade Center of donating nothing, shows both a lack or tact and empathy. It also suggests he isn't very bright - and therefore incapable of seeing the value of faking some empathy and human feeling.

I also doubt that his ego would let him get a professional to do his narration.

Honestly, I think that all three members of LTW would be a liability to any production of distribution company who did a deal with them. If a deal is ever announce then I think there would be some value in sending copies of "Loose Change Creators Speak" to the companies involved.

Again, as a fantasy executive, if Dylan pitched to me and convinced me that there's a market in 911 Conspiracy I'd be tempted to get a trusted documentary maker to make a completely new film for me. I'd probably aim it at TV - all the usual suspects would be happy to be interviewed. Even if Dylan and co refused to cooperate, you could still use footage of them from Democracy Now and Hardfire. I imagine you could use clips from Loose Change under the same fair use principals as it uses for all those news clips. The Truthers aren't especially loyal to Loose Change - they'll go for anything that gives them attention.

The more I think about it, the more I'm convinced that Dylan doesn;t have anything to offer Hollywood.
 
Is it just me, or did Dylan start to show more vindictiveness and arrogance only when he had to defend the errors in LC:FC?

Judging from his appearance on Hardfire, he has stepped back a long way from that stance.

Lately he has veered towards 9/11 Conspiracy Fantasy Lite, I think. He's shown a great deal of respect for the Jersey Girls and 9/11 Press for Truth.

Even if he doesn't renounce Twoofism, in his next movie he could show his Truth journey, and, as I said, "he could plagiarise himself, by showing video of his appearances and travels that he has already recorded".

He's better off making a movie about the twoof movement rather than endorsing any aspect of the TM - that way he doesn't have to adopt a stance (thermite / star wars beam weapon / planes or no planes etc) and risk losing any of his followers.

But I would know he's really thinking he's been a complete gimboid. ;) :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom