Homeopathy and prostate cancer - new study

Could somebody sum up the significance of this study for the humanities graduates amongst us?
 
Could somebody sum up the significance of this study for the humanities graduates amongst us?
The study tried both exposing cancer cell cultures and rats inoculated with cancer cells to homeopathic remedies.

There was no effect noted on cell cultures.

There was a significant reduction of cancer growth in the rats.

From the report, it appears that proper scientific procedures were followed.

The experiment is of insuficient size to make any conclusions of efficacy of homeopathic remedies, but unless something turns up to discredit it, it must be considered valid evidence in favor of homeopathic efficacy.

The project leader, Wayne Jonas has doubtful scientific standing and is known to be an ardent proponent of homeopathy and other alternative methologies.

Hans
 
The study tried both exposing cancer cell cultures and rats inoculated with cancer cells to homeopathic remedies.

There was no effect noted on cell cultures.

There was a significant reduction of cancer growth in the rats.

From the report, it appears that proper scientific procedures were followed.

The experiment is of insuficient size to make any conclusions of efficacy of homeopathic remedies, but unless something turns up to discredit it, it must be considered valid evidence in favor of homeopathic efficacy.

The project leader, Wayne Jonas has doubtful scientific standing and is known to be an ardent proponent of homeopathy and other alternative methologies.

Hans


What is known about the method of the innoculation of the cancer cells? Were they native cancers to the rat, or were they impregnated from another source? If they were impregnanted from another source then a reduction in size could be from any number of reasons.

If in vivo there was no effect, then how did they rule out a different source of destruction of those tumor cells in vitro?

Edit:

Also, without observation in vivo of the method by which these homeopathic remedies works, how do they account for the mechanism by which the cancer cells were destroyed?
 
Last edited:
I have a problem with the idea that the design choses 4 putative remedies and tests them in series. A better design would surely be to test individual preparations. I would also have chosen as a control group rats who recieved homeopathic preparations thought useful for some other unrelated illness, such as menopause symptoms eg.

I have a problem with the KM survival curves (Fig 1a and b). The text suggests that tumour free survival was measured for Fig 1a - fair enough. But what is measured in Fig 1b? The text says rats were sacrificed, so this is an artificial end point. What determined when the rats were sacrificed?
Median time to sacrifice was 26 days in the water-treated control
group and 31 days in the homeopathy-treated group (P = .0002; Figure 1b).


It is unclear whether any rats actually died "naturally". The text also says 2 rats in the homeopathy group died unexpectedly the day after treatment. These deaths are not apparent from the KM chart, which has "deaths" (or sacrifices, whichever you wish to call them) occuring from around 3 weeks. Were these 2 deaths excluded from the analysis?​


Perhaps we can say homeopathy might help your prostate cancer, if you are fortunate enough to survive the first day of treatment!

I haven't looked at all the study in depth, but I noted that the conclusion section is virtually bereft of significant caveats. It is almost de rigeur in scientific studies to include these, since no study is perfect and the authors, who are best placed to know possible deficiencies of the study, are honest enough to acknowledge this most of the time.​

​
 
Thanks everyone for all these useful points. I have now got a colleague outside the forum working on it, and a key issue is the number of potential endpoints. There were multiple interventions, 3 cell lines, various outcome measures etc. Can someone skilled in the art draw up a table of all the possible endpoints? We think it's at least 100, but would like it checked and refined.
 
Hans,

Thank you for answering my initial questions. I see several areas where there could be potential problems, but this is an awkward way to address them. And it looks like the OP is now doing a more detailed analysis anyway.

Linda
 
The study tried both exposing cancer cell cultures and rats inoculated with cancer cells to homeopathic remedies.

There was no effect noted on cell cultures.

There was a significant reduction of cancer growth in the rats.

From the report, it appears that proper scientific procedures were followed.

The experiment is of insuficient size to make any conclusions of efficacy of homeopathic remedies, but unless something turns up to discredit it, it must be considered valid evidence in favor of homeopathic efficacy.

The project leader, Wayne Jonas has doubtful scientific standing and is known to be an ardent proponent of homeopathy and other alternative methologies.

Hans

Many thanks Hans. Not sure how to respond to this. Although "bugger" does come to mind. Do they (or does anyone else) propose how the homeopathic remedies might have achieved this result?
 
Many thanks Hans. Not sure how to respond to this. Although "bugger" does come to mind. Do they (or does anyone else) propose how the homeopathic remedies might have achieved this result?

Don't get too upset. When it comes to homeopathy, any positive study is at least a thousand times more likely to be a false positive, than a true positive. It's equivalent to using your (I assume you are male) urine for a pregnancy test and declaring that you are pregnant based on a positive result.

Linda
 
Don't get too upset. When it comes to homeopathy, any positive study is at least a thousand times more likely to be a false positive, than a true positive. It's equivalent to using your (I assume you are male) urine for a pregnancy test and declaring that you are pregnant based on a positive result.

Linda

But you can fool some people all of the time... (or try, at least)

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/6190772.stm
 
Hans,

Thank you for answering my initial questions. I see several areas where there could be potential problems, but this is an awkward way to address them. And it looks like the OP is now doing a more detailed analysis anyway.

Linda
Yeah. I don't know if emailing or PM'ing you a copy of the full report would be a violation of copyright, but I assume so.

Anyhow, with the reputation of the study leader, and all, I suppose we should not expect too much. However, it is difficult to find more without an actual audit of the trial, and of course we can't do that.

Hans
 
Many thanks Hans. Not sure how to respond to this. Although "bugger" does come to mind. Do they (or does anyone else) propose how the homeopathic remedies might have achieved this result?
Bugger? I don't know about that. After all, effective homeopathic remedies would be a wonderful discovery. Cheap, easy to produce, fairly simple to use, and presumably safe, they would answer our prayers, especially for the third world's need for medication.

Unfortunately, I don't think it's gonna happen. The things have been around for 200 years, and I would expect they would have made a more obvious impression on the world by now, had they worked as advertized.

And, of course, while we can never rule out new discoveries, the lack of support in physics is weighing more and more heavily on homeopathy, as we get ever deeper into an understanding of how substances are put to gether, with still no hint of how it might work.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom