Hitler protected his WW1 jewish commander

We have cartoonish views of good and evil. I think Chomsky argued that you have to distinguish the individual from the institution (which might be exceptionally difficult in the case of Hitler). But the professor gives the example of slavery. You could have a slave-owner who is friendly, generous, loves kids. Likewise, you can find the people who oppose tyranny are themselves abrasive ********.
 
We have cartoonish views of good and evil.

Speak for yourself.:p

I think Chomsky argued that you have to distinguish the individual from the institution (which might be exceptionally difficult in the case of Hitler). But the professor gives the example of slavery. You could have a slave-owner who is friendly, generous, loves kids. Likewise, you can find the people who oppose tyranny are themselves abrasive ********.

Indeed and slave-owners who considered themselves very humane towards their slaves and who cared for the well-being of their slaves and no doubt thinking they were good people for treating their slaves well.

People are quite complex; even obviously very evil people like Hitler.
 
I don't find the word evil useful. It limits complicated acts using cartoonish boxes, and it let's people get distracted from the actual reasons the things we consider evil even happen. I think some people find it respectful to the people who suffered from these acts, in memorial of sorts, to dismiss the things that happened to them as evil, as if recognizing the nuances somehow cheapens or excuses the terrible things that happened to the victims.
 
I don't find the word evil useful. It limits complicated acts using cartoonish boxes, and it let's people get distracted from the actual reasons the things we consider evil even happen. I think some people find it respectful to the people who suffered from these acts, in memorial of sorts, to dismiss the things that happened to them as evil, as if recognizing the nuances somehow cheapens or excuses the terrible things that happened to the victims.

I don't have a problem with the idea of explicable evil. The distraction is a separate, perhaps distracting, issue.
 
Indeed and slave-owners who considered themselves very humane towards their slaves and who cared for the well-being of their slaves and no doubt thinking they were good people for treating their slaves well.

And some thought slaves genuinely enjoyed plantation life, so it was strange to see their former property celebrating emancipation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom