....You know... why would coal miners want to go back to those dirty, back-breaking jobs? I'd think an alternative would be welcome.
Progressives aren't actually offering an alternative, though. "Come be poor and jobless in the city, where we'll take care of you! Just like we take care of the poor in Detroit and Chicago and San Francisco!" That's not much of a value proposition for people accustomed to labor for a living.
Hillary's campaign was pretty clear on the "we're going to take away your current job" part of the program, but fairly opaque on the "and give you a better job and a better life to go with it" part of the program.