Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

I also find them distasteful, because IMO, they border on monarchy. I believe candidates should stand on their own merits - not the recognition the family name brings. I think the Dems would have had a healthier strategy without the Clinton cache giving Hillary momentum, and years of built up power base in the party.

All purely my opinion.

I don't get this in Hillary's case because she was the one that helped to make the name, in fact she's done more to make the Clinton name on the national political stage that he did because of her years as a senator. Isn't this what any politician who wants to have a shot at President does, get their name out to be recognised and build a power base within the party to support and boost them?
 
I don't get this in Hillary's case because she was the one that helped to make the name, in fact she's done more to make the Clinton name on the national political stage that he did because of her years as a senator.

I assume is actually a rational thought, inartfully phrased. Still, I can't make sense of it.
 
I assume is actually a rational thought, inartfully phrased. Still, I can't make sense of it.

Think about it a bit harder then. If you still don't get it, replace "he" with "Bill". If that doesn't help at all, well then you're a lost cause.
 
I dunno what this is supposed to be about, but Hillary moved to Arkansas in 1974 to be with Bill, when both of them were 20-something nobodies who met when both were Yale law students. If her Washington career was derailed, it's largely because she left Washington.
And yet somehow she got to be First Lady for 8 years, did two terms in the Senate and 4 years as Secretary of State, and finally ran for president - getting 2,864,974 more votes than her nearest rival!

If that's 'derailing' a career I can hardly imagine what she might have achieved without being hobbled by the 'Clinton Cache'.

Though it seems that for some people, nothing would have helped.

LSSBB said:
It's not me who was hung up on her name. I wouldn't have voted for her if her last name was Goodall.
Oh, now I get it. When you said "I also find [Dynasties] distasteful... I think the Dems would have had a healthier strategy without the Clinton cache giving Hillary momentum" what you meant was that the 'Clinton Cache' was distasteful because they gave Hillary momentum - Clinton name or not. And yet you complained about Hillary getting momentum from "the recognition the family name brings" when most voters had never even heard it before she and her husband entered the political arena.

Some might think you are confused, but don't worry I get it. The real reason for your railing against the 'Clinton Cache' is not that they are (purportedly) a dynasty, but simply that you don't like Hillary - which is perfectly understandable, what with her being a Democrat and all. Would have been nice if you were more upfront about it, but such tactics are standard practice in conservative circles so it is only to be expected.
 
And yet somehow she got to be First Lady for 8 years, did two terms in the Senate and 4 years as Secretary of State, and finally ran for president - getting 2,864,974 more votes than her nearest rival!

If that's 'derailing' a career I can hardly imagine what she might have achieved without being hobbled by the 'Clinton Cache'.

Though it seems that for some people, nothing would have helped.

Oh, now I get it. When you said "I also find [Dynasties] distasteful... I think the Dems would have had a healthier strategy without the Clinton cache giving Hillary momentum" what you meant was that the 'Clinton Cache' was distasteful because they gave Hillary momentum - Clinton name or not. And yet you complained about Hillary getting momentum from "the recognition the family name brings" when most voters had never even heard it before she and her husband entered the political arena.

Some might think you are confused, but don't worry I get it. The real reason for your railing against the 'Clinton Cache' is not that they are (purportedly) a dynasty, but simply that you don't like Hillary - which is perfectly understandable, what with her being a Democrat and all. Would have been nice if you were more upfront about it, but such tactics are standard practice in conservative circles so it is only to be expected.

No, I felt exactly the same way about Bush Jr., who I did not support either.

Only he had a Dad with Read My Lips to roll on. And Al Gore's stiffness. Hilary should have been VP, she defacto was IMO.

ETA: thanks for bringing up my malapropism again though. I hope your zingers bring you real joy.
 
Last edited:
Isn't this what any politician who wants to have a shot at President does, get their name out to be recognised and build a power base within the party to support and boost them?
Not according to LSSBB. You see, candidates should stand on their own merits, which in Hillary's case are apparently lacking. Receiving any help or support from your husband (especially if people already know and admire him) or even from your own party is tantamount to 'distasteful' dynastic activity.

I'm sure you remember the strident objections that many people had about Bill Clinton having any involvement in Hillary's campaign, and similar objections about the party 'anointing' her as their preferred candidate. Turns out though that many of these objections were actually about support going to Hillary rather than some other candidate - or even that Democrats might field any candidate who had a chance of winning. But they weren't saying that because nobody wants to admit that they are just a partisan hack.
 
No, I felt exactly the same way about Bush Jr., who I did not support either.

Only he had a Dad with Read My Lips to roll on. And Al Gore's stiffness. Hilary should have been VP, she defacto was IMO.
I agree with you re Bush, though the problem wasn't so much the Bush 'dynasty' as it was his neocon handlers. Towards the end of his term he seemed to get better, and might even have made a good president if given a bit more time.

But Al Gore's 'stiffness', and Hillary would have been OK as VP but no way would you vote for her as president? So picky - was there any candidate who met your exacting standards?
 
I agree with you re Bush, though the problem wasn't so much the Bush 'dynasty' as it was his neocon handlers. Towards the end of his term he seemed to get better, and might even have made a good president if given a bit more time.

But Al Gore's 'stiffness', and Hillary would have been OK as VP but no way would you vote for her as president? So picky - was there any candidate who met your exacting standards?

Seeing as I actually HAVE voted for Presidents...
 
And yet somehow she got to be First Lady for 8 years, did two terms in the Senate and 4 years as Secretary of State, and finally ran for president - getting 2,864,974 more votes than her nearest rival!

If that's 'derailing' a career I can hardly imagine what she might have achieved without being hobbled by the 'Clinton Cache'.


Your claim was:
Nobody was interested in her merits any more, only that she was a 'Clinton'.


Tongue in cheek or not, if she had stayed in Washington on her own, she might well have had her own electoral or appointive political career earlier, rather than serving as Bill's helpmate/enabler for almost 30 years. She was never elected First Lady.
 
Huh. Bill was POTUS for two terms. Before Hillary ran for the Senate. A case for her doing more to establish the name than he did seems unlikely.

Yeah he did 8 years as President, with most people saying that she was really pulling the strings. She did 8 years as First Lady, 6 years as a senator and 4 years as Secretary of State. Anyone claiming that she run on his name is kidding themselves.
 
Yeah he did 8 years as President, with most people saying that she was really pulling the strings.

For evidence, there is an episode of Friends from back in the 90s where there is the line, "I believe we should support President Clinton....and her husband Bill"

I don't know that it shows that "most people" were saying it, but it certainly was something that was being said at the time, that HRC had a lot of influence on the Presidency.

No one said that about Barbara or Laura Bush or even Michelle Obama. And to the extent they said it about Nancy Reagan, it was her astrologer.

From the time Bill Clinton get elected president, there was talk of HRC being the first woman president. And that talk was correct. She scared the crap out of the GOP which is why they went on the attack for 25 years. And she STILL got 3 million more votes than her opponent, despite that propaganda campaign.
 
I hate dynasties in American politics and I've always been highly distrustful of established political families with a lot of people in politics on a conceptual level.

But outside of maybe, maybe, some simple PR and name recognition splashback from Bill it's hard to argue Hillary was riding his coattails.

I'm not a Hillary fan on any level, but the idea that's she some sort of tagalong is silly.
 
Yeah he did 8 years as President, with most people saying that she was really pulling the strings. She did 8 years as First Lady, 6 years as a senator and 4 years as Secretary of State. Anyone claiming that she run on his name is kidding themselves.

"First Lady" is not generally considered a stepping-stone to office, unless you can imagine Melania Trump, Laura Bush and Nancy Reagan in the Senate.

There's no doubt that the Clintons were a unique team. Bill wouldn't have been President without her, and Hillary wouldn't have been First Lady without him. Without Bill, she might well have entered electoral politics on her own, probably earlier. But that doesn't mean that she would have gone farther or achieved more than Nancy Pelosi, Barbara Boxer, Dianne Feinstein etc. It's just unrealistic to think she didn't ride Bill's coattails to the presidential nomination -- and ultimately catastrophe for the country when she lost to Trump.
 
Yeah he did 8 years as President, with most people saying that she was really pulling the strings.

Most people? I think this the first time I've heard *anyone* say it.

I can see that being leveled as an accusation, to diminish Bill's accomplishments or tarnish Hillary.

Is it actually a claim that you are making seriously, in Hillary's defense? That we should give her credit for being the architect and engineer of Bill's presidency?

How much credit would she actually deserve, in that case? She took four shots at the presidency, twice with Bill and twice without.
 
Most people? I think this the first time I've heard *anyone* say it.

Seriously? Did you live in a hole in the ground cut off from all communications in the Nineties?

I can see that being leveled as an accusation, to diminish Bill's accomplishments or tarnish Hillary.

Even the couple themselves admit that they worked together as a team during his presidency. There was a lot of comments about how people seemed to believe that he would be the power behind the throne if she had been voted in, whereas in the nineties people called her the power behind the throne.

Is it actually a claim that you are making seriously, in Hillary's defense? That we should give her credit for being the architect and engineer of Bill's presidency?

Here's a extract from a Vanity Fair article from the initial campaign back in 1991....

[URL=https://www.vanityfair.com/news/1992/05/hillary-clinton-first-lady-presidency]Vanity Fair[/URL] said:
And it is Hillary Rodham Clinton, lawyer–activist–teacher–author–corporate boardwoman–mother and wife of Billsomething, who is the diesel engine powering the front-running Democratic campaign. In the space of one week in late January, Hillary fast-forwarded from being introduced as “wife of” (60 Minutes) to the victim of “the other woman” (PrimeTime Live) to “Trapped in a Spotlight, Hillary Clinton Uses It” (The New York Times), the last illustrated by a picture which said it all: Hillary with her arm thrust in the air and wearing a big campaign smile, out in front of her husband.

The forty-four-year-old wife and mother still shows flashes of the sweet ingenue smile of her college years, and has maintained her size 8 by touching little more than a lettuce leaf and water during campaign fund-raisers (her less disciplined husband has put on twenty-five pounds). When the cameras dolly in, however, one can detect the calculation in the f-stop click of Hillary’s eyes. Lips pulled back over her slightly jutting teeth, the public smile is practiced; the small frown establishes an air of superiority; her hair looks lifelessly doll-like.

But there is no mistaking the passion in her words or the impact of her presence. “The instant she came in the door of the ballroom, I knew it,” said a savvy pol, Patricia Derian, an assistant secretary of state under Jimmy Carter, who saw Hillary sway a big-ticket Washington crowd at a benefit in March. There was no fanfare, no spotlight, the lady isn’t even much taller than a podium microphone. “But there was no missing her,” said Derian, “and that’s really rare. She’s a spectacular candidate in her own right. She’s got my vote.”

I suggest you might want to read the entire article, it might be an eye opener about how Hillary was seen PRIOR to Bill being elected as President

How much credit would she actually deserve, in that case? She took four shots at the presidency, twice with Bill and twice without.

She deserves a lot of the credit, again from the Vanity Fair article.

“Some say the wrong Clinton is in the statehouse,” the governor himself drawled at a charity roast of Hillary four years ago, “and I wouldn’t disagree with them.” On February 7, when I asked if he was concerned about being upstaged by his wife, Clinton was unfazed. “I’ve always liked strong women. . . . It doesn’t bother me for people to see her and get excited and say she could be president. I always say she could be president, too.” At his own fund-raisers he has often quipped, “Buy one, get one free!”
 
"First Lady" is not generally considered a stepping-stone to office, unless you can imagine Melania Trump, Laura Bush and Nancy Reagan in the Senate.

There's no doubt that the Clintons were a unique team. Bill wouldn't have been President without her, and Hillary wouldn't have been First Lady without him. Without Bill, she might well have entered electoral politics on her own, probably earlier. But that doesn't mean that she would have gone farther or achieved more than Nancy Pelosi, Barbara Boxer, Dianne Feinstein etc. It's just unrealistic to think she didn't ride Bill's coattails to the presidential nomination -- and ultimately catastrophe for the country when she lost to Trump.

Bill himself doesn't think so. Here is his comment in 1991...

“I’ve always liked strong women. . . . It doesn’t bother me for people to see her and get excited and say she could be president. I always say she could be president, too.” At his own fund-raisers he has often quipped, “Buy one, get one free!”
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom