Brainster
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- May 26, 2006
- Messages
- 22,364
This has been pointed out by several blogs, but it's very revealing. The NY Times had Adam Kirsch, a writer for the center-left political mag the New Republic, review Ayn Rand and the World She Made. That Kirsch is not familiar with Rand's work or her philosophy is apparent in this passage. Rand wrote a long radio address by John Galt, the protagonist of the novel, and her editor, Bennett Cerf wanted to trim it down. Rand agreed to accept smaller royalties on the book rather than cut the speech. Kirsch comments:
No kidding, he finds a contradiction in Rand taking less money than she might have made if she had compromised her principles. Of course, Rand's books (especially the Fountainhead) feature protagonists who will not sacrifice their principles for money, so there's no contradiction here.
That she agreed is a sign of the great contradiction that haunts her writing and especially her life. Politically, Rand was committed to the idea that capitalism is the best form of social organization invented or conceivable....
Yet while Rand took to wearing a dollar-sign pin to advertise her love of capitalism, Heller makes clear that the author had no real affection for dollars themselves. Giving up her royalties to preserve her vision is something that no genuine capitalist, and few popular novelists, would have done. It is the act of an intellectual, of someone who believes that ideas matter more than lucre.
No kidding, he finds a contradiction in Rand taking less money than she might have made if she had compromised her principles. Of course, Rand's books (especially the Fountainhead) feature protagonists who will not sacrifice their principles for money, so there's no contradiction here.