"Hiccup Girl" Charged With Murder



I'm already aware of this, but it never made much sense to me.

Let's say you plan and participate in a robbery (not the one in the OP, just a hypothetical example), and the idea is to use blunt weapons like baseball bats or tire-irons so there's little risk of anyone actually being killed.

If everything goes as planned, but you later get caught, you might be liable for 5 to 10 years imprisonment for robbery (I assume this depends on where you live).

But let's say that during the robbery one of your associates pulls out a gun that you didn't even know they had, and shoots someone.

Now all of a sudden you're looking at maybe 20 years to life for a murder that someone else committed.

In these two scenarios your actions and intentions are exactly the same, the only difference is that somebody else committed murder but you get punished for it as well.

That doesn't make any sense to me. Surely people should be held responsible for their own actions and the predictable consequences that arise from these actions, not actions of other people.

But back to the example in the OP, I do agree that she does bear some shared responsibility for the death of the victim. After all they planned a robbery using a deadly weapon (a gun), so something going wrong and shots being fired was always a possibility from the start. But charging her with first-degree murder just doesn't sound right. From a non-legal perspective, accessory to murder sounds like a more reasonable description of her role in these events.

Of course, this is just a pointless gripe about legal nomenclature. My thoughts on this aren't going to change anything.
 
Last edited:
Let's say you plan and participate in a robbery (not the one in the OP, just a hypothetical example), and the idea is to use blunt weapons like baseball bats or tire-irons so there's little risk of anyone actually being killed.

If everything goes as planned, but you later get caught, you might be liable for 5 to 10 years imprisonment for robbery (I assume this depends on where you live).

But let's say that during the robbery one of your associates pulls out a gun that you didn't even know they had, and shoots someone.

Now all of a sudden you're looking at maybe 20 years to life for a murder that someone else committed.

In these two scenarios your actions and intentions are exactly the same, the only difference is that somebody else committed murder but you get punished for it as well.

That doesn't make any sense to me. Surely people should be held responsible for their own actions and the predictable consequences that arise from these actions, not actions of other people.
Someone bringing a gun to a robbery is foreseeable for an accomplice, but for the heck of it let's throw the gun out of your hypothetical and make it so that the murder was committed by hitting someone in the head with one of the baseball bats (it's pretty easy to kill someone with a baseball bat), even though the criminals discussed it beforehand and planned specifically not to hit anyone in the head with a bat.

Sure, the other participants might have tried as hard as they could not to seriously injure someone, but they could have prevented any injury entirely by not participating in and reporting the planned crime to the police. That's why the felony murder rule exists - because without the underlying crime, nobody gets killed or even hurt.

Depending on the jurisdiction, the death might not even have to be directly caused by one of the criminals; for example, the accomplices can be prosecuted for murder if one of their compatriots is killed by a third party. Again, the logic being that without the underlying crime nobody else would have been given a reason to commit a violent act in an attempt to prevent/stop the crime.
 
Last edited:
I'm already aware of this, but it never made much sense to me.

Let's say you plan and participate in a robbery (not the one in the OP, just a hypothetical example), and the idea is to use blunt weapons like baseball bats or tire-irons so there's little risk of anyone actually being killed.

If everything goes as planned, but you later get caught, you might be liable for 5 to 10 years imprisonment for robbery (I assume this depends on where you live).

But let's say that during the robbery one of your associates pulls out a gun that you didn't even know they had, and shoots someone.

Now all of a sudden you're looking at maybe 20 years to life for a murder that someone else committed.

In these two scenarios your actions and intentions are exactly the same, the only difference is that somebody else committed murder but you get punished for it as well.

That doesn't make any sense to me. Surely people should be held responsible for their own actions and the predictable consequences that arise from these actions, not actions of other people.

But back to the example in the OP, I do agree that she does bear some shared responsibility for the death of the victim. After all they planned a robbery using a deadly weapon (a gun), so something going wrong and shots being fired was always a possibility from the start. But charging her with first-degree murder just doesn't sound right. From a non-legal perspective, accessory to murder sounds like a more reasonable description of her role in these events.

Of course, this is just a pointless gripe about legal nomenclature. My thoughts on this aren't going to change anything.
Can you change the example to leave out the baseball bats? There is every chance of killing someone with one of them things. These accessory cases can be very problematic. I think (without looking it up) if you plan a robbery intending only a low level of force (threats, fists) and one guy brings a knife without the knowledge of the others and uses it to kill, then so long as you did not encourage its use, your liability is confined to robbery (of course, proving who knew exactly what will not be easy).
 
Can you change the example to leave out the baseball bats? There is every chance of killing someone with one of them things. These accessory cases can be very problematic. I think (without looking it up) if you plan a robbery intending only a low level of force (threats, fists) and one guy brings a knife without the knowledge of the others and uses it to kill, then so long as you did not encourage its use, your liability is confined to robbery (of course, proving who knew exactly what will not be easy).

Okay, they're now committing armed robbery attacking their victims with fluffy pillows and vicious tickling.
 
How about this one (it is not my own idea)--what if someone joins a friend in burglarizing what he believes to be an empty house. While he's not looking, his friend finds a sleeping homeowner and suffocates them. They leave together without him even being aware that a murder was committed.
 
How about this one (it is not my own idea)--what if someone joins a friend in burglarizing what he believes to be an empty house. While he's not looking, his friend finds a sleeping homeowner and suffocates them. They leave together without him even being aware that a murder was committed.
Guilty. He participated in the crime that brought them into the house. Again, he could have chosen a) not to participate and b) to report his friend to the police for being a criminal.

Now, would he end up serving time for murder? I don't know. It depends on the state/local laws, the prosecutors, and a jury.

I'm as bleeding heart as the next person but, still, **** him for aiding his friend in a crime that resulted in a murder.
 
I think it is reasonable to hold those who participate in violent acts (B&E, robberies, ect are most definitely violent) responsible for any injuries or deaths that occur as a result of their actions. Ignorance alone that violence can get out of hand is no excuse, and highly unlikely. She knew she was luring a person into a trap to be robbed by threat of violence. She participated in an act that unless she was mentally incompetent she knew would unacceptably increase the risk of death for all of those involved, victim and criminal alike. Intentions do count, but she also intentionally ignored a major risk.
 
Guilty. He participated in the crime that brought them into the house. Again, he could have chosen a) not to participate and b) to report his friend to the police for being a criminal.

Guilty of theft, trespass and breaking-and-entering.

Now, would he end up serving time for murder? I don't know. It depends on the state/local laws, the prosecutors, and a jury.

Assuming the laws counts it as murder, would punishing him for murder in addition to the crimes he actually committed be justice?

I'm as bleeding heart as the next person but, still, **** him for aiding his friend in a crime that resulted in a murder.

But he didn't aid his friend in committing a murder. He just aided his friend in theft and, trespass and breaking-and-entering.

Let's take it one step further....

They're caught by the police, and when the police search the house the occupant of the house is found strangled in bed. He has no idea if it was his friend who strangled the occupant, or someone else did it before they got there.

The only thing they do know is that he stepped on something in the garden which left marks on the floor everywhere he went the house, so they know that he didn't enter the bedroom. But the same can't be said for his friend, who denies strangling anyone.

Does is make any sense that his punishment should depend on whether or not his friend killed someone without his knowledge?
 
Last edited:
A timely example: http://www.stltoday.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/alleged-accomplices-charged-with-murder-in-failed-robbery-in-forest/article_4399593d-2b16-56c8-80cb-c2fe37b67b32.html

Three thugs try to rob an off duty deputy. Off duty deputy shoots all three of them, (sadly only) killing one. The two survivors are charged with murder.

Yes, it's bizarre that they should be charged with murder when no murder was committed. (Justifiable shooting isn't murder.)

The two wounded men, Joshua Hunter and Jamaal Robinson, both 20 and of the 5600 block of Delmar Boulevard, were charged Tuesday with second-degree murder, attempted robbery, first-degree robbery and armed criminal action.

Second-degree murder charges — also known as felony murder — can be filed against anyone committing a felony in which someone is killed.


If felony murder is second-degree murder, why did Jennifer Mee in the OP link get charged with first degree murder?
:confused:

Charging these people with "attempted robbery, first-degree robbery and armed criminal action" sounds fine to me, and they certainly deserve to be locked up for a couple of decades for their actions. But the charge of second-degree murder seems over the top to me.
 
Last edited:
Those are different states. She committed her crime in Florida while the other example is in Missouri. State laws can vary drastically in the US, especially in exact classifications of crimes and sentencing.
 
Another possibly mitigating factor is what she did after the murder.

If she helped them in any way to try to cover up the murder or evade responsibility, even by inaction, that counts against her too. If she did anything but immediately turn herself into the police and confess, she was an accessory to the murder.
 
If felony murder is second-degree murder, why did Jennifer Mee in the OP link get charged with first degree murder?
:confused:

Different state, different laws I suppose.

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Felony-Murder+Rule

The future of the felony-murder rule is in doubt. Some jurisdictions have abolished the rule and others continue to limit its application. In the 1982 case of Enmund v. Florida, 458 U.S. 782, 102 S. Ct. 3368, 73 L. Ed. 2d 1140, the Supreme Court ruled that the imposition of the death penalty upon an Accomplice who neither kills, attempts to kill, or intends that a killing occur or lethal force be used in the commission of a felony-murder constitutes Cruel and Unusual Punishment. In those states that have retained the offense, it is usually classified as murder in the first degree, for which the penalty might be death or imprisonment.

I guess Enmund v. Florida is why she only faces life in prison rather than the death penalty.
 
Does is make any sense that his punishment should depend on whether or not his friend killed someone without his knowledge?
I get the arguments against and I simply don't agree with them. When you start committing serious crimes, you assume a great deal of risk. If you team up with psycho/sociopaths to commit those crimes, you assume even greater risk. I consider felony murder to be one of those risks, and I absolutely consider it "justice" when someone is prosecuted for a murder that occurs while they're in the process of committing a felony, whether they knew it was going to happen or not.

All that said, the person in your example shouldn't get the same sentence as the actual murderer (and, FWIW, I'm against imposing the death penalty for any crime), but tacking another 20 years onto whatever sentence they get for the underlying crime is just fine with me.
 
Babbylonian, that is pretty close to my opinion too. If someone involved in one these incidents turns themselves in and snitches on their accomplices I think that is worth either reducing the type of murder/manslaughter charge or dropping it altogether depending on the specific circumstances. My opinion is while intention matters, it does not absolve one of responsibility when one's actions directly lead to a murderous situation.
 
When dealing with murder charges, its important to remember that classifications such as second or first degree murder are often misleading. Sentences for these offenses often vary wildly and once a person is convict, there is a aggravation / mitigation phase to the trial. For instance, in TN, a person convicted of 2nd degree murder can be sentenced between 15 and 60 years. This is a lot of difference in prison time.

Consequently, merely because two criminal partners are convicted of 2nd degree murder, for instance, does not mean they will receive the same sentence. This is why there is a lot of range in the available sentences, and why during sentencing aggravators and mitigators are considered by the court. The shooter may get closer to 60 years, while the accomplice, who was not involved in the killing may get 15 or 20 years. Both of them are still guilty of 2nd degree murder, but not necessarily deserving of the same sentence.
 
I'm already aware of this, but it never made much sense to me.

Let's say you plan and participate in a robbery (not the one in the OP, just a hypothetical example), and the idea is to use blunt weapons like baseball bats or tire-irons so there's little risk of anyone actually being killed.

If everything goes as planned, but you later get caught, you might be liable for 5 to 10 years imprisonment for robbery (I assume this depends on where you live).

But let's say that during the robbery one of your associates pulls out a gun that you didn't even know they had, and shoots someone.

Now all of a sudden you're looking at maybe 20 years to life for a murder that someone else committed.

In these two scenarios your actions and intentions are exactly the same, the only difference is that somebody else committed murder but you get punished for it as well.

That doesn't make any sense to me. Surely people should be held responsible for their own actions and the predictable consequences that arise from these actions, not actions of other people.

But back to the example in the OP, I do agree that she does bear some shared responsibility for the death of the victim. After all they planned a robbery using a deadly weapon (a gun), so something going wrong and shots being fired was always a possibility from the start. But charging her with first-degree murder just doesn't sound right. From a non-legal perspective, accessory to murder sounds like a more reasonable description of her role in these events.

Of course, this is just a pointless gripe about legal nomenclature. My thoughts on this aren't going to change anything.
Make it even more strange.
One of your partners in crime hits a guy with the bat, knocking him down. His wife pulls her .38 and shoots the bastard.
Even if you were in the getaway car, you are now complicit in murder--or a death during the commission of a Felony.. (the shooter is not, in most jurisdictions)
 
The laws of the State Of Missouri say a murder was committed by these two.

That's what's so bizarre. The laws say these people committed murder against a person who wasn't murdered.

Wait... since the dead guy was also a participant in the crime, isn't he technically guilty of murdering himself as well? (Not that he'd be charge posthumously. But hypothetically, doesn't that count?)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom