Brian-M
Daydreamer
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2008
- Messages
- 8,044
I'm already aware of this, but it never made much sense to me.
Let's say you plan and participate in a robbery (not the one in the OP, just a hypothetical example), and the idea is to use blunt weapons like baseball bats or tire-irons so there's little risk of anyone actually being killed.
If everything goes as planned, but you later get caught, you might be liable for 5 to 10 years imprisonment for robbery (I assume this depends on where you live).
But let's say that during the robbery one of your associates pulls out a gun that you didn't even know they had, and shoots someone.
Now all of a sudden you're looking at maybe 20 years to life for a murder that someone else committed.
In these two scenarios your actions and intentions are exactly the same, the only difference is that somebody else committed murder but you get punished for it as well.
That doesn't make any sense to me. Surely people should be held responsible for their own actions and the predictable consequences that arise from these actions, not actions of other people.
But back to the example in the OP, I do agree that she does bear some shared responsibility for the death of the victim. After all they planned a robbery using a deadly weapon (a gun), so something going wrong and shots being fired was always a possibility from the start. But charging her with first-degree murder just doesn't sound right. From a non-legal perspective, accessory to murder sounds like a more reasonable description of her role in these events.
Of course, this is just a pointless gripe about legal nomenclature. My thoughts on this aren't going to change anything.
Last edited: