Hezbollah TV comes to Australia

lionking

In the Peanut Gallery
Joined
Jan 23, 2007
Messages
59,066
Location
Melbourne
al-Manar TV has just been allowed to broadcast in Australia, after being previously banned. This channel is banned in Spain, France, Germany and the USA and is without doubt anti-semetic and arguably a supporter of terrorism.

In case anyone thinks that Australia is a bastion of free expression, my state of Victoria has the Racial and Religious Tolerance Act, where two preachers have been successfully prosecuted for criticising Islam at a seminar.

The conclusion I draw is that it's fine and dandy to slander Jews in Australia, but do the same against Islam at your peril.

http://www.theage.com.au/national/hezbollah-tv-comes-to-australia-20090731-e4ja.html
 
al-Manar TV has just been allowed to broadcast in Australia, after being previously banned. This channel is banned in Spain, France, Germany and the USA and is without doubt anti-semetic and arguably a supporter of terrorism.

In case anyone thinks that Australia is a bastion of free expression, my state of Victoria has the Racial and Religious Tolerance Act, where two preachers have been successfully prosecuted for criticising Islam at a seminar.
well, actually IIRC "critisizing islam" was something along the lines of Muslims were demons training to make Australia an Islamic state, and that Muslims derived money from drug dealing

The conclusion I draw is that it's fine and dandy to slander Jews in Australia, but do the same against Islam at your peril.
Interesting viewpoint can you give some examples of the slander of Jews that is going unprosecuted?



as for TV broadcasters. We have standards you must meet, if they meet them they are as entitiled to broadcast as anyone else....
 
well, actually IIRC "critisizing islam" was something along the lines of Muslims were demons training to make Australia an Islamic state, and that Muslims derived money from drug dealing

As I recall it was quoting passages from the Koran and commenting on them, but whatever, al-Manar broadcasts things like "Jews kill Christian babies for their Passover meal". It's been banned for good reason, and is being allowed to pander to those who revel in disgusting Hezbollah propaganda.
 
As I recall it was quoting passages from the Koran and commenting on them, but whatever, al-Manar broadcasts things like "Jews kill Christian babies for their Passover meal". It's been banned for good reason, and is being allowed to pander to those who revel in disgusting Hezbollah propaganda.
I think thats the point of the Legislation isn't it? If they carry on with crap like that they will lose their broadcasting licence and possibly be liable to prosecution.
 
I think thats the point of the Legislation isn't it? If they carry on with crap like that they will lose their broadcasting licence and possibly be liable to prosecution.
We'll see, but the station seems to exist for one reason only, anti-semitism. Why is it needed at all?
 
We'll see, but the station seems to exist for one reason only, anti-semitism. Why is it needed at all?
well, If they broadcast the same anti-semitic crap they have broadcast elsewhere they should get dealt with under our broadcast regulations.


They might be handy for Kyle Sanderlands....someone even worse for him to point to?
 
Last edited:
well, If they broadcast the same anti-semitic crap they have broadcast elsewhere they should get dealt with under our broadcast regulations.


They might be handy for Kyle Sanderlands....someone even worse for him to point to?
It would be a close run race.
 
Quite right, Fool -- if it broadcasts stuff like that in Australia it will be banned.

It will, no doubt, limit itself to "why zionism is evil", "how Israel is bad", "let us protest the death of innocent Palestinians", and similar propaganda, in order to not run afoul of such laws.

Which would make Al-Manar a perfect companion to the average member of the "enlightened" "anti-zionist, not antisemitic" Australian inteligentsia.
 
Last edited:
Quite right, Fool -- if it broadcasts stuff like that in Australia it will be banned.

It will, no doubt, limit itself to "why zionism is evil", "how Israel is bad", "let us protest the death of innocent Palestinians", and similar propaganda, in order to not run afoul of such laws.

Which would make Al-Manar a perfect companion to the average member of the "enlightened" "anti-zionist, not antisemitic" Australian inteligentsia.

They may just do that, maybe you could assist them with some contributions from your library of "Enlightened Anti-terrorist, not anti-Arab" material. They could Just substitute Jew wherever Arab appears and its good to go.
 
al-Manar TV has just been allowed to broadcast in Australia, after being previously banned. This channel is banned in Spain, France, Germany and the USA and is without doubt anti-semetic and arguably a supporter of terrorism.

In case anyone thinks that Australia is a bastion of free expression, my state of Victoria has the Racial and Religious Tolerance Act, where two preachers have been successfully prosecuted for criticising Islam at a seminar.

The conclusion I draw is that it's fine and dandy to slander Jews in Australia, but do the same against Islam at your peril.

http://www.theage.com.au/national/hezbollah-tv-comes-to-australia-20090731-e4ja.html
Is it banned in the USA? That would seem to be unconstitutional. Perhaps it's not available here, but I doubt it's banned.

ETA: Maybe it is. Wikipedia says so, but the sources they linked to are now dead links.
 
Last edited:
They WOULD do just that - namely, "limit" themselves to "just anti-zionism", as you say, Fool; and the "just anti-zionist, not anti-semitic" crowd WOULD support them, totally ignoring the fact that they're supporting the same people who claim Jews literally drink the blood of babies and that the holocaust is an evil lie.

Can't say I would be surprised by this. After all, Goebbles too knew quite well whom he needs to address with "let's kill the blood-sucking Jews" propaganda, and whom he needs to address with "let us rationally discuss the negative influences of world Judaism" propaganda.
 
Last edited:
Is it banned in the USA? That would seem to be unconstitutional. Perhaps it's not available here, but I doubt it's banned.

ETA: Maybe it is. Wikipedia says so, but the sources they linked to are now dead links.
It was reported in the Age, which is a respected broadsheet, not a tabloid. But they have been wrong before.
 
They WOULD do just that - namely, "limit" themselves to "just anti-zionism", as you say, Fool; and the "just anti-zionist, not anti-semitic" crowd WOULD support them, totally ignoring the fact that they're supporting the same people who claim Jews literally drink the blood of babies and that the holocaust is an evil lie.

and the "just anti-terrorist, not anti-Arab" crowd WOULD condemn them, totally ignoring the fact that they're aligning with the same people who claim Arabs are bloodthirsty backward savages and that the Nakba is an evil lie.

hey...this slogan chanting business is fun...
 
and the "just anti-terrorist, not anti-Arab" crowd WOULD condemn them, totally ignoring the fact that they're aligning with the same people who claim Arabs are bloodthirsty backward savages and that the Nakba is an evil lie.

hey...this slogan chanting business is fun...

You already have conceded, as a result of my enlightenment, the so-called nakba never occurred in the thread on this very subject. Don't return to your old, uninformed ways.
 
Quite right, Fool -- if it broadcasts stuff like that in Australia it will be banned.

It will, no doubt, limit itself to "why zionism is evil", "how Israel is bad", "let us protest the death of innocent Palestinians", and similar propaganda, in order to not run afoul of such laws.

Which would make Al-Manar a perfect companion to the average member of the "enlightened" "anti-zionist, not antisemitic" Australian inteligentsia.

Thank you for revealing your complete lack of knowledge of Australia.
 
Thank you for revealing your complete lack of knowledge of Australia.

While I'm not privvy to the Australian intelligentsia, Australia, generally, has had a decidedly Jewish-friendly climate. I think a few Governors-General of Australia have been Jewish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom