Help with Shanksville question

Well, I'd argue that it's true for most debunkers. You've got some special LCF mojo working. I was quickly banned on their old and new forums, although I had broken no rules, and a few dozen people here can say the same, I'm sure.
Fine but I am not special. Anyone here can last there just as well as i have. Yes there are times it takes extremely thick skin but it is neither impossible nor is it particularly difficult.

ETA - maybe I have taken the best of the Jedi mind trick from you and Abby :)
 
The burden of proof is on the gov't. They made the preposterous claim. Provide one piece of proof that scrap is from Flight 93.

Hey, you prove your alternative theory is true and the world changes.

Government proves it's story is true and nothing changes.

Who has the burden of proof again?
 
There's a scrap metal yard in rural Pennsylvania?

Well, goll-lly! Who woulda thunk it!

That has to be the dumbest claim ever. The implication, of course, is that the New World Order is hell-bent on killing thousands and fooling the entire world, but too lazy to carry debris fragments more than a couple of miles... You might as well claim the impact crater was dug out with shovels, because there are coal mines in Pennsylvania.

Pretty sad to see what these people are reduced to. This is what happens when you discover no evidence, and come up with no new theories, in six years...
 
You're not following closely enough. I posted the scrap in the container and the fact that a scrap yard is half a mile away.

The gov't claims those pieces are from Flight 93. That is the claim which requires proof. There has been none.

As it appears now, there is greater evidence that the scrap is from a scrap yard and not a commercial airliner, specifically Flight 93.
No, your only evidence is that the scrap yard exists. It is up to you to prove that the material found was from there.

Also, can you provide any other evidence from a similar plane crash that shows drops of blood or any reported? Remember, that has to be a crash of an airliner nosediving into the ground at over 500mph.
 
Fine but I am not special. Anyone here can last there just as well as i have. Yes there are times it takes extremely thick skin but it is neither impossible nor is it particularly difficult.

ETA - maybe I have taken the best of the Jedi mind trick from you and Abby :)
Er, as I pointed out, not everyone can last there as well as you, even if they follow all the rules. My first banning was due to the fact that I provided facts that disputed the truther canon. My second offense was having the temerity to ask Dylan Avery a question. :) Not that I want to post there. I don't read that forum. It's the principle of the thing, y'know?
 
You're not following closely enough. I posted the scrap in the container and the fact that a scrap yard is half a mile away.

The gov't claims those pieces are from Flight 93. That is the claim which requires proof. There has been none.

As it appears now, there is greater evidence that the scrap is from a scrap yard and not a commercial airliner, specifically Flight 93.

No, gravy provided you with an article confirming that enough debris had been picked up off the ground in that area of the crash site to fill 1/3 a trash dumpster.

The crash is confirmed by witnesses, and investigative authorities.

----

You have provided a photo showing a 1/3rd or so filled dumptser.

You have provided info that within 1/2 mile there was a scrap yard.

How does this translate into "greater evidence that the scrap is from a scrap yard and not a commercial airliner, specifically Flight 93."?

Are you insane? That is an honest question?

TAM:)
 
You're not following closely enough. I posted the scrap in the container and the fact that a scrap yard is half a mile away.

The gov't claims those pieces are from Flight 93. That is the claim which requires proof. There has been none.

As it appears now, there is greater evidence that the scrap is from a scrap yard and not a commercial airliner, specifically Flight 93.


How is there greater evidence? By proximity? thats just your assertion not a fact or evidence. By the way. Blood is the very first thing to break down during decomposition according to Dr Jan C. Garavaglia medical examiner.
 
The small plane was definitely a 10-passenger Falcon 20. People are making a mistake to follow TC329's lead and have wound up talking about the wrong plane here, though. The plane she saw was at the time and place flight 93's impact. It was farther away than she understood, and heading in upside-down. Understandably a confusing situation.

THANK YOU!!!! THANK YOU!!!! THANK YOU!!!!!

Now that you've made that claim let's examine where Susan McElwain was on the morning of 9/11.

She was driving north on Bridge St to where it comes to a T with Buchstown, Rd in Stoystown, PA.

Please reference Google Earth for this location.

This location is 1.2 miles southwest of the impact. So here are my follow ups to Mark :

1) Who turned UA93 away from DC and put it on a north east path trajectory?

2) How could the plane flying northeast cause a blast trajectory that solely aims west?

3) What Plane flew over Val McClathcey's house - nearly 2 miles east of Susan's location?


*Cue Jeopardy Theme Song*


Come on Roberts, I challenge you to a debate - Just me and you big guy.

Quit being skeeeeeeeeeered!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Since no one addressed my questions, I take it that no one's skeptical bell was ringing when this photo was posted with the proof that a scrap yard is less than half a mile mile away.

Gravy has me on ignore, so if you're waiting for the supreme debunking proclamation, you might have to rely on your own cognitive abilities.

Here it is again: Container of scrap metal...

http://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k90/jrubins101/Flight93debriscontainer.jpg

... Scrap yard

http://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k90/jrubins101/rollock-map.jpg

Let me know where the 'ignore' button is. Smells like BS to me. I think Mark is making things up to cover up his inability to address our postings.

That's alright he just set himself up big time with his claim UA93 flew over Susan McElwain. :D
 
I gave TC329 the contact information for Wallace Miller, the Somerset County coroner, and Rick Lohr, coordinator of Somerset County Emergency Services (who provided that photo), about ten months ago. I wonder why he's been unable to spread the truth to the rest of the 9/11 crackpot community since then.

How very sad.

Edit: Oh, by the way:

"Over the weekend, about 300 volunteers combed a half-mile square around the crash site and found enough debris from the Boeing 757 to fill about one-third of a trash container."
http://www.post-gazette.com/headlines/20011003crash1003p3.asp

That's a month after people combed the area picking up debris from 3 seperate fields.

Remember on top of hundreds of people picking up pieces of the plane scattered over an 8 mile area for a month that over 95% of the plane was still in the ground. :confused:
 
No, gravy provided you with an article confirming that enough debris had been picked up off the ground in that area of the crash site to fill 1/3 a trash dumpster.

The crash is confirmed by witnesses, and investigative authorities.

----

You have provided a photo showing a 1/3rd or so filled dumptser.

You have provided info that within 1/2 mile there was a scrap yard.

How does this translate into "greater evidence that the scrap is from a scrap yard and not a commercial airliner, specifically Flight 93."?

Are you insane? That is an honest question?

TAM:)

Where's the Tail Section TAM?
 
You're not following closely enough. I posted the scrap in the container and the fact that a scrap yard is half a mile away.

The gov't claims those pieces are from Flight 93. That is the claim which requires proof. There has been none.

You can play "prove the proof" all day long but you will always reach a point where the proof you demand can't be provided, where you set a standard of evidence that is impossibly high. We can't upload an actual piece of the plane, complete with soil samples and DNA can we? But that's where you're heading. Whether we're right or wrong, the discussion can go nowhere with this attitude of yours. That is why the burden of proof isn't on us.

You could take the discussion forward leaps and bounds by producing any evidence that the bits aren't from a plane. A video, a witness, a photo, a confession, anything. Compared to the standard you expect from us, its a small thing to ask. That is why the burden of proof is on you.
 
That's a month after people combed the area picking up debris from 3 seperate fields.

Remember on top of hundreds of people picking up pieces of the plane scattered over an 8 mile area for a month that over 95% of the plane was still in the ground. :confused:

What was the total weight of the parts recovered between 1 and 8 miles from the crash?
 
As it appears now, there is greater evidence that the scrap is from a scrap yard and not a commercial airliner, specifically Flight 93.

On this we disagree. You can't just claim there's greater evidence. There actually has to BE, you know, greater evidence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom