Help me save a life (HIV/AIDS)

kjkent1

Muse
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Messages
731
I have an acquaintance who has AIDS. He (not necessarily the correct gender) is convinced that Peter Duesberg is correct and everyone else is wrong.

I don't really know enough about the controversy to give this person candid advice. All I know is that he looks like he has one foot in the grave and he refuses to take the meds, because he believes that they, and not HIV, "cause" AIDS.

For those of you who understand the issue and can give me some good science on either side, I will appreciate it greatly.
 
Sorry to hear that. He must be facing some tough decisions and it's understandable that he's scared and frustrated.

I don't have any expertise or even helpful links, but it occurs to me that there might somewhere be some stats showing deaths from AIDS when it first began, compared to now. I believe that the drugs offered now were not available then, so would it be possible to demonstrate to him that people with HIV on the new drugs are living longer than people 15 years ago without the drugs? That seems like a pretty easy to understand and hard to refute argument, if you can find the data. I'm taking a leap in assuming that it's true, but I seem to recall reading articles which claim breakthroughs in HIV treatment.

I have a friend with HIV, I can email her to ask if she has any helpful info. Hope you can get through to your friend. If not, then the best you can do is be there for him anyway.

ETA: this page has stats: http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/factsheets/At-A-Glance.htm

TRENDS IN AIDS DIAGNOSES AND DEATHS

During the mid-to-late 1990s, advances in treatment slowed the progression of HIV infection to AIDS and led to dramatic decreases in deaths among persons with AIDS. The number of deaths of persons with AIDS fluctuated from 2001 through 2005, but the number of AIDS cases diagnosed during that same period increased [2]. The reasons for the increase in the number of AIDS diagnoses are unclear but may be due to increased emphasis on testing; the fact that more people are living with HIV and thus are experiencing the development of AIDS; and technical issues in the statistical process used in estimating the number of AIDS diagnoses.

Better treatments have also led to an increase in the number of persons in the 50 states and the District of Columbia (D.C.) who are living with AIDS. From 2001 through 2005, the estimated number of persons in the 50 states and D.C. living with AIDS increased from 331,482 to 421,873—an increase of 27% [2].

Estimated numbers of AIDS diagnoses, deaths, and persons living with AIDS, 2001–2005

The first part is helpful, but then it goes on to say there were more AIDS cases diagnosed for unknown reasons. However, it's important to point out that that does not mean there was an increase in the number of HIV cases leading to AIDS, but an increase in diagnosis. And of course there are more HIV carriers in total. Some percentages would be helpful.

ETA2: http://hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr07-00-00

At the end of 2005 there were approximately 1.2 million [720,000?2.0 million] HIV-infected adults and children in the United States. Nationally, adult HIV prevalence was an estimated 0.6% [0.4%?1.0%]. The number of new HIV cases in the United States has varied only slightly since the late 1990s, but the widespread availability of antiretroviral treatment has increased the longevity of those infected.

Antiretroviral treatment is widely available throughout North America and has greatly reduced AIDS-related deaths while increasing the number of people living with HIV infection. With the introduction of antiretroviral treatment in the mid 1990s, AIDS incidence in the United States has declined sharply. From 1998 through 1999, declines in AIDS incidence began to level, and essentially no change occurred from 1999 through 2001. In 2002 there was a slight (2%) increase in AIDS incidence.

So there you have it. The drugs dramatically reduce the number of AIDS related deaths.
 
Last edited:
Practising physicians are held accountable for their actions. It should perhaps provide a clue that AIDS denalists are those who are exempt from accountability.

Linda
 
There was this thread:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=74560

and this one:


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=45791

and this one:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=87321


IMO, the evidence is overwhelming that AIDS is caused by HIV, and people infected with HIV will live longer with combined antiviral drugs...even though the drugs aren't perfect.

The threads can be tedious reading, but sometimes, you'll find some links to solid information.

Kary Mullis (sp?) is a bright iconoclast, but he cares more about being a contrarian than he apparently does about saving lives. He and Dusbag: Not Cool.
 
I have an acquaintance who has AIDS. He (not necessarily the correct gender) is convinced that Peter Duesberg is correct and everyone else is wrong.
Do you know why he would believe one inividual's theories rather than what everyone else believes? It may be that your friend subconsciously would hope to think HIV doesn't cause AIDS - a natural enough form of denial when someone is diagnosed with a potentially fatal illness. The desire to believe all is well and that one will not get ill and die are common in medicine.

Would it help showing him all the reasons as to why Duesberg is wrong and why all his ideas have been thoroughly debunked? My experience is that once someone is entrenched in denial, there is little hope that logical, reasoned argument and evidence will shift their stance.

Do you think your friend is amenable to reason?

PS. I endorse calebprime's urgings to read some of the previous threads on the subject.
More argument against Duesberg's theories can be found here, and some arguments exploding denialist myths can be found here.
 
Last edited:
What may be more useful is for your friend to have the opportunity to talk to some ordinary people with HIV who are on anti-retrovirals. A local HIV/AIDS support group?

The HIV deniers are capable of making their arguments sound plausible to those who are naive, so I'm not sure that bombarding him with information will make a difference.

Maybe point out that those people in the trenches - the doctors and nurses looking after people with HIV/AIDS - are not the ones denying the connection. It is only those who have the luxury of distancing themselves from the reality who can pretend that malnutrition or drug addiction looks anything at all like AIDS before anti-retrovirals. I was there. I am insulted and disgusted by these deniers and wish there was some way to pile the dead bodies that are their responsibility on their doorsteps.

Linda
 
Are there not an awful lot of people in Africa who are too poor to afford the drugs? I think it would be fair to say that they have not fared well.
 
The NIH has published a fact-sheet giving evidence that HIV causes AIDS:
http://www.niaid.nih.gov/factsheets/evidhiv.htm This publication methodically addresses most of the HIV denialists' claims.

Furthermore, when we say that consensus does not mean something is correct; that is based on the usual situation of a small number of people working in a particular field. In this case, there have been tens of thousands of people working in clinical and basic research in academic, government, non-profit institutional, and commercial labs all around the world for more than 20 years. That is an impossibly large number of mis-guided people, if you believe Duesberg. Sure, the battle is not always won by the largest army; but, all other things being equal, that is the way to bet.

So, perhaps your friend can understand the points in the NIH paper, or be persuaded by the overwhelming number of people who have studied the subject without finding inconsistency.
 
I'm sorry your friend has AIDS.

Why would you disguise the sex of this person?

I hope that your friend smartens up enough to give himself/herself a fighting chance, but I wouldn't hold my breath.
 
Last edited:
{snip}
Why would you disguise the sex of this person?
{snip}
being HIV+ can really screw-up a person's ability to get health insurance, and fair treatment at work etc. "A person" is the least identifying characteristic.
 
Last edited:
Is this person HIV+ or does they (singular) have AIDS?

This is just simple clarification and should not effect anyone's answer.
 
being HIV+ can really screw-up a person's ability to get health insurance, and fair treatment at work etc. "A person" is the least identifying characteristic.
Not relevant. Insurance will not pay if someone is positive and witheld this information. Discrimination rules exist within the workplace (but this can be a factor, I agree)

However, KJKent is pretty anonymous to the world at large anyhow, so knowing whether one of his numerous friends is male or female and happens to be HIV positive is hardly a confidentiality issue.
 
I have an acquaintance who has AIDS. He (not necessarily the correct gender) is convinced that Peter Duesberg is correct and everyone else is wrong.

I don't know if this in any way would help but it is a clear example of how people can be utterly unscrupulous with serious disiseases:

I used to work at a holistic healing centre (I just did the books).

They went through a stage of not doing too well financially so they summoned all the staff into the main office.

They planned on distributing leaflets to AIDS charities and hospices offering complimentary medicine to AIDS sufferers.

At the time I was reasonably sceptical (lI am more sceptical now - largely in part due to my experiences there) and, although I didn't really think there was much to complimentary medicine I thought it was at least okay that they might offer some free treatment to sufferers - maybe it might help a little psychologically with what was (at that time) a mostly untreatable condition.
I was uncomfortable with it being used as a marketing exercise in some way though.

Then the bombshell came - they still fully intended to charge the sufferers, just with a very small discount.

It was simply a revenue generator from what they had identified as a very needy and vulnerable market sector.

I left shortly after.

I mention it mainly because there seems to be a deeply held default position in most people that people would not muck about with the treatment of serious medical conditions. Surely nobody would knowingly make false, questionable or non evidence-based claims about AIDS or cancer.

As most of us know here, that is sadly just not true.

(BTW - I could never prove it but I, and most of the staff in the centre were fairly sure that a robbery at about this time that involved the theft of most of the reasonably expensive 'healing crystals' in the store was in fact carried out by the managers for insurance purposes. Holistic healing centre indeed.)
 
The NIH has published a fact-sheet giving evidence that HIV causes AIDS:
http://www.niaid.nih.gov/factsheets/evidhiv.htm This publication methodically addresses most of the HIV denialists' claims.

Furthermore, when we say that consensus does not mean something is correct; that is based on the usual situation of a small number of people working in a particular field. In this case, there have been tens of thousands of people working in clinical and basic research in academic, government, non-profit institutional, and commercial labs all around the world for more than 20 years. That is an impossibly large number of mis-guided people, if you believe Duesberg. Sure, the battle is not always won by the largest army; but, all other things being equal, that is the way to bet.

So, perhaps your friend can understand the points in the NIH paper, or be persuaded by the overwhelming number of people who have studied the subject without finding inconsistency.
I have to wonder what Duesberg, Mullis, et. al., have to gain from maintaining their position that HIV does not cause AIDS?

Very frustrating.
 
I have to wonder what Duesberg, Mullis, et. al., have to gain from maintaining their position that HIV does not cause AIDS?

Very frustrating.
The last I read from Mullis (years ago) is that he does not deny HIV does causes AIDS, it is just unproven; for him it is just a statement of fact as he understands it. Since then, I suspect deniers keep referring to his more "denialist" early statements. Mullis's statement was a reflection of the fact that one cannot take a large number of people and inject half with virus and half with placebo. The NIH sheet I cited addresses that issue.

Is there anything recent from Mullis (not quote-mined by denialists) that puts him solidly in the denialist camp?

As for Duesberg, I read his early publications, in chronological order, and it seemed his arguments were becoming more desperate and shrill. I am truly sorry to say that I felt he must be mentally ill. Other than that, I would not try to guess at a motive.
 
The last I read from Mullis (years ago) is that he does not deny HIV does causes AIDS, it is just unproven; for him it is just a statement of fact as he understands it. Since then, I suspect deniers keep referring to his more "denialist" early statements. Mullis's statement was a reflection of the fact that one cannot take a large number of people and inject half with virus and half with placebo. The NIH sheet I cited addresses that issue.

Is there anything recent from Mullis (not quote-mined by denialists) that puts him solidly in the denialist camp?

As for Duesberg, I read his early publications, in chronological order, and it seemed his arguments were becoming more desperate and shrill. I am truly sorry to say that I felt he must be mentally ill. Other than that, I would not try to guess at a motive.
Mullis' personal website continues to advertise his book, "Dancing in the Mind Field," which contains two chapters devoted to skepticism re HIV being the cause of AIDS. There is no correction/retraction/errata offered, and the book remains in its 1st edition.

So, if Mullis no longer subscribes to the denialist agenda, he doesn't appear to be informing the public in any meaningful way.

Duesberg is, of course, still very much an opponent of AIDS orthodoxy.

His 2003 peer-reviewed paper (http://duesberg.com/papers/chemical-bases.html) and his 2006 slide presentation (http://duesberg.com/presentations/$bnAIDSQuiz.pdf) remain available online.

The problem with all of this is that the issues "are" confusing to the layperson (and, in my case, to the layperson's lawyer).

Oh well, I guess I'll just have to keep digging for more information.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom